4.3 Article

Progressive Collapse Analysis of Multistory Moment Frames with Varying Mechanisms

Journal

Publisher

ASCE-AMER SOC CIVIL ENGINEERS
DOI: 10.1061/(ASCE)CF.1943-5509.0001192

Keywords

Progressive collapse; Multistory frame structure; Beam mechanism; Catenary mechanism; Vierendeel mechanism

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Multistory frame structures are generally simplified as single-story substructures to study their progressive-collapse resistance. In this study, a single-story substructure was investigated, and its behavior was applied to multistory frame analyses. However, by omitting the effect of the Vierendeel mechanism, the present simplified model could not completely reflect the mechanical behaviors of the entire structure. Based on the double-span beam model, the collapse mechanisms of the single-story substructure was investigated and a resistance calculation method for the beam and catenary mechanisms was proposed. To analyze the effect of the Vierendeel mechanism on the overall behavior of multistory frames, a top-story substructure model was established for the middle-column removal scenario, and the entire failed span was selected for corner-column removal. The contribution index of the Vierendeel mechanism against the progressive collapse was introduced. Then, a two-dimensional (2D) steel frame with four spans and four stories was considered as an example to discuss the force redistribution after middle- and corner-column removal and to verify the validity of the mechanisms mentioned. Incorporating the models, the process of demolishing four columns of the Ohio Union building was simulated. The results showed that the simplified models were reasonable. The top and bottom stories of the multistory frame showed different anticollapse mechanisms, and the Vierendeel mechanism together with other mechanisms resisted the unbalanced load. Furthermore, it was determined that the Ohio Union building has reasonable resistance to progressive collapse.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.3
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Construction & Building Technology

Progressive Collapse Analysis for Steel-Braced Frames Considering Vierendeel Action

Huiyun Qiao, Caisong Lu, Jianpeng Wei, Yu Chen

JOURNAL OF PERFORMANCE OF CONSTRUCTED FACILITIES (2020)

Article Engineering, Civil

Progressive collapse behavior of joints in steel moment frames involving reduced beam section

Canwen Chen, Huiyun Qiao, Jinpeng Wang, Yu Chen

ENGINEERING STRUCTURES (2020)

Article Engineering, Civil

Anti-collapse performance of steel frames with RWS connections under a column removal scenario

Shentong Lin, Huiyun Qiao, Jinpeng Wang, Jiahao Shi, Yu Chen

Summary: This paper investigates the anti-collapse performance of moment resisting frames with reduced-web-section connections under critical column removal scenario. Experimental results show that specimens with openings can develop better deformability and rotational capacities when the dimensions and location parameters of the opening are controlled within a suitable range.

ENGINEERING STRUCTURES (2021)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Experimental study on beam-to-column connections with reduced beam section against progressive collapse

Huiyun Qiao, Yu Chen, Jinpeng Wang, Canwen Chen

JOURNAL OF CONSTRUCTIONAL STEEL RESEARCH (2020)

Article Engineering, Civil

Behaviour of stub columns with initial crack defects under axial compression

Huiyun Qiao, Jiahui Pan, Yu Chen, Jike Pan

Summary: An experimental investigation was conducted to evaluate the axial compressive behavior of circular hollow section (CHS) stub columns with initial crack defects. The study found that initial cracks accelerated local buckling and changed both the bearing capacity and deformation capacity of the columns. The ultimate loads of the stub columns increased with the tube thickness, slightly decreased with an increase in the long crack length, and decreased with an increase in crack spacing.

THIN-WALLED STRUCTURES (2021)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Numerical study of the seismic performance of a double-hinge steel frame joint

Jian-peng Wei, Li-min Tian, Yang Guo, Hui-yun Qiao, Yu Bao, Zhi-an Jiao, Xiao-jun Shi

Summary: A novel double-hinge steel frame joint was developed in this study, with validated finite element analysis proving its reasonable design and good seismic performance. Simulation results showed that the novel double-hinge joint in steel frame structures has better energy dissipation and seismic performance.

JOURNAL OF CONSTRUCTIONAL STEEL RESEARCH (2021)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Performance of Steel Frames with Different Web Bolt Number and Arrangements in a Column-Loss Scenario

Shentong Lin, Jinpeng Wang, Huiyun Qiao, Yu Chen, Yang Zhou

Summary: This study investigated the impact of different bolt arrangements on the anti-collapse performance of double half-span assemblies, and found that increasing the number of bolt rows is an effective approach to enhancing the connections' resistance to collapse.

