4.7 Article Proceedings Paper

Implications of the lead crack philosophy and the role of short cracks in combat aircraft

Journal

ENGINEERING FAILURE ANALYSIS
Volume 29, Issue -, Pages 149-166

Publisher

PERGAMON-ELSEVIER SCIENCE LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.engfailanal.2012.10.023

Keywords

Lead cracks; Short cracks; R ratio; Crack closure; Crack patching

Funding

  1. Aircraft Structural Integrity - Directorate General Technical Airworthiness (ASI-DGTA)

Ask authors/readers for more resources

The Australian Defence Science and Technology (DSTO)/Royal Australian Air Force (RAAF) approach to the management of fatigue cracking in combat and trainer aircraft makes use of the lead crack concept. In this approach crack growth is assumed to initiate from small naturally occurring defects/discontinuities with dimensions of approximately 10 mu m and growth is assumed to commence from day one. As a result, for certification purposes, we need to address the so called short crack anomaly, whereby for a given Delta K the crack growth rate (da/dN) is significantly greater for short cracks than it is for long cracks. In this paper we reveal that there are several instances where this anomaly vanishes if da/dN is represented as a function of (Delta K - Delta K-thr), where Delta K-thr can be thought of as an apparent threshold. We then show that for operational aircraft the true da/dN versus Delta K curve is an amalgam of the short and long crack growth curves. We next show that existing test procedures used to establish the effect of composite repairs to cracks in fleet aircraft overestimate their effect. We also show that the growth of cracks from small naturally occurring defects exhibits little, if any, R ratio effects. (C) 2012 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Review Chemistry, Physical

Review of Requirements for the Durability and Damage Tolerance Certification of Additively Manufactured Aircraft Structural Parts and AM Repairs

Sudip Kundu, Rhys Jones, Daren Peng, Neil Matthews, Alankar Alankar, Singh R. K. Raman, Pu Huang

MATERIALS (2020)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Characterising crack growth in commercially pure titanium

Rhys Jones, Jeff Lang, Vahram Papyan, Daren Peng, Jim Lua, Andrew Ang

Summary: This paper reveals that commercially pure (CP) Titanium has superior corrosion resistance, fracture toughness, and fatigue crack growth resistance compared to commonly used aluminum alloy AA7050-T7451. CP Titanium may be an attractive option for replacement parts in aircraft and unmanned aerial vehicles (UAV's).

ENGINEERING FAILURE ANALYSIS (2021)

Article Chemistry, Physical

Modelling the Variability and the Anisotropic Behaviour of Crack Growth in SLM Ti-6Al-4V

Rhys Jones, Calvin Rans, Athanasios P. Iliopoulos, John G. Michopoulos, Nam Phan, Daren Peng

Summary: The study examines the variability in crack growth in AM Ti-6Al-4V specimens and highlights the ability of the Hartman-Schijve crack growth equation to capture this variability and anisotropic behavior. Despite the large variability in crack growth, the intrinsic crack growth equation remains unchanged, with changes in both the fatigue threshold and cyclic fracture toughness accounting for the variability and anisotropy observed in the test program.

MATERIALS (2021)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Fatigue crack growth in epoxy polymer nanocomposites

Anthony J. Kinloch, Rhys Jones, John G. Michopoulos

Summary: This paper presents detailed analyses of experimental data on the cyclic-fatigue behavior of epoxy nanocomposite polymers. It establishes key materials parameters and their relationship to the observed fracture and fatigue behavior of these materials, providing insights for material development, selection, design, and service-life prediction in engineering applications.

PHILOSOPHICAL TRANSACTIONS OF THE ROYAL SOCIETY A-MATHEMATICAL PHYSICAL AND ENGINEERING SCIENCES (2021)

Article Chemistry, Physical

Computing the Fatigue Life of Cold Spray Repairs to Simulated Corrosion Damage

Daren Peng, Caixian Tang, Neil Matthews, Rhys Jones, Sudip Kundu, R. K. Singh Raman, Alankar Alankar

Summary: This paper summarises a study on the durability of cold spray repairs to simulated corrosion damage in AA7075-T7351 aluminium alloy specimens, demonstrating how to perform the mandatory durability analysis of repaired corroded structures in accordance with specified requirements.

