4.3 Article

Measuring the risk attitude of decision-makers: are there differences between groups of methods and persons?

Journal

Publisher

WILEY-BLACKWELL
DOI: 10.1111/j.1467-8489.2012.00620.x

Keywords

contextualized statements; Holt-and-Laury-lottery; measuring the risk attitude; self-assessment

Funding

  1. Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG)

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Many studies quantifying individual risk preferences of test persons show that results of different measuring methods may vary. Additional reservations about the reliability of the results regarding the risk attitude measurement arise from the fact that most studies are based on convenience groups, such as students or businessmen in developing countries. With this in mind, we systematically compare different measuring methods to answer the question how the choice of method affects the results. Moreover, we compare the risk preferences of German farmers with those of students and Kazakhstani farmers to investigate whether farmers' risk preferences can be approximated through those of convenience groups. The methods applied comprise an incentive-compatible Holt-and-Laury-lottery as well as two psychometric methods. Results show that students respond consistently across all three elicitation methods whereas German and Kazakhstani farmers are more inconsistent. Significant differences exist in the responses of German students and German farmers. The comparison of risk preferences between German and Kazakhstani farmers, however, reveals significant similarities with respect to the psychometric methods.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.3
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Ecology

Experience of losses and aversion to uncertainty-experimental evidence from farmers in Mexico

Hanna Freudenreich, Oliver Musshoff

Summary: The experience of severe harvest losses is associated with greater risk aversion and stronger overweighting of small probabilities. However, the severity of harvest shocks is not related to loss or ambiguity aversion.

ECOLOGICAL ECONOMICS (2022)

Article Environmental Studies

Farm growth and land concentration

Jana Plogmann, Oliver Musshoff, Martin Odening, Matthias Ritter

Summary: This study examines the relationship between land market concentration and farm size changes using data from Brandenburg, Germany. The findings indicate that although concentration rates did not increase over time, there are spatial differences. For farms that remained active during the study period, there is a negative correlation between farm size and relative growth.

LAND USE POLICY (2022)

Article Economics

Investigating inconsistencies in complex lotteries: The role of cognitive skills of low-numeracy subjects

Selina Bruns, Daniel Hermann, Oliver Musshoff

Summary: This study investigates the inconsistency levels of smallholder farmers from rural Cambodia in the HL-task. The results show that cognitive skills are a significant determinant of inconsistency levels, with a statistically significant explanation for men but not for women. Therefore, researchers should conduct comprehensive pre-tests when using abstract risk-elicitation methods among low numeracy subjects.

JOURNAL OF BEHAVIORAL AND EXPERIMENTAL ECONOMICS (2022)

Article Agricultural Economics & Policy

How (un)informative are experiments with students for other social groups? A study of agricultural students and farmers

Sven Gruener, Mira Lehberger, Norbert Hirschauer, Oliver Musshoff

Summary: Experiments using university students as participants may not accurately reflect the behavior of other social groups, including farmers. While risk aversion is similar between agricultural students and farmers, positive reciprocity and trust in farmers are influenced by monetary incentives, whereas this effect is not observed in agricultural students. Further research is needed to determine the generalizability of these findings.

AUSTRALIAN JOURNAL OF AGRICULTURAL AND RESOURCE ECONOMICS (2022)

Article Development Studies

Digital credit and the gender gap in financial inclusion: Empirical evidence from Kenya

Constantin Johnen, Oliver Musshoff

Summary: Formal digital credit was expected to decrease the gender gap in financial inclusion, but the study reveals that it has actually led to an increase in the gap in Kenya. The gender disparity is largely attributable to socio-economic differences and a lack of heterogeneity in contract terms in the market.

JOURNAL OF INTERNATIONAL DEVELOPMENT (2023)

Article Development Studies

Insuring against droughts: addressing issues of trust, transparency and liquidity in the demand for livestock index insurance

Maike Linhoff, Oliver Musshoff, Martin C. Parlasca

Summary: Pastoralists in sub-Saharan Africa are vulnerable to climate change and severe droughts. Research shows that they prefer lower strike levels and transparency in livestock index insurance contracts, and value trust enhancing features.

CLIMATE AND DEVELOPMENT (2023)

Article Economics

Improving the statistical power of economic experiments using adaptive designs

Sebastian Jobjoernsson, Henning Schaak, Oliver Musshoff, Tim Friede

Summary: This paper discusses the important issue of ensuring sufficient power to reject hypotheses in economic experiments and introduces methods for testing multiple hypotheses simultaneously in adaptive, two-stage designs to improve experiment power. The paper provides a concise overview of relevant theory and demonstrates the method in three different applications, including a simulation study and analysis of previous experiment data sets. Simulation results highlight the potential for reducing sample sizes while maintaining the power to reject at least one hypothesis and controlling the overall Type I error probability.

