4.4 Article

Developing teachers' pedagogical identities through a community of practice: learning to sustain the use of a student-centered inquiry as curriculum approach

Journal

SPORT EDUCATION AND SOCIETY
Volume 24, Issue 8, Pages 855-866

Publisher

ROUTLEDGE JOURNALS, TAYLOR & FRANCIS LTD
DOI: 10.1080/13573322.2018.1476336

Keywords

Community of practice; student centered pedagogy; inquiry based learning; student engagement; teacher change; participatory action research; collaboration; critical pedagogy

Ask authors/readers for more resources

This collaborative self-study explores how educators' pedagogical identities developed in the process of learning to use a Student-Centered Inquiry as Curriculum (SCIC) approach in activity settings within a community of practice (CoP). Participants included a university professor, college instructor, postdoctoral student and doctoral student. Data included 16 weekly field notes and debriefings following observations, teacher artifacts, 16 weekly collaborative group meetings, and 3 90-minute interviews per teacher. Culture, values, beliefs and professional background were critical for the development of the teachers' pedagogical identities in the process of learning to use a SCIC approach within a community of practice. These experiences created for some, places to further develop their ideas about teaching, whereas for others they caused great discomfort and a sense of personal loss. The CoP facilitated the development of the teachers' pedagogical identities, changing positionalities, and negotiating culture, values, beliefs and professional backgrounds.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.4
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Education & Educational Research

Towards a culturally relevant sport pedagogy: lessons learned from African Australian refugee-background coaches in grassroots football

Carla Luguetti, Loy Singehebhuye, Ramon Spaaij

Summary: This paper explores the pedagogies of African Australian refugee-background coaches working with young people in a grassroots football programme in Melbourne. The study identifies the coaches as "barrier breakers" who connect young people to resources, nurture cultural competence, and create spaces for critical awareness. The findings highlight the importance of including diverse cultural knowledges to develop more culturally responsive sport programmes.

SPORT EDUCATION AND SOCIETY (2022)

Article Education & Educational Research

Rethinking pedagogical practices with care-experienced young people: lessons from a sport-based programme analysed through a Freirean lens

Thomas Quarmby, Carla Luguetti

Summary: This article examines pedagogical practices with care-experienced young people in a sport-based programme, using Paulo Freire's critical pedagogy as a theoretical framework. The analysis identifies specific pedagogical practices that create spaces for empowering care-experienced young people, as well as the challenges and tensions in this process.

PHYSICAL EDUCATION AND SPORT PEDAGOGY (2023)

Article Education & Educational Research

'I know how researchers are [ horizontal ellipsis ] taking more from you than they give you': tensions and possibilities of youth participatory action research in sport for development

Carla Luguetti, Nyayoud Jice, Loy Singehebhuye, Kashindi Singehebhuye, Adut Mathieu, Ramon Spaaij

Summary: This article explores the use of youth participatory action research (YPAR) in sport for development (SfD) and highlights the challenges and possibilities of involving co-researchers throughout the research process. The findings reveal that authentic engagement of co-researchers is often limited to data collection and highlights the tensions between co-researchers and coaches regarding the use of space within the sport context. The article challenges the notion that YPAR guarantees empowerment for young people and emphasizes the complexities of power sharing in SfD.

SPORT EDUCATION AND SOCIETY (2023)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

Enhancing social inclusion in sport: Dynamics of action research in super-diverse contexts

Ramon Spaaij, Carla Luguetti, Brent McDonald, Fiona McLachlan

Summary: This paper examines the development of an action research project aimed at supporting the co-creation of inclusive climates in sports clubs in culturally and linguistically diverse communities in Melbourne, Australia. The findings indicate that the collaborative process of assessing clubs' diversity and inclusion climates had an impact on participants' awareness of inequities and exclusionary practices, and the co-creation of strategies for change brought together diverse perspectives. The paper reflects on the implications and limitations of the action research for promoting equitable social inclusion for culturally and linguistically diverse migrants in community sport.