MATERIALS (2021)

Review Chemistry, Physical

Distinct Advantages of Circumferential Notch Tensile (CNT) Testing in the Determination of a Threshold for Stress Corrosion Cracking (KISCC)

R. K. Singh Raman, Rhys Jones

Summary: Stress corrosion cracking (SCC) poses a challenge for load-bearing equipment in corrosive environments across industries like aerospace, chemical and mineral processing, civil structures, bioimplants, and energy generation. Reliable K-ISCC data is crucial for safe operation and maintenance of such equipment, with traditional techniques being costly. This article highlights the use of the circumferential notch tensile (CNT) technique as a newer and more cost-effective approach to determine K-ISCC, overcoming critical limitations of traditional techniques like double-cantilever beam (DCB) and compact tension (CT).

MATERIALS (2021)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Assessment of mechanical and fatigue crack growth properties of wire plus arc additively manufactured mild steel components

Muhammad Shamir, Victor Igwemezie, Saeid Lotfian, Rhys Jones, Huzaifa Asif, Supriyo Ganguly, Ali Mehmanparast

Summary: A study was conducted to evaluate the mechanical and fatigue crack propagation properties of wire + arc additively manufactured ER70S-6 components. The hardness values were slightly higher at the bottom and top of the wall. There was a marginal difference in mechanical properties between orientations. The crack growth rates of both deposition strategies were found to be very similar, and the NASGRO crack growth equation can capture the variability in crack growth histories reasonably well.

FATIGUE & FRACTURE OF ENGINEERING MATERIALS & STRUCTURES (2022)

Article Materials Science, Multidisciplinary

A Numerical Study into the Effect of Machining on the Interaction between Surface Roughness and Surface Breaking Defects on the Durability of WAAM Ti-6Al-4V Parts

Daren Peng, Rhys Jones, Andrew S. M. Ang, Victor Champagne, Aaron Birt, Alex Michelson

Summary: This paper analyzes the effect of surface roughness and machining on the durability of AM parts using LEFM and a valid small crack growth equation. The results show that the component's life is strongly influenced by surface roughness and the local radius of the curvature of the trough.

METALS (2022)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Computing the durability of WAAM 18Ni 250 maraging steel specimens

Daren Peng, Rhys Jones, Andrew S. M. Ang, Alex Michelson, Victor Champagne, Aaron Birt, Samuel Pinches, Sudip Kundu, Alankar Alankar, Raman R. K. Singh

Summary: This paper illustrates the durability analysis required to certify an additively manufactured part by using the examples of durability tests performed on two wire arc additively manufactured (WAAM) 18Ni 250 Maraging steel specimens.

FATIGUE & FRACTURE OF ENGINEERING MATERIALS & STRUCTURES (2022)

Letter Engineering, Mechanical

Further thoughts on EIDS and the durability analysis of WAAM 18Ni 250 steel with rough surfaces

Daren Peng, Rhys Jones, Andrew S. M. Ang, Alex Michelson, Victor Champagne, Aaron Birt

FATIGUE & FRACTURE OF ENGINEERING MATERIALS & STRUCTURES (2023)

Article Chemistry, Physical

Analysis of the Effect of Machining of the Surfaces of WAAM 18Ni 250 Maraging Steel Specimens on Their Durability

Daren Peng, Andrew S. M. Ang, Alex Michelson, Victor Champagne, Aaron Birt, Rhys Jones

Summary: The partial machining of WAAM 18Ni 250 Maraging steel surfaces may not significantly improve their durability, as shown in the study, and only through full machining to completely remove any remnants of print artefacts can the improvement in durability be realized.

