4.3 Article

Species-area relationships underestimate extinction rates

Journal

Publisher

ELSEVIER
DOI: 10.1016/j.actao.2012.02.006

Keywords

Island biogeography; Conservation biogeography; Habitat loss; Power function; SAR; Species extinction

Categories

Ask authors/readers for more resources

The species-area relationship (SAR), i.e. the increase in species number with area, has been repeatedly used to predict species extinction, at both local and global scales, with habitat reduction. He and Hubbell (Nature, 2011; 473, 368-371), however, argued that the function that relates species loss with decreasing habitat area cannot be simply obtained reversing the species-area accumulation curve. Using a statistically more appropriate curve based on endemics (EAR), they concluded that the SAR overestimates species extinction. Although we agree that SARs and EARs have different shapes, this does not imply that SARs overestimate species extinction. Empirical evidence suggests that SARs do not overestimate, but underestimate species extinction by habitat loss and fragmentation. We discuss various examples taken from recent literature to show that SARs underestimate species extinction. (C) 2012 Elsevier Masson SAS. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.3
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Ecology

Gains and losses in ecosystem services and disservices after converting native forest to agricultural land on an oceanic island

Marco Ferrante, Gabor L. Lovei, Rui Nunes, Paulo Monjardino, Lucas Lamelas-Lopez, Daniella Moller, Antonio Onofre Soares, Paulo A. V. Borges

Summary: This study monitored the effects of habitat conversion on ecosystem services and disservices on an oceanic island, and found that the intensity of ecological processes did not significantly decrease except for vertebrate predation.

BASIC AND APPLIED ECOLOGY (2023)

Article Forestry

Edge effects constraint endemic but not introduced arthropod species in a pristine forest on Terceira (Azores, Portugal)

Noelline Tsafack, Gabor Pozsgai, Mario Boieiro, Alejandra Ros-Prieto, Rui Nunes, Maria Teresa Ferreira, Paulo A. V. Borges

Summary: This study examines the impact of forest edges on arthropod assemblages, finding that edges have an effect on species composition and that endemic species are more likely to be constrained by edges. It highlights the need to avoid fragmentation and increase the size of natural parks to protect and manage these endemic species.

FOREST ECOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT (2023)

Article Geography, Physical

Plant-insect interactions in the Quaternary fossil record of the Azores Archipelago (Portugal)

Richard Pokorny, Paulo A. V. Borges

Summary: The fossil record of the Azores still lacks evidence of terrestrial invertebrates. However, a recent study on Quaternary fossil plant imprints from the Azores revealed several samples of fossil leaves with traces of plant-animal interactions, including marginal feeding and anophionome mine. The study also suggests possible originators of these trace fossils, such as butterfly caterpillars and wood-destroying beetles.

JOURNAL OF QUATERNARY SCIENCE (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

The Importance of Including Spatial Autocorrelation When Modelling Species Richness in Archipelagos: A Bayesian Approach

Diogo Duarte Barros, Maria da Luz Mathias, Paulo A. V. Borges, Luis Borda-de-Agua

Summary: The aim of island biogeography theory is to explain species richness in archipelagos. Traditionally, area and distance to the mainland are used as variables to explain species richness, but other variables, such as distance between islands, should also be considered. This study uses a Bayesian framework to assess the role of spatial autocorrelation in determining arthropod species richness patterns in the Azores and Canary Islands.

DIVERSITY-BASEL (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

SLAM Project - Long Term Ecological Study of the Impacts of Climate Change in the natural forest of Azores: VI - Inventory of Arthropods of Azorean Urban Gardens

Lucas Lamelas-Lopez, Rosalina Gabriel, Alejandra Ros-Prieto, Paulo A. V. Borges

Summary: This article presents an inventory of arthropods collected in two urban gardens in the Azores. A total of 8,342 specimens were collected, belonging to four classes, 15 orders, 80 families, and 159 species and subspecies of arthropods. The study identifies 84 introduced species/subspecies, 50 native non-endemic species/subspecies, eight endemic species/subspecies, and 17 species with an indeterminate origin. Additionally, the article revises the arthropod inventory of these gardens by updating the taxonomic names of three orders, 10 families, and 22 species.

