4.6 Article

Surgical specialty, surgical unit volume and mortality after oesophageal cancer surgery

Journal

EJSO
Volume 35, Issue 8, Pages 820-825

Publisher

ELSEVIER SCI LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.ejso.2008.11.004

Keywords

Oesophagectomy; Oesophageal cancer; Mortality; Hospital volume; Surgical specialty

Funding

  1. University of Oxford

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Background: Mortality after oesophagectomy is lower in high-volume than in low-volume surgical units. Case series from cardiothoracic surgeons report lower mortality rates than those from general surgeons. We therefore used a national data set to investigate the effects of surgical specialty and volume on mortality after oesophagectomy. Methods: We analysed Hospital Episode Statistics for oesophagectomy for cancer (n = 9034 cases), linked to data from death certificates, in England front 1998 to 2003. Results: After adjustment for patients' age, sex and deprivation score, the odds ratio (OR) for death of general surgeons' (GS) patients, compared with cardiothoracic surgeons' (CTS) patients. was significantly high: 1.62 [95% CI 1.34-1.96] at 30 days and 1.38 [1.18-1.61] at 90 days. The odds ratio for high-volume GS patients was not significantly different from that for high-volume CTS patients. However, the odds ratio for low-volume GS patients compared with high-volume CTS patients was significantly high: 1.72 (1.40-2.11) at 30 days and 1.48 (1.26-1.74) at 90 days. Conclusion: Patients treated by general Surgeons in low-volume hospitals had worse mortality outcomes than those treated by general surgeons in high-volume hospitals or by cardiothoracic-surgeons. This is important because a majority of patients who underwent oesophagectomy for cancer were in this high-mortality risk croup. (C) 2008 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.6
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Review Surgery

No Surgical Innovation Without Evaluation Evolution and Further Development of the IDEAL Framework and Recommendations

Allison Hirst, Yiannis Philippou, Jane Blazeby, Bruce Campbell, Marion Campbell, Joshua Feinberg, Maroeska Rovers, Natalie Blencowe, Christopher Pennell, Tom Quinn, Wendy Rogers, Jonathan Cook, Angelos G. Kolias, Riaz Agha, Philipp Dahm, Art Sedrakyan, Peter McCulloch

ANNALS OF SURGERY (2019)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Development and evaluation of an electronic hospital referral system: a human factors approach

Matthew Woodward, Nicholas De Pennington, Carly Grandidge, Peter McCulloch, Lauren Morgan

ERGONOMICS (2020)

Review Clinical Neurology

The IDEAL framework in neurosurgery: a bibliometric analysis

Helen C. U. Ota, Brandon G. Smith, Alexander Alamri, Faith C. Robertson, Hani Marcus, Allison Hirst, Marike Broekman, Peter Hutchinson, Peter McCulloch, Angelos Kolias

ACTA NEUROCHIRURGICA (2020)

Review Surgery

The IDEAL Reporting Guidelines A Delphi Consensus Statement Stage Specific Recommendations for Reporting the Evaluation of Surgical Innovation

Nicole A. Bilbro, Allison Hirst, Arsenio Paez, Baptiste Vasey, Maria Pufulete, Art Sedrakyan, Peter McCulloch

Summary: This study aimed to define reporting standards for IDEAL format studies, and developed draft checklists for stages 1, 2a, 2b, and 4 through surveys and consensus processes. Participants familiar with IDEAL called for new reporting guidelines for most IDEAL stages except stage 3.

ANNALS OF SURGERY (2021)

Letter Medicine, General & Internal

INDEPENDENT SAFETY REVIEW The IDEAL framework for ensuring safety and effectiveness of medical devices

Peter McCulloch

BMJ-BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL (2020)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Failure to rescue following emergency surgery: A FRAM analysis of the management of the deteriorating patient

M. Sujan, N. Bilbro, A. Ross, L. Earl, M. Ibrahim, G. Bond-Smith, A. Ghaferi, L. Pickup, P. McCulloch

Summary: This study examined the response to deteriorating patients following emergency abdominal surgery using the FRAM method, highlighting the importance of improving team communication, organizational learning, and relationships to enhance system resilience. The study suggested that the potential value of FRAM in analyzing surgical work systems should be further explored through empirical evaluation for systems improvement.