MATERIALS (2022)

Article Crystallography

Computing the Durability of WAAM 18Ni-250 Maraging Steel Specimens with Surface Breaking Porosity

Daren Peng, Victor K. Champagne, Andrew S. M. Ang, Aaron Birt, Alex Michelson, Sam Pinches, Rhys Jones

Summary: The durability assessment of additively manufactured parts must consider both surface-breaking material discontinuities and porosity, and how these factors interact with as-built parts. The authors have previously shown how the Hartman-Schijve variant of the NASGRO crack growth equation can predict the durability of wire arc additively manufactured specimens with surface-breaking cracks due to surface roughness. This paper demonstrates that the same equation can also be used to predict the durability of specimens with failure caused by surface-breaking porosity.

CRYSTALS (2023)

Article Materials Science, Multidisciplinary

Modelling Crack Growth in Additively Manufactured Inconel 718 and Inconel 625

Rhys Jones, Andrew Ang, Daren Peng, Victor K. K. Champagne, Alex Michelson, Aaron Birt

Summary: This paper investigates crack growth in both additively manufactured (AM) and conventionally manufactured Inconel 718, as well as Inconel 625. It is found that when the crack growth rate (da/dN) is plotted as a function of the stress intensity factor range (& UDelta;K), there is considerable scatter. However, when da/dN is expressed in terms of the Schwalbe crack driving force (& UDelta;& kappa;), all curves collapse onto a single curve. This observation challenges the materials science community to address the underlying fundamental science.

METALS (2023)

Article Engineering, Aerospace

A Comparison of the Damage Tolerance of AA7075-T6, AA2024-T3, and Boeing Space, Intelligence, and Weapons Systems AM-Built LPBF Scalmalloy

Rhys Jones, Daren Peng, Andrew Ang, Richard W. Aston, Nicole D. Schoenborn, Nam D. Phan

Summary: This paper presents the results of an experimental study on the damage tolerance of AA7075-T6 and LBPF Scalmalloy specimens built by Boeing. The study reveals that Boeing's AM-built Scalmalloy is more damage tolerant than conventionally built AA7075-T6. It suggests the potential for using AM-built Scalmalloy to extend the operational lives of military aircraft by 3D printing replacement parts.

AEROSPACE (2023)

Article Engineering, Manufacturing

Crack growth in conventionally manufactured pure nickel, titanium and aluminum and the cold spray additively manufactured equivalents

Rhys Jones, Ondrej Kovarik, Jan Cizek, Andrew Ang, Jeff Lang

Summary: Recent studies have shown that the da/dN versus ΔK curves associated with crack growth in different manufacturing methods can collapse onto a single master curve, indicating the independence of crack growth behavior from manufacturing processes.

ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING LETTERS (2022)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Fatigue behaviour of additive manufactured Nb-48Ti alloy parts from powders produced by Plasma Atomization (PA) and Hydride-Dehydride (HDH) process

Willy Ank de Morais, Railson Bolsoni Falcao, Mario Boccalini Jr, Fernando Jose Gomes Landgraf

Summary: This study compares the fatigue behavior of bcc Nb-48 wt%Ti (Ti-36at%Nb) alloy parts processed by Laser Powder Bed Fusion (L-PBF) using two different types of powders (spherical powder produced by Plasma Atomization and irregularly shaped powder produced by Hydride-Dehydride). The results show that the fatigue behavior is similar for both powders, but the specimens produced from the Hydride-Dehydride powder have higher dispersed results. Fracture primarily occurs in the porosities near the machined sample surface, and the fatigue cracks propagate in a zigzag mode parallel to the L-PBF building direction.

ENGINEERING FAILURE ANALYSIS (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Prediction of thermomechanical fatigue life in RuT450 compacted graphite cast iron cylinder heads using the Neu/Sehitoglu model

Guoxi Jing, Shuai Sun, Teng Ma, Shubo Li, Tian Ma, Junchao Wei, Jianchao Pang

Summary: This study proposes a parameter identification method for predicting the TMF life of CGI materials used in cylinder heads. The study evaluates the TMF behavior of RuT450 material and successfully predicts its TMF life using multi-objective optimization. The results highlight the influence of plastic strain amplitude, temperature, and strain rate on the damage mechanism and life prediction.

