4.5 Review

Connectomics and epilepsy

Journal

CURRENT OPINION IN NEUROLOGY
Volume 26, Issue 2, Pages 186-194

Publisher

LIPPINCOTT WILLIAMS & WILKINS
DOI: 10.1097/WCO.0b013e32835ee5b8

Keywords

epilepsy; functional connectivity; local circuits; structural connectivity; whole brain

Funding

  1. NIH [P01 NS02808, R01 NS033310, U01 NS042372, P20 NS080181, R01 080655, R01 MH097268, R01 A6040060, R01 EB008432, P41 EB015922, K23 NS044936, R01 NS071048, R01 NS65877, R01 NS030549, R01 NS075429, R01 MH076994, R21 MH092647]
  2. CURE
  3. Epilepsy Foundation
  4. Epilepsy Therapy Project

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Purpose of review Tremendous advances have occurred in recent years in elucidating basic mechanisms of epilepsy at the level of ion channels and neurotransmitters. Epilepsy, however, is ultimately a disease of functionally and/or structurally aberrant connections between neurons and groups of neurons at the systems level. Recent advances in neuroimaging and electrophysiology now make it possible to investigate structural and functional connectivity of the entire brain, and these techniques are currently being used to investigate diseases that manifest as global disturbances of brain function. Epilepsy is such a disease, and our understanding of the mechanisms underlying the development of epilepsy and the generation of epileptic seizures will undoubtedly benefit from research utilizing these connectomic approaches. Recent findings MRI using diffusion tensor imaging provides structural information, whereas functional MRI and electroencephalography provide functional information about connectivity at the whole brain level. Optogenetics, tracers, electrophysiological approaches, and calcium imaging provide connectivity information at the level of local circuits. These approaches are revealing important neuronal network disturbances underlying epileptic abnormalities. Summary An understanding of the fundamental mechanisms underlying the development of epilepsy and the generation of epileptic seizures will require delineation of the aberrant functional and structural connections of the whole brain. The field of connectomics now provides approaches to accomplish this.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Neurosciences

How do substance use disorders compare to other psychiatric conditions on structural brain abnormalities? A cross-disorder meta-analytic comparison using theENIGMAconsortium findings

Xavier Navarri, Mohammad H. Afzali, Jacob Lavoie, Rajita Sinha, Dan J. Stein, Reza Momenan, Dick J. Veltman, Ozlem Korucuoglu, Zsuzsika Sjoerds, Ruth J. van Holst, Rob Hester, Catherine Orr, Janna Cousijn, Murat Yucel, Valentina Lorenzetti, Reinout Wiers, Neda Jahanshad, David C. Glahn, Paul M. Thompson, Scott Mackey, Patricia J. Conrod

Summary: Alcohol use disorder (AUD) and cannabis use disorder (CUD) are associated with significant brain alterations, particularly in subcortical and cortical regions. The brain abnormalities in AUD are comparable to or larger than those found in other psychiatric disorders, while CUD is most strongly related to reduced cortical thickness in the medial orbitofrontal cortex.

HUMAN BRAIN MAPPING (2022)

Review Neurosciences

ENIGMA-anxietyworking group: Rationale for and organization oflarge-scaleneuroimaging studies of anxiety disorders

Janna Marie Bas-Hoogendam, Nynke A. Groenewold, Moji Aghajani, Gabrielle F. Freitag, Anita Harrewijn, Kevin Hilbert, Neda Jahanshad, Sophia I. Thomopoulos, Paul M. Thompson, Dick J. Veltman, Anderson M. Winkler, Ulrike Lueken, Daniel S. Pine, Nic J. A. van der Wee, Dan J. Stein

Summary: Anxiety disorders are prevalent and disabling, but can be effectively studied using translational neuroscience methodologies. The ENIGMA-Anxiety Working Group aims to address the limitations of small sample sizes and heterogenous imaging methodology in anxiety disorders research, and generate more reliable and reproducible findings. The group has created a harmonized and coordinated effort to study different subtypes of anxiety disorders using neuroimaging data.

