Tectonic overpressure and underpressure in lithospheric tectonics and metamorphism

The lithostatic pressure concept is most commonly applied on a geological scale for lithospheric processes and related evolution of metamorphic rock complexes. Here, various aspects of non-lithostatic overpressure and underpressure phenomena in lithospheric tectonics and metamorphism are reviewed on the basis of recently published literature. The main conclusion from this short review is that these phenomena certainly exist in nature on all time and space scales including geological ones. They are, in particular, responsible for some geological processes, which are otherwise difficult to explain, such as downward water suction into the interior of subducting slabs. Magnitudes of overpressure and underpressure are strongly variable and may potentially reach up to +/- 100% of the lithostatic pressure and up to a GPa-level. These magnitudes depend mainly on the rheology of deforming rocks and on the nature of related tectonic process. Rheological heterogeneity of deforming rock units, which is common in nature, has a tendency to enhance overpressure and underpressures. Large overpressure can typically be expected in rheologically strong (dry) bending rock units, in particular in the mantle lithosphere. However, rheological weakness of rocks and small local deviatoric stresses do not guarantee the absence of large overpressures in these rocks. Therefore, the influence of significant tectonic overpressure and/or underpressure cannot be excluded for any metamorphic complex a priori but should be instead tested by exploring realistic thermomechanical models for envisaged tectono-metamorphic scenarios. Many lithospheric rocks subjected to large overpressures and underpressures cannot be studied as they do not exhume to the surface. Some controversy exists concerning overpressure magnitudes for the ultrahigh-pressure (UHP) rocks and several conflicting hypotheses are proposed, which need to be thoroughly tested in the future. In this respect, the Alpine region may offer a unique opportunity for the testing of geological-scale overpressures in (U)HP rocks by combining structural-geological and petrological data with realistic lithospheric-scale numerical modelling.