4.7 Review

Water reuse in river basins with multiple users: A literature review

Journal

JOURNAL OF HYDROLOGY
Volume 522, Issue -, Pages 558-571

Publisher

ELSEVIER SCIENCE BV
DOI: 10.1016/j.jhydrol.2015.01.016

Keywords

Water reuse; Recoverable flow; Return flow; Non-consumed water; Water resources planning

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Unraveling the interaction between water users in a river basin is essential for sound water resources management, particularly in a context of increasing water scarcity and the need to save water. While most attention from managers and decision makers goes to allocation and withdrawals of surface water resources, reuse of non-consumed water gets only marginal attention despite the potentially significant volumes. As a consequence, claims of water saving are often grossly exaggerated. It is the purpose of this paper to explore the processes associated with water reuse in a river basin among users of varying nature and review existing methods for directly or indirectly describing non-consumed water, recoverable flow and/or water reuse. First a conceptual representation of processes surrounding water withdrawals and associated definitions is discussed, followed by a section on connectivity between individual withdrawals and the complex dynamics arising from dependencies and tradeoffs within a river basin. The current state-of-the-art in categorizing basin hydrological flows is summarized and its applicability to a water system where reuse occurs is explored. The core of the paper focuses on a selection and demonstration of existing indicators developed for assessing water reuse and its impacts. It is concluded that although several methods for analyses of water reuse and recoverable flows have been developed, a number of essential aspects of water reuse are left out of existing indicators. Moreover, a proven methodology for obtaining crucial quantitative information on recoverable flows is currently lacking. Future studies should aim at spatiotemporal tracking of the recoverable portion of water withdrawals and showing the dependency of multiple water users on such flows to water policy makers. (C) 2015 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Water Resources

Multi-year observations of the high mountain water cycle in the Langtang catchment, Central Himalaya

Jakob F. Steiner, Tika R. Gurung, Sharad P. Joshi, Inka Koch, Tuomo Saloranta, Joseph Shea, Arun B. Shrestha, Emmy Stigter, Walter W. Immerzeel

Summary: The Langtang catchment, located in the Central Himalaya, has been the focus of numerous research projects over the past four decades, with a strong emphasis on the cryospheric components of the water balance. Multiple weather stations and discharge stations have been established since 2012 to monitor atmospheric and hydrologic variables.

HYDROLOGICAL PROCESSES (2021)

Article Remote Sensing

Creating 1-km long-term (1980-2014) daily average air temperatures over the Tibetan Plateau by integrating eight types of reanalysis and land data assimilation products downscaled with MODIS-estimated temperature lapse rates based on machine learning

Hongbo Zhang, W. W. Immerzeel, Fan Zhang, Remco J. de Kok, Sally J. Gorrie, Ming Ye

Summary: A novel machine-learning based method was developed to accurately estimate daily air temperature in high-elevation areas of the Tibetan Plateau, utilizing remote sensing data and reanalysis datasets. By integrating observational data and multiple data sources, the accuracy of air temperature estimation was significantly improved.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF APPLIED EARTH OBSERVATION AND GEOINFORMATION (2021)

Article Environmental Sciences

Variable 21st Century Climate Change Response for Rivers in High Mountain Asia at Seasonal to Decadal Time Scales

S. Khanal, A. F. Lutz, P. D. A. Kraaijenbrink, B. van den Hurk, T. Yao, W. W. Immerzeel

Summary: The study reveals that the hydrological response to climate change in High Mountain Asia (HMA) varies across different river basins, largely influenced by their hydrological regimes. While total water availability increases at decadal scales, changes in seasonality and magnitude differ between basins, highlighting the importance of addressing these variations in adaptation strategies for future changes in the region.

WATER RESOURCES RESEARCH (2021)

Article Geography, Physical

Spatial and temporal patterns of snowmelt refreezing in a Himalayan catchment

Sanne B. M. Veldhuijsen, Remco J. de Kok, Emmy E. Stigter, Jakob F. Steiner, Tuomo M. Saloranta, Walter W. Immerzeel

Summary: The study aimed to improve understanding of spatial and temporal variability of refreezing in the Himalaya. Results showed significant spatial variability of refreezing amounting to 122 mm w.e. annually, with a seasonal altitudinal variability related to air temperature and snow depth. Daily refreezing simulations decreased by 84% compared to hourly simulations, emphasizing the importance of using sub-daily time steps to capture melt-refreeze cycles.