HUMAN BRAIN MAPPING (2022)

Article Neurosciences

Common andgender-specificassociations with cocaine use on gray matter volume: Data from theENIGMAaddiction working group

Rachel A. Rabin, Scott Mackey, Muhammad A. Parvaz, Janna Cousijn, Chiang-shan Li, Godfrey Pearlson, Lianne Schmaal, Rajita Sinha, Elliot Stein, Dick Veltman, Paul M. Thompson, Patricia Conrod, Hugh Garavan, Nelly Alia-Klein, Rita Z. Goldstein

Summary: This study investigates the impact of gender on gray matter volume (GMV) in cocaine-dependent individuals (CD) compared to controls. The results suggest gender differences in certain brain areas, and the diagnosis differences are predominantly found in frontal regions. These findings may shed light on the gender-specific mechanisms in cocaine addiction.

HUMAN BRAIN MAPPING (2022)

Article Neurosciences

Intelligence, educational attainment, and brain structure in those at familial high-risk for schizophrenia or bipolar disorder

Sonja M. C. de Zwarte, Rachel M. Brouwer, Ingrid Agartz, Martin Alda, Silvia Alonso-Lana, Carrie E. Bearden, Alessandro Bertolino, Aurora Bonvino, Elvira Bramon, Elizabeth E. L. Buimer, Wiepke Cahn, Erick J. Canales-Rodriguez, Dara M. Cannon, Tyrone D. Cannon, Xavier Caseras, Josefina Castro-Fornieles, Qiang Chen, Yoonho Chung, Elena de la Serna, Caterina del Mar Bonnin, Caroline Demro, Annabella Di Giorgio, Gaelle E. Doucet, Mehmet Cagdas Eker, Susanne Erk, Mar Fatjo-Vilas, Scott C. Fears, Sonya F. Foley, Sophia Frangou, Janice M. Fullerton, David C. Glahn, Vina M. Goghari, Jose M. Goikolea, Aaron L. Goldman, Ali Saffet Gonul, Oliver Gruber, Tomas Hajek, Emma L. Hawkins, Andreas Heinz, Ceren Hidiroglu Ongun, Manon H. J. Hillegers, Josselin Houenou, Hilleke E. Hulshoff Pol, Christina M. Hultman, Martin Ingvar, Viktoria Johansson, Erik G. Jonsson, Fergus Kane, Matthew J. Kempton, Marinka M. G. Koenis, Miloslav Kopecek, Bernd Kraemer, Stephen M. Lawrie, Rhoshel K. Lenroot, Machteld Marcelis, Venkata S. Mattay, Colm McDonald, Andreas Meyer-Lindenberg, Stijn Michielse, Philip B. Mitchell, Dolores Moreno, Robin M. Murray, Benson Mwangi, Leila Nabulsi, Jason Newport, Cheryl A. Olman, Jim van Os, Bronwyn J. Overs, Aysegul Ozerdem, Giulio Pergola, Marco M. Picchioni, Camille Piguet, Edith Pomarol-Clotet, Joaquim Radua, Ian S. Ramsay, Anja Richter, Gloria Roberts, Raymond Salvador, Aybala Saricicek Aydogan, Salvador Sarro, Peter R. Schofield, Esma M. Simsek, Fatma Simsek, Jair C. Soares, Scott R. Sponheim, Gisela Sugranyes, Timothea Toulopoulou, Giulia Tronchin, Eduard Vieta, Henrik Walter, Daniel R. Weinberger, Heather C. Whalley, Mon-Ju Wu, Nefize Yalin, Ole A. Andreassen, Christopher R. K. Ching, Sophia I. Thomopoulos, Theo G. M. van Erp, Neda Jahanshad, Paul M. Thompson, Rene S. Kahn, Neeltje E. M. van Haren

Summary: First-degree relatives of patients diagnosed with schizophrenia show widespread thinner cortex, while relatives of patients diagnosed with bipolar disorder show widespread larger cortical surface area. Both groups have lower IQ scores compared to controls, with schizophrenia relatives showing more pronounced brain abnormalities and bipolar disorder relatives showing weaker effects after adjusting for IQ or educational attainment.

