4.1 Article

Interspecific covariation between stomatal density and other functional leaf traits in a local flora

Journal

BOTANY
Volume 88, Issue 1, Pages 30-38

Publisher

CANADIAN SCIENCE PUBLISHING
DOI: 10.1139/B09-103

Keywords

SLA; stomatal density; allometry; comparative ecology; leaf lamina thickness; variance components

Categories

Funding

  1. Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Despite the importance of stomata in leaf functioning, and despite the recent interest in interspecific leaf trait covariation in functional ecology, little is known about how stomatal density relates to other leaf traits in a broad interspecific context. This is especially important because stomatal density has been widely used to deduce temporal variation in atmospheric CO2 concentrations [CO2atm] from fossilized or herbarium leaves. We therefore measured stomatal density, specific leaf area (SLA) and its components, leaf thickness, and leaf chlorophyll content in both sun and shade leaves of 169 individuals from 52 angiosperm species in southwestern Quebec. Using mixed models, we show that stomatal density decreases allometrically with increasing SLA and chlorophyll content, and increases allometrically with increasing lamina thickness. The sun-shade contrast changes the intercepts, but not the slopes, of these relationships. It is important to take into consideration these relations when correlating stomatal density with [CO2], to avoid spurious interpretations.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.1
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Plant Sciences

Habitat filtering determines the functional niche occupancy of plant communities worldwide

Yuanzhi Li, Bill Shipley, Jodi N. Price, Vinicius de L. Dantas, Riin Tamme, Mark Westoby, Andrew Siefert, Brandon S. Schamp, Marko J. Spasojevic, Vincent Jung, Daniel C. Laughlin, Sarah J. Richardson, Yoann Le Bagousse-Pinguet, Christian Schob, Antonio Gazol, Honor C. Prentice, Nicolas Gross, Jake Overton, Marcus V. Cianciaruso, Frederique Louault, Chiho Kamiyama, Tohru Nakashizuka, Kouki Hikosaka, Takehiro Sasaki, Masatoshi Katabuchi, Cedric Frenette Dussault, Stephanie Gaucherand, Ning Chen, Marie Vandewalle, Marco Antonio Batalha

JOURNAL OF ECOLOGY (2018)

Article Forestry

Leaf and bark functional traits predict resprouting strategies of understory woody species after prescribed fires

P. Casals, T. Valor, A. Rios, B. Shipley

FOREST ECOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT (2018)

Article Ecology

Geographic scale and disturbance influence intraspecific trait variability in leaves and roots of North American understorey plants

Bright B. Kumordzi, Isabelle Aubin, Francoise Cardou, Bill Shipley, Cyrille Violle, Jill Johnstone, Madhur Anand, Andre Arsenault, F. Wayne Bell, Yves Bergeron, Isabelle Boulangeat, Maxime Brousseau, Louis De Grandpre, Sylvain Delagrange, Nicole J. Fenton, Dominique Gravel, S. Ellen Macdonald, Benoit Hamel, Morgane Higelin, Francois Hebert, Nathalie Isabel, Azim Mallik, Anne C. S. McIntosh, Jennie R. McLaren, Christian Messier, Dave Morris, Nelson Thiffault, Jean-Pierre Tremblay, Alison D. Munson

FUNCTIONAL ECOLOGY (2019)

Article Ecology

Causal hypotheses accounting for correlations between decomposition rates of different mass fractions of leaf litter

Bill Shipley, Antoine Tardif

Summary: The study measured decomposition rates in different mixtures of tree leaf litters and rejected three alternative causal hypotheses. Instead, a new hypothesis was proposed, suggesting that rapid decomposition of the labile fraction stimulates the decomposition of lignin and hemicellulose, leading to the decomposition of cellulose. This new hypothesis is consistent with known biology and the data and is proposed as the most viable current hypothesis.

ECOLOGY (2021)

Article Plant Sciences

The complexity of trait-environment performance landscapes in a local subtropical forest

Yuanzhi Li, Yuan Jiang, Bill Shipley, Buhang Li, Wenqi Luo, Yongfa Chen, Kangning Zhao, Dong He, Diego I. Rodriguez-Hernandez, Chengjin Chu

Summary: The research found that in environments with low variations, the interactions between traits and environments are not very important, and individual performances are similarly predicted at the individual and species levels. Future studies are encouraged to test the interactive effects of traits and environments on individual performances and lifelong fitness at larger spatial scales or along experimentally manipulated environmental gradients.

