4.8 Article

Divestment prevails over the green paradox when anticipating strong future climate policies

Journal

NATURE CLIMATE CHANGE
Volume 8, Issue 2, Pages 130-+

Publisher

NATURE PORTFOLIO
DOI: 10.1038/s41558-017-0053-1

Keywords

-

Funding

  1. German Federal Ministry of Education and Research (BMBF) in the Call 'Economics of Climate Change' [01LA11020B]
  2. UK Research Councils under Natural Environment Research Council [NE/G007748/1]
  3. Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council [EP/L024756/1, EP/P022405/1] Funding Source: researchfish
  4. EPSRC [EP/L024756/1, EP/P022405/1] Funding Source: UKRI

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Fossil fuel market dynamics will have a significant impact on the effectiveness of climate policies(1). Both fossil fuel owners and investors in fossil fuel infrastructure are sensitive to climate policies that threaten their natural resource endowments and production capacities(2-4), which will consequently affect their near-term behaviour. Although weak in near-term policy commitments(5,6), the Paris Agreement on climate(7) signalled strong ambitions in climate change stabilization. Many studies emphasize that the 2 degrees C target can still be achieved even if strong climate policies are delayed until 2030(8-10). However, sudden implementation will have severe consequences for fossil fuel markets and beyond and these studies ignore the anticipation effects of owners and investors. Here we use two energy-economy models to study the collective influence of the two central but opposing anticipation arguments, the green paradox(11) and the divestment effect(12), which have, to date, been discussed only separately. For a wide range of future climate policies, we find that anticipation effects, on balance, reduce CO2 emissions during the implementation lag. This is because of strong divestment in coal power plants starting ten years ahead of policy implementation. The green paradox effect is identified, but is small under reasonable assumptions.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.8
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Review Environmental Sciences

Exploring the possibility space: taking stock of the diverse capabilities and gaps in integrated assessment models

I Keppo, I Butnar, N. Bauer, M. Caspani, O. Edelenbosch, J. Emmerling, P. Fragkos, C. Guivarch, M. Harmsen, J. Lefevre, T. Le Gallic, M. Leimbach, W. McDowall, J-F Mercure, R. Schaeffer, E. Trutnevyte, F. Wagner

Summary: Integrated assessment models (IAMs) are key tools for climate mitigation scenarios, but face critiques on method adequacy and result communication. Despite conceptual diversity, IAMs are often criticized collectively. Six main critiques include representation of actors, technology diffusion modeling, capital markets representation, energy-economy feedbacks, policy scenarios, and interpretation and use of model results.

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2021)

Article Environmental Sciences

COVID-19-induced low power demand and market forces starkly reduce CO2 emissions

Christoph Bertram, Gunnar Luderer, Felix Creutzig, Nico Bauer, Falko Ueckerdt, Aman Malik, Ottmar Edenhofer

Summary: The COVID-19 pandemic has significantly impacted global energy systems, leading to a substantial decline in global power sector emissions. Global policy should learn from the lessons of 2020 to ensure that power sector emissions have peaked in 2018 and are now in a structural decline phase.

NATURE CLIMATE CHANGE (2021)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Alternative carbon price trajectories can avoid excessive carbon removal

Jessica Strefler, Elmar Kriegler, Nico Bauer, Gunnar Luderer, Robert C. Pietzcker, Anastasis Giannousakis, Ottmar Edenhofer

Summary: Most climate change mitigation scenarios overestimate the need for carbon dioxide removal (CDR) due to assumptions of exponentially increasing carbon prices. However, controlling global warming well below 2 degrees C may be more achievable with lower long-term economic effort and CDR deployment if high carbon prices are set initially to ensure target compliance, and then increase at a slower rate after carbon neutrality is reached.

NATURE COMMUNICATIONS (2021)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Combining ambitious climate policies with efforts to eradicate poverty

Bjoern Soergel, Elmar Kriegler, Benjamin Leon Bodirsky, Nico Bauer, Marian Leimbach, Alexander Popp

Summary: Climate change poses a threat to eradicating extreme poverty, but this impact can be offset by redistributing national carbon pricing revenues and implementing international climate finance, leading to a significant reduction in global poverty.

