Article
Neurosciences
Lewis S. Crawford, Emily P. Mills, Theo Hanson, Paul M. Macey, Rebecca Glarin, Vaughan G. Macefield, Kevin A. Keay, Luke A. Henderson
Summary: Perception of pain can be influenced by expectations and beliefs. This study used ultra-high-field fMRI to investigate the brainstem pathways involved in placebo analgesia and nocebo hyperalgesia, revealing differential activation of key pain modulatory nuclei during these phenomena.
JOURNAL OF NEUROSCIENCE
(2021)
Article
Behavioral Sciences
Yu Shi, Shaoye Cui, Yanyan Zeng, Shimin Huang, Guiyuan Cai, Jianming Yang, Wen Wu
Summary: This study investigated nocebo hyperalgesia and placebo analgesia responses in an acute lower back pain model using multivariate Granger causality analysis. The results suggest that placebo mainly works by activating the reward system and inhibiting pain-related network, while nocebo works in the opposite way. The study also found that the two networks share some brain regions but also have unique structural features.
FRONTIERS IN BEHAVIORAL NEUROSCIENCE
(2021)
Article
Pharmacology & Pharmacy
Fabrizio Benedetti, Martina Amanzio, Fabio Giovannelli, Karen Craigs-Brackhahn, Aziz Shaibani
Summary: This study revealed that participants who read a list of possible adverse events before receiving a placebo treatment reported more adverse events compared to those who did not read the list. Moreover, increased activity in the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis and higher state anxiety scores were observed in those who reported multiple adverse events, indicating a potential neuroendocrine mechanism following placebo administration.
CLINICAL PHARMACOLOGY & THERAPEUTICS
(2021)
Article
Neurosciences
Junjun Fu, Shuyi Wu, Cuizhen Liu, Julia A. Camilleri, Simon B. Eickhoff, Rongjun Yu
Summary: A meta-analysis comparing neural representations of placebo analgesia and nocebo hyperalgesia processes revealed distinct brain networks underlying these two phenomena, suggesting they may operate via different neuropsychological processes.
Article
Multidisciplinary Sciences
Mia A. Thomaidou, Joseph S. Blythe, Dieuwke S. Veldhuijzen, Kaya J. Peerdeman, Johan (Hans) P. A. van Lennep, Erik J. Giltay, Henk R. Cremers, Andrea W. M. Evers
Summary: This study examined the impact of targeted pharmacological manipulation on nocebo responses and their brain correlates. The results showed that learning and negative outcome expectations can increase pain sensitivity, and nocebo hyperalgesia involves integrative cognitive-emotional processes.
SCIENTIFIC REPORTS
(2022)
Review
Anesthesiology
Stefanie H. Meeuwis, Mateusz T. Wasylewski, Elzbieta A. Bajcar, Helena Bieniek, Waclaw M. Adamczyk, Sofiia Honcharova, Marianna Di Nardo, Giuliana Mazzoni, Przemyslaw Babel
Summary: Observational learning has an impact on placebo hypoalgesia and nocebo hyperalgesia, and can be used to optimize treatment of chronic pain conditions. The type of observation and the observer's empathic concern modulate this impact.
Review
Medicine, General & Internal
Morton E. Tavel
Summary: The placebo effect refers to improvements in illnesses or subjective symptom reduction caused by interventions with no known physical effects, while the nocebo effect refers to undesirable symptoms or illnesses following interventions with no known physical effects, and it may play a role in chronic illnesses without objective confirmation. Both placebo and nocebo effects are powerful and must be understood by practitioners and researchers in clinical medicine. Individual caregivers can apply these principles to modify patient care outcomes.
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF MEDICINE
(2022)
Article
Behavioral Sciences
Shari A. Steinman, Joseph E. Dunsmoor, Zhamilya Gazman, Yael Stovezky, Olivia Pascucci, Justin Pomerenke, Elizabeth A. Phelps, Abby Fyer, H. Blair Simpson
Summary: Studies show that replacing the expected threat with a novel outcome is more effective in reducing the return of conditioned fear in individuals with pathological anxiety compared to threat omission alone. However, this preliminary test did not find that novelty facilitated extinction.
FRONTIERS IN BEHAVIORAL NEUROSCIENCE
(2022)
Article
Neurosciences
Paul Siegel, Barry Cohen, Richard Warren
Summary: Unconscious exposure therapy reduces fear by generating new implicit learning of nonaversive, stimulus-response associations that facilitate fear extinction in phobic persons.
BIOLOGICAL PSYCHIATRY
(2022)
Article
Psychology, Multidisciplinary
Carina Schlintl, Anne Schienle
Summary: The study showed that written information can influence the occurrence of reported placebo/nocebo side effects. Additionally, information about the provider's optimistic personality was associated with a lower frequency of reported adverse side effects.
