4.4 Article

GP-delivered brief weight loss interventions: a cohort study of patient responses and subsequent actions, using conversation analysis in UK primary care

Journal

BRITISH JOURNAL OF GENERAL PRACTICE
Volume 68, Issue 674, Pages E646-E653

Publisher

ROYAL COLL GENERAL PRACTITIONERS
DOI: 10.3399/bjgp18X698405

Keywords

conversation analysis; health behaviours; medical communication; primary health care

Funding

  1. National Institute for Health Research School for Primary Care Research
  2. National Prevention Research Initiative
  3. Alzheimer's Research UK
  4. Alzheimer's Society
  5. Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council
  6. British Heart Foundation
  7. Cancer Research UK
  8. Chief Scientist Office
  9. Scottish Government Health Directorate
  10. Department of Health
  11. Diabetes UK
  12. Economic and Social Research Council
  13. Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council
  14. Health and Social Care Research Division
  15. Public Health Agency
  16. Northern Ireland
  17. MRC
  18. Stroke Association
  19. Wellcome Trust
  20. Welsh Government
  21. World Cancer Research Fund [MR/J000515/1]
  22. Oxford NIHR Biomedical Research Centre
  23. CLAHRC
  24. MRC [MR/J000515/1] Funding Source: UKRI

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Background Guidelines encourage GPs to make brief opportunistic interventions to support weight loss. However, GPs fear that starting these discussions will lead to lengthy consultations. Recognising that patients are committed to take action could allow GPs to shorten brief interventions. Aim To examine which patient responses indicated commitment to action, and the time saved if these had been recognised and the consultation closed sooner. Design and setting A mixed-method cohort study of UK primary care patients participating in a trial of opportunistic weight management interventions. Method Conversation analysis was applied to 226 consultation audiorecordings to identify types of responses from patients that indicated that an offer of referral to weight management was well received. Odds ratios (OR) were calculated to examine associations between response types and likelihood of weight management programme attendance. Results Affirmative responses, for example 'yes', displayed no conversational evidence that the referral was well received and showed no association with attendance: 'yes' (OR 1.2, 95% confidence interval [CI] = 0.37 to 3.95, P = 0.97). However, 'oh'-prefaced responses and marked positive responses, for example 'lovely', showed conversational evidence of enthusiasm and were associated with higher odds of commercial weight management service attendance. Recognising these could have saved doctors a mean of 31 seconds per consultation. Conclusion When doctors make brief opportunistic interventions that incorporate the offer of help, 'oh'-prefaced or marked positive responses indicate enthusiastic acceptance of the offer and a higher likelihood of take-up. Recognising these responses and moving swiftly to facilitate patient action would shorten the brief intervention in many cases.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.4
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Acceptability of integrating smoking cessation treatment into routine care for people with mental illness: A qualitative study

Katherine Sawyer, Kim Fredman Stein, Pamela Jacobsen, Tom P. Freeman, Anna K. M. Blackwell, Chris Metcalfe, David Kessler, Marcus R. Munafo, Paul Aveyard, Gemma M. J. Taylor

Summary: This study aimed to understand participants' views and experiences of receiving a novel smoking cessation intervention. The results showed that the majority of people accepted the integrated smoking cessation and mental health treatment, but there were also some implementation barriers.

HEALTH EXPECTATIONS (2023)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Clinician-patient communication about emergency aerial medical evacuation in case of infectious disease

Charlotte Albury, Madeleine Tremblett, Helena Webb, Rachna Begh, Rebecca Barnes, Wendy Lawrence, Nichola Walmsley, Deborah Groenewald, Marise Caunter, Dipti Patel

Summary: The analysis of clinician-patient telephone consultations revealed that informing individuals about the process and potential for Accompanied Medical Escort (AME) could enhance their understanding and enable informed decision making before traveling. Clear steps for clinicians to facilitate this were identified.

JOURNAL OF TRAVEL MEDICINE (2023)

Article Endocrinology & Metabolism

Weight regain and mental health outcomes following behavioural weight management programmes: A systematic review with meta-analyses

Annika Theodoulou, Jamie Hartmann-Boyce, Jordan Gorenberg, Jason L. L. Oke, Ailsa R. R. Butler, Anastasios Bastounis, Susan A. A. Jebb, Paul Aveyard

Summary: Behavioral weight management programs can lead to weight loss, but subsequent weight regain may negatively affect mental health outcomes. A meta-analysis of 47 studies found that these programs did not harm mental health and may actually improve some dimensions of it. However, the association between weight change and changes in depression and/or anxiety scores over time was inconclusive.

CLINICAL OBESITY (2023)

Article Substance Abuse

Effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of behavioural support for prolonged abstinence for smokers wishing to reduce but not quit: Randomised controlled trial of physical activity assisted reduction of smoking (TARS)

Adrian H. Taylor, Tom P. Thompson, Adam Streeter, Jade Chynoweth, Tristan Snowsill, Wendy Ingram, Michael Ussher, Paul Aveyard, Rachael L. Murray, Tess Harris, Lynne Callaghan, Colin Green, Colin J. Greaves, Lisa Price, Siobhan Creanor

Summary: Behavioral support can effectively reduce smoking and increase physical activity for smokers who are unmotivated to quit, but it does not have long-term effects on smoking cessation and physical activity.