INTERNATIONAL REVIEW FOR THE SOCIOLOGY OF SPORT (2023)

Review Education & Educational Research

What would bell hooks think of the remote teaching and learning in Physical Education during the COVID-19 pandemic? A critical review of the literature

Karen Lambert, Christopher Hudson, Carla Luguetti

Summary: This critical narrative review explores the pedagogies used by PE teachers and PETE educators during the COVID-19 pandemic, examining them through the lens of bell hooks' engaged pedagogy. A total of 86 articles were reviewed, with 38 articles meeting the inclusion criteria for data extraction. The study utilized both inductive and deductive methods of data analysis. The findings reveal a lack of evidence supporting the adoption of engaged pedagogy in PE and PETE during COVID-19, with a focus on day-to-day survival rather than transformative and meaningful learning. The review highlights the need for PE teachers and PETE educators to develop equitable, inclusive, and empathetic classroom spaces.

SPORT EDUCATION AND SOCIETY (2023)

Article Education & Educational Research

'It wasn't adults and young people [...] we're all in it together': co-designing a post-secondary transition program through youth participatory action research

Carla Luguetti, Juliana Ryan, Bill Eckersley, Amy Howard, Sarah Buck, Aisha Osman, Chloe Hansen, Patrick Galati, Robinson Jack Cahill, Sarah Craig, Claire Brown

Summary: This paper contributes to youth participatory action research (YPAR) by using bell hooks' engaged pedagogy to illustrate the process of co-designing a program for transition beyond secondary school. Engaged pedagogy combines critical consciousness and radical wholeness to foster a learning community. The research findings show that YPAR, informed by engaged pedagogy, raised critical consciousness and allowed for the demonstration of radical wholeness, leading to a more holistic approach in education.

EDUCATIONAL ACTION RESEARCH (2023)

Article Education & Educational Research

Is meaningful physical education and social justice a complimentary combination? A physical education teacher educator collaborative self-study

C. Iannucci, D. Ni Chroinin, C. Luguetti, D. Hamblin

Summary: This study explores the concepts of Meaningful PE and social justice, and their relationship, in teacher education pedagogies. It examines how these ideas can be complementary, overlapping, or distinctive.

PHYSICAL EDUCATION AND SPORT PEDAGOGY (2023)

Article Management

Everybody's talking about doing co-design, but to really truly genuinely authentically do it [...] it's bloody hard: Radical openness in youth participatory action research

Carla Luguetti, Juliana Ryan, Bill Eckersley, Amy Howard, Sarah Craig, Claire Brown

Summary: Guided by bell hooks' concept of 'radical openness', this study explores the challenges faced by multi-party facilitation teams in youth participatory action research (YPAR) and how these challenges were overcome through critical reflection and dialogue. The study found that radical openness enabled the team to recognize and address biases, negotiate authenticity and accountability, and deepen their consciousness and research praxis. The findings suggest that multi-party facilitation teams should embrace radical openness to disrupt hegemonic and colonized views in YPAR.

ACTION RESEARCH (2023)

Review Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

Teaching Games for Understanding (TGfU) as comprehensive teaching method in physical education: Systematic review of the last 5 years

Omar Ricardo Ortiz Gomez, Oscar Nunez Enriquez, Ramon Candia Lujan, Raul Josue Najera Longoria, Felipe Valenzuela Jurado, Gilberto Santos Sambrano

Summary: Physical education has implemented various pedagogical approaches, including the Teaching Games for Understanding, to improve educational practice. This systematic review focuses on analyzing the use of this approach as a pedagogical tool in physical education classes in Mexico. The results indicate that the Teaching Games for Understanding is an effective and efficient method, predominantly used in developed countries. Combining it with other methods also enhances student participation. This pedagogical tool could be successfully implemented by physical education teachers in Mexico, providing an opportunity for further research and study.

