4.4 Article

The Legitimacy of Placebo Treatments in Clinical Practice: Evidence and Ethics

Journal

AMERICAN JOURNAL OF BIOETHICS
Volume 9, Issue 12, Pages 39-47

Publisher

ROUTLEDGE JOURNALS, TAYLOR & FRANCIS LTD
DOI: 10.1080/15265160903316263

Keywords

Placebo treatments; Clinical practice; Healing; Bioethics; Informed consent; Deception

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Physicians commonly recommend 'placebo treatments', which are not believed to have specific efficacy for the patient's condition. Motivations for placebo treatments include complying with patient expectations and promoting a placebo effect. In this article, we focus on two key empirical questions that must be addressed in order to assess the ethical legitimacy of placebo treatments in clinical practice: 1) do placebo treatments have the potential to produce clinically significant benefit? and 2) can placebo treatments be effective in promoting a therapeutic placebo response without the use of deception? We examine evidence from clinical trials and laboratory experiments bearing on these two questions. The conclusion is reached that based on currently available evidence, it is premature to judge whether placebo treatments are ethically justifiable, with the possible exception of acupuncture for pain relief.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.4
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Psychology, Multidisciplinary

Do Side Effects to the Primary COVID-19 Vaccine Reduce Intentions for a COVID-19 Vaccine Booster?

Andrew L. Geers, Kelly S. Clemens, Ben Colagiuri, Emily Jason, Luana Colloca, Rebecca Webster, Lene Vase, Mette Seig, Kate Faasse

Summary: The aim of this study was to examine whether side effects of the primary COVID-19 vaccine are associated with a decrease in intentions to receive a COVID-19 booster, as well as to identify psychological and demographic factors that predict booster intentions. The results showed that intentions for a booster vaccination were high and not correlated with the side effects of the primary vaccine. Positive vaccination attitudes, trust in vaccine development, worry about the COVID-19 pandemic, low concern over vaccine side effects, and affiliation with the democratic political party were predictors of booster intentions.

ANNALS OF BEHAVIORAL MEDICINE (2022)

Article Anesthesiology

How negative and positive constructs and comorbid conditions contribute to disability in chronic orofacial pain

Sharon Thomas, Yang Wang, Rachel Cundiff-O'Sullivan, Rachel Massalee, Luana Colloca

Summary: This study examined the role of jaw function, psychological factors, and chronic overlapping pain conditions (COPCs) on pain-related disability in patients with temporomandibular disorders (TMD). The results suggest that improving joint function, providing psychosocial support, and managing pain conditions can improve pain-related disability in TMD patients.

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF PAIN (2023)

Review Clinical Neurology

Optimizing and Accelerating the Development of Precision Pain Treatments for Chronic Pain: IMMPACT Review and Recommendations

Robert R. Edwards, Kristin L. Schreiber, Robert H. Dworkin, Dennis C. Turk, Ralf Baron, Roy Freeman, Troels S. Jensen, Alban Latremoliere, John D. Markman, Andrew S. C. Rice, Michael Rowbotham, Roland Staud, Simon Tate, Clifford J. Woolf, Nick A. Andrews, Daniel B. Carr, Luana Colloca, Doina Cosma-Roman, Penney Cowan, Luda Diatchenko, John Farrar, Jennifer S. Gewandter, Ian Gilron, Robert D. Kerns, Serge Marchand, Gwendolyn Niebler, Kushang V. Patel, Lee S. Simon, Tina Tockarshewsky, Geertrui F. Vanhove, Daniel Vardeh, Gary A. Walco, Ajay D. Wasan, Ursula Wesselmann

Summary: There is a large variability in individual response to pain treatments, even those that are highly effective, which has led to calls for personalized approaches to treating patients with pain. Precision pain medicine aims to determine the optimal treatments for specific patients by using empirically based algorithms. This review surveys the current state of precision pain medicine and presents evidence-based recommendations for its application in chronic pain research.

JOURNAL OF PAIN (2023)

Article Pharmacology & Pharmacy

Predicting Treatment Responses in Patients With Osteoarthritis: Results From Two Phase III Tanezumab Randomized Clinical Trials

Luana Colloca, Robert H. Dworkin, John T. Farrar, Leslie Tive, Jiyue Yang, Lars Viktrup, Gorana Dasic, Christine R. West, Ed Whalen, Mark T. Brown, Steven A. Gilbert, Kenneth M. Verburg

Summary: This study conducted secondary analyses on data from two clinical trials to identify patient-based variables that predicted responses to placebo or tanezumab. The findings will inform the design of future clinical trials and advance clinical pharmacology and translational science.

CLINICAL PHARMACOLOGY & THERAPEUTICS (2023)

Article Clinical Neurology

Expectations for Improvement: A Neglected but Potentially Important Covariate or Moderator for Chronic Pain Clinical Trials

Dale J. Langford, Raissa Lou, Soun Sheen, Dagmar Amtmann, Luana Colloca, Robert R. Edwards, John T. Farrar, Nathaniel P. Katz, Michael P. McDermott, Bryce B. Reeve, Ajay D. Wasan, Dennis C. Turk, Robert H. Dworkin, Jennifer S. Gewandter

Summary: Variability in pain outcomes can hinder the sensitivity of chronic pain clinical trials. Participants' expectations may contribute to this variability and impede the development of new pain treatments. Measurement and management of expectations in clinical trials need to be optimized and standardized. This article provides an overview of research findings on the relationship between baseline expectations and pain outcomes, emphasizing the potential benefit of adjusting for participants' expectations in trial analyses.