JOURNAL OF STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING (2021)

Article Engineering, Civil

Experimental investigation on square steel tubular columns with initial crack defects

Huiyun Qiao, Mingfeng Zhang, Zhongcun Liu, Yu Chen, Huasheng Qiu, Zheng Wang

Summary: The research found that initial cracks accelerated local buckling and affected the bearing and deformation capacities of SST columns. The ultimate load of steel tubes increased with an increase in tube thickness and slightly decreased with an increase in crack length. Additionally, the effects of crack number and spacing on bearing capacity were complex and had a coupling relationship with tube thickness.

STRUCTURES (2022)

Article Engineering, Civil

Experimental investigation of a substructure in a frame with castellated steel beams in case of a column loss

Huiyun Qiao, Zhuangzhuang Guo, Yu Chen

Summary: This paper presents experimental and numerical investigations of a substructure with castellated steel beams under a column removal scenario. The results provide important insights into improving the resistance of steel structures against progressive collapse.

ENGINEERING STRUCTURES (2022)

Article Engineering, Civil

Improvement of progressive collapse resistance for a steel frame system with beam-web opening

Huiyun Qiao, Xinyu Xie, Yu Chen

Summary: This study proposes a novel principle of using web openings and kinked reinforced bars to improve the preventive strategies for frame structures. Experimental and numerical investigations evaluate the factors affecting the kinked reinforced bars and their roles in the frame structures. The results indicate the importance of kinked reinforced bars in catenary action and suggest selecting the kinked height based on the deformation capacity of the beam.

ENGINEERING STRUCTURES (2022)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Prediction model for catenary action of welded RWS connections using PVM link element

Shentong Lin, Xiaolei Xue, Huiyun Qiao, Yu Chen

Summary: In this study, a link element model incorporating a nonlinear PVM yield function was established to investigate the static response of idealized beams with reduced web section under column loss. The model can predict the load-displacement relationship before failure and analyze the internal force evolution of web opening beams.

JOURNAL OF CONSTRUCTIONAL STEEL RESEARCH (2022)

Article Construction & Building Technology

A novel principle for improving collapse resistance of steel frame structures

Huiyun Qiao, Jian Xia, Yu Chen, Canwen Chen, Juhuan Zheng

Summary: A novel principle is proposed to improve the performance of RBS connections by installing kinked reinforced bars. Experimental and numerical investigations show that the kinked reinforced bars can be effective in RBS connections, and their performance can be adjusted based on the diameter, kinked height, and length of the reinforced bars.

JOURNAL OF CONSTRUCTIONAL STEEL RESEARCH (2022)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Seismic performance of a double-hinge steel frame joint with replaceable T-shape energy dissipator

Jian-peng Wei, Li-min Tian, Yang Guo, Hui-yun Qiao, Zhi-an Jiao, Yu Bao

Summary: This study investigated a double-hinge steel frame joint with a replaceable T-shape energy dissipator through testing and finite element analysis. The seismic performance of the joint was verified to be better than a traditional welded joint, and the accuracy and reliability of the earthquake-resilient design were demonstrated. The energy dissipators had a high energy dissipation efficiency, and the earthquake-resilient function was validated. The low weight of the joint was determined through validated finite element analysis, improving the application of this novel earthquake-resilient joint.

JOURNAL OF CONSTRUCTIONAL STEEL RESEARCH (2022)

Article Engineering, Civil

Study on anti-progressive collapse performance of cellular steel frames with different web opening shapes

Han Zheng, Huiyun Qiao, Yu Chen, Bo Yang, Bin Zhu, Lifang Lai

Summary: This paper investigates the resistance to progressive collapse of weakened beam-column joints through experiments and numerical simulations on cellular joints with different opening shapes. The results show that the load carrying capacity and deformation capacity of cellular joints have different degrees of improvement compared to traditional joints, with hexagonal openings exhibiting the best performance. Changing the opening weakening parameters can effectively improve the failure mode and load carrying capacity of the specimens. It is recommended to increase the values of parameters a and c and reduce the value of parameter b in the design of collapse resistance.

STRUCTURES (2023)

Article Engineering, Civil

Progressive collapse behavior of beam-to-column connections involving flange openings

Huiyun Qiao, Xinyu Xie, Juhuan Zheng, Zhiquan Xing, Yu Chen, Jianpeng Wei

Summary: This study developed a new principle of beam-to-column connections, which improved the ductility of the structure and enhanced the seismic performance of steel-frame structures by arranging openings at the beam flange to form a flange-opening section (FO).

ENGINEERING STRUCTURES (2023)

No Data Available