EXPERIMENTAL ECONOMICS (2023)

Article Economics

Compliance with pre-harvest interval rules in apple production-A comparative analysis of green nudges among fruit growers and agricultural students in Germany

Marius Michels, Hao Luo, Paul Johann Weller Von Ahlefeld, Oliver Musshoff

Summary: This study investigates how nudges can improve compliance with a 14-day pre-harvest interval rule in apple production. The findings show that nudging has a preventive effect and reduces non-compliance behavior in a virtual apple farm management game. The results are of interest to policy makers and contribute to the field of (experimental) economics and nudging. Overall, the importance of this study is rated 8 out of 10.

JOURNAL OF BEHAVIORAL AND EXPERIMENTAL ECONOMICS (2023)

Article Agricultural Economics & Policy

Dealing with low-probability shocks: The role of selected heuristics in farmers' risk management decisions

Christoph Duden, Oliver Musshoff, Frank Offermann

Summary: It is found that farmers' willingness to pay for risk mitigation is influenced by simplified decision rules, such as the imitation heuristic, shock experience heuristic, and threshold of concern heuristic. Farmers tend to imitate successful risk-loving farmers and assign less weight to low-probability shocks. Lack of personal experience with low-probability events and considering them to be rare leads to lower willingness to pay. Understanding these heuristic preferences can aid in designing better risk management instruments and policies.

AGRICULTURAL ECONOMICS (2023)

Article Agricultural Economics & Policy

New insights on regional differences of the farmland price structure: An extended replication study on the parcel size-price relationship

Henning Schaak, Luise Meissner, Oliver Musshoff

Summary: This study examines the nonlinear effect of parcel sizes on farmland prices by replicating Ritter et al.'s research in four different ways. The study contributes to the literature by providing insights into regional differences in farmland price structure and the role of assumptions regarding the functional form for the size-price relationship. The extended replication results reveal variations in the size-price relationship across federal states and highlight the significance of assumptions on functional forms in hedonic regression studies.

APPLIED ECONOMIC PERSPECTIVES AND POLICY (2023)

Article Development Studies

Farmers' awareness of digital credit: Does financial literacy matter?

Yaw Sarfo, Oliver Musshoff, Ron Weber

Summary: This study examines the relationship between financial literacy and farmers' awareness of digital credit in rural Madagascar. The researchers measured farmers' financial literacy through questions related to numeracy, interest compounding, inflation, and risk diversification. The findings demonstrate that financial literacy positively and significantly affects farmers' awareness of digital credit. The study highlights the importance of financial literacy in increasing farmers' awareness of digital credit in rural areas of Madagascar and supports the widely acknowledged view that financial literacy is crucial for individuals' awareness of financial products.

JOURNAL OF INTERNATIONAL DEVELOPMENT (2023)

Article Agricultural Economics & Policy

German farmers' perceived usefulness of satellite-based index insurance: insights from a transtheoretical model

Eike Florenz Nordmeyer, Oliver Musshoff

Summary: The purpose of this study is to investigate farmers' perceived usefulness of satellite-based index insurance. The results show that German farmers generally perceive satellite-based index insurance as useful. Higher education levels, higher trust in index insurance products, and higher relative weather-related income losses increase farmers' perceived usefulness.

AGRICULTURAL FINANCE REVIEW (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Understanding German farmers' intention to adopt drought insurance

Eike Florenz Nordmeyer, Oliver Musshoff

Summary: This study surveyed and analyzed the intention of German farmers to adopt drought insurance, finding that factors such as gender, risk attitude, land tenure, previous weather risk impacts, and trust in index insurance products have a significant impact on farmers' intention. The results are important for policymakers, insurers, and researchers focusing on farmer adaptation to climate change.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2023)

Review Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Replanting challenges among Indonesian oil palm smallholders: a narrative review

Heinrich Petri, Dienda Hendrawan, Tobias Bahr, Oliver Musshoff, Meike Wollni, Rosyani Asnawi, Heiko Faust

Summary: Three decades after establishment, smallholder oil palm plantations need replanting to redesign plantations, boost farm productivity, and secure livelihoods. However, replanting requires knowledge, inputs, and financing, and postponement or slow action can worsen socioeconomic and environmental challenges. Access to inputs, finances, and knowledge are paramount challenges that affect smallholders' decisions on when, how, and what to replant.

ENVIRONMENT DEVELOPMENT AND SUSTAINABILITY (2023)

Article Agricultural Economics & Policy

Female smallholder farmers' preferences for digital and conventional credit attributes: evidence from Madagascar

Annkathrin Wahbi, Yaw Sarfo, Oliver Musshoff

Summary: This article examines the preferences of rural women in Sub-Saharan Africa for digital and conventional credit. The findings show that female respondents have a higher demand for credit than males, but there are no significant differences in willingness to pay for credit attributes. Therefore, designing gender-specific services may not be advisable.

AGRICULTURAL FINANCE REVIEW (2023)

No Data Available