FRONTIERS IN PSYCHOLOGY
(2021)
Article
Clinical Neurology
B. Colagiuri, J. Park, K. Barnes, L. Sharpe, R. A. Boakes, L. Colloca, E. J. Livesey
Summary: The study discovered that pre-exposing treatment cues without pain, rather than overshadowing them with other cues, has the ability to inhibit conditioned nocebo hyperalgesia, providing a potentially effective preventive strategy.
Article
Chemistry, Multidisciplinary
Yair Sharav, Yaron Haviv, Michael Tal
Summary: The purpose of this study was to investigate the effects of placebo and nocebo under hypnotic analgesia in lowly and highly hypnotizable subjects. Placebo and nocebo effects were studied through verbal expectation and conditioning in 12 lowly and 12 highly hypnotizable subjects under hypnosis. The results showed that placebo-produced analgesia differed significantly from nocebo-produced hyperalgesia in lowly hypnotizable subjects. However, no difference was detected between placebo and nocebo effects in highly hypnotizable subjects. The study suggests that combining placebo intervention with hypnotic analgesia can significantly improve pain relief regardless of hypnotic susceptibility.
APPLIED SCIENCES-BASEL
(2023)
Article
Neurosciences
Elan A. Cohen, Howard H. Hassman, Larry Ereshefsky, David P. Walling, Vera M. Grindell, Richard S. E. Keefe, Katarzyna Wyka, William P. Horan
Summary: The high and growing placebo response rates in clinical trials for CNS indications present a major challenge for drug development. This study found that educating participants about placebo response factors through the Placebo-Control Reminder Script (PCRS) can help mitigate placebo response rates and reduce the number of adverse events.
NEUROPSYCHOPHARMACOLOGY
(2021)
Review
Physiology
Susanne Fischer, Florence Haas, Jana Strahler
Summary: The study aimed to investigate alterations in thermosensory/thermoregulatory system in individuals with anxiety disorders. Results showed no changes in thermosensation in specific phobia, while individuals with social anxiety and panic disorder may exhibit altered vasodilation and sweating. Longitudinal research is needed to explore whether these changes represent vulnerability to anxiety/panic.
FRONTIERS IN PHYSIOLOGY
(2021)
Review
Neurosciences
Mia A. Thomaidou, Kaya J. Peerdeman, Melissa I. Koppeschaar, Andrea W. M. Evers, Dieuwke S. Veldhuijzen
Summary: This comprehensive review summarizes and interprets the neurobiological correlates of nocebo hyperalgesia in healthy humans, shedding light on the involvement of cognitive-affective and physiological processes in pain modulation and calling for more consistency and replication studies. The findings point towards the complexity of nocebo effects on pain perception and emphasize the need for further research to understand the mechanisms through which these effects exacerbate pain. Despite methodological differences and inconsistent results, these studies provide key insights into the neurobiological processes involved in nocebo hyperalgesia.
FRONTIERS IN NEUROSCIENCE
(2021)
Article
Anesthesiology
Jonathan N. Davies, Louise Sharpe, Melissa A. Day, Ben Colagiuri
Summary: Recent studies suggest that placebo effects contribute to acute pain relief after mindfulness interventions. However, the specific effects of mindfulness processes and their interaction with placebo effects are still unclear. This study aimed to examine the role of mindfulness and placebo processes in mindfulness-based pain attenuation.
Review
Psychiatry
Amelia J. Scott, Louise Sharpe, Ben Colagiuri
Summary: The study found that there is little reporting on blinding in RCTs of antidepressants, with a high rate of blinding failure. Pharmaceutical company sponsorship predicted the assessment of blinding in trials, with unsponsored trials more likely to evaluate blinding.
PSYCHIATRY RESEARCH
(2022)
Letter
Psychiatry
Andrew L. Geers, Kelly S. Clemens, Kate Faasse, Ben Colagiuri, Rebecca Webster, Lene Vase, Mette Sieg, Emily Jason, Luana Colloca
PSYCHOTHERAPY AND PSYCHOSOMATICS
(2022)
Article
Environmental Sciences
Julie Y. L. Chow, Ben Colagiuri, Benjamin M. Rottman, Micah Goldwater, Evan J. Livesey
Summary: The study found that causal beliefs are related to perceived cause-effect contingency, and unvalidated health beliefs may also be influenced by the subjective perception of meaningful contingency between events, highlighting the heterogeneity in health beliefs and the importance of tailoring intervention strategies according to underlying causes.
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH AND PUBLIC HEALTH
(2021)
Review
Psychiatry
Amelia J. Scott, Louise Sharpe, Veronica Quinn, Ben Colagiuri
Summary: This study examined the association of single-blind placebo run-in periods with placebo response, drug response, and drug-placebo difference in randomized clinical trials of antidepressants. Results showed that trials using PRI periods had smaller placebo and drug responses, but no significant difference in drug-placebo difference. The study suggests that the practice of using PRI periods should be ceased due to lack of benefits in RCT outcomes.
