4.7 Article

Higher seed number compensates for lower fruit set in deceptive orchids

Journal

JOURNAL OF ECOLOGY
Volume 104, Issue 2, Pages 343-351

Publisher

WILEY
DOI: 10.1111/1365-2745.12511

Keywords

deception; nectar reward; Orchidaceae; phylogenetic comparative methods; pollination; reproductive ecology; reproductive success; seed mass; seed number; thousand-seed weight

Funding

  1. OTKA [K108992, PD100192, PD109686]
  2. [TAMOP-4.2.4.A/2-11/1-2012-0001]
  3. [TAMOP-4.2.2.B-15/1/KONV-2015-0001]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Floral deception is widespread in orchids, with more than one-third of the species being pollinated this way. The evolutionary success of deceptive orchids is puzzling, as species employing this strategy are thought to have low reproductive success (less flowers yielding fruits) because of low pollination rates. However, direct measurements of total seed production in orchids - which is a better measure of reproductive success - are scarce due to the extremely small size of their seeds. Here, we quantified seed numbers in 1015 fruits belonging to 48 orchid species from the Pannonian ecoregion (central Europe) and obtained fruit set and thousand-seed weight data for these species from the literature. We used phylogenetic comparative methods to test the hypothesis that deceptive species should compensate for their lower fruit set by having either more flowers, larger seeds or more seeds in a fruit. Similarly to previous studies, we found that deceptive orchids have substantially lower fruits-set than nectar-rewarding ones. Also, we found that deceptive species have more seeds in a fruit but not more flowers or larger seeds compared to nectar-rewarding ones. Based on our results, deceptive species compensate for their lower fruit set by having higher seed numbers per fruit. As a consequence, their seed numbers per shoot do not differ from that of nectar-rewarding ones. Together with other benefits of deceptive pollination (e.g. lower energy expenditure due to the lack of nectar production and higher genetic variability due to decreased probability of geitonogamous pollination), our results can explain why deceptive strategies are so widespread in the orchid family.Synthesis. Our results indicate that deceptive orchids can compensate for their lower fruit set by having more (but not larger) seeds in a fruit than rewarding species. These findings highlight possible ways in which plants can increase their reproductive success in face of pollinator limitation. We emphasize that fruit set in itself is an inappropriate measure of the reproductive success of orchids - the total number of seeds per shoot is a much better approximation.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Ecology

Post-restoration grassland management overrides the effects of restoration methods in propagule-rich landscapes

Csaba Tolgyesi, Csaba Vadasz, Robert Kun, Andras Istvan Csatho, Zoltan Batori, Alida Habenczyus, Laszlo Erdos, Peter Torok

Summary: Grassland restoration globally is seeing progress in addressing biodiversity loss and ecosystem service depletion. The choice of post-restoration management plays a crucial role in the long-term community reassembly, potentially having a comparable impact to the restoration method chosen. Selecting an optimal post-restoration management strategy is essential for ensuring successful restoration outcomes in grasslands.

ECOLOGICAL APPLICATIONS (2022)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Turning old foes into new allies-Harnessing drainage canals for biodiversity conservation in a desiccated European lowland region

Csaba Tolgyesi, Attila Torma, Zoltan Batori, Jelena Seat, Milos Popovic, Robert Galle, Nikolett Galle-Szpisjak, Laszlo Erdos, Tamas Vinko, Andras Kelemen, Peter Torok

Summary: Drainage canals, previously considered detrimental to nature conservation, have been found to harbor high biodiversity and should be recognized as important novel ecosystems with conservation value. Agricultural canals support remarkable species richness, especially for native species, but may also serve as important dispersal corridors for non-native invasive plants. Canal size has little effect on biodiversity, but habitat stress, such as sandiness and salinity, plays a significant role in determining the added value of canals to landscape-wide biodiversity.

JOURNAL OF APPLIED ECOLOGY (2022)

Article Ecology

Urgent need for updating the slogan of global climate actions from tree planting to restore native vegetation

Csaba Tolgyesi, Elise Buisson, Aveliina Helm, Vicky M. Temperton, Peter Torok

Summary: While tree planting is a common nature-based solution for addressing climate change, it has serious drawbacks in many regions. Grasslands, as natural vegetation, may support higher biodiversity and a safer carbon stock than plantations and forests, suggesting that restoring native vegetation may be a more effective alternative to tree planting.

