4.6 Article

Design methodology accounting for the effects of porous medium heterogeneity on hydraulic residence time and biodegradation in horizontal subsurface flow constructed wetlands

Journal

ECOLOGICAL ENGINEERING
Volume 37, Issue 5, Pages 758-770

Publisher

ELSEVIER
DOI: 10.1016/j.ecoleng.2010.04.031

Keywords

Hydraulic residence time distribution; Sand filter; Treatment efficiency; Benzene; Reactive transport modeling; Wastewater treatment; Optimization

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Horizontal flow constructed wetlands are engineered systems capable of eliminating a wide range of pollutants from the aquatic environment. Nevertheless, poor hydrodynamic behavior is commonly found resulting in preferential pathways and variations in both (i) the hydraulic residence time distribution (HRTD) and, consequently, (ii) the wetland's treatment efficiency. The aim of this work was to outline a methodology for wetland design that accounts for the effect of heterogeneous hydraulic properties of the porous substrate on the HRTD and treatment efficiency. Biodegradation of benzene was used to illustrate the influence of hydraulic conductivity heterogeneity on wetland efficiency. Random, spatially correlated hydraulic conductivity fields following a log-normal distribution were generated and then introduced in a subsurface flow numerical model. The results showed that the variance of the distribution and the correlation length in the longitudinal direction are key indicators of the extent of heterogeneity. A reduction of the mean hydraulic residence time was observed as the extent of heterogeneity increased, while the HRTD became broader with increased skewness. At the same time, substrate heterogeneity induced preferential flow paths within the wetland bed resulting in variations of the benzene treatment efficiency. Further to this it was observed that the distribution of biomass within the porous bed became heterogeneous, rising questions on the representativeness of sampling. It was concluded that traditional methods for wetland design based on assumptions such as a homogeneous porous medium and plug flow are not reliable. The alternative design methodology presented here is based on the incorporation of heterogeneity directly during the design phase. The same methodology can also be used to optimize existing systems, where the HRTD has been characterized with tracer experiments. (C) 2010 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.6
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Water Resources

Approximate analytical solutions for assessing the effects of unsaturated flow on seawater extent in thin unconfined coastal aquifers

Zhaoyang Luo, Jun Kong, Chengji Shen, Chunhui Lu, Pei Xin, Adrian D. Werner, Ling Li, D. A. Barry

Summary: This study develops approximate analytical solutions for seawater extent in unconfined coastal aquifers considering unsaturated flow, and verifies the accuracy of these solutions. The results show that neglecting unsaturated flow underestimates the steady-state seawater extent, particularly for flux controlled aquifers.

ADVANCES IN WATER RESOURCES (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Colloidal transport and deposition through dense vegetation

Congrong Yu, Peiyi Duan, D. A. Barry, William P. Johnson, Li Chen, Zhongbo Yu, Yufeng Sun, Ying Li

Summary: The study investigated the effectiveness of submerged synthetic aquatic vegetation on removing colloids from flowing water to explore the retention of particulate nonpoint source pollutants in aquatic systems. Results showed that the colloid deposition rate coefficient decreases in a power-law trend with travel distance in submerged synthetic aquatic vegetation, reaching a steady state value before the end of the flume. The observed decrease in colloid retention could not be fully explained by changes in colloid properties with transport distance, suggesting that additional processes may be at play.

CHEMOSPHERE (2022)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Detecting Submesoscale Cold Filaments in a Basin-Scale Gyre in Large, Deep Lake Geneva (Switzerland/France)

S. M. Hamze-Ziabari, A. M. Razmi, U. Lemmin, D. A. Barry

Summary: Submesoscale filaments have been found in Lake Geneva for the first time based on high-resolution 3D numerical simulations, field observations, and remote sensing imagery. These filaments are formed during summertime and have significant impacts on the biophysical processes in the lake.

GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2022)

Review Geochemistry & Geophysics

Surface Water and Groundwater Interactions in Salt Marshes and Their Impact on Plant Ecology and Coastal Biogeochemistry

Pei Xin, Alicia Wilson, Chengji Shen, Zhenming Ge, Kevan B. Moffett, Isaac R. Santos, Xiaogang Chen, Xinghua Xu, Yvonne Y. Y. Yau, Willard Moore, Ling Li, D. A. Barry

Summary: Salt marshes are important ecosystems that provide essential ecological services, but they have been lost globally due to human activities and climate change. The interactions between tidal water and groundwater in salt marshes affect plant growth and biogeochemical exchange with coastal water. However, there are still significant knowledge gaps regarding the hydrological and ecological links in salt marshes and the challenges they face.

REVIEWS OF GEOPHYSICS (2022)

Article Oceanography

Wind-Induced Hypolimnetic Upwelling Between the Multi-Depth Basins of Lake Geneva During Winter: An Overlooked Deepwater Renewal Mechanism?

Rafael S. Reiss, U. Lemmin, D. A. Barry

Summary: This study investigates wind-induced interbasin exchange between two basins of Lake Geneva using field observations, modeling, and particle tracking. The results show that a two-layer flow field is formed after a strong wind event, with downwind surface drift into the deeper basin balanced by hypolimnetic currents into the shallower basin. The Coriolis force greatly affects the interbasin exchange dynamics. Upwelling leads to an increase in hypolimnetic volume and turbulent mixing between the water masses.

JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-OCEANS (2022)

Article Limnology

Effects of natural surfactants on the spatial variability of surface water temperature under intermittent light winds on Lake Geneva

Mehrshad Foroughan, Ulrich Lemmin, David Andrew Barry

Summary: This study investigates the spatial variability of Lake Surface Water Temperature (LSWT) and its association with natural surfactant distribution in the surface microlayer in a lake. The results show that intense short-wave radiation and intermittent light wind conditions lead to the formation of a diurnal warm layer with strong thermal stratification near the water surface. The study also finds that a wind speed threshold of 1.5 m/s affects the surface roughness and the distribution of LSWT.

JOURNAL OF LIMNOLOGY (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Unconfined Plunging of a Hyperpycnal River Plume Over a Sloping Bed and Its Lateral Spreading: Laboratory Experiments and Numerical Modeling

H. Shi, M. E. Negretti, J. Chauchat, K. Blanckaert, U. Lemmin, D. A. Barry

Summary: This study examines the characteristics of three-dimensional plunging flow patterns of hyperpycnal river inflow into lakes and oceans. The researchers found that the inflow densimetric Froude number and the bed slope of the receiving water body are the dominant control parameters. They also observed that the hydrodynamics of laterally unconfined plunging are fundamentally different from confined plunging, with the hyperpycnal plume forming a triangle on the surface and exhibiting increased entrainment coefficient. The study highlights the importance of understanding the dynamics of hyperpycnal inflow for better management of lakes and oceans.

WATER RESOURCES RESEARCH (2022)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Applicability of the landscape evolution model in the absence of rills

Mohsen Cheraghi, Andrea Rinaldo, Graham C. Sander, Paolo Perona, Andrea Cimatoribus, Seifeddine Jomaa, D. A. Barry

Summary: This study challenges a widely used landscape evolution model for non-uniform rainfall on unchanneled surfaces. The experimental results suggest that the model has limitations in accurately simulating the surface morphology under such conditions.

FRONTIERS IN EARTH SCIENCE (2022)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

A Persistent Submesoscale Frontal Slick: A Novel Marker of the Mesoscale Flow Field in a Large Lake (Lake Geneva)

Mehrshad Foroughan, Seyed Mahmood Hamze-Ziabari, Ulrich Lemmin, David Andrew Barry

Summary: This study documented for the first time the presence of frontal slick in a lake, indicating the formation of submesoscale fronts. The sharpening of temperature gradient in the submesoscale created an active front with strong convergent flow.

GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Monitoring Mesoscale to Submesoscale Processes in Large Lakes with Sentinel-1 SAR Imagery: The Case of Lake Geneva

Seyed Mahmood Hamze-Ziabari, Mehrshad Foroughan, Ulrich Lemmin, David Andrew Barry

Summary: Large-scale coherent circulations, such as gyres and eddies, are common in large lakes and play a crucial role in determining water quality. However, field measurements of near-surface currents in lakes are challenging due to their high variability. Satellite imagery, combined with numerical simulations and field observations, can provide valuable insights into the mesoscale and submesoscale processes in lakes. In this study, Sentinel-1 SAR satellite imagery was used to identify gyres/eddies in Lake Geneva, and the results were validated using numerical models and in situ observations.

REMOTE SENSING (2022)

Article Water Resources

Dynamic Effective Porosity Explains Laboratory Experiments on Watertable Fluctuations in Coastal Unconfined Aquifers

Zhaoyang Luo, Jun Kong, Lili Yao, Chunhui Lu, Ling Li, D. A. Barry

Summary: Watertable fluctuations in coastal unconfined aquifers, characterized by their interaction with the vadose zone and the creation of a dynamic effective porosity, have been studied. A new expression for the dynamic effective porosity, based on a dimensionless parameter related to the fluctuation frequency, has been proposed and implemented into a modified Boussinesq equation. The dispersion relation arising from the modified equation accurately predicts laboratory experimental data, highlighting the importance of the dynamic effective porosity in modeling watertable fluctuations in coastal unconfined aquifers.

ADVANCES IN WATER RESOURCES (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Effects of Unsaturated Flow on Salt Distributions in Tidally Influenced Coastal Unconfined Aquifers

Zhaoyang Luo, Jun Kong, Xiayang Yu, Chunhui Lu, Adrian D. Werner, David A. Barry

Summary: The effects of unsaturated flow on density-dependent solute transport in coastal unconfined aquifers were analyzed using numerical simulations and laboratory experiments. The results showed that unsaturated flow has a more pronounced influence on salt distributions in coastal unconfined aquifers when tides are considered. Neglecting unsaturated flow effects can lead to expansion of the upper saline plume, shrinkage of the saltwater wedge, and overestimation of water and salt exchange across the aquifer-ocean interface.

WATER RESOURCES RESEARCH (2023)

Article Oceanography

Chimney-Like Intense Pelagic Upwelling in the Center of Basin-Scale Cyclonic Gyres in Large Lake Geneva

S. M. Hamze-Ziabari, U. Lemmin, M. Foroughan, R. S. Reiss, D. A. Barry

Summary: Dome-shaped thermoclines form in the center of cyclonic gyres in large lakes, caused by pelagic upwelling. Field observations in Lake Geneva confirm the presence of intense pelagic upwelling within the surface mixed layer. A 3D numerical model suggests that nonlinear divergent flows and 3D ageostrophic strain are responsible for the chimney-like upwelling in the surface mixed layer.

JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-OCEANS (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Basin-scale gyres and mesoscale eddies in large lakes: a novel procedure fortheir detection and characterization, assessed in Lake Geneva

Seyed Mahmood Hamze-Ziabari, Ulrich Lemmin, Frederic Soulignac, Mehrshad Foroughan, David Andrew Barry

Summary: In large lakes, basin-scale gyres and mesoscale eddies play a crucial role in spreading biochemical materials and energy. Detailed transect field observations are needed to assess their spatial and temporal extent and to validate numerical simulation results. A novel approach combining numerical simulations, statistical analyses, and remote sensing data was developed to determine the patterns and characteristics of basin-scale gyres in different seasons in Lake Geneva.