ENGINEERING FAILURE ANALYSIS (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Experimental investigation of the failure of conical picks under thermal and abrasive effects

Xin Zhang, Xu Li, Weipeng Xu, Kuidong Gao, Kao Jiang, Xinyu Wang, Hongxin Wei

Summary: Conical picks are commonly used in tunnel excavation and often experience high temperatures during the cutting process. This study investigated the influence of temperature on the wear of conical picks and proposed a method for measuring rock abrasiveness that takes into account the thermal effect. The experimental results showed that cooling liquid reduced the maximum temperature and the mean mass loss of the conical pick. Additionally, the study examined the characteristics of oxygen and found evidence of peeling, cracking, and oxidation on the grinding rod used for rock abrasiveness measurement.

ENGINEERING FAILURE ANALYSIS (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Root cause analysis of flywheel gear failure in a marine diesel engine

Vivek Srivastava, Deependra Singh, A. G. Rao, V. P. Deshmukh

Summary: Engine gear failures are a significant concern in various industries. Investigating each gear failure and determining the root cause is important for preventing future failures. This study used experimental and numerical analysis techniques to investigate the premature failure of a flywheel gear in a marine diesel engine. The findings revealed that the gear failed due to overload stresses caused by overload torque generated from sudden inertial thrust in the internal combustionengine.

ENGINEERING FAILURE ANALYSIS (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Crack cause analysis of a third stage stator vane of the low-pressure compressor in an aeroengine

Jun Zhang, Weidong Liu, Feilong Liu, Zhiqiang Yang, Jinfang Peng, Minhao Zhu

Summary: During a major overhaul of an aeroengine, a cracked stator vane of the low-pressure compressor was discovered, with the crack originating from a corrosion pit located on the arc transition between the leading edge and the upper edge plate. The fracture surface exhibited signs of fatigue cracks, indicating a pit-related fatigue crack. Metallographic examination revealed that most corrosion pits were distributed beneath the bulging or peeling paint layer on the leading edge and the concave side. Identification of the corrosion products showed the presence of sulfate and alumina, suggesting atmospheric corrosion as a likely cause for the cracked stator vane.

ENGINEERING FAILURE ANALYSIS (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Failure analysis of a train coach underframe

Juan Jose Jimenez de Cisneros Fonfria, Ester Olmeda, Susana Sanz, Maria Garrosa, Vicente Diaz

Summary: Energy absorbing devices in vehicles can partially transform impact energy and protect passengers. In this paper, the failure analysis of the underframe crumple zone in a train car was conducted through finite element simulations, showing that the component acted properly after the impact.

ENGINEERING FAILURE ANALYSIS (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Experimental and numerical analysis study on the low and medium speed bird strike

Fengqi Zhang, Gang Luo, Haiyang Zhang, Peihong Cong, Lulu Liu, Wei Chen

Summary: In this study, a predictive model for bird strike trajectory was developed based on the quasi-linear viscoelastic model. By combining simulation analysis under multiple conditions, the model reproduced the trajectory change law in low and medium speed bird impact experiments.

ENGINEERING FAILURE ANALYSIS (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Emergency Shutdown Valve damage classification by machine learning using synthetic data

S. M. de Gouveia, L. de Abreu Correa, D. B. Teles, M. Oliveira, T. G. R. Clarke

Summary: Emergency Shutdown Valves (EDSVs) are used in industrial applications to interrupt fluid flow during hazardous events. The damage to the valve seats can be detected by analyzing the pressure and torque data. This study compared three processing options and found that evaluating the complete signature with a Gradient Boosting Classifier algorithm is the most effective strategy.

