4.8 Editorial Material

Comment on Plant diversity increases with the strength of negative density dependence at the global scale

Journal

SCIENCE
Volume 360, Issue 6391, Pages -

Publisher

AMER ASSOC ADVANCEMENT SCIENCE
DOI: 10.1126/science.aar4685

Keywords

-

Funding

  1. McDonnell Foundation [220020470]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

LaManna et al. (Reports, 30 June 2017, p. 1389) found higher conspecific negative density dependence in tree communities at lower latitudes, yielding a possible mechanistic explanation for the latitudinal diversity gradient. We show that their results are artifacts of a selective data transformation and a forced zero intercept in their fitted model. A corrected analysis shows no latitudinal trend.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.8
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Quantifying the relative performance of two undetected-extinction models

Deon Lum, Pablo A. Tedesco, Bernard Hugueny, XingLi Giam, Ryan A. Chisholm

Summary: This study compared two models of undetected extinctions in estimating the true number of undetected extinctions, finding that the SEUX model performed better when detection rates were independent of species abundance. Analysis of real-world data sets showed that undetected extinctions may be higher than observed values, with the SEUX model yielding lower absolute estimates compared to the Tedesco model in most cases. The correlation between detection and extinction rates across species in some data sets suggests that the actual biodiversity loss in these groups may be more severe than documented.

CONSERVATION BIOLOGY (2021)

Review Ecology

Is Variation in Conspecific Negative Density Dependence Driving Tree Diversity Patterns at Large Scales?

Lisa Huelsmann, Ryan A. Chisholm, Florian Hartig

Summary: Studies have found evidence of conspecific negative density dependence (CNDD) in local populations, but it remains challenging to assess whether CNDD scales up to control community diversity and affect local and global biodiversity patterns. More robust statistical methods, new study designs, and eco-evolutionary models are needed for a more definite evaluation of the importance of CNDD for geographic variation in plant species diversity.

TRENDS IN ECOLOGY & EVOLUTION (2021)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

ForestGEO: Understanding forest diversity and dynamics through a global observatory network

Stuart J. Davies, Iveren Abiem, Kamariah Abu Salim, Salomon Aguilar, David Allen, Alfonso Alonso, Kristina Anderson-Teixeira, Ana Andrade, Gabriel Arellano, Peter S. Ashton, Patrick J. Baker, Matthew E. Baker, Jennifer L. Baltzer, Yves Basset, Pulcherie Bissiengou, Stephanie Bohlman, Norman A. Bourg, Warren Y. Brockelman, Sarayudh Bunyavejchewin, David F. R. P. Burslem, Min Cao, Dairon Cardenas, Li-Wan Chang, Chia-Hao Chang-Yang, Kuo-Jung Chao, Wei-Chun Chao, Hazel Chapman, Yu-Yun Chen, Ryan A. Chisholm, Chengjin Chu, George Chuyong, Keith Clay, Liza S. Comita, Richard Condit, Susan Cordell, Handanakere S. Dattaraja, Alexandre Adalardo de Oliveira, Jan den Ouden, Matteo Detto, Christopher Dick, Xiaojun Du, Alvaro Duque, Sisira Ediriweera, Erle C. Ellis, Nestor Laurier Engone Obiang, Shameema Esufali, Corneille E. N. Ewango, Edwino S. Fernando, Jonah Filip, Gunter A. Fischer, Robin Foster, Thomas Giambelluca, Christian Giardina, Gregory S. Gilbert, Erika Gonzalez-Akre, I. A. U. N. Gunatilleke, C. V. S. Gunatilleke, Zhanqing Hao, Billy C. H. Hau, Fangliang He, Hongwei Ni, Robert W. Howe, Stephen P. Hubbell, Andreas Huth, Faith Inman-Narahari, Akira Itoh, David Janik, Patrick A. Jansen, Mingxi Jiang, Daniel J. Johnson, F. Andrew Jones, Mamoru Kanzaki, David Kenfack, Somboon Kiratiprayoon, Kamil Kral, Lauren Krizel, Suzanne Lao, Andrew J. Larson, Yide Li, Xiankun Li, Creighton M. Litton, Yu Liu, Shirong Liu, Shawn K. Y. Lum, Matthew S. Luskin, James A. Lutz, Hong Truong Luu, Keping Ma, Jean-Remy Makana, Yadvinder Malhi, Adam Martin, Caly McCarthy, Sean M. McMahon, William J. McShea, Herve Memiaghe, Xiangcheng Mi, David Mitre, Mohizah Mohamad, Logan Monks, Helene C. Muller-Landau, Paul M. Musili, Jonathan A. Myers, Anuttara Nathalang, Kang Min Ngo, Natalia Norden, Vojtech Novotny, Michael J. O'Brien, David Orwig, Rebecca Ostertag, Konstantinos Papathanassiou, Geoffrey G. Parker, Rolando Perez, Ivette Perfecto, Richard P. Phillips, Nantachai Pongpattananurak, Hans Pretzsch, Haibo Ren, Glen Reynolds, Lillian J. Rodriguez, Sabrina E. Russo, Lawren Sack, Weiguo Sang, Jessica Shue, Anudeep Singh, Guo-Zhang M. Song, Raman Sukumar, I-Fang Sun, Hebbalalu S. Suresh, Nathan G. Swenson, Sylvester Tan, Sean C. Thomas, Duncan Thomas, Jill Thompson, Benjamin L. Turner, Amanda Uowolo, Maria Uriarte, Renato Valencia, John Vandermeer, Alberto Vicentini, Marco Visser, Tomas Vrska, Xugao Wang, Xihua Wang, George D. Weiblen, Timothy J. S. Whitfeld, Y. Wolf, S. Joseph Wright, Han Xu, Tze Leong Yao, Sandra L. Yap, Wanhui Ye, Mingjian Yu, Minhua Zhang, Daoguang Zhu, Li Zhu, Jess K. Zimmerman, Daniel Zuleta