JOURNAL OF PAIN (2023)

Article Psychiatry

Social communication pathways to COVID-19 vaccine side-effect expectations and experience

Kelly S. Clemens, Kate Faasse, Winston Tan, Ben Colagiuri, Luana Colloca, Rebecca Webster, Lene Vase, Emily Jason, Andrew L. Geers

Summary: This study investigates the influence of social communication on vaccine side-effect experiences, particularly focusing on personal acquaintances and social media. The results show that both sources of social communication can predict pre-vaccination side-effect expectations and post-vaccination side-effect experiences. Moreover, pre-vaccination expectations mediate the relationships between social communication and experienced side-effects. This study provides evidence for the importance of modifying side-effect expectations through personal and online channels.

JOURNAL OF PSYCHOSOMATIC RESEARCH (2023)

Article Anesthesiology

Yoga and massage are associated with small experimental placebo effects in chronic orofacial pain

Margaret Yin, Salim A. Muhammed, Yang Wang, Luana Colloca

Summary: This study found that the use of physically oriented mind-body practices, such as yoga and massage, was associated with reduced placebo effects in chronic pain patients with Temporomandibular Disorders. The use of psychologically oriented practices and natural products was not associated with placebo effects. This finding provides insights into the relationship between complementary and integrative approaches and placebo effects, and the potential therapeutic perspective of endogenous pain modulation in chronic pain management.

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF PAIN (2023)

Article Clinical Neurology

Individual Dimensions of Pain Catastrophizing Do Not Mediate the Effect of Sociodemographic and Psychological Factors on Chronic Orofacial Pain Severity, Interference, and Jaw Limitation: A Structural Equation Modeling Approach

Rachel L. Cundiff-O'Sullivan, Yang Wang, Sharon Thomas, Shijun Zhu, Claudia M. Campbell, Luana Colloca

Summary: This study utilized structural equation modeling to analyze the impact of psychological and sociodemographic factors on pain severity, interference, and jaw limitation in temporomandibular disorder (TMD) patients, and found that the dimensions of pain catastrophizing do not mediate these relationships.

JOURNAL OF PAIN (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Harnessing the placebo effect to enhance emotion regulation effectiveness and choice

Roni Shafir, Maya Israel, Luana Colloca

Summary: The placebo effect demonstrates how positive expectancies shape the effectiveness of various treatments. This study shows that placebo-induced expectancies can improve individuals' internal emotion regulation attempts. The placebo distraction was effective in reducing fear of pain and was preferred by the participants.

SCIENTIFIC REPORTS (2023)

Review Rheumatology

Placebo effects in osteoarthritis: implications for treatment and drug development

Tuhina Neogi, Luana Colloca

Summary: Osteoarthritis (OA) is a common form of arthritis that affects millions of people worldwide, but there are currently no effective treatments to stop its progression. The development of drugs for OA is hindered by the gradual nature of the disease and the requirement to demonstrate improvements in both structure and symptoms. Clinical trials for OA are also hampered by high placebo responses, which make it difficult to identify new effective treatments. Understanding placebo responses and effects in OA trials can help improve clinical practice and enhance symptom management.

NATURE REVIEWS RHEUMATOLOGY (2023)

Article Medicine, General & Internal

Study protocol: randomised controlled trial of conditioned open-label placebo (COLP) for perioperative pain management in patients with head and neck cancer

Danielle R. Trakimas, Luana Colloca, Carole Fakhry, Marietta Tan, Zubair Khan, Peter S. Vosler

Summary: Patients with head and neck cancer are at risk of chronic opioid dependence after surgery. This study aims to examine whether the addition of conditioned open-label placebos (COLPs) to standard multimodal analgesia can reduce opioid consumption within 5 days after surgery in these patients. The study will use a randomized controlled trial design to assess the effectiveness of COLPs as adjunctive pain management in patients with head and neck cancer.

BMJ OPEN (2023)

Editorial Material Psychiatry

The Intricate Interaction Between Expectations and Therapeutic Outcomes of Psychedelic Agents

Luana Colloca, Sina Nikayin, Gerard Sanacora

JAMA PSYCHIATRY (2023)

Article Psychology, Multidisciplinary

An international consensus definition for contextual factors: findings from a nominal group technique

Chad E. Cook, Antoine Bailliard, Jennifer A. Bent, Joel E. Bialosky, Elisa Carlino, Luana Colloca, Jorge E. Esteves, Dave Newell, Alvisa Palese, William R. Reed, Jennifer Plumb Vilardaga, Giacomo Rossettini

Summary: The objective of this study was to create a consensus definition of contextual factors to better refine this concept for clinicians and researchers. Using a multi-stage virtual Nominal Group Technique, the study resulted in the creation and ranking of 12 final definitions of contextual factors.

FRONTIERS IN PSYCHOLOGY (2023)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Medical Extended Reality Trials: Building Robust Comparators, Controls, and Sham

Susan Persky, Luana Colloca

Summary: The rapid development of medical extended reality (MXR) in healthcare and medicine shows great promise. However, there is a lack of rigorous clinical trials to establish its efficacy. The paper proposes a framework for designing controls and sham conditions in MXR trials to improve research findings and develop generalizable knowledge.

JOURNAL OF MEDICAL INTERNET RESEARCH (2023)

Article Communication

Integration of virtual platforms for enhanced conference experience: Data-based evidence from the Society of Interdisciplinary Placebo Studies 2021 conference

Jessica Cornell, Ariana Taj, John Sivinski, Margaret Yin, Parth Bhatia, Desai Oula, Sophia Fatschel, Patricia Franklin, Jason Noel, Luana Colloca, Chamindi Seneviratne

Summary: This article reports on the methods used to design and analyze a virtual scientific conference and the findings suggest that the virtual platform allowed for virtual attendance, produced moderate engagement, and the majority of attendees were satisfied with the quality of the conference.

FRONTIERS IN COMMUNICATION (2022)

No Data Available