BIODIVERSITY DATA JOURNAL (2023)

Article Ecology

A global analysis of avian island diversity-area relationships in the Anthropocene

Thomas J. Matthews, Joseph P. Wayman, Robert J. Whittaker, Pedro Cardoso, Julian P. Hume, Ferran Sayol, Konstantinos Proios, Thomas E. Martin, Benjamin Baiser, Paulo A. V. Borges, Yasuhiro Kubota, Luiz dos Anjos, Joseph A. Tobias, Filipa C. Soares, Xingfeng Si, Ping Ding, Chase D. Mendenhall, Yong Chee Keita Sin, Frank E. Rheindt, Kostas A. Triantis, Francois Guilhaumon, David M. Watson, Lluis Brotons, Corrado Battisti, Osanna Chu, Francois Rigal

Summary: Research on island species-area relationships (ISAR) has expanded to incorporate functional (IFDAR) and phylogenetic (IPDAR) diversity. However, we lack comprehensive global analyses of how these categories of island diversity-area relationship (IDAR) vary. In this study, we provide the first comparative evaluation of IDARs at the global scale using avian data sets from 51 archipelagos. Our results show that increasing richness with area drives the non-richness corrected IPDAR and IFDAR. We also find that archipelagos with steeper ISARs have larger differences in slope between IDARs, indicating increased redundancy on larger islands in these archipelagos.

ECOLOGY LETTERS (2023)

Article Entomology

Drivers of Insect Community Change along the Margins of Mountain Streams in Serra da Estrela Natural Park (Portugal)

Ana Ceia-Hasse, Mario Boieiro, Albano Soares, Sandra Antunes, Hugo Figueiredo, Carla Rego, Paulo A. V. Borges, Jose Conde, Artur R. M. Serrano

Summary: In this study, the diversity patterns of butterflies and odonates in a mountainous area were analyzed, and the factors responsible for insect community change were assessed. It was found that butterfly species richness was lowest at high altitudes, while odonate species richness did not differ between elevations. Species replacement drove the changes in butterfly assemblages, while changes in odonate communities were mostly due to species richness differences. Climatic factors, particularly temperature and precipitation, were the main drivers of community change for the two insect groups.

INSECTS (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Assessing the Impact of Insect Decline in Islands: Exploring the Diversity and Community Patterns of Indigenous and Non-Indigenous Arthropods in the Azores Native Forest over 10 Years

Sebastien Lhoumeau, Paulo A. V. Borges

Summary: The decline of insect populations emphasizes the importance of long-term ecological monitoring. This study investigated changes in arthropod diversity and community structure over a ten-year period in the native forest of Terceira Island. The results showed stable species richness and dominance of endemic arthropods, while non-endemic and introduced arthropods experienced changes in biomass and dynamics. The research contributes to understanding the temporal dynamics of arthropods in native island forests and highlights the need for ongoing conservation efforts.

DIVERSITY-BASEL (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Monitoring ten insect pests in selected orchards in three Azorean Islands: The project CUARENTAGRI

Lucas Lamelas-Lopez, Paulo A. V. Borges, Elisa Tarantino, Maria Manuela Juliano, Jose Carlos Fontes, Cristina Moules, Ricardo Rodrigues, Jessica Machado, Jose Adriano Mota, Beatriz Sousa, Helder Amaral, Maria da Conceicao Filipe, David H. Lopes

Summary: The data presented in this study are part of a project involving the Macaronesia archipelagos, aiming to identify and evaluate the risks associated with new arthropod pests and develop monitoring and prevention systems. A total of 114,827 insect specimens were collected, representing four orders and ten pest species. The study provides valuable knowledge for pest management and future prevention strategies.