Summary: ForestGEO is a network of scientists and long-term forest dynamics plots that aims to advance understanding of forest diversity and dynamics, as well as strengthen global capacity for forest science research. With large-scale plot dimensions, comprehensive censusing, and investigation of various biotic and abiotic drivers, ForestGEO provides a holistic view of forest functioning. Through extensive research, ForestGEO has made significant contributions in areas such as species coexistence and diversity, and ecosystem functioning, while also highlighting the need for further research to predict the impacts of climate change and other stressors on forest diversity and function.

BIOLOGICAL CONSERVATION (2021)

Article Ecology

Adding stage-structure to a spatial neutral model: implications for explaining local and regional patterns of biodiversity

Ryan A. Chisholm, Tak Fung

Summary: Theoretical ecologists introduced a stage-structured neutral model, showing that the presence of a juvenile stage can significantly increase species richness. A case study on tropical forest trees in Panama revealed that while the stage-structured model made different predictions compared to the standard model, it did not solve known cross-scale prediction issues.

OIKOS (2021)

Article Ecology

Bird diversity on shelf islands does not benefit from recent land-bridge connections

Yong Chee Keita Sin, Nadiah P. Kristensen, Chyi Yin Gwee, Ryan A. Chisholm, Frank E. Rheindt

Summary: Research on bird species diversity and composition on tropical shelf islands in Southeast Asia found that post-LGM effects on diversity are minimal, with present-day island characteristics such as area, distance to the mainland, and proportion of land surrounding the island within a 10 km radius being more explanatory. Avifaunal diversity is maintained by high immigration rates, especially on small islands, with over-water dispersal limited to short distances among Sundaic birds.

JOURNAL OF BIOGEOGRAPHY (2022)

Article Ecology

Effects of temporal environmental stochasticity on species richness: a mechanistic unification spanning weak to strong temporal correlations

Tak Fung, James P. O'Dwyer, Ryan A. Chisholm

Summary: The impact of temporal environmental stochasticity (TES) on species coexistence depends on the strength of temporal correlation, with weak correlation creating temporal niches and increasing species richness, while strong correlation intensifying interspecific competition and decreasing species richness. The direct effects of TES on species richness through temporal fluctuations in species abundances were found to be relatively minor compared to these indirect community effects.

OIKOS (2022)

Article Ecology

Examining the generality of the biphasic transition from niche-structured to immigration-structured communities

Ryan A. Chisholm, Tak Fung

Summary: Theoretical and empirical studies suggest that increasing immigration leads to a transition in ecological communities from a niche-structured regime to an immigration-structured regime. Different ecological models predict a biphasic species-area relationship, while a unified model predicts an overall four-phase SAR with a rare shallow niche-structured phase usually observed in mainland SARs because of the immigration-structured regime.

