4.6 Review

Biodiversity-based options for arable weed management. A review

Journal

AGRONOMY FOR SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
Volume 38, Issue 5, Pages -

Publisher

SPRINGER FRANCE
DOI: 10.1007/s13593-018-0525-3

Keywords

Agroecology; Ecological intensification; Plant competition; Granivory; Cover plants; Pathogenic fungi; Cropping systems

Ask authors/readers for more resources

In the context of a shift towards pesticide reduction in arable farming, weed management remains a challenging issue. Integrated Weed Management currently recommends agronomic practices for weed control, but it does not integrate the use of biodiversity-based options, enhancing the biological regulation of weeds. Here, wereview existing knowledge related to three potentially beneficial interactions, of crop-weed competition, weed seed granivory, and weed interactions with pathogenic fungi. Our main finding are the following : (1) promoting cropped plant-weed competition by manipulating cropped cover could greatly contribute to weed reduction; (2) weed seed granivory by invertebrates can significantly lower weed emergence, although this effect can be highly variable because seed predation is embedded within complex multitrophic interactions that are to date not fully understood; (3) a wide range of fungi are pathogenic to various stages of weed development, but strain efficacy in field trials does not often match that in controlled conditions. We present a framework that superimposes biodiversity-based options for weed biocontrol on a classical Integrated Weed Management system. We then describe the current state of knowledge on interactions between agronomic practices and the organisms at play and between the different biological components of the system. We argue that further advances in our understanding of biodiversity-based options and their performance for weed biocontrol will require farm-scale experimental trials.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.6
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Direct and indirect effects of landscape and field management intensity on carabids through trophic resources and weeds

Benjamin Carbonne, David A. Bohan, Hana Foffova, Eirini Daouti, Britta Frei, Veronika Neidel, Pavel Saska, Sandrine Petit

Summary: The study found that both the direct and indirect effects of field management intensity and surrounding landscape have impacts on Carabid diversity. Increasing landscape complexity has mainly positive effects on Carabids through the mediation of trophic resources, while field management intensity primarily has negative effects on Carabids by suppressing standing weeds and weed seeds.

JOURNAL OF APPLIED ECOLOGY (2022)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Building capacities for the design of agroecological landscapes: The added-value of Landscape Monitoring Networks

Sandrine Petit, Audrey Alignier, Roland Allart, Stephanie Aviron, Hugues Boussard, Pierre Franck, Caroline Gibert, Sylvie Ladet, Claire Lavigne, Lou Lecuyer, Maxime Moncamp, Lucile Muneret, Sylvain Poggi, Benoit Ricci, Adrien Rusch, Aude Vialatte, Juliette Young

Summary: The failure of most agricultural landscapes in delivering biodiversity conservation and ecosystem services suggests the need for more explicit design in future landscapes. However, designing such landscapes is challenging due to context-dependent ecological responses and limited understanding of collective management obstacles. Landscape Monitoring Networks (LMN) can help address these challenges and provide relevant knowledge for landscape design.

AGRICULTURE ECOSYSTEMS & ENVIRONMENT (2023)

Article Agronomy

Long-term cover cropping in tillage-based systems filters weed community phenology: A seedbank analysis

Guillaume Adeux, Alain Rodriguez, Clemence Penato, Daniele Antichi, Stefano Carlesi, Massimo Sbrana, Paolo Barberi, Stephane Cordeau

Summary: This study found that cover crops contribute little to weed management in tillage-and herbicide-based cropping systems. Hairy vetch showed a significant suppressive effect on weed seedling density, while brown mustard had little effect. The suppressive effect of hairy vetch was observed on specific weed species, but differences in biomass productivity could not fully explain the variations in weed suppression between cover crop species.