BIODIVERSITY DATA JOURNAL (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Standardised inventories of lepidopterans and odonates from Serra da Estrela Natural Park (Portugal)- setting the scene for mountain biodiversity monitoring

Mario Boieiro, Sandra Antunes, Hugo Figueiredo, Albano Soares, Ana Lopes, Eva Monteiro, Patricia Garcia-Pereira, Carla Rego, Jose Conde, Paulo A. V. Borges, Artur R. M. Serrano

Summary: The highest mountain in mainland Portugal, Serra da Estrela, is an important biodiversity hotspot. However, there is still a lack of basic knowledge on the abundance, distribution, and ecology of lepidopteran and odonate species in this area. Standardised sampling is crucial to provide valuable biological information for conservation management and long-term monitoring of mountain biodiversity.

BIODIVERSITY DATA JOURNAL (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Surveying Cory Shearwater colonies with camera traps and identifying potential invasive nest predators

Lucas Lamelas-Lopez, Paulo A. V. Borges

Summary: This study provides a dataset of the Cory's shearwater population, as well as the threats it faces from invasive species. The results include records of 15 species and provide information about the biology of the species.

BIODIVERSITY DATA JOURNAL (2023)

Article Entomology

Flowering Coriander (Coriandrum sativum) Strips Do Not Enhance Ecosystem Services in Azorean Orchards

Marco Ferrante, Gabor L. Lovei, Lambert Lavigne, Mario Caballero Vicente, Elisa Tarantino, David Horta Lopes, Paulo Monjardino, Paulo A. V. Borges

Summary: This study examined the effects of coriander strips on herbivory, seed predation, and predation on artificial caterpillars in mixed orchards on Terceira Island, Portugal. Vertebrates had a greater influence on ecosystem services and disservices. The coriander strips did not increase ecosystem services/reduce disservices levels in this habitat.

INSECTS (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Terra Nostra Garden 2023 dataset of Camellia species, hybrids and their cultivars (Azores, Portugal)

Carina Costa, Fernando Costa, Antonio Trota, Paulo A. V. Borges, Paulo Monjardino, Maria J. Pereira

Summary: The Terra Nostra Garden is a historic garden with a rich collection of camellia varieties that has undergone a comprehensive rejuvenation process. The recent publication of a digital database provides the opportunity to present the dataset of camellia species, hybrids, and cultivars cultivated in the Terra Nostra Garden.

BIODIVERSITY DATA JOURNAL (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Effects of a short-term temperature increase on arthropod communities associated with pastures

Sophie Wallon, Noelline Tsafack, Gabor Pozsgai, Catarina Melo, Paulo A. Borges, Rui Elias

Summary: This study simulated climate change in forage crops in the Azores Archipelago and investigated the response of arthropod communities. The results showed lower arthropod abundance in Open Top Chambers (OTCs), with spiders and beetles responding quickly to the presence of OTCs. Non-indigenous spider assemblages adapted to pastures showed higher richness but lower abundance inside the warmer plots. However, the presence of OTCs led to a decrease in beetle richness and abundance.

BIODIVERSITY DATA JOURNAL (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Monitoring Arthropods in maize and pasture fields in São Miguel and São Jorge Islands: IPM-Popillia Project

Merio Brum Teixeira, Antonio O. Soares, Paulo A. V. Borges, Mar Torres Calvet, Angel Penalver, Hugo R. Monteiro, Jorge Frias, Nelson Simoes

Summary: The presented dataset is an inventory of terrestrial arthropods recorded in two Azorean agroecosystems (maize and pasture fields) from Sao Miguel and Sao Jorge Islands. A total of 18559 specimens belonging to the phylum Arthropoda, four classes, twelve orders, twenty-six families and forty morphospecies were collected and identified. Among the identified taxa, 18 species were predators, 15 were plant feeders, and five were omnivores. The origin of the predators included both native and introduced species.

BIODIVERSITY DATA JOURNAL (2023)

No Data Available