HUMAN BRAIN MAPPING (2022)

Article Neurosciences

Greater male than female variability in regional brain structure across the lifespan

Lara M. Wierenga, Gaelle E. Doucet, Danai Dima, Ingrid Agartz, Moji Aghajani, Theophilus N. Akudjedu, Anton Albajes-Eizagirre, Dag Alnaes, Kathryn Alpert, Ole A. Andreassen, Alan Anticevic, Philip Asherson, Tobias Banaschewski, Nuria Bargallo, Sarah Baumeister, Ramona Baur-Streubel, Alessandro Bertolino, Aurora Bonvino, Dorret Boomsma, Stefan Borgwardt, Josiane Bourque, Anouk den Braber, Daniel Brandeis, Alan Breier, Henry Brodaty, Rachel M. Brouwer, Jan K. Buitelaar, Geraldo F. Busatto, Vince D. Calhoun, Erick J. Canales-Rodriguez, Dara M. Cannon, Xavier Caseras, Francisco X. Castellanos, Tiffany M. Chaim-Avancini, Christopher R. K. Ching, Vincent P. Clark, Patricia J. Conrod, Annette Conzelmann, Fabrice Crivello, Christopher G. Davey, Erin W. Dickie, Stefan Ehrlich, Dennis Van't Ent, Simon E. Fisher, Jean-Paul Fouche, Barbara Franke, Paola Fuentes-Claramonte, Eco J. C. de Geus, Annabella Di Giorgio, David C. Glahn, Ian H. Gotlib, Hans J. Grabe, Oliver Gruber, Patricia Gruner, Raquel E. Gur, Ruben C. Gur, Tiril P. Gurholt, Lieuwe de Haan, Beathe Haatveit, Ben J. Harrison, Catharina A. Hartman, Sean N. Hatton, Dirk J. Heslenfeld, Odile A. van den Heuvel, Ian B. Hickie, Pieter J. Hoekstra, Sarah Hohmann, Avram J. Holmes, Martine Hoogman, Norbert Hosten, Fleur M. Howells, Hilleke E. Hulshoff Pol, Chaim Huyser, Neda Jahanshad, Anthony C. James, Jiyang Jiang, Erik G. Jonsson, John A. Joska, Andrew J. Kalnin, Marieke Klein, Laura Koenders, Knut K. Kolskar, Bernd Kramer, Jonna Kuntsi, Jim Lagopoulos, Luisa Lazaro, Irina S. Lebedeva, Phil H. Lee, Christine Lochner, Marise W. J. Machielsen, Sophie Maingault, Nicholas G. Martin, Ignacio Martinez-Zalacain, David Mataix-Cols, Bernard Mazoyer, Brenna C. McDonald, Colm McDonald, Andrew M. McIntosh, Katie L. McMahon, Genevieve McPhilemy, Dennis van der Meer, Jose M. Menchon, Jilly Naaijen, Lars Nyberg, Jaap Oosterlaan, Yannis Paloyelis, Paul Pauli, Giulio Pergola, Edith Pomarol-Clotet, Maria J. Portella, Joaquim Radua, Andreas Reif, Genevieve Richard, Joshua L. Roffman, Pedro G. P. Rosa, Matthew D. Sacchet, Perminder S. Sachdev, Raymond Salvador, Salvador Sarro, Theodore D. Satterthwaite, Andrew J. Saykin, Mauricio H. Serpa, Kang Sim, Andrew Simmons, Jordan W. Smoller, Iris E. Sommer, Carles Soriano-Mas, Dan J. Stein, Lachlan T. Strike, Philip R. Szeszko, Henk S. Temmingh, Sophia Thomopoulos, Alexander S. Tomyshev, Julian N. Trollor, Anne Uhlmann, Ilya M. Veer, Dick J. Veltman, Aristotle Voineskos, Henry Volzke, Henrik Walter, Lei Wang, Yang Wang, Bernd Weber, Wei Wen, John D. West, Lars T. Westlye, Heather C. Whalley, Steven C. R. Williams, Katharina Wittfeld, Daniel H. Wolf, Margaret J. Wright, Yuliya N. Yoncheva, Marcus Zanetti, Georg C. Ziegler, Greig de Zubicaray, Paul M. Thompson, Eveline A. Crone, Sophia Frangou, Christian K. Tamnes

Summary: Males exhibit greater variability than females in many traits, which may have implications for understanding sex differences in health and disease. A mega-analysis of brain structure variability based on MRI data of 16,683 healthy individuals spanning nine decades of life reveals significant patterns of greater male than female between-subject variance in subcortical volumes, cortical surface area, and cortical thickness. These sex differences are present in childhood and may be influenced by early life genetic or gene-environment interaction mechanisms. The findings underscore the importance of individual differences within each sex, which may contribute to sex-specific vulnerability to disorders.