FIELD CROPS RESEARCH (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Carabid beetles have hump-shaped responses to disturbance and resource gradients within agricultural landscapes

Lucile Muneret, Benoit Ricci, Aude Vialatte, Stephanie Aviron, Chantal Ducourtieux, Luc Biju-Duval, Sandrine Petit

Summary: Understanding the effects of cropping systems on biodiversity is challenging. This study found that environmental context contributed more to carabid variations than resource and disturbance gradients. Avoiding bare soils, reducing pesticide use, and adopting a wide diversity of tillage strategies can enhance in-field carabid occurrences and richness.

JOURNAL OF APPLIED ECOLOGY (2023)

Article Agronomy

The utility of the 'Arable Weeds and Management in Europe' database: Challenges and opportunities of combining weed survey data at a European scale

Helen Metcalfe, Jana Buerger, Christoph von Redwitz, Alicia Cirujeda, Silvia Fogliatto, Denise F. Dostatny, Barbel Gerowitt, Michael Glemnitz, Jose L. Gonzalez-Andujar, Eva Hernandez Plaza, Jordi Izquierdo, Michaela Kolarova, Jevgenija Necajeva, Sandrine Petit, Gyula Pinke, Matthias Schumacher, Lena Ulber, Francesco Vidotto, Guillaume Fried

Summary: The 'Arable Weeds and Management in Europe' (AWME) database is a collection of 36 surveys on weed vegetation and management data. This database provides opportunities for future research by addressing challenges in combining disparate datasets. Three case studies conducted in France, Germany, and the UK demonstrate the utility and versatility of the AWME database, showing consistent results across different spatial scales. The Europe-wide data collection offers numerous opportunities for analysis on climate change, weed diversity, and specific weed characteristics in Europe.

WEED RESEARCH (2023)

Article Ecology

Individual flowering phenology shapes plant-pollinator interactions across ecological scales affecting plant reproduction

Audrey Labonte, Lucie S. Monticelli, Melinda Turpin, Emeline Felten, Emilien Laurent, Annick Matejicek, Chantal Ducourtieux, Eric Vieren, Violaine Deytieux, Stephane Cordeau, David Bohan, Adam J. Vanbergen

Summary: The competition and facilitation of pollination among plants and the availability of abiotic resources have an impact on plant reproduction. Floral resource succession and spatial heterogeneity affect plant-pollinator interactions at different ecological scales. Variations in flowering phenology influence the level of spatio-temporal heterogeneity in floral resources and pollinator interactions, thereby affecting reproduction. This study examined the effects of abiotic resources and multi-scale plant-pollinator interactions on individual plant seed set. The results demonstrated the importance of plant attractiveness, assemblage floral density, and conspecific pollen donor density in seed set, while the impact of abiotic conditions on seed set was minimal.

ECOLOGY AND EVOLUTION (2023)

Editorial Material Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Landscape-scale management for biodiversity and ecosystem services

Sandrine Petit, Douglas A. Landis

AGRICULTURE ECOSYSTEMS & ENVIRONMENT (2023)

Article Agronomy

Carry-over effects of cover crops on weeds and crop productivity in no-till systems

Alicia Rouge, Guillaume Adeux, Hugues Busset, Rodolphe Hugard, Juliette Martin, Annick Matejicek, Delphine Moreau, Jean-Philippe Guillemin, Stephane Cordeau

Summary: This study explored the impact of cover crop management on weed biomass and crop productivity in subsequent crops, finding that the composition of cover crops, termination methods, and soil resource availability all played a role.

FIELD CROPS RESEARCH (2023)

Article Entomology

Consumer identity but not food availability affects carabid diet in cereal crops

Yasemin Guenay-Greunke, Harald Trager, David A. A. Bohan, Michael Traugott, Corinna Wallinger

Summary: Understanding trophic interactions in agroecosystems is crucial for reducing pesticide use. Carabid beetles have the potential to regulate insect pests, weed seeds, and slugs. This study investigated the food choices of different carabid species in a cereal field and found that plant DNA was more common in their gut contents than animal prey. Seasonality and species identity influenced carabid food choice, while increased availability of seeds and slugs did not. The study highlights the importance of a diverse carabid community for resilient pest control services.