ENGINEERING FAILURE ANALYSIS (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Root cause analysis of an abnormal groove-clogging failure on sink rolls in continuous hot-dip galvanizing line

Xinyan Jin, Kai Wang, Hongwei Qian

Summary: This study investigated the root cause of an abnormal premature groove-clogging failure on a sink roll in a hot-dip galvanizing line. It was found that the failure was caused by the buildup of a large amount of Fe2Al5Znx dross in the grooves, and the key factor was the control of Tstrip.

ENGINEERING FAILURE ANALYSIS (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Study on the mechanism of mechanical properties deterioration of brake disc materials of high-speed train

Zhiqiang Li, Jie Li, Cen Li, Xiaodong Xie, Zhiyong Yang

Summary: In this study, the microstructure evolution of the material in the hot spot area of the high-speed train brake disc was observed and the mechanism of mechanical property degradation was obtained through tensile tests. The research results provide guidance for crack damage identification of the brake disc and condition-based maintenance.

ENGINEERING FAILURE ANALYSIS (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Tube-to-tube impact wear damage mechanism and nonlinear ultrasonic detection method of alloy 690 tubes

Lijia Luo, Yincheng Wang, Wei Chen, Zuming Zhao, Wenfei Chen, Shiyi Bao

Summary: Tube-to-tube impact wear is a significant factor in the failure of alloy 690 tubes in nuclear steam generators. This paper investigates the wear damage mechanism and detection method of alloy 690 tubes under tube-to-tube impact loads. The results reveal the wear damage mechanism through analysis of macro and micro morphologies as well as metallographic structures. A nonlinear ultrasonic wave mixing method is proposed for damage detection and a detection device is developed to implement this method. Experimental results indicate that the damage mode of tube-to-tube impact wear varies with impact load and cycle number, and the nonlinear modulation index is effective in assessing the damage degree of alloy 690 tubes.

ENGINEERING FAILURE ANALYSIS (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Collapse-resistant mechanism of RC beam-slab substructures using kinked steel plates under two-adjacent-edge-columns removal scenario

Xing-Ju Yang, Feng Lin, Xu Du, Lu Qiu

Summary: This paper proposes a novel method of improving the progressive collapse resistance of RC frame structures by adding locally debonded kinked steel plates (KPs). Experimental tests and finite element analysis reveal that the addition of KPs significantly enhances the ultimate resistance and deformability of the beam-slab substructures. The mechanism of resistance improvement is explained, and an analytical model is developed for predicting the ultimate resistance of the structures.

ENGINEERING FAILURE ANALYSIS (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

A dynamic installation method to improve the morphological characteristics of the bolt-hole contact interface in CFRP interference bolted structures

Xiaohe Wang, Zengqiang Cao

Summary: This paper presents a dynamic installation (DI) method based on electromagnetic force to reduce damage to composite laminates and improve joint performance. The study shows that DI can effectively decrease installation resistance, reduce severe damage to laminates, and improve stress distribution in the joint.

ENGINEERING FAILURE ANALYSIS (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Failure probability analysis of hydrogen doped pipelines based on the Bayesian network

Jitong Cui, Yingying Kong, Cuiwei Liu, Baoping Cai, Faisal Khan, Yuxing Li

Summary: This paper presents a method for quantifying the failure probability of hydrogen doped pipelines and utilizes Bayesian network for quantitative calculation. The results show that this method can more accurately assess the failure probability of hydrogen doped pipelines and provide a decision basis for preventing failure accidents.

ENGINEERING FAILURE ANALYSIS (2024)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Investigation on the mechanism and measures of derailment of empty freight train passing a turnout in the diverging route

Yiping Jiang, Maoru Chi, Jungang Yang, Liangcheng Dai, Yuchen Xie, Zhaotuan Guo

Summary: This article investigates and simulates the derailment of empty freight trains at the switch section of a turnout in the diverging route, and proposes preventive measures. The results show that the derailment is caused by the combined effect of various factors, and reducing the longitudinal coupler force and the wheel rail friction coefficient can decrease the possibility of derailment. Additionally, installing a guard rail in front of the turnout can effectively prevent derailment.

ENGINEERING FAILURE ANALYSIS (2024)