4.7 Article

Mountain torrents: Quantifying vulnerability and assessing uncertainties

Journal

ENGINEERING GEOLOGY
Volume 155, Issue -, Pages 31-44

Publisher

ELSEVIER SCIENCE BV
DOI: 10.1016/j.enggeo.2012.12.019

Keywords

Quantitative risk assessment; Vulnerability; Mountain hazards; Uncertainties; Validation; European Alps

Funding

  1. Austrian Science Fund [FWF: L535-N10]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Vulnerability assessment for elements at risk is an important component in the framework of risk assessment. The vulnerability of buildings affected by torrent processes can be quantified by vulnerability functions that express a mathematical relationship between the degree of loss of individual elements at risk and the intensity of the impacting process. Based on data from the Austrian Alps, we extended a vulnerability curve for residential buildings affected by fluvial sediment transport processes to other torrent processes and other building types. With respect to this goal to merge different data based on different processes and building types, several statistical tests were conducted. The calculation of vulnerability functions was based on a nonlinear regression approach applying cumulative distribution functions. The results suggest that there is no need to distinguish between different sediment-laden torrent processes when assessing vulnerability of residential buildings towards torrent processes. The final vulnerability functions were further validated with data from the Italian Alps and different vulnerability functions presented in the literature. This comparison showed the wider applicability of the derived vulnerability functions. The uncertainty inherent to regression functions was quantified by the calculation of confidence bands. The derived vulnerability functions may be applied within the framework of risk management for mountain hazards within the European Alps. The method is transferable to other mountain regions if the input data needed are available. (C) 2013 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Risk communication and adaptive behaviour in flood-prone areas of Austria: A Q-methodology study on opinions of affected homeowners

Marie-Sophie Attems, Matthias Schloegl, Thomas Thaler, Magdalena Rauter, Sven Fuchs

PLOS ONE (2020)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

The influence of tailored risk communication on individual adaptive behaviour

Marie-Sophie Attems, Thomas Thaler, Karin A. W. Snel, Peter Davids, Thomas Hartmann, Sven Fuchs

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF DISASTER RISK REDUCTION (2020)

Article Environmental Sciences

An institutional approach to vulnerability: evidence from natural hazard management in Europe

M. Papathoma-Koehle, T. Thaler, S. Fuchs

Summary: This paper provides an in-depth examination of the impact of institutional vulnerability on natural disasters, emphasizing its close connection with other vulnerability dimensions and its susceptibility to various types of crises. Through three European case studies, the direct influence of institutional vulnerability on all other vulnerability dimensions is highlighted.

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2021)

Article Environmental Sciences

Trends in torrential flooding in the Austrian Alps: A combination of climate change, exposure dynamics, and mitigation measures

Matthias Schlogl, Sven Fuchs, Christian Scheidl, Micha Heiser

Summary: In recent years, losses due to torrential flooding in the Eastern European Alps have been increasing, with climate change and settlement growth as the postulated root causes. However, despite increasing triggering precipitation indices and exposed building numbers, there were no clear trends in the frequency, magnitude, and seasonality of damage-inducing torrential flooding, possibly due to a compensatory effect of the increasing number of technical mitigation structures.

CLIMATE RISK MANAGEMENT (2021)

Article Environmental Sciences

Evaluating targeted heuristics for vulnerability assessment in flood impact model chains

Andreas Paul Zischg, Veronika Roethlisberger, Markus Mosimann, Rahel Profico-Kaltenrieder, David Bresch, Sven Fuchs, Martina Kauzlaric, Margreth Keiler

Summary: The choice of vulnerability functions is crucial in flood risk management, impacting the overall uncertainty of flood damage modeling. In data-scarce regions, developing flood impact models based on global datasets is feasible, and targeted heuristics can be a valuable alternative approach.

JOURNAL OF FLOOD RISK MANAGEMENT (2021)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Bottom-up innovations in natural hazard risk management in Austria

Thomas Thaler, Marie-Sophie Attems, Sven Fuchs

Summary: This paper assesses and explains institutional innovations in natural hazard risk management by analyzing examples of multi-functional protection schemes. The results highlight the importance of bottom-up initiatives and risk acceptance among decision makers and the public in driving institutional innovations in risk management.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF DISASTER RISK REDUCTION (2022)

Article Engineering, Civil

Physical vulnerability to dynamic flooding: Vulnerability curves and vulnerability indices

Maria Papathoma-Koehle, Matthias Schloegl, Lea Dosser, Florian Roesch, Marco Borga, Marcel Erlicher, Margreth Keiler, Sven Fuchs

Summary: This study compares the results of vulnerability assessment using vulnerability curves and vulnerability indices. It found that vulnerability curves, while valuable, tend to over-estimate damages, while vulnerability indices provide better understanding of local-scale damage patterns but require more detailed data and further research. Both methods complement each other and provide better insights into the physical vulnerability of buildings exposed to torrential hazards.

