4.5 Article

Evidence flowers: An innovative, visual method of presenting best evidence summaries to health professional and lay audiences

Journal

RESEARCH SYNTHESIS METHODS
Volume 9, Issue 2, Pages 273-284

Publisher

WILEY
DOI: 10.1002/jrsm.1295

Keywords

evidence-based practice; dissemination; accessibility; evidence synthesis; clinical guidelines

Funding

  1. National Institute for Health Research (NIHR)
  2. Knowledge Mobilisation Research Fellowship [KMRF-2014-03-002]
  3. Programme Grants for Applied Research scheme [RP-PG-1211-20010]
  4. Arthritis Research UK [20202]
  5. National Institutes of Health Research (NIHR) [NIHR-IPF-15-09-20, CAT CDRF 10-018] Funding Source: National Institutes of Health Research (NIHR)
  6. National Institute for Health Research [CAT CDRF 10-018, NIHR-IPF-15-09-20, RP-PG-0407-10386, KMRF-2014-03-002] Funding Source: researchfish

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Background & Aims: Barriers to dissemination and engagement with evidence pose a threat to implementing evidence-based medicine. Understanding, retention, and recall can be enhanced by visual presentation of information. The aim of this exploratory research was to develop and evaluate the accessibility and acceptability of visual summaries for presenting evidence syntheses with multiple exposures or outcomes to professional and lay audiences. Methods: Evidence flowers were developed as a visual method of presenting data from 4 case scenarios: 2 complex evidence syntheses with multiple outcomes, Cochrane reviews, and clinical guidelines. Petals of evidence flowers were coloured according to the GRADE evidence rating system to display key findings and recommendations from the evidence summaries. Application of evidence flowers was observed during stakeholder workshops. Evaluation and feedback were conducted via questionnaires and informal interviews. Results: Feedback from stakeholders on the evidence flowers collected from workshops, questionnaires, and interviews was encouraging and helpful for refining the design of the flowers. Comments were made on the content and design of the flowers, as well as the usability and potential for displaying different types of evidence. Conclusions: Evidence flowers are a novel and visually stimulating method for presenting research evidence from evidence syntheses with multiple exposures or outcomes, Cochrane reviews, and clinical guidelines. To promote access and engagement with research evidence, evidence flowers may be used in conjunction with other evidence synthesis products, such as (lay) summaries, evidence inventories, rapid reviews, and clinical guidelines. Additional research on potential adaptations and applications of the evidence flowers may further bridge the gap between research evidence and clinical practice.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Endocrinology & Metabolism

Identifying and managing osteoporosis before and after COVID-19: rise of the remote consultation?

Z. Paskins, F. Crawford-Manning, L. Bullock, C. Jinks

OSTEOPOROSIS INTERNATIONAL (2020)

Review Endocrinology & Metabolism

Quality and effectiveness of osteoporosis treatment decision aids: a systematic review and environmental scan

Z. Paskins, V. D. Torres Roldan, A. W. Hawarden, L. Bullock, S. Meritxell Urtecho, G. F. Torres, L. Morera, N. R. Espinoza Suarez, A. Worrall, S. Blackburn, S. Chapman, C. Jinks, J. P. Brito

OSTEOPOROSIS INTERNATIONAL (2020)

Review Multidisciplinary Sciences

A systematic review and evidence synthesis of non-medical triage, self-referral and direct access services for patients with musculoskeletal pain

Opeyemi O. Babatunde, Annette Bishop, Elizabeth Cottrell, Joanne L. Jordan, Nadia Corp, Katrina Humphries, Tina Hadley-Barrows, Alyson L. Huntley, Danielle A. van der Windt

PLOS ONE (2020)

Article Endocrinology & Metabolism

Public priorities for osteoporosis and fracture research: results from a focus group study

Ashley Hawarden, Clare Jinks, Waheed Mahmood, Laurna Bullock, Steven Blackburn, Stephen Gwilym, Zoe Paskins

ARCHIVES OF OSTEOPOROSIS (2020)

Article Endocrinology & Metabolism

Evaluation of quality and readability of online patient information on osteoporosis and osteoporosis drug treatment and recommendations for improvement

F. Crawford-Manning, C. Greenall, A. Hawarden, L. Bullock, S. Leyland, C. Jinks, J. Protheroe, Z. Paskins

Summary: This study identified and assessed commonly accessed osteoporosis patient information resources for readability, quality, accuracy, and consistency. The resources were found to have inconsistencies, low quality and readability scores. Practical recommendations were made to improve understanding, relevance, balance, bias, and address information gaps.

