4.5 Article

The major barriers to evidence-informed conservation policy and possible solutions

Journal

CONSERVATION LETTERS
Volume 11, Issue 5, Pages -

Publisher

WILEY
DOI: 10.1111/conl.12564

Keywords

conservation policy; evidence-based conservation; evidence-informed conservation; knowledge exchange; political science; science communication; science-policy

Funding

  1. Arcadia Fund
  2. Seventh Framework Programme [308454]
  3. Natural Environment Research Council [NE/L002507/1]
  4. Scriven Fellowship
  5. Grantham Foundation for the Protection of the Environment
  6. Austrian Science Fund
  7. Fondation Wiener Anspach
  8. Kenneth Miller Trust
  9. Cambridge Trust Cambridge Australia Poynton Scholarship
  10. Cambridge Department of Zoology JS Gardiner Fellowship
  11. International Climate Initiative (IKI), German Federal Ministry for the Environment, Nature Conservation, Building and Nuclear Safety

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Conservation policy decisions can suffer from a lack of evidence, hindering effective decision-making. In nature conservation, studies investigating why policy is often not evidence-informed have tended to focus on Western democracies, with relatively small samples. To understand global variation and challenges better, we established a global survey aimed at identifying top barriers and solutions to the use of conservation science in policy. This obtained the views of 758 people in policy, practice, and research positions from 68 countries across six languages. Here we show that, contrary to popular belief, there is agreement between groups about how to incorporate conservation science into policy, and there is thus room for optimism. Barriers related to the low priority of conservation were considered to be important, while mainstreaming conservation was proposed as a key solution. Therefore, priorities should focus on convincing the public of the importance of conservation as an issue, which will then influence policy-makers to adopt pro-environmental long-term policies.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Mapping research gaps for sustainable forest management based on the nominal group technique

Jean Huge, Behara Satyanarayana, Nibedita Mukherjee, Viviana Otero, Katherine Vande Velde, Farid Dahdouh-Guebas

Summary: Managing a complex social-ecological system requires consideration of multiple variables and their interactions. There is a growing interest in involving non-academic stakeholders in researching social-ecological systems. The study applied the nominal group technique (NGT) to identify research priorities for Matang mangroves. NGT is a systematic and participatory approach that provides a rapid and accurate way to identify priorities.

ENVIRONMENT DEVELOPMENT AND SUSTAINABILITY (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Connectivity between countries established by landbirds and raptors migrating along the African-Eurasian flyway

Joao L. Guilherme, Victoria R. Jones, Ines Catry, Martin Beal, Maria P. Dias, Steffen Oppel, Juliet A. Vickery, Chris M. Hewson, Stuart H. M. Butchart, Ana S. L. Rodrigues

Summary: The conservation of long-distance migratory birds requires coordination between countries connected by their movements. Tracking studies have provided new information on these movements, but it is often inaccessible to conservation practitioners and policy makers. This study synthesized current knowledge on migratory connectivity between European breeding countries and sub-Saharan African nonbreeding countries. The number of available tracking studies has increased, but the coverage of data is incomplete and biased towards certain species and regions. Despite limitations, the results can inform policy discussions and help prioritize future tracking studies.

CONSERVATION BIOLOGY (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Methods to detect spatial biases in tracking studies caused by differential representativeness of individuals, populations and time

Virginia Morera-Pujol, Paulo Catry, Maria Magalhaes, Clara Peron, Jose Manuel Reyes-Gonzalez, Jose Pedro Granadeiro, Teresa Militao, Maria P. Dias, Daniel Oro, Giacomo Dell'Omo, Martina Muller, Vitor H. Paiva, Benjamin Metzger, Veronica Neves, Joan Navarro, Georgios Karris, Stavros Xirouchakis, Jacopo G. Cecere, Antonio Zamora-Lopez, Manuela G. Forero, Ridha Ouni, Mohamed Salah Romdhane, Fernanda De Felipe, Zuzana Zajkova, Marta Cruz-Flores, David Gremillet, Jacob Gonzalez-Solis, Raul Ramos

Summary: The study of movement through tracking data has exceeded expectations and posed new challenges for movement ecologists. This research developed R functions to detect the effects of individual site fidelity, environmental stochasticity, and space-use variability on the distribution of animal groups inferred from individual tracking data. The procedures were applied to simulated and real-world datasets, providing a useful tool for researchers using animal tracking data to model species distributions and establish conservation measures.