HUMAN BRAIN MAPPING (2022)

Article Neurosciences

A meta-analysis of deep brain structural shape and asymmetry abnormalities in 2,833 individuals with schizophrenia compared with 3,929 healthy volunteers via the ENIGMA Consortium

Boris A. Gutman, Theo G. M. van Erp, Kathryn Alpert, Christopher R. K. Ching, Dmitry Isaev, Anjani Ragothaman, Neda Jahanshad, Arvin Saremi, Artemis Zavaliangos-Petropulu, David C. Glahn, Li Shen, Shan Cong, Dag Alnaes, Ole Andreas Andreassen, Nhat Trung Doan, Lars T. Westlye, Peter Kochunov, Theodore D. Satterthwaite, Daniel H. Wolf, Alexander J. Huang, Charles Kessler, Andrea Weideman, Dana Nguyen, Bryon A. Mueller, Lawrence Faziola, Steven G. Potkin, Adrian Preda, Daniel H. Mathalon, Juan Bustillo, Vince Calhoun, Judith M. Ford, Esther Walton, Stefan Ehrlich, Giuseppe Ducci, Nerisa Banaj, Fabrizio Piras, Federica Piras, Gianfranco Spalletta, Erick J. Canales-Rodriguez, Paola Fuentes-Claramonte, Edith Pomarol-Clotet, Joaquim Radua, Raymond Salvador, Salvador Sarro, Erin W. Dickie, Aristotle Voineskos, Diana Tordesillas-Gutierrez, Benedicto Crespo-Facorro, Esther Setien-Suero, Jacqueline Mayoral van Son, Stefan Borgwardt, Fabienne Schoenborn-Harrisberger, Derek Morris, Gary Donohoe, Laurena Holleran, Dara Cannon, Colm McDonald, Aiden Corvin, Michael Gill, Geraldo Busatto Filho, Pedro G. P. Rosa, Mauricio H. Serpa, Marcus Zanetti, Irina Lebedeva, Vasily Kaleda, Alexander Tomyshev, Tim Crow, Anthony James, Simon Cervenka, Carl M. Sellgren, Helena Fatouros-Bergman, Ingrid Agartz, Fleur Howells, Dan J. Stein, Henk Temmingh, Anne Uhlmann, Greig de Zubicaray, Katie L. McMahon, Margie Wright, Derin Cobia, John G. Csernansky, Paul M. Thompson, Jessica A. Turner, Lei Wang

Summary: Schizophrenia is associated with significant shape differences in subcortical brain structures, specifically more-concave-than-convex shapes in the hippocampus, amygdala, accumbens, and thalamus in individuals with schizophrenia. The study also found exaggerated patterns of asymmetry in schizophrenia patients compared to healthy controls, as well as associations between medication dosage and positive symptom levels with subcortical shape differences. These findings suggest common neural mechanisms may contribute to gray matter reduction in schizophrenia.

HUMAN BRAIN MAPPING (2022)

Article Clinical Neurology

A systems-level analysis highlights microglial activation as a modifying factor in common epilepsies

