4.6 Article

Tracking residence times in hydrological systems: forward and backward formulations

Journal

HYDROLOGICAL PROCESSES
Volume 29, Issue 25, Pages 5203-5213

Publisher

WILEY-BLACKWELL
DOI: 10.1002/hyp.10513

Keywords

tracer transport; travel time distributions; catchment scale

Funding

  1. SNF-FNS [200021-124930/1, 200021-135241]
  2. Swiss National Science Foundation (SNF) [200021_135241] Funding Source: Swiss National Science Foundation (SNF)

Ask authors/readers for more resources

In recent years, several papers contributed to the development and clarification of key theoretical issues underlying the formulation of transport by travel time distributions in catchments. Such a formulation provides a robust description of the temporal evolution of ages contained in the catchment storage and sampled by the output fluxes. In particular, special attention has been devoted to general time-variant dynamics that are likely to occur in complex systems like catchments. In this context, important theoretical and practical implications arise from a proper distinction between backward and forward age distributions, which are based on the definition of diverse reference variables. The 'age' of a water particle represents the time elapsed since a previous injection, and as such, it is intrinsically a backward time concept. A forward approach, instead, requires the introduction of the particle's 'life expectancy', which quantifies the time a water particle will spend within the system before being sampled by one of the outflows (e.g. stream discharge or evapotranspiration). The sum of age and life expectancy is the particle's travel time. Despite forward and backward approaches being different, and that they only coincide in the special case of stationary systems, a proper distinction of these formulations has been sometimes overlooked in the literature. In this contribution, we review recent backward formulations using a unified notation and discuss a novel forward formulation. This paper illustrates how age and life-expectancy distributions naturally evolve in response to unsteady hydrologic fluxes and presents numerical applications relevant to catchment-scale solute circulation. In both forward and backward formulations, the mixing of ages, which is modelled through age-selection functions, plays a central role in describing the fate of solutes introduced in the system and measured at the system outlets. Copyright (C) 2015 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.6
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Water Resources

Nitrate removal and young stream water fractions at the catchment scale

Paolo Benettin, Ophelie Fovet, Li Li

HYDROLOGICAL PROCESSES (2020)

Article Water Resources

Tree water deficit and dynamic source water partitioning

Magali F. Nehemy, Paolo Benettin, Mitra Asadollahi, Dyan Pratt, Andrea Rinaldo, Jeffrey J. McDonnell

Summary: The study combines isotope data with physiological measurements to investigate the mechanism driving tree water source partitioning. Results show that tree water use is a dynamic process on the time scale of days, primarily determined by plant hydraulic response to changes in soil matric potential.

HYDROLOGICAL PROCESSES (2021)

Article Environmental Sciences

Toward catchment hydro-biogeochemical theories

Li Li, Pamela L. Sullivan, Paolo Benettin, Olaf A. Cirpka, Kevin Bishop, Susan L. Brantley, Julia L. A. Knapp, Ilja van Meerveld, Andrea Rinaldo, Jan Seibert, Hang Wen, James W. Kirchner

Summary: Headwater catchments are fundamental units connecting land and ocean, with hydrological flow and biogeochemical processes intricately linked yet lacking integration in their scientific development. The absence of integrated theories hinders understanding and forecasting the future of the Critical Zone under human and climate-induced perturbations.

WILEY INTERDISCIPLINARY REVIEWS-WATER (2021)

Article Water Resources

On the use of leaf water to determine plant water source: A proof of concept

Paolo Benettin, Magali F. Nehemy, Lucas A. Cernusak, Ansgar Kahmen, Jeffrey J. McDonnell

Summary: Source water apportionment studies using dual isotopes have advanced our understanding of ecohydrology, but technical challenges still exist in linking xylem water to its sources. This study explores the use of leaf water isotopes to quantify rainfall inputs, providing a potentially non-intrusive method for addressing plant water source questions.

HYDROLOGICAL PROCESSES (2021)

Article Environmental Sciences

Tracing and Closing the Water Balance in a Vegetated Lysimeter

Paolo Benettin, Magali F. Nehemy, Mitra Asadollahi, Dyan Pratt, Michael Bensimon, Jeffrey J. McDonnell, Andrea Rinaldo

Summary: Closing the soil water balance is crucial in ecohydrology, but challenges exist in tracing the specific components. Results from a controlled tracer experiment revealed the significant impact of evapotranspiration on the water balance, providing insights into plant uptake and deep percolation.

WATER RESOURCES RESEARCH (2021)

Article Water Resources

Using water age to explore hydrological processes in contrasting environments

Gianluca Botter, Paolo Benettin, Chris Soulsby

HYDROLOGICAL PROCESSES (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

A Note on the Role of Seasonal Expansions and Contractions of the Flowing Fluvial Network on Metapopulation Persistence

J. Giezendanner, P. Benettin, N. Durighetto, G. Botter, A. Rinaldo

Summary: Recent research has shown that the structure of river networks integrates seasonal fluctuations into a nontrivial scaling of metapopulation capacity and total active contributing sites, linking ecological patterns across a river network to clearly identified hydrological and geomorphological factors.