DIVERSITY AND DISTRIBUTIONS (2023)

Article Ornithology

Using empirical data analysis and expert opinion to identify farmland-associated bird species from their habitat associations

Da-Li Lin, Martine Maron, Tatsuya Amano, An-Yu Chang, Richard A. Fuller

Summary: Agricultural expansion poses a threat to biodiversity, and intensification of farming activities can decrease the diversity and abundance of farmland-associated species. This study developed an integrated approach using empirical data analysis and expert opinion to identify farmland-associated bird species in Taiwan. The results showed that the classifications of 104 species based on both methods were consistent, with 72.1% of the species classified consistently. The study highlights the importance of expert opinion in cases where empirical data are insufficient.
Article Fisheries

Building leaders for the UN Ocean Science Decade: a guide to supporting early career women researchers within academic marine research institutions

R. J. Shellock, C. Cvitanovic, M. C. McKinnon, M. Mackay, I. E. van Putten, J. Blythe, R. Kelly, P. Tuohy, K. M. Maltby, S. Mynott, N. Simmonds, M. Bailey, A. Begossi, B. Crona, K. A. Fakoya, B. P. Ferreira, A. J. G. Ferrer, K. Frangoudes, J. Gobin, H. C. Goh, P. Haapasaari, B. D. Hardesty, V. Haussermann, K. Hoareau, A-K. Hornidge, M. Isaacs, M. Kraan, Y. Li, M. Liu, P. F. M. Lopes, M. Mlakar, T. H. Morrison, H. A. Oxenford, G. Pecl, J. Penca, C. Robinson, S. A. Selim, M. Skern-Mauritzen, K. Soejima, D. Soto, A. K. Spalding, A. Vadrot, N. Vaidianu, M. Webber, M. S. Wisz

Summary: This article emphasizes the importance of diverse and inclusive marine research in addressing ocean sustainability challenges in the 21st century. Despite efforts to diversify ocean science, women still face barriers to career progression within academic institutions. Drawing on the experiences of 34 global women leaders, the article proposes practical strategies and actions to empower early career women researchers to become future leaders.

ICES JOURNAL OF MARINE SCIENCE (2023)

Article Geography

Landscapes of support for farming mental health: Adaptability in the face of crisis

Faye Shortland, Jilly Hall, Paul Hurley, Ruth Little, Caroline Nye, Matt Lobley, David Christian Rose

Summary: Poor mental health in the farming industry is a significant and increasingly common issue. The adaptability of support systems, referred to as 'landscapes of support', is crucial in times of crisis. This article examines the factors that influence the adaptability of these support landscapes, with a focus on the UK. Through literature review, interviews, surveys, and a workshop, it was found that while support-giving organizations implemented interventions during the pandemic, they faced challenges such as limited digital training, funding shortages, and operational constraints. The article discusses ways to make the landscapes of support for farming mental health more sustainable.

SOCIOLOGIA RURALIS (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

The inverted forest: Aboveground and notably large belowground carbon stocks and their drivers in Brazilian savannas

Marcela C. N. S. Terra, Matheus Henrique Nunes, Cleber R. Souza, Gabriel W. D. Ferreira, Jamir A. do Prado-Junior, Vanessa L. Rezende, Rafaella Maciel, Vanessa Mantovani, Andre Rodrigues, Vinicius Augusto Morais, Jose Roberto Soares Scolforo, Jose Marcio de Mello

Summary: Savannas in South America contribute significantly to terrestrial net primary productivity and carbon storage. A unique dataset of 21 Cerrado sites in Southeastern Brazil was used to assess the patterns of above and belowground carbon stocks. Environmental factors and tree diversity had significant effects on carbon stocks, with belowground carbon storage being particularly important. The findings highlight the need for better management and protection of the Cerrado.