JOURNAL OF GLACIOLOGY (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Snow cover persistence reverses the altitudinal patterns of warming above and below 5000 m on the Tibetan Plateau

Hongbo Zhang, W. W. Immerzeel, Fan Zhang, Remco J. de Kok, Deliang Chen, Wei Yan

Summary: The study shows that in the Tibetan Plateau, high snow cover at high elevations weakens the strengthening of positive feedback, resulting in a reversed warming pattern above and below 5000 meters in altitude. Additionally, the presence of snow and glaciers induces a negative feedback by buffering effects that consume or reflect energy, and further decreases in snow cover and glacier extent at high elevations may amplify warming on the Tibetan Plateau.

SCIENCE OF THE TOTAL ENVIRONMENT (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Controls on the relative melt rates of debris-covered glacier surfaces

E. S. Miles, J. F. Steiner, P. Buri, W. W. Immerzeel, F. Pellicciotti

Summary: The study explores the impact of supraglacial debris, ice cliffs, and supraglacial ponds on glacier melt rates, highlighting the importance of considering these factors in global melt modeling. Results show that ice cliffs have a melt rate 2-3 times higher than clean glacier ice, with supraglacial ponds primarily influenced by latent heat exchange.

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

South Asian agriculture increasingly dependent on meltwater and groundwater

A. F. Lutz, W. W. Immerzeel, C. Siderius, R. R. Wijngaard, S. Nepal, A. B. Shrestha, P. Wester, H. Biemans

Summary: Climate change impacts the importance of meltwater and groundwater in South Asian agriculture, requiring offset of reduced rainfall. Additionally, socio-economic growth increases water demand.

NATURE CLIMATE CHANGE (2022)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

High Mountain Asia hydropower systems threatened by climate-driven landscape instability

Dongfeng Li, Xixi Lu, Desmond E. Walling, Ting Zhang, Jakob F. Steiner, Robert J. Wasson, Stephan Harrison, Santosh Nepal, Yong Nie, Walter W. Immerzeel, Dan H. Shugar, Michele Koppes, Stuart Lane, Zhenzhong Zeng, Xiaofei Sun, Alexandr Yegorov, Tobias Bolch

Summary: Climate change is worsening geohazards in High Mountain Asia, posing an increasing risk to hydropower and water infrastructure in the region. Melting and thawing of the cryosphere are altering water supply, affecting downstream food and energy systems. Building reservoirs to regulate water flow and generate hydropower is crucial, but vulnerable to various destabilizing processes.

NATURE GEOSCIENCE (2022)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Critical Role of Groundwater Inflow in Sustaining Lake Water Balance on the Western Tibetan Plateau

Yanbin Lei, Kun Yang, Walter W. Immerzeel, Peiping Song, Broxton W. Bird, Jiankun He, Huabiao Zhao, Zhiguo Li

Summary: Groundwater inflow plays a critical role in maintaining the water balance of lakes on the Tibetan Plateau. Our study reveals that endorheic lakes in the western Tibetan Plateau experience significant water level increase during the ice-covered period, which is attributed to substantial groundwater inflow. This inflow is likely associated with large-scale active faults in the limestone bedrock and abundant meltwater from high elevations.

GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2022)

Article Meteorology & Atmospheric Sciences

Historical Climate Trends over High Mountain Asia Derived from ERA5 Reanalysis Data

S. Khanal, S. Tiwari, A. F. Lutz, B. V. D. Hurk, W. W. Immerzeel

Summary: The climate of High Mountain Asia (HMA) has been changing in recent decades, with increasing temperatures and inconsistent precipitation changes. This study used daily ERA5 reanalysis data to explore changes in climate variables in HMA along the full altitudinal range. The results showed winter warming and summer wetting dominating in the interior part of HMA, with significant increasing trends in heatwave occurrences and heavy precipitation in certain areas. The changes in climatic extremes indicate potential increases in hazards such as floods, landslides, and droughts, impacting economic production and infrastructure.