ADDICTION (2023)

Article Psychiatry

Development and initial evaluation of a behavioural intervention to support weight management for people with serious mental illness: an uncontrolled feasibility and acceptability study

Charlotte Lee, Felicity Waite, Carmen Piernas, Paul Aveyard

Summary: This study aimed to develop an intervention to improve uptake and engagement with a mainstream weight management program for people with serious mental illness (SMI). The intervention included attending a 12-week mainstream weight management program and receiving online adjunct support and regular check-ins. Preliminary results showed that the intervention was feasible and acceptable, warranting further trials.

BMC PSYCHIATRY (2023)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

#TreatmentResistantDepression: A qualitative content analysis of Tweets about difficult-to-treat depression

Amelia Talbot, Tori Ford, Sara Ryan, Kamal R. Mahtani, Charlotte Albury

Summary: This study explores the role of the Twitter community in the context of treatment-resistant depression (TRD). The findings indicate that Twitter serves as a platform for individuals with TRD to share experiences, symptoms, and recommendations. However, it also highlights the potential risks of sharing misinformation and the perceived lack of knowledge and support from general practitioners (GPs).

HEALTH EXPECTATIONS (2023)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Motivational support intervention to reduce smoking and increase physical activity in smokers not ready to quit: the TARS RCT

Adrian H. Taylor, Tom P. Thompson, Adam Streeter, Jade Chynoweth, Tristan Snowsill, Wendy Ingram, Michael Ussher, Paul Aveyard, Rachael L. Murray, Tess Harris, Colin Green, Jane Horrell, Lynne Callaghan, Colin J. Greaves, Lisa Price, Lucy Cartwright, Jonny Wilks, Sarah Campbell, Dan Preece, Siobhan Creanor

Summary: This study examined the effect of motivational support for smokers who wanted to reduce smoking but not quit immediately. The intervention, which aimed to increase physical activity and reduce smoking, did not lead to significant increases in prolonged abstinence. Additionally, the intervention was not cost-effective.

HEALTH TECHNOLOGY ASSESSMENT (2023)

Article Endocrinology & Metabolism

Association between the month of starting a weight management program and weight change in people at high risk of type 2 diabetes: A prospective cohort study

Dimitrios A. Koutoukidis, Emma Barron, Richard Stevens, Paul Aveyard, Jonathan Valabhji, Susan A. Jebb

Summary: This study found that people who start a weight management program in January tend to lose more weight compared to those who start at other times of the year, with a difference ranging from 12% to 30%.

OBESITY (2023)

Editorial Material Medicine, Research & Experimental

Recommendations for progression criteria during external randomised pilot trial design, conduct, analysis and reporting

Katie Mellor, Charlotte Albury, Susan J. Dutton, Sandra Eldridge, Sally Hopewell

Summary: This commentary presents a proposed set of recommendations for progression criteria in external randomised pilot trials, aimed at guiding researchers in decision-making at different stages of the trials. The recommendations provide a useful resource for researchers and suggest further research to evaluate their impact on established guidelines for trial design, conduct, analysis, and reporting.

PILOT AND FEASIBILITY STUDIES (2023)

Article Medicine, General & Internal

Relationship Between Clinician Language and the Success of Behavioral Weight Loss Interventions: A Mixed-Methods Cohort Study

Charlotte Albury, Helena Webb, Elizabeth Stokoe, Sue Ziebland, Constantinos Koshiaris, Joseph J. Lee, Paul Aveyard

Summary: This study examined the relationship between language used in clinical visits and patient weight loss. The results showed that presenting weight loss treatment as a positive opportunity was associated with greater treatment uptake and weight loss.

ANNALS OF INTERNAL MEDICINE (2023)

Article Endocrinology & Metabolism

A low-energy total diet replacement program demonstrates a favorable safety profile and improves liver disease severity in nonalcoholic steatohepatitis

Dimitrios A. Koutoukidis, Ferenc E. Mozes, Susan A. Jebb, Jeremy W. Tomlinson, Michael Pavlides, Francesca Saffioti, Rosemary Huntriss, Paul Aveyard, Jeremy F. Cobbold

Summary: The study demonstrates that a low-energy diet is a highly adherent, safe, and effective treatment for nonalcoholic steatohepatitis (NASH).

OBESITY (2023)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Clinician resistance to broaching the topic of weight in primary care: Digging deeper into weight management using strong structuration theory

Anisa Hajizadeh, Laura Heath, Aryati Ahmad, Maryam Kebbe, Susan Anne Jebb, Paul Aveyard, Gemma Hughes

Summary: Clinical trials have shown that providing advice and support for weight management can lead to meaningful weight loss. However, in real-world clinical settings, the offering of weight management advice is often low. Using Strong Structuration Theory, this study explored how weight stigma and professional responsibilities influenced clinicians in primary care to raise (or not) the issue of excess weight with patients. The findings suggest a tension between clinical guidelines and the lived experience of patients, resulting in an absence of weight management advice and potentially reinforcing weight stigma.

SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE (2023)

Review Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Effectiveness of hand-hygiene interventions in reducing illness-related absence in educational settings in high income countries: systematic review and behavioural analysis

Emily Hoyle, Henrietta Davies, Jana Bourhill, Nia Roberts, Joseph J. J. Lee, Charlotte Albury

Summary: Hand-hygiene interventions in school settings have been found to effectively reduce infection-related absence, especially for respiratory and gastrointestinal infections. Results from a meta-analysis of 9 studies with 11 papers showed that school-based interventions significantly reduced such absences. The number and type of behavior change techniques used in the interventions were found to be important factors in their success.

JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH-HEIDELBERG (2023)

No Data Available