WATER RESOURCES RESEARCH (2021)

Article Ecology

Phloem water isotopically different to xylem water: Potential causes and implications for ecohydrological tracing

Magali F. Nehemy, Paolo Benettin, Scott T. Allen, Kathy Steppe, Andrea Rinaldo, Marco M. Lehmann, Jeffrey J. McDonnell

Summary: The study systematically sampled xylem and phloem water to show that phloem water is significantly less enriched in heavy isotopes than xylem water. The results also revealed a larger isotopic difference between xylem and phloem during phloem water refilling and under periods of tree water deficit. These findings suggest that radial water transport across the xylem-phloem boundary may drive the relative depletion of heavy isotopes in phloem and their relative enrichment in xylem.

ECOHYDROLOGY (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Toward a Closure of Catchment Mass Balance: Insight on the Missing Link From a Vegetated Lysimeter

Mitra Asadollahi, Magali F. Nehemy, Jeffrey J. McDonnell, Andrea Rinaldo, Paolo Benettin

Summary: This study delves into the spatiotemporal origins of water used by plants and contrasts information from soil, drainage, and xylem samples using models. The interplay of advective and dispersive forces was found to drive the age composition of drainage, with vegetation influencing it mainly through diversifying subsurface transport pathways.

WATER RESOURCES RESEARCH (2022)

Review Astronomy & Astrophysics

Instructive Surprises in the Hydrological Functioning of Landscapes

James W. Kirchner, Paolo Benettin, Ilja van Meerveld

Summary: Landscapes play a crucial role in the movement and distribution of water, affecting various natural processes and ecosystems. Recent field observations and measurement methods have challenged our traditional conceptualizations, leading to a shift towards a more dynamic and nonstationary understanding of hydrological processes at different scales.

ANNUAL REVIEW OF EARTH AND PLANETARY SCIENCES (2023)

Review Environmental Sciences

Transit Time Estimation in Catchments: Recent Developments and Future Directions

Paolo Benettin, Nicolas B. Rodriguez, Matthias Sprenger, Minseok Kim, Julian Klaus, Ciaran J. Harman, Ype van der Velde, Markus Hrachowitz, Gianluca Botter, Kevin J. McGuire, James W. Kirchner, Andrea Rinaldo, Jeffrey J. McDonnell

Summary: This study reviews the recent developments in water transit time research, focusing on water-age-balance approaches and data-based approaches. Various methods, including StorAge-Selection functions, well/partially mixed compartments, and direct transit time estimates, are discussed and compared. The study aims to unify the heterogeneity in the literature and highlight the remaining open questions in transit time research.

WATER RESOURCES RESEARCH (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Spatially Explicit Linkages Between Redox Potential Cycles and Soil Moisture Fluctuations

Filippo Miele, Paolo Benettin, Simiao Wang, Ivan Retti, Mitra Asadollahi, Manon Frutschi, Binayak Mohanty, Rizlan Bernier-Latmani, Andrea Rinaldo

Summary: Redox cycles measured through soil redox potential are associated with soil microbial activity. This study investigates the interplay between soil moisture and redox potential dynamics by manipulating hydrologic and geochemical conditions in soil column installations. The findings highlight the importance of understanding joint hydrologic flow/transport and redox processes in predicting redox potential changes and the minimum amount of biogeochemistry needed for characterizing electron donors/acceptors responsible for redox patterns. The study's results improve our understanding of how and where activity hotspots develop within soil microbial communities.

WATER RESOURCES RESEARCH (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Isotope Ratio - Discharge Relationships of Solutes Derived From Weathering Reactions

Jennifer L. Druhan, Paolo Benettin

Summary: To date, most studies on linking discharge to solute concentrations have been based on time-invariant fluid age distributions in watersheds. However, as more detailed spatial and temporal datasets become available, it is crucial to understand the transient routing of reactive fluids in Critical Zone environments for quantitative interpretation. The relationship between fluid age distributions and stable isotope ratios of geogenic solutes is less developed, but it is essential for understanding concentration-discharge relationships. This study presents a novel modeling framework that combines a hydrological model with time-variant fluid age distributions and a geochemical model for isotopically fractionating weathering reactions. The results demonstrate that the stable isotope signatures of riverine solutes produced by weathering reactions reflect a unique component of the fluid age distribution. The modeling framework provides a quantitative basis for interpreting solutes derived from weathering reactions in watersheds subject to time-varying discharge.

AMERICAN JOURNAL OF SCIENCE (2023)

Article Water Resources

Using continuous electrical conductivity measurements to derive major solute concentrations in karst systems

Beatrice Richieri, Daniel Bittner, Andreas Hartmann, Paolo Benettin, Boris M. van Breukelen, David Labat, Gabriele Chiogna

Summary: In this study, a method is developed to retrieve high-temporal-resolution solute concentration time series and their uncertainty for karst springs by using continuous observations of electrical conductivity (EC) and low-frequency ionic measurements. The method considers the complexation processes for the reconstruction of solute concentration time series, and the results show that complexation processes are significant for certain solutes.

HYDROLOGICAL PROCESSES (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Precipitation fate and transport in a Mediterranean catchment through models calibrated on plant and stream water isotope data

Matthias Sprenger, Pilar Llorens, Francesc Gallart, Paolo Benettin, Scott T. Allen, Jerome Latron

Summary: This study investigates the partitioning of precipitation in the Can Vila catchment using stable isotopes, and quantifies the dynamics of water evapotranspiration and streamflow. The results show that the multi-objective calibration approach can accurately simulate the isotope ratios of both stream water and xylem water. The findings support recent ecohydrological studies that highlight the heterogeneity of water storage and fluxes, as well as the use of relatively old water by trees.

HYDROLOGY AND EARTH SYSTEM SCIENCES (2022)

No Data Available