SCIENCE OF THE TOTAL ENVIRONMENT (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

DOCU-CLIM: A global documentary climate dataset for climate reconstructions

Angela-Maria Burgdorf, Stefan Broennimann, George Adamson, Tatsuya Amano, Yasuyuki Aono, David Barriopedro, Teresa Bullon, Chantal Camenisch, Dario Camuffo, Valeerie Daux, Maria del Rosario Prieto, Petr Dobrovolny, David Gallego, Ricardo Garcia-Herrera, Joelle Gergis, Stefan Grab, Matthew J. Hannaford, Jari Holopainen, Clare Kelso, Zoltan Kern, Andrea Kiss, Elaine Kuan-Hui Lin, Neil J. Loader, Martin Mozny, David Nash, Sharon E. Nicholson, Christian Pfister, Fernando S. Rodrigo, This Rutishauser, Sapna Sharma, Katalin Takacs, Ernesto T. Vargas, Inmaculada Vega

Summary: Documentary climate data, derived from written historical documents, provide evidence of past climate. A global dataset of documentary climate time series has not been compiled before. This study presents the first global collection of documentary climate records, consisting of 621 time series, including temperature, precipitation, and wind regime variations. The results show strong correlations, particularly for temperature-sensitive series, indicating the considerable potential of documentary records as climate data.

SCIENTIFIC DATA (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

A psychometric approach to assess justice perceptions in support of the governance of agricultural sustainability transitions

Auvikki de Boon, Sabrina Dressel, Camilla Sandstrom, David Christian Rose

Summary: There is agreement that sustainability transitions should be conducted in a just manner, but the meaning of a 'just transition' and how to achieve it is not clear. Examining the justice of transitions so far has relied on normative interpretations. This study develops an instrument based on dimensions of justice to provide decision-makers with insights into societal perceptions of a just agricultural transition. The instrument can also be valuable for sustainability transitions in other sectors, although some constructs like distributive justice will require further refinement.

ENVIRONMENTAL INNOVATION AND SOCIETAL TRANSITIONS (2023)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

The role of non-English-language science in informing national biodiversity assessments

Tatsuya Amano, Violeta Berdejo-Espinola, Munemitsu Akasaka, Milton A. U. de Andrade Junior, Ndayizeye Blaise, Julia Checco, F. Goezde cilingir, Geoffroy Citegetse, Marina Corella Tor, Szymon M. Drobniak, Sylvaine Giakoumi, Marina Golivets, Mihaela C. Ion, Javiera P. Jara-Diaz, Ryosuke Katayose, Felicia P. S. Lasmana, Hsien-Yung Lin, Erick Lopez, Peter Mikula, Lucia Morales-Barquero, Anne-Christine Mupepele, Juan P. Narvaez-Gomez, Thi Hieu Nguyen, Sa Nogueira Lisboa, Martin A. Nunez, Diego Pavon-Jordan, Patrice Pottier, Graham W. Prescott, Farah Samad, Marko Sciban, Hae-Min Seo, Yushin Shinoda, Flora Vajna, Svetlana Vozykova, Jessica C. Walsh, Alison K. S. Wee, Hui Xiao, Veronica Zamora-Gutierrez

Summary: Consultation of non-English-language scientific literature is crucial for successful conservation decision-making. However, global assessments often overlook non-English-language literature, resulting in a lack of understanding about its contribution to conservation decision-making. Our study on biodiversity assessment reports from 37 countries reveals that non-English-language literature plays a significant role as a source of local information, with an average of 65% of references being non-English. Ignoring non-English-language science may lead to important information on local and regional biodiversity being overlooked. Additionally, a quarter of authors acknowledged difficulties in understanding English-language literature, indicating a need for improved access and translation.