GEOSCIENTIFIC MODEL DEVELOPMENT (2022)

Article Water Resources

Tracing Unconfined Nearfield Spreading of a River Plume Interflow in a Large Lake (Lake Geneva): Hydrodynamics, Suspended Particulate Matter, and Associated Fluxes

Violaine Piton, Frederic Soulignac, Ulrich Lemmin, Benjamin Graf, Htet Kyi Wynn, Koen Blanckaert, David Andrew Barry

Summary: River inflows have a significant impact on lake water quality, contributing to the input of sediments, nutrients, and contaminants. In Lake Geneva, the interaction between the Rhone River plume and lake waters was studied, revealing the dynamics of nearfield hydro-sedimentation. The study found that the river inflow intruded into the lake as a lateral unconfined interflow and mainly spread laterally due to entrainment of ambient water.

FRONTIERS IN WATER (2022)

Article Ecology

Development and testing of a mechanistic model for wetland treatment of neutral and polar organic contaminants in oil sands process-affected water

Alexander M. Cancelli, Frank A. P. C. Gobas

Summary: A mechanistic model was developed to assess the removal efficiency of pollutants in a wetland system, particularly in oil sands process-affected water (OSPW). The model simulated wetland mechanisms of chemical removal and showed that sustained wetland treatment is feasible. It is a helpful tool to evaluate the feasibility of treatment systems and to assess trade-offs in wetland design and operation.

ECOLOGICAL ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Ecology

Analyzing vegetation recovery and erosion status after a large Landslide at Mt. Hakusan, Central Japan

Prakash Singh Thapa, Hiromu Daimaru, Seiji Yanai

Summary: This study assessed the vegetation recovery and erosion condition in a landslide area in central Japan. The results show that the upper slope, where reforestation activities were implemented, has seen significant vegetation recovery and no significant erosion, while the lower slope lacks vegetation and has experienced continued erosion.

ECOLOGICAL ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Ecology

The role of calcium and alkalinity on phosphorus removal by submerged aquatic vegetation in hardwater wetlands

Mike Jerauld, Forrest Dierberg, Thomas DeBusk, Scott Jackson, Kevin Grace, John Juston

Summary: The Everglades Stormwater Treatment Areas (STAs) are constructed wetlands built to remove phosphorus (P) from agricultural and urban runoff in support of Everglades restoration. Research shows that the levels of calcium (Ca) and alkalinity (Alk) have an impact on phosphorus removal in these wetlands.

ECOLOGICAL ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Ecology

Effects of increasing complexity in biogeochemistry and hydrology on variability of total phosphorus concentration in models of a low flow subtropical wetland

Kalindhi Larios, Stefan Gerber, Rafael Munoz-Carpena, Patrick Inglett, K. Ramesh Reddy, Michael Chimney

Summary: This study modeled the phosphorus biogeochemical dynamics in one of the best performing Everglades treatment wetlands and found that the complexity of the hydrological system significantly affected the simulated water column P concentration. The modeling tool developed in this study can guide future data collection and optimization efforts for treatment wetlands in the Everglades.

ECOLOGICAL ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Ecology

An analysis of long-term Everglades Stormwater Treatment Areas performance using structural equation models

Jing Hu, Benjamin Baiser, R. Thomas James, K. Ramesh Reddy

Summary: This study examined the long-term phosphorus retention in Stormwater Treatment Areas (STAs) and identified the factors influencing their performance. The results showed that the operational performance of STAs improved over time. There were notable differences among individual STAs, with the co-precipitation of phosphorus with calcium playing a critical role in one of the STAs. This highlights the complexity of phosphorus removal in STAs and the need for site-specific management strategies.

ECOLOGICAL ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Ecology

Biogeochemical response of subtropical treatment wetlands to different flow conditions

Odi Villapando, K. R. Reddy, J. King

Summary: The biogeochemical response to different flow conditions within two parallel flow-ways in Everglades Stormwater Treatment Area (STA)-2 was studied. It was found that there was a gradual decrease in the total phosphorus (TP) concentration from inflow to outflow for both emergent aquatic vegetation (EAV) and submerged aquatic vegetation (SAV) dominated systems, with EAV showing a higher reduction rate. Significant increase in TP concentration was observed in the SAV system under no flow condition, possibly due to the production of particulate phosphorus (PP) through various mechanisms.

ECOLOGICAL ENGINEERING (2024)