4.4 Review

Key concepts in consumer and community engagement: a scoping meta-review

Journal

BMC HEALTH SERVICES RESEARCH
Volume 14, Issue -, Pages -

Publisher

BMC
DOI: 10.1186/1472-6963-14-250

Keywords

Consumer and community engagement (CCE); Concepts; Shared decision making (SDM); Self-management; Peer support

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Background: Although consumer and community engagement (CCE) in health care is receiving increasing attention, research and practice in this area are hampered by the variability of concepts and terminology commonly employed. This scoping meta-review aims to identify key CCE concepts and examine terminology used to describe them. Methods: In a scoping meta-review, an extensive list of 47 phrases and 11 Medical Subject Headings (MeSH) was used to undertake a comprehensive and systematic search in PubMed Central, Embase, EBM reviews, CINAHL, APAPsycNET, and Scopus. Results: 59 systematic reviews met the selection criteria and were included in the final analysis. The analysis identified nine different concepts related to CCE: shared decision making, self-management, CCE in health care systems, community-based health promotion, providing access to health care, rehabilitation, participation in research, collaboration in research design and conduct, and peer support. The identified concepts differ from each other in many aspects including the aim of the activity, the role of consumers and the type of professionals' involvement. Each concept was described by a range of terms, with some terms shared by different concepts. In addition, two overlapping concepts of patient-centeredness and patient empowerment were recognised. Conclusions: This study describes CCE-related key concepts and provides new insight into their relationship with different CCE-related terms. Identification of key CCE-related concepts and terms will be useful to focus future studies and initiatives and enhance production of CCE-related evidence.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.4
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Review Orthopedics

Psychological sequelae of hand injuries: an integrative review

Kay Maddison, Lin Perry, Deborah Debono

Summary: This integrative review explores the psychological impact and sequelae of traumatic hand injuries. The findings suggest that depression, anxiety, and post-traumatic stress disorder are common in patients with hand injuries. Factors such as injury severity, pain, limb dysfunction, negative perceptions, maladaptive coping mechanisms, and limited social support contribute to the psychological sequelae. Symptoms persist for a protracted period but generally attenuate after 3 months. Further research is urgently needed to optimize treatment.

JOURNAL OF HAND SURGERY-EUROPEAN VOLUME (2023)

Article Biochemistry & Molecular Biology

The more you do it, the easier it gets: using behaviour change theory to support health care professionals offering reproductive genetic carrier screening

Stephanie Best, Janet C. Long, Zoe Fehlberg, Tahlia Theodorou, Sarah Hatem, Alison Archibald, Jeffrey Braithwaite

Summary: Recent advances in genomic sequencing have made reproductive genetic carrier screening (RGCS) more accessible. Non-genetic health care professionals are increasingly offering RGCS to consumers. A qualitative interview study was conducted to identify influences on health care professionals offering RGCS through the Australian research study, Mackenzie's Mission. Barriers and enabling factors were identified and categorized across three target behaviors: engaging with RGCS, identifying eligible patients, and offering RGCS. Understanding the drivers of current health care professionals' behavior can help improve service delivery.

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF HUMAN GENETICS (2023)

Article Nursing

Determining the role and responsibilities of the community epilepsy nurse in the management of epilepsy

Karen Hutchinson, Tayhla Ryder, Honor Coleman, Ruqaiya Nullwala, Geoffrey Herkes, Andrew Bleasel, Armin Nikpour, Chong Wong, Lisa Todd, Carol Ireland, Graeme Shears, Melissa Bartley, Wendy Groot, Michael Kerr, Sanjyot Vagholkar, Jeffrey Braithwaite, Frances Rapport

Summary: The aim of this study is to enhance the understanding of the community-based epilepsy nurse's role and responsibilities. The study found three key themes: the career trajectory of epilepsy nurses, the diversity of their role and practice in epilepsy management, and the impact of external factors on their work practices. Community epilepsy nurses play a pivotal role in providing holistic, person-centred epilepsy management.

JOURNAL OF CLINICAL NURSING (2023)

Article Genetics & Heredity

Australian Genomics: Outcomes of a 5-year national program to accelerate the integration of genomics in healthcare

Zornitza Stark, Tiffany Boughtwood, Matilda Haas, Jeffrey Braithwaite, Clara L. Gaff, Ilias Goranitis, Amanda B. Spurdle, David P. Hansen, Oliver Hofmann, Nigel Laing, Sylvia Metcalfe, Ainsley J. Newson, Hamish S. Scott, Natalie Thorne, Robyn L. Ward, Marcel E. Dinger, Stephanie Best, Janet C. Long, Sean M. Grimmond, John Pearson, Nicola Waddell, Christopher P. Barnett, Matthew Cook, Michael Field, David Fielding, Stephen B. Fox, Jozef Gecz, Adam Jaffe, Richard J. Leventer, Paul J. Lockhart, Sebastian Lunke, Andrew J. Mallett, Julie McGaughran, Linda Mileshkin, Katia Nones, Tony Roscioli, Ingrid E. Scheffer, Christopher Semsarian, Cas Simons, David M. Thomas, David R. Thorburn, Richard Tothill, Deborah White, Sally Dunwoodie, Peter T. Simpson, Peta Phillips, Marie-Jo Brion, Keri Finlay, Michael CJ. Quinn, Tessa Mattiske, Emma Tudini, Kirsten Boggs, Sean Murray, Kathy Wells, John Cannings, Andrew H. Sinclair, John Christodoulou, Kathryn N. North