NATURE SUSTAINABILITY (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

IOs in the BBNJ Regime Complex - the Dataset

Arne Langlet, Alice Vadrot

Summary: This article presents visualizations and an overview of the involvement of international organizations (IOs) in the negotiations for a new legally binding instrument for the conservation and sustainable use of marine Biodiversity Beyond National Jurisdiction (BBNJ) under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS). The dataset describes the various ways in which IOs participate in the negotiations, including participation, making statements, being referred to by states, hosting side events, and being mentioned in a draft text. Each involvement is mapped to a specific package item of the BBNJ agreement and the corresponding provision of the draft text.

DATA IN BRIEF (2023)

Editorial Material Geography

Farming wellbeing through and beyond COVID-19: Stressors, gender differences and landscapes of support

David Christian Rose, Hannah Budge, Michael Carolan, Jilly Hall, Conor Hammersley, Jorie Knook, Matt Lobley, Caroline Nye, Alexis O'Reilly, Faye Shortland, Rebecca Wheeler

Summary: Despite recent research on poor farmer wellbeing and mental health, the understanding of wellbeing in farming communities worldwide and how it can be supported is still limited. This special issue expands our knowledge on the challenges to the wellbeing of farmers, farming families, and farm workers from various stressors and how these impacts can be unequally distributed. It advances research on farmer wellbeing by examining the combined effects of social, economic, and environmental drivers and emphasizes the importance of accessible, well-funded, and adaptable support systems for farming communities. The issue explores farmer wellbeing in the context of global agricultural transitions and shock events like the COVID-19 pandemic, highlighting the need for nuanced investigations and context-specific support.

SOCIOLOGIA RURALIS (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Drone-induced flight initiation distances for shorebirds in mixed-species flocks

Joshua P. P. Wilson, Tatsuya Amano, Richard A. A. Fuller

Summary: The increase in drone use has led to a need for regulations on flights near vulnerable wildlife, but a lack of data on drone-induced wildlife disturbance has hindered these efforts. This study characterizes the disturbance caused by drones among mixed-species shorebird flocks to provide guidance for drone management near shorebirds. The researchers conducted drone approaches on roosting non-breeding shorebirds in Moreton Bay, Australia and found that the flight initiation distance varies depending on the species and certain factors such as drone noise, approach velocity, and distance. The researchers recommend careful regulation of drone use, evaluation of disturbance risk in drone surveys, and seeking alternatives in the absence of disturbance data.

JOURNAL OF APPLIED ECOLOGY (2023)

Review Veterinary Sciences

Factors that influence dairy farmers' decisions to implement Johne's Disease control practices: A systematic review

Rosie Morrison, David Christian Rose

Summary: This study aims to fill the research gap on the driving factors of farmer participation in Johne's control. The results suggest that psychological factors act as barriers to farmer participation, and it is important to engage farmers, advisers, and supply chain actors with different attitudes and levels of knowledge in the design and delivery of control programs.

PREVENTIVE VETERINARY MEDICINE (2023)

Article Biochemistry & Molecular Biology

The manifold costs of being a non-native English speaker in science

Tatsuya Amano, Valeria Ramirez-Castaneda, Violeta Berdejo-Espinola, Israel Borokini, Shawan Chowdhury, Marina Golivets, Juan David Gonzalez-Trujillo, Flavia Montano-Centellas, Kumar Paudel, Rachel Louise White, Diogo Verissimo

Summary: The use of English as the common language of science is a major barrier for non-native English speakers in contributing to science. This study surveyed 908 researchers in environmental sciences and found that non-native English speakers, particularly early in their careers, exert more effort in conducting scientific activities in English compared to native English speakers. Language barriers also prevent them from attending or giving oral presentations at international conferences conducted in English. The study suggests that scientific communities should address these disadvantages and proposes potential solutions.

PLOS BIOLOGY (2023)

No Data Available