JOURNAL OF PEST SCIENCE (2023)

Review Agronomy

Knowledge of Cover Crop Seed Traits and Treatments to Enhance Weed Suppression: A Narrative Review

Iraj Nosratti, Nicholas E. Korres, Stephane Cordeau

Summary: Cover crops can suppress weeds through direct competition, allelopathy, or physical barriers. Farmers adopting sustainable farming practices are using cover crops to achieve weed control. Poor and unstable establishment, volunteer cover crops as subsequent cash crops, and seed costs limit cover crop adoption. This study reviews the scientific literature on seed traits to choose suitable cover crops and improve establishment and growth. Seed priming and coating, as well as proper sowing patterns and depth, can enhance cover crop establishment. Different cover crop families exhibit varying germination percentages under water-deficit conditions. Seed dormancy in some Fabaceae species limits their use. The selection of suitable cover crop cultivars is crucial for weed suppression and multiple ecosystem services in the context of climate change.

AGRONOMY-BASEL (2023)

Article Biotechnology & Applied Microbiology

Sex-specific foraging response to interspecific interactions in carabid beetles

Alice Charalabidis, Stephane A. P. Derocles, Diana M. Mosquera-Munoz, Sandrine Petit, Francois-Xavier Dechaume-Moncharmont, David A. Bohan

Summary: Carabids beetles are important biocontrol agents of weeds, but it is difficult to predict their consumption levels and regulation of weed seeds. Olfactory cues from predators or potential competitors can influence the selection and consumption of food resources by foraging individuals. Identifying and understanding the factors that drive the seed foraging behavior of carabid beetles is essential for predicting consumption levels in different carabid communities and improving weed regulation.

BIOLOGICAL CONTROL (2023)

Article Agronomy

Modelling weed seed predation by carabids and its effects on crop production under contrasted farming systems

Laurene Perthame, Sandrine Petit, Nathalie Colbach

Summary: This study investigates the impact of different factors on weed seed predation by carabid beetles and evaluates the importance of including seed predation in predicting weed dynamics in different cropping systems. The simulations show that factors such as daily incident radiation, light interception, harvest, carabid reproduction, and temperature have the most influence on seed predation rates. Including seed predation in the simulations improves the prediction quality of the model, reducing overestimation in weed variable predictions. Weed seed predation by carabids can contribute to managing weeds and improving crop yields, but the effectiveness varies among different crops.

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF AGRONOMY (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Conservation agriculture affects multitrophic interactions driving the efficacy of weed biological control

B. Carbonne, L. Muneret, E. Laurent, E. Felten, C. Ducourtieux, N. Henon, A. Matejicek, B. Chauvel, S. Petit

Summary: This study analyzed how multitrophic interactions drive weed seed control under different farming systems. The findings showed that conservation agriculture can promote weed seed predation by increasing the number of seed predators. However, the presence of alternative prey and higher-order predators can negatively affect the efficacy of seed predators and indirectly reduce seed predation.

JOURNAL OF APPLIED ECOLOGY (2023)

Review Agronomy

Phytotoxic fungal secondary metabolites as herbicides

Ana Bendejacq-Seychelles, Stephanie Gibot-Leclerc, Jean-Philippe Guillemin, Gregory Mouille, Christian Steinberg

Summary: This study discusses the diversity of fungal secondary metabolites that are phytotoxic to weeds and the methods commonly used to extract, characterize, identify and exploit them for weed management. The 183 phytotoxic fungal secondary metabolites identified in this review have different toxic effects on plants, including inhibition of germination, root and vegetative growth, and tissue and organ alterations. The biochemical characterization of these metabolites requires specialized knowledge and tools, as well as toxicity tests and effectiveness evaluations in laboratory and field conditions.

PEST MANAGEMENT SCIENCE (2023)

Letter Plant Sciences

Weed-induced yield loss through resource competition cannot be sidelined

Nathalie Colbach, Guillaume Adeux, Stephane Cordeau, Delphine Moreau

TRENDS IN PLANT SCIENCE (2023)

No Data Available