NATURE COMMUNICATIONS (2021)

Article Environmental Sciences

The contribution of bioenergy to the decarbonization of transport: a multi-model assessment

Florian Leblanc, Ruben Bibas, Silvana Mima, Matteo Muratori, Shogo Sakamoto, Fuminori Sano, Nico Bauer, Vassilis Daioglou, Shinichiro Fujimori, Matthew J. Gidden, Estsushi Kato, Steven K. Rose, Junichi Tsutsui, Detlef P. van Vuuren, John Weyant, Marshall Wise

Summary: The paper highlights the potential of bioenergy to reduce transport GHG emissions, although it may not be the dominant solution. Lignocellulosic fuels could play a significant role in decarbonizing transportation sector, but the limited biomass supply and uncertainties in allocation to and within the sector are key factors affecting the use of biofuels in transport.

CLIMATIC CHANGE (2022)

Article Energy & Fuels

Impact of declining renewable energy costs on electrification in low-emission scenarios

Gunnar Luderer, Silvia Madeddu, Leon Merfort, Falko Ueckerdt, Michaja Pehl, Robert Pietzcker, Marianna Rottoli, Felix Schreyer, Nico Bauer, Lavinia Baumstark, Christoph Bertram, Alois Dirnaichner, Florian Humpenoder, Antoine Levesque, Alexander Popp, Renato Rodrigues, Jessica Strefler, Elmar Kriegler

Summary: The rapid cost degression in photovoltaics, wind-power, and battery storage, along with climate policies like carbon pricing to reach the Paris Climate targets, could make electricity cheaper than carbon-based fuels. This could lead to electricity accounting for nearly two-thirds of global energy use by mid-century, inducing a fundamental transformation in energy systems.

NATURE ENERGY (2022)

Article Economics

Capital markets and the costs of climate policies

Marian Leimbach, Nico Bauer

Summary: Globalization has led to increasing current account imbalances, while climate change challenges require cooperative action. A study investigating potential market feedback mechanisms between climate policies, energy sector transformation, and imperfect capital markets has shown initial results of the dominant effect of capital market imperfections on macroeconomic variables in global climate policy scenarios.

ENVIRONMENTAL ECONOMICS AND POLICY STUDIES (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Using large ensembles of climate change mitigation scenarios for robust insights

Celine Guivarch, Thomas Le Gallic, Nico Bauer, Panagiotis Fragkos, Daniel Huppmann, Marc Jaxa-Rozen, Ilkka Keppo, Elmar Kriegler, Tamas Krisztin, Giacomo Marangoni, Steve Pye, Keywan Riahi, Roberto Schaeffer, Massimo Tavoni, Evelina Trutnevyte, Detlef van Vuuren, Fabian Wagner

Summary: Mitigation scenario ensembles are a crucial tool for achieving net zero emissions. This study explores their potential and outlines key steps for their effective use and promotion of good practices.

NATURE CLIMATE CHANGE (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Coal-exit alliance must confront freeriding sectors to propel Paris-aligned momentum

Stephen L. L. Bi, Nico Bauer, Jessica Jewell

Summary: This research presents a new approach to evaluate the potential risks of coal phase-out and the bottom-up momentum. The study highlights the importance of global coal phase-out for the Paris Agreement. It introduces the dynamic policy evaluation (DPE) method to assess the likelihood of PPCA participation and predicts potential leakage risks that may undermine sector-specific actions.

NATURE CLIMATE CHANGE (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Exploring risks and benefits of overshooting a 1.5 °C carbon budget over space and time

Nico Bauer, David P. Keller, Julius Garbe, Kristine Karsten, Franziska Piontek, Werner von Bloh, Wim Thiery, Maria Zeitz, Matthias Mengel, Jessica Strefler, Kirsten Thonicke, Ricarda Winkelmann

Summary: Temperature targets of the Paris Agreement limit global net cumulative emissions to tight carbon budgets, and the possibility of overshooting the budget and offsetting near-term excess emissions with net-negative emissions is economically attractive. However, the additional climate risks and impacts and damages associated with carbon removal deployment have received less attention. An integrative analysis linking six models reveals that overshooting a carbon budget consistent with the 1.5 degrees C target has significant effects on climatic, environmental, and socio-economic systems. The study highlights the need for differentiated analysis of these systems in overshoot scenarios.