OSTEOPOROSIS INTERNATIONAL (2021)

Article Medicine, General & Internal

Clinical and cost-effectiveness of bracing in symptomatic knee osteoarthritis management: protocol for a multicentre, primary care, randomised, parallel-group, superiority trial

Melanie A. Holden, Michael Callaghan, David Felson, Fraser Birrell, Elaine Nicholls, Sue Jowett, J. Kigozi, John McBeth, Belinda Borrelli, Clare Jinks, Nadine E. Foster, Krysia Dziedzic, Christian Mallen, Carol Ingram, Alan Sutton, Sarah Lawton, Nicola Halliday, Liz Hartshorne, Helen Williams, Rachel Browell, Hannah Hudson, Michelle Marshall, Gail Sowden, Dan Herron, Evans Asamane, George Peat

Summary: This study will assess the clinical and cost-effectiveness of adding knee bracing to the treatment package for knee osteoarthritis patients. Findings will be analyzed at 3, 6, and 12 months post-randomization.

BMJ OPEN (2021)

Article Endocrinology & Metabolism

Developing a model Fracture Liaison Service consultation with patients, carers and clinicians: a Delphi survey to inform content of the iFraP complex consultation intervention

Laurna Bullock, Fay Crawford-Manning, Elizabeth Cottrell, Jane Fleming, Sarah Leyland, John Edwards, Emma M. Clark, Simon Thomas, Stephen Chapman, Christopher Gidlow, Cynthia P. Iglesias, Joanne Protheroe, Robert Horne, Terence W. O'Neill, Christian Mallen, Clare Jinks, Zoe Paskins

Summary: This study conducted a modified Delphi survey to establish consensus on tasks for clinicians in a model Fracture Liaison Service (FLS) consultation. Seventy-two, 49, and 52 patients, carers, and clinicians participated in three rounds of the survey, resulting in 81 essential statements for FLS consultations covering various aspects of the consultation process. This Delphi consensus exercise provided a clear framework for clinicians and highlighted the importance of patient involvement in shared decision-making and communication in fracture prevention.

ARCHIVES OF OSTEOPOROSIS (2021)

Article Medicine, General & Internal

Improving uptake of Fracture Prevention drug treatments: a protocol for Development of a consultation intervention (iFraP-D)

Zoe Paskins, Laurna Bullock, Fay Crawford-Manning, Elizabeth Cottrell, Jane Fleming, Sarah Leyland, John James Edwards, Emma Clark, Simon Thomas, Stephen Robert Chapman, Sarah Ryan, J. E. Lefroy, Christopher J. Gidlow, C. Iglesias, Joanne Protheroe, Robert Horne, Terence W. O'Neill, Christian Mallen, Clare Jinks

Summary: The iFraP programme aims to improve patient commitment to fracture prevention treatment by enhancing communication of scientific evidence and elicitation of patient medication-related beliefs. This aims to overcome the barriers inhibiting the uptake of fracture prevention medicines, ultimately improving informed treatment adherence.

BMJ OPEN (2021)

Article Rheumatology

The attitudes towards, and beliefs about, physical activity in people with osteoarthritis and comorbidity: A qualitative investigation

Sarah McKevitt, Clare Jinks, Emma L. Healey, Jonathan G. Quicke

Summary: Through semi-structured interviews with older adults with osteoarthritis and comorbidity, it was found that they faced complex barriers to physical activity due to the impact of multiple long-term conditions. However, social support and support from knowledgeable healthcare professionals, along with physical activity adapted for their conditions, were identified as key facilitators in overcoming these barriers and increasing physical activity levels.