JOURNAL OF APPLIED METEOROLOGY AND CLIMATOLOGY (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Progress and challenges in glacial lake outburst flood research (2017-2021): a research community perspective

Adam Emmer, Simon K. Allen, Mark Carey, Holger Frey, Christian Huggel, Oliver Korup, Martin Mergili, Ashim Sattar, Georg Veh, Thomas Y. Chen, Simon J. Cook, Mariana Correas-Gonzalez, Soumik Das, Alejandro Diaz Moreno, Fabian Drenkhan, Melanie Fischer, Walter W. Immerzeel, Enaut Izagirre, Ramesh Chandra Joshi, Ioannis Kougkoulos, Riamsara Kuyakanon Knapp, Dongfeng Li, Ulfat Majeed, Stephanie Matti, Holly Moulton, Faezeh Nick, Valentine Piroton, Irfan Rashid, Masoom Reza, Anderson Ribeiro de Figueiredo, Christian Riveros, Finu Shrestha, Milan Shrestha, Jakob Steiner, Noah Walker-Crawford, Joanne L. Wood, Jacob C. Yde

Summary: This study provides an overview of recent research on glacial lake outburst floods (GLOFs) and presents trends and challenges for future research based on perspectives from the first GLOF conference. The study highlights the increasing focus on understanding the physical drivers and mechanisms of GLOF hazards and the socioeconomic factors affecting vulnerabilities to GLOF events.

NATURAL HAZARDS AND EARTH SYSTEM SCIENCES (2022)

Review Environmental Sciences

The imbalance of the Asian water tower

Tandong Yao, Tobias Bolch, Deliang Chen, Jing Gao, Walter Immerzeel, Shilong Piao, Fengge Su, Lonnie Thompson, Yoshihide Wada, Lei Wang, Tao Wang, Guangjian Wu, Baiqing Xu, Wei Yang, Guoqing Zhang, Ping Zhao

Summary: The Hindu Kush-Karakoram-Himalayan system, known as the Third Pole, is the largest global store of frozen water after the polar regions. It provides water supply to almost 2 billion people. However, atmospheric warming has caused an imbalance in this system, altering water resources in downstream countries. Future predictions suggest that global warming will amplify this imbalance, alleviating water scarcity in some regions while increasing it in others.

NATURE REVIEWS EARTH & ENVIRONMENT (2022)

Article Geography, Physical

Understanding monsoon controls on the energy and mass balance of glaciers in the Central and Eastern Himalaya

Stefan Fugger, Catriona L. Fyffe, Simone Fatichi, Evan Miles, Michael McCarthy, Thomas E. Shaw, Baohong Ding, Wei Yang, Patrick Wagnon, Walter Immerzeel, Qiao Liu, Francesca Pellicciotti

Summary: The Indian and East Asian summer monsoons have complex effects on the melt and accumulation patterns of glaciers in High Mountain Asia. This study uses an energy- and mass-balance model and weather station datasets to investigate the influence of monsoon conditions on glacier surface energy and mass balance.

CRYOSPHERE (2022)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Future upstream water consumption and its impact on downstream water availability in the transboundary Indus Basin

Wouter J. Smolenaars, Sanita Dhaubanjar, Muhammad K. Jamil, Arthur Lutz, Walter Immerzeel, Fulco Ludwig, Hester Biemans

Summary: The water resources in the upstream Indus Basin, originating from the mountains, are crucial for the densely populated plains in the lower Indus Basin. This study quantifies the comparative impact of future water usage in the upper Indus on downstream water availability, considering climate change and socio-economic development. The results show that water consumption and pressure on water resources will vary across seasons and sub-basins in the upper Indus, leading to reduced water availability in the lower Indus during the dry season. This study highlights the importance of considering socio-economic changes in the upper Indus and anticipating competition between upstream and downstream riparian states in long-term water management.

HYDROLOGY AND EARTH SYSTEM SCIENCES (2022)

Article Geography, Physical

Mapping the aerodynamic roughness of the Greenland Ice Sheet surface using ICESat-2: evaluation over the K-transect

Maurice van Tiggelen, Paul C. J. P. Smeets, Carleen H. Reijmer, Bert Wouters, Jakob F. Steiner, Emile J. Nieuwstraten, Walter W. Immerzeel, Michiel R. van den Broeke

Summary: The study used an aerodynamic roughness model to estimate the aerodynamic roughness of different surfaces on the Greenland Ice Sheet, and validated it against in situ observations using satellite laser altimetry and UAV photogrammetry. The results showed significant spatio-temporal variability in aerodynamic roughness over the ice sheet, ranging from smooth snow surfaces to rough crevassed areas, highlighting the importance of incorporating variable aerodynamic roughness in atmospheric models over ice sheets.

CRYOSPHERE (2021)

Article Engineering, Civil

Reconstructing high-resolution groundwater level data using a hybrid random forest model to quantify distributed groundwater changes in the Indus Basin

Arfan Arshad, Ali Mirchi, Javier Vilcaez, Muhammad Umar Akbar, Kaveh Madani

Summary: High-resolution, continuous groundwater data is crucial for adaptive aquifer management. This study presents a predictive modeling framework that incorporates covariates and existing observations to estimate groundwater level changes. The framework outperforms other methods and provides reliable estimates for unmonitored sites. The study also examines groundwater level changes in different regions and highlights the importance of effective aquifer management.