RESTORATION ECOLOGY (2022)

Article Plant Sciences

Taxonomic, functional and phylogenetic diversity peaks do not coincide along a compositional gradient in forest-grassland mosaics

Laszlo Erdos, Khanh Vu Ho, Zoltan Batori, Gyorgy Kroel-Dulay, Gabor Onodi, Csaba Tolgyesi, Peter Torok, Attila Lengyel

Summary: Ecosystems with forest and grassland patches as alternative stable states contain various habitats aligned along a vegetation cover gradient, showing different patterns of taxonomic, functional, and phylogenetic diversity. Taxonomic diversity peaks in the middle of the gradient, functional diversity is high in woody habitats but lower in grassland, and phylogenetic diversity varies depending on the evolutionary age of the habitats. The community assembly in grasslands may be dominated by environmental filtering, while competition may be decisive in woody habitats.

JOURNAL OF ECOLOGY (2023)

Article Ecology

Resource availability modulates the effect of body size on reproductive development

Reka Gergely, Jacint Tokolyi

Summary: Within-species variation in animal body size predicts major differences in life history, for example, in reproductive development, fecundity, and longevity. Large size could fuel different life functions, such as reproduction and survival (the energy reserve hypothesis), while demanding more energy for maintenance (the energy demand hypothesis). Disentangling these hypotheses is difficult due to resource availability, but manipulating body size and resource availability in Hydra oligactis, we found evidence supporting the energy reserve hypothesis and observed different responses in males and females.

ECOLOGY AND EVOLUTION (2023)

Article Plant Sciences

Intensity-dependent effects of cattle and sheep grazing in sand grasslands - Does livestock type really matter?

Gergely Kovacsics-Vari, Judit Sonkoly, Katalin Toth, Andrea McIntosh-Buday, Patricia Diaz Cando, Viktoria Toro-Szijgyarto, Nora Balogh, Luis Roberto Guallichico Suntaxi, Francis David Espinoza Ami, Laszlo Demeter, Bela Tothmeresz, Peter Torok

Summary: By analysing cattle-and sheep-grazed sand grasslands in the Nyirseg region, East Hungary, the study aimed to determine the effects of livestock type and grazing intensity on vegetation characteristics. The results showed that livestock type did not have a significant independent effect on the studied characteristics, but the interaction between livestock type and grazing intensity did have an impact. It was concluded that careful adjustment of grazing intensity and long-term experiments studying different livestock and habitat types are essential for the management of sand grasslands.

APPLIED VEGETATION SCIENCE (2023)

Article Forestry

Non-native tree plantations are weak substitutes for near-natural forests regarding plant diversity and ecological value

Khanh Vu Ho, Gyorgy Kroel-Dulay, Csaba Tolgyesi, Zoltan Batori, Eszter Tanacs, Miklos Kertesz, Peter Torok, Laszlo Erdos

Summary: This study investigated the differences in species composition and ecological value between natural poplar forests and three common types of tree plantations in central Hungary. The results showed that natural poplar forests had the highest species richness and diversity and the highest ecological and conservation value compared to the plantations. The study suggests that conservation and restoration efforts should prioritize the protection of natural poplar forests.

FOREST ECOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT (2023)

Article Agronomy

Effects of habitat management on newly found populations of the endangered weed, Mummenhoffia alliacea (Brassicaceae)

Henrietta Bak, Reka Fekete, Peter Torok, Kristof Suveges, V. Attila Molnar

Summary: Garlic pennycress (Mummenhoffia alliacea) is a rare weed protected in Hungary, and three new sites of this species were discovered in 2021. A study was conducted to investigate the effects of habitat management practices on seed mass and germination. Late-spring mowing was found to be optimal for the reproduction of M. alliacea, and traditional mowing methods were more beneficial for the species' survival compared to modern lawnmowers. The highest observed NaCl concentration for germination was 0.75 m/m%, indicating that anthropogenic habitats could be suitable for the species.

WEED RESEARCH (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Spontaneously occurring tumors in different wild-derived strains of hydra

Justine Boutry, Marie Buysse, Sophie Tissot, Chantal Cazevielle, Rodrigo Hamede, Antoine M. Dujon, Beata Ujvari, Mathieu Giraudeau, Alexander Klimovich, Frederic Thomas, Jacint Tokolyi

Summary: This study investigates the diversity of tumors found in freshwater cnidarians called hydras, specifically looking at different sexes and geographical origins. The study also identifies a unique microbiota associated with these tumors, providing new insights into the understanding of tumor susceptibility and diversity in hydras.