APPLIED ERGONOMICS (2022)

Article Engineering, Industrial

Radiography as a sociotechnical system-Improving patient identification with a multi-level human factors approach

Matthew Woodward, Rounaq Nayak, Peter McCulloch

Summary: This study applied a systems human factors/ergonomics approach in an NHS trust to develop interventions to reduce irradiation errors. The interventions at micro, unit and organisation levels resulted in decreased interruptions in control rooms, decreased patient identification incidents, and increased near miss reporting. The study demonstrates the effectiveness of a multi-level systems approach in reducing risk.

SAFETY SCIENCE (2022)

Article Medicine, General & Internal

Reporting guideline for the early stage clinical evaluation of decision support systems driven by artificial intelligence: DECIDE-AI

Baptiste Vasey, Myura Nagendran, Bruce Campbell, David A. Clifton, Gary S. Collins, Spiros Denaxas, Alastair K. Denniston, Livia Faes, Bart Geerts, Mudathir Ibrahim, Xiaoxuan Liu, Bilal A. Mateen, Piyush Mathur, Melissa D. McCradden, Lauren Morgan, Johan Ordish, Campbell Rogers, Suchi Saria, Daniel S. W. Ting, Peter Watkinson, Wim Weber, Peter Wheatstone, Peter McCulloch

BMJ-BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL (2022)

Editorial Material Surgery

IDEAL, Versius, Reality

Peter McCulloch

ANNALS OF SURGERY (2023)

Editorial Material Urology & Nephrology

Versius in urology: an IDEAL start

Peter McCulloch

BJU INTERNATIONAL (2022)

Review Radiology, Nuclear Medicine & Medical Imaging

DECIDE-AI: a new reporting guideline and its relevance to artificial intelligence studies in radiology

B. Vasey, A. Novak, S. Ather, M. Ibrahim, P. McCulloch

Summary: DECIDE-AI is a new reporting guideline specifically designed for the early and live evaluation of decision-support systems based on AI. It addresses the need for more attention to human factors impacting AI performance in clinical settings and more transparent reporting of clinical studies in this field. With the rapid expansion of AI systems and the concentration of related studies in radiology, these standards are expected to be widely adopted in the near future.

CLINICAL RADIOLOGY (2023)

Letter Biochemistry & Molecular Biology

PRISMA AI reporting guidelines for systematic reviews and meta-analyses on AI in healthcare

Giovanni E. Cacciamani, Timothy N. Chu, Daniel I. Sanford, Andre Abreu, Vinay Duddalwar, Assad Oberai, C. -C. Jay Kuo, Xiaoxuan Liu, Alastair K. Denniston, Baptiste Vasey, Peter McCulloch, Robert F. Wolff, Sue Mallett, John Mongan, Charles E. Kahn, Viknesh Sounderajah, Ara Darzi, Philipp Dahm, Karel G. M. Moons, Eric Topol, Gary S. Collins, David Moher, Inderbir S. Gill, Andrew J. Hung

NATURE MEDICINE (2023)

Article Surgery

Assessing the development status of intraoperative fluorescence imaging for anatomy visualisation, using the IDEAL framework

Takeaki Ishizawa, Peter McCulloch, Laurents Stassen, Jacqueline van den Bos, Jean-Marc Regimbeau, Jeanne Dembinski, Sylke Schneider-Koriath, Luigi Boni, Takeshi Aoki, Hiroto Nishino, Kiyoshi Hasegawa, Yasuo Sekine, Toyofumi Chen-Yoshikawa, Trevor Yeung, Eren Berber, Bora Kahramangil, Michael Bouvet, Michele Diana, Norihiro Kokudo, Fernando Dip, Kevin White, Raul J. Rosenthal

Summary: Intraoperative fluorescence imaging is a valuable technique for enhancing the identification of anatomical structures during surgery. It has been shown to improve short-term and long-term postoperative outcomes in various surgical fields. The use of the IDEAL framework helps in evaluating the current research evidence and guiding further studies in developing fluorescence imaging techniques into an essential intraoperative navigation tool.