THEORETICAL ECOLOGY (2022)

Article Biology

Downstream resource leakage a necessary condition for the stress-gradient hypothesis in processing chain commensalisms

Hong Jhun Sim, Weng Ngai Lam, Ryan A. Chisholm, Kwek Yan Chong

Summary: This study investigates the stress-gradient hypothesis (SGH) in the context of consumer-resource interactions. The outcomes suggest that the specific algebraic forms of the functional responses do not affect the long-term behavior of the system, and the SGH holds only under specific conditions.

JOURNAL OF THEORETICAL BIOLOGY (2022)

Article Biology

Tracking scientific discovery of avian phylogenetic diversity over 250 years

Deon Lum, Frank E. Rheindt, Ryan A. Chisholm

Summary: This study suggests that the knowledge of the evolutionary history of extant birds is almost complete and there are unlikely to be many highly evolutionarily novel discoveries in the future. The conclusions drawn from studies using avian phylogenies are likely to be robust to future species discoveries.

PROCEEDINGS OF THE ROYAL SOCIETY B-BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES (2022)

Review Ecology

Measuring habitat complexity and spatial heterogeneity in ecology

Lynette H. L. Loke, Ryan A. Chisholm

Summary: This article reviews the methods of measuring complexity in ecology and provides a framework for measuring habitat complexity and spatial heterogeneity. The two most commonly used complexity metrics, fractal dimension and rugosity, are discussed and evaluated using practical examples. The article also discusses informational metrics of complexity and their potential benefits, and outlines the necessary criteria for future research on measuring habitat complexity.

ECOLOGY LETTERS (2022)

Article Ecology

Improving the realism of neutral ecological models by incorporating transient dynamics with temporal changes in community size

Tak Fung, Ryan A. Chisholm

Summary: Neutral models in ecology assume that all species have equal demographic effects and their differences in abundance are mainly determined by demographic stochasticity rather than selection. These models have been found to accurately reproduce static patterns of biodiversity, but they exhibit slow dynamics and poor fits to temporally dynamic patterns of biodiversity.

THEORETICAL POPULATION BIOLOGY (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Ancestral social environments plus nonlinear benefits can explain cooperation in human societies

Nadiah P. Kristensen, Hisashi Ohtsuki, Ryan A. Chisholm

Summary: In this study, a mathematical model is used to explore the origin of human cooperation. The findings suggest that cooperation first evolved through kin selection in ancient humans due to genetic homophily, and continued to persist as social homophily decreased or interactions with strangers became common, explaining the coexistence of cooperators and defectors observed in the human population.

SCIENTIFIC REPORTS (2022)

Editorial Material Ecology

Clarifications on habitat complexity: A response to technical note by Madin et al.

Lynette H. L. Loke, Ryan A. Chisholm

Summary: In their critique, Madin et al. (2023) support the use of fractal dimension in ecology and defend their geometric constraint theory of habitat complexity. We address the flaws in their arguments and clarify their misinterpretation of our statements.

ECOLOGY LETTERS (2023)

Article Forestry

Pioneer tree species accumulate higher neighbourhood diversity than late-successional species in a subtropical forest

Fanhua Kong, Xiaorong Chen, Minhua Zhang, Yu Liu, Sha Jiang, Ryan A. Chisholm, Fangliang He

Summary: A long-standing paradigm in ecology states that species diversity in a community increases over succession. However, there is limited understanding of the accumulation of neighbourhood diversity and its contribution to community diversity. In this study, we investigated the neighbourhood diversity of different functional groups of trees in a forest plot in subtropical China. We found that early successional species played a crucial role in accumulating neighbourhood diversity and contributing to overall plant community diversity. These results highlight the importance of conserving secondary forests, which are predominantly composed of early successional species.

FOREST ECOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT (2023)

Review Ecology

A critical assessment of the biodiversity-productivity relationship in forests and implications for conservation

Ryan A. Chisholm, Tanvi Dutta Gupta

Summary: The question of whether biodiversity conservation and carbon conservation can be synergistic depends on the biodiversity-productivity relationship (BPR), a fundamental ecological pattern. Forests, which contribute greatly to both biodiversity and carbon, have a relatively poor understanding of the BPR. Research shows general support for a positive forest BPR, suggesting synergy between biodiversity and carbon conservation, but there are several major caveats.

OECOLOGIA (2023)

No Data Available