SCIENTIFIC REPORTS (2023)

Article Ecology

Warming increases survival and asexual fitness in a facultatively sexual freshwater cnidarian with winter diapause

Jacint Tokolyi

Summary: Temperature plays a crucial role in controlling population dynamics of facultatively sexual animals. The increasing temperature due to global warming is likely to disrupt the population dynamics of these animals, which are key components of freshwater ecosystems. This study focused on the fitness effects of warming in Hydra oligactis, a freshwater cnidarian. The results showed that warming had a complex effect on sexual fitness, with a decrease in gonad number but an increase in multiple rounds of gamete production. Asexual reproduction and survival rate also increased in response to higher temperature. These findings predict an increased population growth of H. oligactis in temperate freshwater habitats, which will have implications for the whole aquatic ecosystem.

ECOLOGY AND EVOLUTION (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

New thousand-seed weight dataset for plant species of Central Europe

Viktoria Toro-Szijgyarto, Nora Balogh, Tamas Henn, Andrea McIntosh-Buday, Judit Sonkoly, Attila Takacs, Gergely Kovacsics-Vari, Patricia Diaz Cando, V. Attila Molnar, Gabor Matus, Balazs Teleki, Kristof Suveges, Balazs A. Lukacs, Adam Lovas-Kiss, Bela Tothmeresz, Edina Toth, Katalin Toth, Peter Torok

Summary: Seed weight is an important and measurable physical characteristic of plant seeds, influencing crucial ecological processes. It affects dispersal, predation, germination, growth, and survival of seedlings. Providing trait data for species missing from international databases is essential for advancing our understanding of plant communities and ecosystems in the face of global climate change and biodiversity loss.

DATA IN BRIEF (2023)

Article Marine & Freshwater Biology

Linear water column stratification and euphotic depth determine the number of phytoplankton taxa that create biomass peaks in a hypertrophic oxbow lake

Eniko T-Krasznai, Viktoria B-Beres, Verona Lerf, Gabor Varbiro, Andras Abonyi, Peter Torok, Gabor Borics

Summary: The distribution of phytoplankton in lakes is largely determined by the mixing regime, the spatial distribution of nutrients, and light. Linear stratification, representing a continuous and gradual decrease in water temperature with depth, was investigated to understand its impact on the vertical distribution of phytoplankton. The study found that multiple biomass peaks of different phytoplankton functional groups could develop in response to the strong linear stratification of the water column. Light irradiance did not influence the vertical distribution of biomass and taxonomic richness, but the depth of the euphotic zone played a role in determining the number of distinct biomass peaks.

HYDROBIOLOGIA (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

PADAPT 1.0-the Pannonian Dataset of Plant Traits

Judit Sonkoly, Edina Toth, Nora Balogh, Lajos Balogh, Denes Bartha, Kinga Csendesne Bata, Zoltan Batori, Nora Bekefi, Zoltan Botta-Dukat, Janos Boloni, Aniko Csecserits, Janos Csiky, Peter Csontos, Istvan Dancza, Balazs Deak, Zoltan Konstantin Dobolyi, Anna E-Vojtko, Ferenc Gyulai, Alida Anna Habenczyus, Tamas Henn, Ferenc Horvath, Maria Hohn, Gusztav Jakab, Andras Kelemen, Gergely Kiraly, Szabolcs Kis, Gergely Kovacsics-Vari, Andras Kun, Eva Lehoczky, Attila Lengyel, Barbara Lhotsky, Viktor Loki, Balazs Andras Lukacs, Gabor Matus, Andrea McIntosh-Buday, Attila Mesterhazy, Tamas Miglecz, V. Attila Molnar, Zsolt Molnar, Tamas Morschhauser, Laszlo Papp, Patricia Posa, Tamas Redei, David Schmidt, Ferenc Szmorad, Attila Takacs, Julia Tamas, Viktor Tiborcz, Csaba Tolgyesi, Katalin Toth, Bela Tothmeresz, Orsolya Valko, Viktor Virok, Tamas Wirth, Peter Torok

Summary: The existing plant trait databases have limited applicability for studying the flora and vegetation of Eastern and Central Europe due to their limited geographical data coverage and incorporation of records from regions with different climatic conditions. To address this issue, PADAPT, a regional dataset of plant traits for the Pannonian region, has been compiled, providing data on 54 traits and attributes of plant species in the region.

SCIENTIFIC DATA (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

How to not trade water for carbon with tree planting in water-limited temperate biomes

Csaba Tolgyesi, Alida Anna Habenczyus, Andras Kelemen, Peter Torok, Orsolya Valko, Balazs Deak, Laszlo Erdos, Benedek Toth, Nandor Csikos, Zoltan Batori

Summary: Tree planting is a widely used nature-based solution for mitigating climate change. However, it can have adverse effects in naturally open biomes, such as water shortage due to increased evapotranspiration. This study assessed how soil texture affects the trade-off between tree cover and water balance in the forest-steppe biome.

SCIENCE OF THE TOTAL ENVIRONMENT (2023)

No Data Available