BMJ SURGERY INTERVENTIONS & HEALTH TECHNOLOGIES (2022)

Article Surgery

Improving the WHO Surgical Safety Checklist sign-out

P. A. Tully, B. Ng, D. McGagh, N. Meehan, A. Khachane, J. Higgs, M. Newman, L. Morgan, E. David, P. McCulloch

Summary: Using a workload-based approach, the study identified the optimal timing for WHO checklist sign-out as during final wound closure, leading to improved active participation among team members through iterative modifications of the sign-out process.

BJS OPEN (2021)

Article Surgery

Assessing the development status of intraoperative fluorescence imaging for perfusion assessments, using the IDEAL framework

Takeaki Ishizawa, Peter Mcculloch, Derek Muehrcke, Thomas Carus, Ory Wiesel, Giovanni Dapri, Sylke Schneider-Koriath, Steven D. Wexner, Mahmoud Abu-Gazala, Luigi Boni, Elisa Cassinotti, Charles Sabbagh, Ronan Cahill, Frederic Ris, Michele Carvello, Antonino Spinelli, Eric Vibert, Muga Terasawa, Mikiya Takao, Kiyoshi Hasegawa, Rutger M. Schols, Tim Pruimboom, Yasuo Murai, Fumihiro Matano, Michael Bouvet, Michele Diana, Norihiro Kokudo, Fernando Dip, Kevin White, Raul J. Rosenthal

Summary: Intraoperative fluorescence imaging is used in various surgical fields for assessing tissue perfusion, identifying cancer, mapping lymphatic systems, and visualizing anatomy. Research evidence on fluorescence imaging for perfusion assessments is currently at different stages in different surgical specialties, with potential benefits for surgical decision making. However, more studies are needed to demonstrate its efficacy in improving postoperative outcomes across disciplines.

BMJ SURGERY INTERVENTIONS & HEALTH TECHNOLOGIES (2021)

Article Oncology

Preoperative 6-minute walk distance is associated with postoperative complications in patients undergoing laparoscopic gastrointestinal cancer surgery

Yuchao Liu, Zijia Liu, Liangyan Zhang, Yuelun Zhang, Ningchen Zhang, Yue Han, Le Shen

Summary: This study found an association between preoperative 6-min walk distance and postoperative complications in patients undergoing laparoscopic gastrointestinal cancer surgery.
Review Oncology

Uterine transposition versus uterine ventrofixation before radiotherapy as a fertility sparing option in young women with pelvic malignancies: Systematic review of the literature and dose simulation

Matteo Pavone, Rosa Autorino, Nicolo Bizzarri, Giuditta Chilorio, Vincenzo Valentini, Giacomo Corrado, Gabriella Ferrandina, Gabriella Macchia, Maria Antonietta Gambacorta, Giovanni Scambia, Denis Querleu

Summary: Ovarian transposition is an established method for protecting the ovaries from radiation, while surgical procedures for protecting the uterus are still under investigation. This study conducted a systematic review of uterine displacement techniques and performed dose simulation to assess the radiation dose received by the uterus. The results showed that the transposition approach was the most protective.
Article Oncology

A pragmatic approach improves the clinical management of stage IV gastric cancer: Comparison between the Meta-Gastro results and the GIRCG's retrospective series

Silvia Ministrini, Maria Bencivenga, Federica Filippini, Gianni Mura, Carlo Milandri, Maria Antonietta Mazzei, Giulio Bagnacci, Mattia Berselli, Manlio Monti, Paolo Morgagni, Leonardo Solaini, Daniele Marrelli, Stefania Piccioni, Stefano De Pascale, Luigina Graziosi, Rossella Reddavid, Fausto Rosa, Claudio Belluco, Guido Tiberio