JOURNAL OF HYDROLOGY (2022)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

The challenge to use multi-temporal InSAR for landslide early warning

Matthias Schlogl, Karlheinz Gutjahr, Sven Fuchs

Summary: This article discusses the powerful tool of satellite radar interferometry for measuring displacements of the Earth's surface. It recommends extending the current focus on ex-post analyses and monitoring towards ex-ante early warning applications.

NATURAL HAZARDS (2022)

Correction Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

The challenge to use multi-temporal InSAR for landslide early warning (May, 2022, 10.1007/s11069-022-05289-9)

Matthias Schloegl, Karlheinz Gutjahr, Sven Fuchs

NATURAL HAZARDS (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

A wildfire vulnerability index for buildings

M. Papathoma-Koehle, M. Schloegl, C. Garlichs, M. Diakakis, S. Mavroulis, S. Fuchs

Summary: This paper presents an innovative solution for assessing the vulnerability of buildings to wildfires, using a physical vulnerability index developed through a relevant feature selection algorithm. Data from a recent wildfire event in Greece were used to select and weight building characteristics to form the index. The index can be used in Europe and other places where empirical data is lacking to support decision-making and risk reduction for emerging hazards.

SCIENTIFIC REPORTS (2022)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Comment on Hydrometeorological Triggers of Periglacial Debris Flows in the Zermatt Valley (Switzerland) Since 1864 by Michelle Schneuwly-Bollschweiler and Markus Stoffel

M. Heiser, M. Schlogl, C. Scheidl, S. Fuchs

Summary: This article discusses the trend reports of a debris flow series in Zermatt Valley, Switzerland, and points out that we were unable to confirm the findings of the original study. We also explain that confusion between different types of data analytic questions can lead to the confirmation of trends that may not hold beyond the data set, and demonstrate how the reported effect could be an artifact of incomplete data.

JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-EARTH SURFACE (2022)

Article Environmental Studies

Adjustment or transformation? Disaster risk intervention examples from Austria, Indonesia, Kiribati and South Africa

Alexander Fekete, Sven Fuchs, Matthias Garschagen, Gerard Hutter, Silja Klepp, Catharina Luder, Thomas Neise, Dominic Sett, Kirsten von Elverfeldt, Mia Wannewitz

Summary: This paper discusses the dynamic changes and risks caused by natural hazards and climate change, and explores the theoretical foundations of adjustment and transformation. It analyzes four interdisciplinary cases from different countries to provide insights for risk managers and decision-makers in dealing with climate change-related hazards.

LAND USE POLICY (2022)

Article Geography, Physical

Repose time patterns of debris-flow events in alpine catchments

Micha Heiser, Matthias Schloegl, Bernhard Spangl, Sven Fuchs, Dieter Rickenmann, Markus Zimmermann, Christian Scheidl

Summary: The threat of natural hazards in mountainous regions has created a risk culture that requires understanding of the frequency of hazardous processes. Research indicates that the frequency of debris-flow events in a single catchment is influenced by its geological, lithological, and geomorphological characteristics, in addition to climatic thresholds. Our study, based on analysis of debris-flow event frequencies in 47 headwater catchments, supports the categorization of recurrence intervals as irregular, clustered, or regular, proposed by Zimmermann et al. in 1997. However, our classification considers potential dependencies between events based on their inter-event times, rather than solely relying on geomorphological characteristics. Furthermore, we demonstrate that for irregular frequencies, neither climatic nor geomorphological thresholds are affected by the last debris-flow event, while for regular and clustered time series, dynamic changes of climatic and geomorphological thresholds are reasonable due to mutual dependency between events.

EARTH SURFACE PROCESSES AND LANDFORMS (2023)

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

Vulnerability of Buildings to Meteorological Hazards: A Web-Based Application Using an Indicator-Based Approach

Maria Papathoma-Koehle, Ahmadreza Ghazanfari, Roland Mariacher, Werner Huber, Timo Luecksmann, Sven Fuchs

Summary: Recent events have shown the devastating impact of meteorological hazards on buildings and infrastructure. The possible effects of climate change and the rise in asset value may significantly increase future risks. Decision-makers need to analyze these risks and focus on the vulnerability of the built environment to minimize consequences and costs. However, there is limited research on the vulnerability of buildings to meteorological hazards.

APPLIED SCIENCES-BASEL (2023)

Article Environmental Studies

The impact of humanitarian assistance on post-disaster social vulnerabilities: some early reflections on the Nepal earthquake in 2015

Marina Huelssiep, Thomas Thaler, Sven Fuchs

Summary: In summary, humanitarian assistance following the Gorkha earthquake in Nepal did not have a long-term positive impact on the root causes of vulnerability, but did partially address vulnerabilities at the micro level. To reduce the extent of future disasters, the fundamental reasons for vulnerability need to be addressed more effectively.

DISASTERS (2021)

No Data Available