Summary: Australian Genomics is a national collaborative partnership that aims to integrate genomics into healthcare through a whole-of-system approach. It has evaluated genomic testing outcomes in over 5,200 individuals across rare disease and cancer studies and provided evidence-based changes in policy and practice, resulting in government funding and access to genomic tests. It has also developed national skills, infrastructure, policy, and data resources to support data sharing and improve clinical genomic delivery.

AMERICAN JOURNAL OF HUMAN GENETICS (2023)

Review Oncology

Rates of adherence to cancer treatment guidelines in Australia and the factors associated with adherence: A systematic review

Mia Bierbaum, Frances Rapport, Gaston Arnolda, Yvonne Tran, Brona Nic Giolla Easpaig, Kristiana Ludlow, Robyn Clay-Williams, Elizabeth Austin, Bela Laginha, Chi Yhun Lo, Kate Churruca, Lieke van Baar, Karen Hutchinson, Renuka Chittajallu, Syeda Somyyah Owais, Ruqaiya Nullwala, Peter Hibbert, Diana Fajardo Pulido, Jeffrey Braithwaite

Summary: Adherence to cancer treatment clinical practice guidelines varies across Australia. This systematic review aimed to characterize adherence rates and related factors. After screening and review, 20 studies were included. Overall adherence rates ranged from 29% to 100%. Factors associated with higher adherence included younger age, female gender, never smoking, non-Indigenous Australian status, less advanced stage disease, absence of comorbidities, good performance status, living in moderately accessible places, and treatment in metropolitan facilities.

ASIA-PACIFIC JOURNAL OF CLINICAL ONCOLOGY (2023)

Review Dermatology

Measuring the quality of skin cancer management in primary care: A scoping review

Samantha Spanos, Nehal Singh, Bela I. Laginha, Gaston Arnolda, David Wilkinson, Andrea L. Smith, Anne E. Cust, Jeffrey Braithwaite, Frances Rapport

Summary: This scoping review aimed to gather contemporary evidence on the measurement of quality in skin cancer management in primary care settings. The data analysis of 46 texts resulted in 13 key emergent groups, categorizing quality measures according to the domains of healthcare quality. The study found that quality assessment was predominantly based on retrospective cohort studies, with limited systematic reviews and randomized controlled trials.

AUSTRALASIAN JOURNAL OF DERMATOLOGY (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

A protocol for the Hearing impairment in Adults: A Longitudinal Outcomes Study (HALOS)

Diana Tang, Yvonne Tran, Catherine McMahon, Jessica Turner, Janaki Amin, Kompal Sinha, Mohammad Nure Alam, Viviana Wuthrich, Kerry A. Sherman, Patrick Garcia, Rebecca Mitchell, Jeffrey Braithwaite, Greg Leigh, Shermin Lim, Giriraj Singh Shekhawat, Frances Rapport, Melanie Ferguson, Bamini Gopinath

Summary: The HALOS study aims to evaluate the impacts of hearing devices, differences in timing of interventions, and cost-effectiveness of early intervention for adult-onset hearing loss. It collects cross-sectional and longitudinal data on health and social outcomes from 908 hearing aid and/or cochlear implant users aged >= 40 years. The study has been approved by the Macquarie University Human Research Ethics Committee and Southern Adelaide Local Health Network.

PLOS ONE (2023)

Article Gastroenterology & Hepatology

Age-related experiences of colorectal cancer diagnosis: a secondary analysis of the English National Cancer Patient Experience Survey

Syeda Somyyah Owais, Gaston Arnolda, Klay Lamprell, Winston Liauw, Geoff P. Delaney, Ian Olver, Jonathan Karnon, Jeffrey Braithwaite

Summary: A secondary analysis of the English National Cancer Patient Experience Survey found that patients aged 65-74 or 75 years and older reported the highest rates of positive diagnosis-related experiences.

BMJ OPEN GASTROENTEROLOGY (2023)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Digital Health Implementation Strategies Coproduced With Adults With Acquired Brain Injury, Their Close Others, and Clinicians: Mixed Methods Study With Collaborative Autoethnography and Network Analysis

Melissa Miao, Rosemary Morrow, Alexander Salomon, Ben Mcculloch, Jean-Christophe Evain, Meg Rebecca Wright, Marie Therese Murphy, Monica Welsh, Liz Williams, Emma Power, Rachael Rietdijk, Deborah Debono, Melissa Brunner, Leanne Togher

Summary: Individuals with acquired brain injuries may suffer from cognitive-communication disorders, affecting both themselves and their close others. Speech-language pathologists are recommended to provide communication support, while also supporting digital communication post ABI. The study aimed to co-produce implementation knowledge to support the use of the Social Brain Toolkit for digital communication rehabilitation.