MUSCULOSKELETAL CARE (2022)

Article Orthopedics

Acceptability of, and preferences for, remote consulting during COVID-19 among older patients with two common long-term musculoskeletal conditions: findings from three qualitative studies and recommendations for practice

Zoe Paskins, Laurna Bullock, Fay Manning, Simon Bishop, Paul Campbell, Elizabeth Cottrell, G. P. Partner, Clare Jinks, Melanie Narayanasamy, Ian C. Scott, Opinder Sahota, Sarah Ryan

Summary: This study aimed to explore the acceptability of and preferences for remote consultations among patients with osteoporosis and rheumatoid arthritis. The findings show that attitudes towards remote consultations, views on fairness and intervention coherence varied depending on the patients' consultation needs and their perceptions of the pandemic.

BMC MUSCULOSKELETAL DISORDERS (2022)

Article Medicine, General & Internal

Clinical effectiveness of one ultrasound guided intra-articular corticosteroid and local anaesthetic injection in addition to advice and education for hip osteoarthritis (HIT trial): single blind, parallel group, three arm, randomised controlled trial

Zoe Paskins, Kieran Bromley, Martyn Lewis, Gemma Hughes, Emily Hughes, Susie Hennings, Andrea Cherrington, Alison Hall, Melanie A. Holden, Kay Stevenson, Ajit Menon, Philip Roberts, George Peat, Clare Jinks, Jesse Kigozi, Raymond Oppong, Nadine E. Foster, Christian D. Mallen, Edward Roddy

Summary: This study compared the clinical effectiveness of adding ultrasound guided intra-articular hip injection of corticosteroid and local anaesthetic to advice and education in adults with hip osteoarthritis. The results showed that this treatment option can improve hip pain intensity, especially for patients with synovitis or effusion.

BMJ-BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL (2022)

Article Primary Health Care

Integrating case-finding and initial management for osteoarthritis, anxiety, and depression into primary care long-term condition reviews: results from the ENHANCE pilot trial

Emma L. Healey, Christian D. Mallen, Carolyn A. Chew-Graham, Elaine Nicholls, Martyn Lewis, Sarah A. Lawton, Andrew G. Finney, Valerie Tan, Vince Cooper, Krysia S. Dziedzic, Jennifer Liddle, Simon Wathall, Clare Jinks

Summary: This study aimed to test the feasibility of integrating intervention for osteoarthritis, anxiety, and depression into routine long-term condition reviews. The results showed that primary care practices were able to implement the intervention during routine assessments, but there is room for improvement in training and recruitment.

FAMILY PRACTICE (2022)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Resistance or appropriation? Uptake of exercise after a nurse-led intervention to promote self-management for osteoarthritis

Andrew Morden, Bie Nio Ong, Clare Jinks, Emma Healey, Andrew Finney, Krysia S. Dziedzic

Summary: This study investigates the outcomes of a complex intervention to promote self-management for osteoarthritis. Findings suggest that communication styles influence the outcomes of self-management interventions.

HEALTH (2022)

Review Medicine, Research & Experimental

A pilot study of a nurse-led integrated care review (the INCLUDE review) for people with inflammatory rheumatological conditions in primary care: feasibility study findings

Samantha L. Hider, Milica Bucknall, Clare Jinks, Kelly Cooke, Kendra Cooke, Erandie Ediriweera Desilva, Andrew G. Finney, Emma L. Healey, Daniel Herron, Annabelle R. Machin, Christian D. Mallen, Simon Wathall, Carolyn A. Chew-Graham

Summary: Patients with inflammatory rheumatological conditions are at increased risk of comorbidities, but are currently not systematically targeted for management. This pilot study shows that implementing a nurse-led integrated care review in primary care is feasible, providing insights for improving comorbidity management.

PILOT AND FEASIBILITY STUDIES (2021)

Review Medicine, General & Internal

Acceptability of bisphosphonates among patients, clinicians and managers: a systematic review and framework synthesis

Zoe Paskins, Fay Crawford-Manning, Elizabeth Cottrell, Nadia Corp, Jenny Wright, Clare Jinks, Simon Bishop, Alison Doyle, Terence Ong, Neil Gittoes, Jo Leonardi-Bee, Tessa Langley, Robert Horne, Opinder Sahota

BMJ OPEN (2020)

No Data Available