Review
Psychology, Multidisciplinary
Biya Tang, Kirsten Barnes, Andrew Geers, Evan Livesey, Ben Colagiuri
Summary: Making a treatment choice can effectively enhance the placebo effect, especially in contexts where placebo effects without choice are weaker.
ANNALS OF BEHAVIORAL MEDICINE
(2022)
Article
Psychology, Clinical
Suzanne G. Helfer, Ben Colagiuri, Kate Faasse, Kelly S. Clemens, Fawn Caplandies, Andrew L. Geers
Summary: Attribute framing is a method that can be used ethically to reduce adverse nocebo effects, however, previous studies have shown inconsistent results. This study used a sham tDCS procedure to induce nocebo headaches and explored factors that may contribute to the efficacy of attribute framing. The results showed that attribute framing did not influence headache measures during the sham tDCS task, but did have a modest influence on post-task headache items. It is suggested that attribute framing may have a stronger influence on delayed nocebo effect measures or retrospective symptom reports.
JOURNAL OF BEHAVIORAL MEDICINE
(2022)
Letter
Psychiatry
Amelia J. Scott, Louise Sharpe, Ben Colagiuri
Article
Psychology, Multidisciplinary
Andrew L. Geers, Kelly S. Clemens, Ben Colagiuri, Emily Jason, Luana Colloca, Rebecca Webster, Lene Vase, Mette Seig, Kate Faasse
Summary: The aim of this study was to examine whether side effects of the primary COVID-19 vaccine are associated with a decrease in intentions to receive a COVID-19 booster, as well as to identify psychological and demographic factors that predict booster intentions. The results showed that intentions for a booster vaccination were high and not correlated with the side effects of the primary vaccine. Positive vaccination attitudes, trust in vaccine development, worry about the COVID-19 pandemic, low concern over vaccine side effects, and affiliation with the democratic political party were predictors of booster intentions.
ANNALS OF BEHAVIORAL MEDICINE
(2022)
Article
Immunology
Kirsten Barnes, Ben Colagiuri
Summary: This study compared the effects of positive and negative framing on COVID-19 vaccination intentions and found that positive framing was effective in increasing intentions for receiving less familiar vaccines. However, standard negative framing appeared to increase intentions for familiar vaccines. These findings provide important evidence for the use of positive framing to improve vaccine uptake for less familiar vaccines, but caution is needed when using positive framing for familiar vaccines.
Article
Medicine, General & Internal
Dean J. Wright, Ben Colagiuri, Nick Glozier
Summary: Psychiatrists showed more hesitancy towards trials of MDMA-AP compared to psychologists and researchers in Australia. Experienced mental health professionals were more likely to have negative views about MDMA-AP trials.
Article
Anesthesiology
Jonathan N. Davies, Ben Colagiuri, Louise Sharpe, Melissa A. Day
Summary: This study compared the effects of mindfulness and sham treatments on chronic pain, and found that improvements in pain unpleasantness may be driven by placebo effects rather than mindfulness-specific processes. These findings suggest that further research is needed to understand if mindfulness-specific effects emerge after longer durations of online training.
Article
Psychology, Multidisciplinary
Winston Tan, Brydee Pickup, Kate Faasse, Ben Colagiuri, Kirsten Barnes
Summary: This study explores the possibility of symptom transmission through a three-generation social chain in an online setting, and the results demonstrate that symptoms can be readily transmitted online and are influenced by expectancy and anxiety. Social learning plays a significant role in symptom transmission, and observing others' experiences can provide individuals with insights into their own future experiences.
ANNALS OF BEHAVIORAL MEDICINE
(2023)
Article
Psychology, Multidisciplinary
Cosette Saunders, Ben Colagiuri, Kirsten Barnes
Summary: Socially acquired nocebo effects can spread to similar but distinct interventions, causing a significant impact on our experiences. However, having a choice does not reduce the negative effects observed, indicating the need for alternative methods to counteract the influence of social learning.
ANNALS OF BEHAVIORAL MEDICINE
(2023)
Article
Psychology, Social
Andrew L. Geers, Kate Faasse, Darwin A. Guevarra, Kelly S. Clemens, Suzanne G. Helfer, Ben Colagiuri
Summary: The paper reviews the empirical data linking affective states to placebo and nocebo effects, addressing three key questions regarding the modulation of affect in these effects, the influence of administering placebo and nocebo treatments on affective states, and the potential use of placebo treatments to regulate different affective states. The evidence suggests that affect plays a key role in placebo and nocebo effects, indicating a reciprocal dynamic between treatment events, affect, and placebo/nocebo effects.
SOCIAL AND PERSONALITY PSYCHOLOGY COMPASS
(2021)