NEW PHYTOLOGIST (2021)

Article Ecology

A multigroup extension to piecewise path analysis

Jacob C. Douma, Bill Shipley

Summary: Path analysis is a method used to test the consistency of data and hypothesized causal relationships between variables, especially in examining differences in hypothesized dependencies between groups. Various constraints can be imposed for multigroup comparisons, but traditional path analysis and structural equation modeling may not be suitable for ecological studies. The d-sep test and generalized chi-squared test relax some assumptions for path models, but currently lack a multigroup test.

ECOSPHERE (2021)

Article Plant Sciences

A measure of generalized soil fertility that is largely independent of species identity

Xavier Lamontagne, Bill Shipley

Summary: This study evaluated a critical assumption of the generalized soil fertility (FG) model and proposed an alternative model. The results showed that the original model did not apply to soils with extreme pH values and specific adaptive species, while the new model provided a better explanation for these cases.

ANNALS OF BOTANY (2022)

Article Ecology

Quantifying the relationship linking the community-weighted means of plant traits and soil fertility

Laurent Daou, Eric Garnier, Bill Shipley

Summary: The study found quantifiable relationships between plant traits like leaf dry-matter content and specific leaf area with soil fertility that are generalizable across different species assemblages and geographical areas. These relationships were nonlinear but displayed expected qualitative trends, indicating a strong correlation between these traits and soil fertility.

ECOLOGY (2021)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Crop functional diversity drives multiple ecosystem functions during early agroforestry succession

Diego dos Santos, Fernando Joner, Bill Shipley, Marinice Teleginski, Renata Rodrigues Lucas, Ilyas Siddique

Summary: The study suggests that high crop functional diversity can enhance the multifunctionality of agroecosystems, increase crop yield, reduce weed cover, and improve soil protection. It also shows that greater crop functional diversity leads to increased photosynthetic light interception, resulting in higher crop yields. Furthermore, high functional diversity in crops can decrease the functional diversity of weed communities.

JOURNAL OF APPLIED ECOLOGY (2021)

Article Ecology

Exploring trait-performance relationships of tree seedlings along experimentally manipulated light and water gradients

Yuanzhi Li, Yuan Jiang, Kangning Zhao, Yang Chen, Wei Wei, Bill Shipley, Chengjin Chu

Summary: A foundational assumption of trait-based ecology is that individual performances can be predicted by its functional traits. However, trait-performance relationships reported in literature are typically weak, which may be due to the ignorance of trait-environment interactions, intraspecific trait variability, and hard traits directly linked to physiological processes. Our study highlights the importance of considering trait-environment interactions when predicting plant responses to changing environments.

ECOLOGY (2022)

Article Mathematics, Interdisciplinary Applications

Testing Model Fit in Path Models with Dependent Errors Given Non-Normality, Non-Linearity and Hierarchical Data

Jacob C. Douma, Bill Shipley

Summary: This article proposes a generic method for testing path models that involve dependent errors, nonlinear functional relationships, and the use of nonnormal, hierarchically structured data. The method involves decomposing the causal model into smaller, independent subsets and modeling them independently based on the type of data in each subset. It also introduces the use of copulas to model dependent errors between non-normally distributed variables. The results obtained using this method are identical to those of classical covariance-based path modeling under the assumptions of linearity and normality, outperforms classical SEM when nonlinear functional relationships are present, and can easily accommodate any parametric probability function and nonlinear functional relationships.

STRUCTURAL EQUATION MODELING-A MULTIDISCIPLINARY JOURNAL (2023)

Article Plant Sciences

Explaining variation in productivity requires intraspecific variability in plant height among communities

Li Zhang, Xiang Liu, Shurong Zhou, Bill Shipley

Summary: This study demonstrates that both inter- and intraspecific trait variability in plant height play important roles in maintaining ecosystem functions, particularly productivity. The findings suggest that the selection effect and shade-avoidance syndrome may simultaneously regulate productivity.

JOURNAL OF PLANT ECOLOGY (2022)

No Data Available