JOURNAL OF HYDROLOGY (2024)

Article Engineering, Civil

Hydrological modelling of large-scale karst-dominated basin using a grid-based distributed karst hydrological model

Lihua Chen, Jie Deng, Wenzhe Yang, Hang Chen

Summary: A new grid-based distributed karst hydrological model (GDKHM) is developed to simulate streamflow in the flood-prone karst area of Southwest China. The results show that the GDKHM performs well in predicting floods and capturing the spatial variability of karst system.

JOURNAL OF HYDROLOGY (2024)

Article Engineering, Civil

Using a physics-based hydrological model and storm transposition to investigate machine-learning algorithms for streamflow prediction

Faruk Gurbuz, Avinash Mudireddy, Ricardo Mantilla, Shaoping Xiao

Summary: Machine learning algorithms have shown better performance in streamflow prediction compared to traditional hydrological models. In this study, researchers proposed a methodology to test and benchmark ML algorithms using artificial data generated by physically-based hydrological models. They found that deep learning algorithms can correctly identify the relationship between streamflow and rainfall in certain conditions, but fail to outperform traditional prediction methods in other scenarios.

JOURNAL OF HYDROLOGY (2024)

Article Engineering, Civil

Uncertainty separation of drought projection in the 21st century using SMILEs and CMIP6

Yadong Ji, Jianyu Fu, Bingjun Liu, Zeqin Huang, Xuejin Tan

Summary: This study distinguishes the uncertainty in drought projection into scenario uncertainty, model uncertainty, and internal variability uncertainty. The results show that the estimation of total uncertainty reaches a minimum in the mid-21st century and that model uncertainty is dominant in tropical regions.

JOURNAL OF HYDROLOGY (2024)

Article Engineering, Civil

Quantifying the natural flood management potential of leaky dams in upland catchments, Part II: Leaky dam impacts on flood peak magnitude

Z. R. van Leeuwen, M. J. Klaar, M. W. Smith, L. E. Brown

Summary: This study quantifies the effectiveness of leaky dams in reducing flood peak magnitude using a transfer function noise modelling approach. The results show that leaky dams have a significant but highly variable impact on flood peak magnitude, and managing expectations should consider event size and type.

JOURNAL OF HYDROLOGY (2024)

Article Engineering, Civil

Forecasting and optimization for minimizing combined sewer overflows using Machine learning frameworks and its inversion techniques

Zeda Yin, Yasaman Saadati, M. Hadi Amini, Linlong Bian, Beichao Hu

Summary: Combined sewer overflows pose significant threats to public health and the environment, and various strategies have been proposed to mitigate their adverse effects. Smart control strategies have gained traction due to their cost-effectiveness but face challenges in balancing precision and computational efficiency. To address this, we propose exploring machine learning models and the inversion of neural networks for more efficient CSO prediction and optimization.

JOURNAL OF HYDROLOGY (2024)

Article Engineering, Civil

Characterizing nitrogen dynamics and their response to sediment dredging in a lowland rural river

Qimou Zhang, Jiacong Huang, Jing Zhang, Rui Qian, Zhen Cui, Junfeng Gao

Summary: This study developed a N-cycling model for lowland rural rivers covered by macrophytes and investigated the N imports, exports, and response to sediment dredging. The findings showed a considerable N retention ability in the study river, with significant N imports from connected rivers and surrounding polders. Sediment dredging increased particulate nitrogen resuspension and settling rates, while decreasing ammonia nitrogen release, denitrification, and macrophyte uptake rates.

JOURNAL OF HYDROLOGY (2024)

Article Engineering, Civil

Using a two-step downscaling method to assess the impact of climate change on total nitrogen load in a small basin

Xue Li, Yingyin Zhou, Jian Sha, Man Zhang, Zhong-Liang Wang

Summary: High-resolution climate data is crucial for predicting regional climate and water environment changes. In this study, a two-step downscaling method was developed to enhance the spatial resolution of GCM data and improve the accuracy for small basins. The method combined medium-resolution climate data with high-resolution topographic data to capture spatial and temporal details. The downscaled climate data were then used to simulate the impacts of climate change on hydrology and water quality in a small basin. The results demonstrated the effectiveness of the downscaling method for spatially differentiated simulations.

