Darwin's sexual selection: Understanding his ideas in context

Darwin's writings need to be seen in their fullness, as opposed to quote-mining individual sentences without the context of his passages. Sometimes Darwin wrote at length, apparently favorably, about ideas that he subsequently undermined, replacing them with a more integrative view that reflected his own broad compass. Darwin understood that nature is not simple, that not all members of a group may have evolved under the same selective regime, and that variation of all kinds is fundamental to selection in its several forms. Sexual selection requires sexual dimorphism; it is not centred on variation within sexes but on selection for the ability to acquire mates. Mutual sexual selection was rejected by Darwin for every species except humans. Mating success is not a matter of mere numbers but of the transmission of the most attractive features to the opposite sex. The term sexual selection should only be used when one sex uses a feature not present in the other sex to attract mates or repel rivals for mates. (C) 2014 Academie des sciences. Published by Elsevier Masson SAS. All rights reserved.