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2023)

Correction Environmental Sciences

Exploring risks and benefits of overshooting a 1.5 degrees C carbon budget over space and time (vol 18, 054015, 2023)

Nico Bauer, David P. Keller, Julius Garbe, Kristine Karstens, Franziska Piontek, Werner von Bloh, Wim Thiery, Maria Zeitz, Matthias Mengel, Jessica Strefler, Kirsten Thonicke, Ricarda Winkelmann

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Bioenergy-induced land-use-change emissions with sectorally fragmented policies

Leon Merfort, Nico Bauer, Florian Humpenoeder, David Klein, Jessica Strefler, Alexander Popp, Gunnar Luderer, Elmar Kriegler

Summary: Controlling bioenergy-induced land-use-change emissions is crucial for utilizing bioenergy as a climate change mitigation strategy. The impact of different land-use and energy sector policies on bioenergy emissions has not been previously studied. This study reveals that a uniform price on emissions and comprehensive coverage of carbon-rich land areas are essential for reducing total biofuel emissions. In the absence of proper land-use regulation, bioenergy may contribute less to climate change mitigation than previously assumed.

NATURE CLIMATE CHANGE (2023)

Editorial Material Environmental Sciences

State of global land regulation inadequate to control biofuel land-use-change emissions

Leon Merfort, Nico Bauer, Florian Humpenoeder, David Klein, Jessica Strefler, Alexander Popp, Gunnar Luderer, Elmar Kriegler

Summary: Under the current land-use regulation, carbon dioxide emissions from biofuel production are higher than those from fossil diesel combustion. Consequently, international agreements should prioritize the comprehensive protection of natural land before modern bioenergy can make meaningful contributions towards achieving carbon neutrality.

NATURE CLIMATE CHANGE (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

REMIND2.1: transformation and innovation dynamics of the energy-economic system within climate and sustainability limits

Lavinia Baumstark, Nico Bauer, Falk Benke, Christoph Bertram, Stephen Bi, Chen Chris Gong, Jan Philipp Dietrich, Alois Dirnaichner, Anastasis Giannousakis, Jerome Hilaire, David Klein, Johannes Koch, Marian Leimbach, Antoine Levesque, Silvia Madeddu, Aman Malik, Anne Merfort, Leon Merfort, Adrian Odenweller, Michaja Pehl, Robert C. Pietzcker, Franziska Piontek, Sebastian Rauner, Renato Rodrigues, Marianna Rottoli, Felix Schreyer, Anselm Schultes, Bjoern Soergel, Dominika Soergel, Jessica Strefler, Falko Ueckerdt, Elmar Kriegler, Gunnar Luderer

Summary: The REMIND model is an integrated assessment model that provides a comprehensive view of the global energy-economy-emissions system and explores self-consistent transformation pathways. It uses non-linear optimization to derive welfare-optimal regional transformation pathways of the energy-economic system and has particular strength in representing the scale-up of new technologies. The spatial resolution of REMIND is flexible and can be used for a variety of applications, balancing detail requirements and overall complexity.

GEOSCIENTIFIC MODEL DEVELOPMENT (2021)

Review Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Ten new insights in climate science 2021: a horizon scan

Maria A. Martin, Olga Alcaraz Sendra, Ana Bastos, Nico Bauer, Christoph Bertram, Thorsten Blenckner, Kathryn Bowen, Paulo M. Brando, Tanya Brodie Rudolph, Milena Buchs, Mercedes Bustamante, Deliang Chen, Helen Cleugh, Purnamita Dasgupta, Fatima Denton, Jonathan F. Donges, Felix Kwabena Donkor, Hongbo Duan, Carlos M. Duarte, Kristie L. Ebi, Clea M. Edwards, Anja Engel, Eleanor Fisher, Sabine Fuss, Juliana Gaertner, Andrew Gettelman, Cecile A. J. Girardin, Nicholas R. Golledge, Jessica F. Green, Michael R. Grose, Masahiro Hashizume, Sophie Hebden, Helmke Hepach, Marina Hirota, Huang-Hsiung Hsu, Satoshi Kojima, Sharachchandra Lele, Sylvia Lorek, Heike K. Lotze, H. Damon Matthews, Darren McCauley, Desta Mebratu, Nadine Mengis, Rachael H. Nolan, Erik Pihl, Stefan Rahmstorf, Aaron Redman, Colleen E. Reid, Johan Rockstrom, Joeri Rogelj, Marielle Saunois, Lizzie Sayer, Peter Schlosser, Giles B. Sioen, Joachim H. Spangenberg, Detlef Stammer, Thomas N. S. Sterner, Nicola Stevens, Kirsten Thonicke, Hanqin Tian, Ricarda Winkelmann, James Woodcock

Summary: Recent research highlights the importance of limiting global warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius and the potential ways to achieve this goal, such as through demand-side and nature-based solutions. It also emphasizes the significant impacts of political challenges on the effectiveness of carbon pricing.

GLOBAL SUSTAINABILITY (2021)

No Data Available