Andre Altmann, Mina Ryten, Martina Di Nunzio, Teresa Ravizza, Daniele Tolomeo, Regina H. Reynolds, Alyma Somani, Marco Bacigaluppi, Valentina Iori, Edoardo Micotti, Rossella Di Sapia, Milica Cerovic, Eleonora Palma, Gabriele Ruffolo, Juan A. Botia, Julie Absil, Saud Alhusaini, Marina K. M. Alvim, Pia Auvinen, Nuria Bargallo, Emanuele Bartolini, Benjamin Bender, Felipe P. G. Bergo, Tauana Bernardes, Andrea Bernasconi, Neda Bernasconi, Boris C. Bernhardt, Karen Blackmon, Barbara Braga, Maria Eugenia Caligiuri, Anna Calvo, Chad Carlson, Sarah J. A. Carr, Gianpiero L. Cavalleri, Fernando Cendes, Jian Chen, Shuai Chen, Andrea Cherubini, Luis Concha, Philippe David, Norman Delanty, Chantal Depondt, Orrin Devinsky, Colin P. Doherty, Martin Domin, Niels K. Focke, Sonya Foley, Wendy Franca, Antonio Gambardella, Renzo Guerrini, Khalid Hamandi, Derrek P. Hibar, Dmitry Isaev, Graeme D. Jackson, Neda Jahanshad, Reetta Kalviainen, Simon S. Keller, Peter Kochunov, Raviteja Kotikalapudi, Magdalena A. Kowalczyk, Ruben Kuzniecky, Patrick Kwan, Angelo Labate, Soenke Langner, Matteo Lenge, Min Liu, Pascal Martin, Mario Mascalchi, Stefano Meletti, Marcia E. Morita-Sherman, Terence J. O'Brien, Jose C. Pariente, Mark P. Richardson, Raul Rodriguez-Cruces, Christian Rummel, Taavi Saavalainen, Mira K. Semmelroch, Mariasavina Severino, Pasquale Striano, Thomas Thesen, Rhys H. Thomas, Manuela Tondelli, Domenico Tortora, Anna Elisabetta Vaudano, Lucy Vivash, Felix Podewils, Jan Wagner, Bernd Weber, Roland Wiest, Clarissa L. Yasuda, Guohao Zhang, Junsong Zhang, Costin Leu, Andreja Avbersek, Maria Thom, Christopher D. Whelan, Paul Thompson, Carrie R. McDonald, Annamaria Vezzani, Sanjay M. Sisodiya

Summary: The study identified elevated fractions of microglia and endothelial cells in regions of reduced cortical thickness, with differentially expressed genes showing enrichment for microglial markers, particularly activated microglial states. Findings suggest that activated microglia may play a role in cortical thinning in epilepsy.

NEUROPATHOLOGY AND APPLIED NEUROBIOLOGY (2022)

Review Neurosciences

The Enhancing NeuroImaging Genetics through Meta-Analysis Consortium: 10 Years of Global Collaborations in Human Brain Mapping

Paul M. Thompson, Neda Jahanshad, Lianne Schmaal, Jessica A. Turner, Anderson M. Winkler, Sophia I. Thomopoulos, Gary F. Egan, Peter Kochunov

Summary: This article introduces a special issue commemorating the 10th anniversary of the ENIGMA Consortium, highlighting the progress and achievements of international neuroimaging projects over the past decade, as well as exploring the impact of genetics on human brain development and disease.

HUMAN BRAIN MAPPING (2022)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

ENIGMA plus COINSTAC: Improving Findability, Accessibility, Interoperability, and Re-usability

Jessica A. Turner, Vince D. Calhoun, Paul M. Thompson, Neda Jahanshad, Christopher R. K. Ching, Sophia Thomopoulos, Eric Verner, Gregory P. Strauss, Anthony O. Ahmed, Matthew D. Turner, Sunitha Basodi, Judith M. Ford, Daniel H. Mathalon, Adrian Preda, Aysenil Belger, Bryon A. Mueller, Kelvin O. Lim, Theo G. M. van Erp

Summary: The application of the FAIR principles to clinical and neuroimaging data aims to make research products findable, accessible, interoperable, and reusable. ENIGMA and COINSTAC platforms combine technological approaches with sociological approaches to facilitate the use of machine-actionable data objects. Current efforts focus on improving access, interoperability, and reusability, with future plans to enhance findability and further connections to other resources.

NEUROINFORMATICS (2022)

Article Clinical Neurology

Development of a core outcome set for quality of life for adults with drug-resistant epilepsy: A multistakeholder Delphi consensus study

Sharon Chiang, Robert Moss, John M. Stern, Inna Hughes, S. Andrew Josephson, Jennifer R. Pearce, Brandon E. Kopald, Anup D. Patel, Vikram R. R. Rao

Summary: Using patient-centered Delphi methodology, this study defines the first core outcome set for measuring quality of life in clinical practice for adults with drug-resistant epilepsy. This set includes 32 outcomes that are not related to seizure frequency and severity.