RETOS-NUEVAS TENDENCIAS EN EDUCACION FISICA DEPORTE Y RECREACION (2023)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

Factors that influence in Physical Education in Mexico

Ramon Alfonso Gonzalez Rivas, Azaneth Laguna Celia, Oscar Nunez Enriquez

Summary: Considering the high rates of overweight and obesity in Mexican children and adolescents due to a sedentary lifestyle, physical education (PE) classes have become increasingly important. The Federal Government of Mexico has implemented strategies to improve the quality of PE in recent years. A narrative and critical review was conducted on PE in Mexico, analyzing scientific research articles and government proposals to enhance educational quality from different perspectives. The study identified factors influencing PE, including curricular changes, class schedules, recruitment, infrastructure and resources, teacher involvement, teacher training, and research. Although the efforts of the Federal Government to promote quality PE are relevant, the changes have not yet translated into practical improvements in schools. The importance of ongoing research in PE and the role of teacher training universities are emphasized.

RETOS-NUEVAS TENDENCIAS EN EDUCACION FISICA DEPORTE Y RECREACION (2023)

Review Education & Educational Research

Pedagogies implemented with young people with refugee backgrounds in physical education and sport: a critical review of the literature

Christopher Hudson, Carla Luguetti, Ramon Spaaij

Summary: This review critically examines the pedagogies implemented with young people with refugee backgrounds in physical education and sport, and outlines the directions and challenges for future research. It emphasizes the importance of engaging in dialogue with the young people and moving towards co-designed ways of working in PE and sport.

CURRICULUM STUDIES IN HEALTH AND PHYSICAL EDUCATION (2023)

Article Education & Educational Research

Feminists against fad, fizz ed: a poetic commentary exploring the notion of Joe Wicks as physical education

Karen Lambert, Carla Luguetti, Shrehan Lynch

Summary: This study utilized a poststructural feminist framework to challenge hegemonic reproduction in physical education through collaborative autoethnography, with participants including three female-identified PE teacher educators. Through the collection and presentation of data in poetic forms, the findings were divided into two parts corresponding to responses to two themes, ultimately contributing to advancing scholarship in the field of physical education.

PHYSICAL EDUCATION AND SPORT PEDAGOGY (2022)

Article Education & Educational Research

'The teacher makes us feel like we are a family': students from refugee backgrounds' perceptions of physical education in Swedish schools

Erica Cseplo, Stefan Wagnsson, Carla Luguetti, Ramon Spaaij

Summary: The study found that refugee-background students in Swedish high schools perceive Physical Education (PE) to be more meaningful than in their country of origin, providing both short-term and long-term benefits. Understanding the rules and purpose of activities helped students better comprehend their experiences in PE and communicate with others. Constructive social relationships with teachers and classmates were identified as essential resources to make PE manageable.

PHYSICAL EDUCATION AND SPORT PEDAGOGY (2022)

Article Education & Educational Research

'We united to defend ourselves and face our struggles': nurturing a physical education teachers' community of practice in a precarious context

Luiza Goncalves, Melissa Parker, Carla Luguetti, Michele Carbinatto

Summary: This study explored the development of a democratic Physical Education (PE) Community of Practice (CoP) in a precarious school context in Brazil. The findings showed that through an ongoing and dynamic progression, teachers were able to build their own practice to overcome the marginalization of PE and were supported to exist in a challenging environment.

PHYSICAL EDUCATION AND SPORT PEDAGOGY (2022)

Article Hospitality, Leisure, Sport & Tourism

'Stop mocking, start respecting': an activist approach meets African Australian refugee-background young women in grassroots football

Carla Luguetti, Loy Singehebhuye, Ramon Spaaij

Summary: This study explored the process of co-creating a sports program with young refugee women using an activist approach. The researchers and participants learned the importance of collaboration in sports programs and identified the lack of female representation as a main concern.

QUALITATIVE RESEARCH IN SPORT EXERCISE AND HEALTH (2022)

No Data Available