JOURNAL OF HYDROLOGY (2024)

Article Engineering, Civil

Permafrost on the Tibetan Plateau is degrading: Historical and projected trends

Tongqing Shen, Peng Jiang, Jiahui Zhao, Xuegao Chen, Hui Lin, Bin Yang, Changhai Tan, Ying Zhang, Xinting Fu, Zhongbo Yu

Summary: This study evaluates the long-term interannual dynamics of permafrost distribution and active layer thickness on the Tibetan Plateau, and predicts future degradation trends. The results show that permafrost area has been decreasing and active layer thickness has been increasing, with an accelerated degradation observed in recent decades. This has significant implications for local water cycle processes, water ecology, and water security.

JOURNAL OF HYDROLOGY (2024)

Article Engineering, Civil

Quantifying precipitation moisture contributed by different atmospheric circulations across the Tibetan Plateau

Chi Zhang, Xu Zhang, Qiuhong Tang, Deliang Chen, Jinchuan Huang, Shaohong Wu, Yubo Liu

Summary: Precipitation over the Tibetan Plateau is influenced by systems such as the Asian monsoons, the westerlies, and local circulations. The Indian monsoon, the westerlies, and local circulations are the main systems affecting precipitation over the entire Tibetan Plateau. The East Asian summer monsoon primarily affects the eastern Tibetan Plateau. The Indian monsoon has the greatest influence on precipitation in the southern and central grid cells, while the westerlies have the greatest influence on precipitation in the northern and western grid cells. Local circulations have the strongest influence on the central and eastern grid cells.

JOURNAL OF HYDROLOGY (2024)

Article Engineering, Civil

A methodology to improve the accuracy of Total phosphorous diffuse load estimates from agroforestry watersheds

Manuel Almeida, Antonio Rodrigues, Pedro Coelho

Summary: This study aimed to improve the accuracy of Total Phosphorus export coefficient models, which are essential for water management. Four different models were applied to 27 agroforestry watersheds in the Mediterranean region. The modeling approach showed significant improvements in predicting the Total Phosphorus diffuse loads.

JOURNAL OF HYDROLOGY (2024)

Article Engineering, Civil

Prediction of dissolved organic nitrogen via spectroscopic fingerprint in the shallow riverbed sediments of effluent-dominated rivers: A case study in Xi'an, northwest China

Yutao Wang, Haojie Yin, Ziyi Wang, Yi Li, Pingping Wang, Longfei Wang

Summary: This study investigated the distribution and transformation of dissolved organic nitrogen (DON) in riverbed sediments impacted by effluent discharge. The authors found that the spectral characteristics of dissolved organic matter (DOM) in surface water and sediment porewater could be used to predict DON variations in riverbed sediments. Random forest and extreme gradient boosting machine learning methods were employed to provide accurate predictions of DON content and properties at different depths. These findings have important implications for wastewater discharge management and river health.

JOURNAL OF HYDROLOGY (2024)

Article Engineering, Civil

Uncertainty analysis of 100-year flood maps under climate change scenarios

Saba Mirza Alipour, Kolbjorn Engeland, Joao Leal

Summary: This study assesses the uncertainty associated with 100-year flood maps under different scenarios using Monte Carlo simulations. The findings highlight the importance of employing probabilistic approaches for accurate and secure flood maps, with the selection of probability distribution being the primary source of uncertainty in precipitation.

JOURNAL OF HYDROLOGY (2024)

Article Engineering, Civil

Hydrological consequences of controlled drainage with subirrigation

Janine A. de Wit, Marjolein H. J. van Huijgevoort, Jos C. van Dam, Ge A. P. H. van den Eertwegh, Dion van Deijl, Coen J. Ritsema, Ruud P. Bartholomeus

Summary: The study focuses on the hydrological consequences of controlled drainage with subirrigation (CD-SI) on groundwater level, soil moisture content, and soil water potential. The simulations show that CD-SI can improve hydrological conditions for crop growth, but the success depends on subtle differences in geohydrologic characteristics.

JOURNAL OF HYDROLOGY (2024)

Article Engineering, Civil

Understanding the global success criteria for managed aquifer recharge schemes

Constantin Seidl, Sarah Ann Wheeler, Declan Page

Summary: Water availability and quality issues will become increasingly important in the future due to climate change impacts. Managed Aquifer Recharge (MAR) is an effective water management tool, but often overlooked. This study analyzes global MAR applications and identifies the key factors for success, providing valuable insights for future design and application.

JOURNAL OF HYDROLOGY (2024)