EPILEPSIA (2023)

Article Neurosciences

Multisite test-retest reliability and compatibility of brain metrics derived from FreeSurfer versions 7.1, 6.0, and 5.3

Elizabeth Haddad, Fabrizio Pizzagalli, Alyssa H. Zhu, Ravi R. Bhatt, Tasfiya Islam, Iyad Ba Gari, Daniel Dixon, Sophia I. Thomopoulos, Paul M. Thompson, Neda Jahanshad

Summary: Automatic neuroimaging processing tools provide convenient and systematic methods for extracting features from brain magnetic resonance imaging scans. In this study, the reliability and compatibility of regional morphometric metrics derived from different versions of FreeSurfer were empirically assessed using test-retest data. The results showed lower compatibility between the latest version and older versions in terms of cortical thickness, surface area, and subcortical volumes. Replication studies in an independent sample confirmed these findings. The study highlights the importance of considering version-related inconsistencies in published findings.

HUMAN BRAIN MAPPING (2023)

Article Computer Science, Artificial Intelligence

Signed graph representation learning for functional-to-structural brain network mapping

Haoteng Tang, Lei Guo, Xiyao Fu, Yalin Wang, Scott Mackin, Olusola Ajilore, Alex D. Leow, Paul M. Thompson, Heng Huang, Liang Zhan

Summary: MRI-derived brain networks are widely used to understand interactions among brain regions and their relationships with brain development and diseases. Graph mining on these networks can help discover biomarkers for clinical phenotypes and neurodegenerative diseases. Most current studies focus on projecting structural networks onto functional networks to extract a fused representation.

MEDICAL IMAGE ANALYSIS (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Anatomically interpretable deep learning of brain age captures domain-specific cognitive impairment

Chenzhong Yin, Phoebe Imms, Mingxi Cheng, Anar Amgalan, Nahian F. Chowdhury, Roy J. Massett, Nikhil N. Chaudhari, Xinghe Chen, Paul M. Thompson, Paul Bogdan, Andrei Irimia

Summary: This study introduces a convolutional neural network (CNN) to estimate brain age (BA) from magnetic resonance images (MRIs) and achieves lower estimation errors compared to previous studies. The CNN provides detailed brain aging maps that reveal sex differences and neurocognitive trajectories in individuals with mild cognitive impairment (MCI) and Alzheimer's disease (AD). BA is shown to capture dementia symptom severity, functional disability, and executive function better than chronological age (CA) in individuals with MCI. The proposed framework can systematically map the relationship between aging-related neuroanatomy changes and neurocognitive measures in both cognitively normal individuals and those with MCI or AD, aiding in early identification of AD risk.

PROCEEDINGS OF THE NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA (2023)

Article Clinical Neurology

Stimulation better targets fast-ripple generating networks in super responders to the responsive neurostimulator system

Shennan Aibel Weiss, Dawn Eliashiv, John Stern, Daniel Rubinstein, Itzhak Fried, Chengyuan Wu, Ashwini Sharan, Jerome Engel, Richard Staba, Michael R. Sperling

Summary: The mechanism by which responsive neurostimulation (RNS) reduces seizure frequency is not well understood. This study examined whether stimulation of fast ripples (FRs) generating networks differs between RNS super responders and intermediate responders. The results showed that the efficiency of the FR temporal correlational network on stimulated contacts differed significantly between the two groups. These findings suggest that RNS that targets FR networks more effectively may reduce epileptogenicity better.

EPILEPSIA (2023)

Article Clinical Neurology

Increasing challenges to trial recruitment and conduct over time

Wesley T. T. Kerr, Advith S. S. Reddy, Sung Hyun Seo, Neo Kok, William C. C. Stacey, John M. M. Stern, Page B. B. Pennell, Jacqueline A. A. French

Summary: This study aimed to assess the changes in recruitment and retention challenges in clinical trials for focal onset epilepsy over time. A systematic analysis of randomized clinical trials was conducted to evaluate changes in participant numbers, trial sites, and countries since 1990. The study also analyzed the proportion of participants who completed each trial phase and the reasons for early trial exit. The findings highlight increasing challenges with participant recruitment and retention, as well as an increasing placebo response, emphasizing the need for changes in clinical trial design.

EPILEPSIA (2023)

No Data Available