JOURNAL OF MEDICAL INTERNET RESEARCH (2023)

Article Computer Science, Artificial Intelligence

Finite-Time and Fixed-Time Synchronization of Delayed Memristive Neural Networks via Adaptive Aperiodically Intermittent Adjustment Strategy

Liyan Cheng, Fangcheng Tang, Xinli Shi, Xiangyong Chen, Jianlong Qiu

Summary: This article investigates the finite-time and fixed-time synchronization for memristive neural networks (MNNs) with mixed time-varying delays under the adaptive aperiodically intermittent adjustment strategy. The article employs the aperiodically intermittent adjustment feedback control and adaptive control to drive the MNNs to achieve synchronization in finite time and fixed time. The sufficient conditions for finite-time and fixed-time synchronization of the drive-response MNNs are obtained by designing an effective aperiodically intermittent adjustment with adaptive updating law.

IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON NEURAL NETWORKS AND LEARNING SYSTEMS (2023)

Review Health Policy & Services

What factors are considered in hospital funding models? A review of the literature on health services funding in organisation for economic co-operation and development countries

Robyn Clay-Williams, Yvonne Zurynski, Janet C. Long, Isabelle Meulenbroeks, Elizabeth E. Austin, Zeyad Mahmoud, Louise A. Ellis, Gilbert Knaggs, Diana Fajardo Pulido, Lieke Richardson, Golo Ahlenstiel, Graham Reece, Jeffrey Braithwaite

Summary: This review aimed to identify international funding models for government-funded public hospitals in OECD countries and evaluate their efficacy. The study found that while some models considered factors like deprivation and ethnicity, none of them adjusted funding allocation for social determinants such as health literacy levels.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF HEALTH PLANNING AND MANAGEMENT (2023)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

The place of digital triage in a complex healthcare system: An interview study with key stakeholders in Australia's national provider

Kate Churruca, Louise A. Ellis, Catherine Pope, Jennifer MacLellan, Yvonne Zurynski, Jeffrey Braithwaite

Summary: This study examined stakeholders' perspectives on Healthdirect, Australia's national digital triage provider, and its role in the health system and operational barriers, particularly in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. The findings revealed varying views among stakeholders on the purpose of Healthdirect's digital triage services, and identified challenges related to lack of integration, competition, and limited public awareness. The value of these services during the COVID-19 pandemic was acknowledged, with expectations for greater potential in the rapidly expanding telehealth landscape.

DIGITAL HEALTH (2023)

Article Primary Health Care

People with early-onset colorectal cancer describe primary care barriers to timely diagnosis: a mixed-methods study of web-based patient reports in the United Kingdom, Australia and New Zealand

Klay Lamprell, Diana Fajardo Pulido, Gaston Arnolda, Brona Nic Giolla Easpaig, Yvonne Tran, Syeda Somyyah Owais, Winston Liauw, Jeffrey Braithwaite

Summary: People with early-onset colorectal cancer are more likely to experience diagnostic delay due to doctors' low suspicion and lack of screening, leading to late-stage diagnosis. Patients also reported inadequate information continuity and tensions with doctors regarding symptom seriousness and shared decision-making. Therefore, it is essential to disseminate information and improve patient education at primary care level to improve patients' diagnosis experience.

BMC PRIMARY CARE (2023)

Article Geriatrics & Gerontology

The role of frailty risk for fracture-related hospital readmission and mortality after a hip fracture

Seigo Mitsutake, Zhisheng Sa, Janet Long, Jeffrey Braithwaite, Jean-Frederic Levesque, Diane E. Watson, Jacqueline Close, Rebecca Mitchell

Summary: Frailty risk estimated using hospital administrative data can contribute to identifying older hip fracture patients at-risk of fracture-related readmissions and mortality, providing guidance for targeted interventions.

ARCHIVES OF GERONTOLOGY AND GERIATRICS (2024)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Using a theory informed approach to design, execute, and evaluate implementation strategies to support offering reproductive genetic carrier screening in Australia

Stephanie Best, Janet C. Long, Zoe Fehlberg, Natalie Taylor, Louise A. Ellis, Kirsten Boggs, Jeffrey Braithwaite

Summary: This study aimed to design, execute, and evaluate implementation strategies to support healthcare professionals in offering reproductive genetic carrier screening. Barriers reported by healthcare professionals were aligned with behavior change techniques to develop strategies. The strategies were trialled with a subset of healthcare professionals, and the primary outcome measure showed little change. Developing and testing strategies that acknowledge contextual factors are essential for offering carrier screening.

BMC HEALTH SERVICES RESEARCH (2023)

No Data Available