Summary: The Italian Research Group for Gastric Cancer developed a prospective database to evaluate the impact of a pragmatic attitude on the management of stage IV gastric cancer patients. The study found that different metastatic sites did not affect survival rates, but multiple metastatic sites were associated with worse survival. Patients who could undergo curative resection had better survival rates. A more accurate diagnostic workup and staging had a favorable impact on survival.
Article Oncology

Stentless florence robotic intracorporeal neobladder (FloRIN), a feasibility prospective randomized clinical trial

Luca Lambertini, Fabrizio Di Maida, Anna Cadenar, Samuele Nardoni, Antonio Andrea Grosso, Francesca Valastro, Pietro Spinelli, Riccardo Fantechi, Agostino Tuccio, Gianni Vittori, Andrea Mari, Lorenzo Masieri, Andrea Minervini

Summary: The aim of this study was to evaluate the functional outcomes of Florence intracorporeal neobladder (FloRIN) configuration technique performed with a stentless procedure. The results showed that the stentless procedure was associated with shorter console time and lower estimated blood loss compared to the stent group. There were no significant differences in terms of perioperative features and mid-term functional outcomes between the two groups.
Article Oncology

Neoadjuvant chemotherapy followed by surgery for HPV-associated tonsillar cancer: Does imaging reflect the pathological response?

Geun-Jeon Kim, Jooin Bang, Hyun-Il Shin, Sang-Yeon Kim, Dong -Il Sun

Summary: This study evaluated the outcome of tonsillar cancer managed with neoadjuvant chemotherapy followed by surgery. The results showed that neoadjuvant chemotherapy reduced tumor volume and pathological adverse features, significantly decreasing the need for adjuvant therapy. A greater reduction in tumor volume predicted a complete pathologic response. There was no significant difference in survival rates between the groups.
Article Oncology

Factors of oncological failure in two stage hepatectomy for colorectal liver metastases

Alexandra Nassar, Stylianos Tzedakis, Ugo Marchese, Gaanan Naveendran, Remy Sindayigaya, Martin Gaillard, Francois Cauchy, Mickael Lesurtel, Brice Gayet, Olivier Soubrane, David Fuks

Summary: This study identified recurrence between the two stages and a larger tumor size in the future liver remnant as critical factors contributing to the failure of two-stage hepatectomy for bilobar colorectal liver metastases. These findings have important clinical implications for the selection and evaluation of TSH surgery.
Letter Oncology

Pancreatic cancer care: Lighting the way with the torch of staging laparoscopy and advanced imaging

Michele Fiore, Gian Marco Petrianni, Gabriele D'Ercole, Pasquale Trecca, Sara Ramella

Review Oncology

Impact of thoracic duct resection during radical esophagectomy on oncological and survival outcomes: Systematic review

Harry Farrow, Oliver J. Pickering, James A. Gossage, Philip H. Pucher

Summary: The inclusion or exclusion of the thoracic duct in radical esophagectomy for esophageal cancer is a controversial issue. While removing the thoracic duct may increase lymph node yield, it may also lead to higher morbidity without any survival benefit.
Article Oncology

A novel tumor staging system incorporating cN status for stratifying early stage esophageal squamous cell carcinoma patients after trimodal therapy

Xiaokun Li, Siyuan Luan, Chi Zhang, Weili Kong, Xin Xiao, Haowen Zhang, Jianfeng Zhou, Yushang Yang, Yang Xu, Yong Qiang, Pinhao Fang, Yi Shen, Yong Yuan

Summary: This study proposes a new staging system based on ypTNM stage and cN status for early stage ESCC patients after nCRT. The new ypTNM-cN staging system demonstrates superior predictive ability and classification efficacy compared to the AJCC 8th ypTNM staging system. It provides new insights for accurately stratifying ypI stage ESCC patients.