4.5 Article

Collaboration as a process and an outcome: Consumer experiences of collaborating with nurses in care planning in an acute inpatient mental health unit

Journal

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF MENTAL HEALTH NURSING
Volume 27, Issue 4, Pages 1204-1211

Publisher

WILEY
DOI: 10.1111/inm.12463

Keywords

care plan; collaboration; consumer experience; recovery

Ask authors/readers for more resources

This qualitative study explores inpatient mental health consumer perceptions of how collaborative care planning with mental health nurses impacts personal recovery. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with consumers close to discharge from one unit in Sydney, Australia. The unit had been undertaking a collaborative care planning project which encouraged nurses to use care plan documentation to promote person-centred and goal-focussed interactions and the development of meaningful strategies to aid consumer recovery. The interviews explored consumer understandings of the collaborative care planning process, perceptions of the utility of the care plan document and the process of collaborating with the nurses, and their perception of the impact of collaboration on their recovery. Findings are presented under four organizing themes: the process of collaborating, the purpose of collaborating, the nurse as collaborator and the role of collaboration in wider care and recovery. Consumers highlighted the importance of the process of developing their care plan with a nurse as being as helpful for recovery as the goals and strategies themselves. The findings provide insights into consumers' experiences of care planning in an acute inpatient unit, the components of care that support recovery and highlight specific areas for mental health nursing practice improvement in collaboration.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Psychiatry

Does a community based recovery service reduce inpatient bed days?

Sophie Isobel, Margaret Thomas, Helen Boardman, Paul Clenaghan

Summary: By examining the impact of community-based step up/step down (SUSD) care on hospital usage, it was found that there was a decrease in inpatient bed days in the 12 months following admission, although this was not statistically significant. Further consideration is needed to determine whether reducing inpatient bed days is an appropriate outcome measure for services based on principles of personal recovery.

AUSTRALASIAN PSYCHIATRY (2021)

Article Psychiatry

Clinician stakeholder experiences of a new youth mental health model in Australia: A qualitative study

Louise Nash, Sophie Isobel, Margaret Thomas, Thao Nguyen, Renae van Der Pol

Summary: The study shows that clinicians value the services provided by the headspace Early Intervention Teams (hEIT), but there are also challenges such as referral confusion and staff turnover. Suggestions to increase staffing to improve the stability, skill diversity, and viability of the service have been made.

EARLY INTERVENTION IN PSYCHIATRY (2021)

Article Nursing

'What would a trauma-informed mental health service look like?' Perspectives of people who access services

Sophie Isobel, Allyson Wilson, Katherine Gill, Deborah Howe

Summary: The findings of this study illustrate that consumers and family members in Australian mental health services believe that trauma-informed care requires mental health staff to have a greater understanding of trauma, provide opportunities for collaboration, establish trust and safety, offer diverse models of care, and ensure consistency and continuity of care.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF MENTAL HEALTH NURSING (2021)

Article Psychiatry

Bridging the gap: A new integrated early intervention service for young people with complex mental health issues

Caitlin White, Louise Nash, Aspasia Karageorge, Renae van der Pol, Glenn E. Hunt, Blake Hamilton, Sophie Isobel

Summary: In 2017, two integrated headspace Early Intervention Teams (hEITs) were established to bridge gaps between headspace and state funded mental health services in Australia. A retrospective file audit for patients accepted into the service over a 6-month period in 2018 showed common presentations of depression/anxiety, trauma and stress related, and psychotic disorders, with significant improvements in functioning observed in young people during their time in the service.

EARLY INTERVENTION IN PSYCHIATRY (2022)

Article Psychiatry

The 'trauma' of trauma-informed care

Sophie Isobel

Summary: To provide 'trauma-informed care', mental health services need to reflect on the challenges posed by this movement, including re-evaluating the concept of trauma and engaging in further debate.

AUSTRALASIAN PSYCHIATRY (2021)

Article Psychiatry

Is trauma informed care possible in the current public mental health system?

Sophie Isobel

Summary: This paper discusses the challenges of integrating trauma-informed care into the current public mental health system, highlighting the lack of clarity about expectations as a potential barrier. It suggests transparent and ongoing debate to ensure the system meets the needs of those who require it.

AUSTRALASIAN PSYCHIATRY (2021)

Article Nursing

Towards epistemic justice doing: Examining the experiences and shifts in knowledge of lived experience researchers over the course of a mental health research training programme

Brett Bellingham, Holly Kemp, Katherine Boydell, Sophie Isobel, Katherine Gill, Jo River

Summary: The participation of people with lived experience is crucial for improving mental health research and achieving healthcare reform, but challenges such as lack of training and marginalized experiences need to be addressed. A qualitative study on a co-produced research training program found that participants gained a deeper understanding of the role and value of lived experience in research, but also highlighted the need for improvements in navigating challenges and empowering participants.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF MENTAL HEALTH NURSING (2021)

Article Nursing

Trauma-informed qualitative research: Some methodological and practical considerations

Sophie Isobel

Summary: It is important for mental health nurses to be aware of and sensitive to trauma when conducting research on sensitive topics. Recommendations include training and structural supports, collaborative research designs, consideration of environments, awareness of approaches to distress, and inclusion of trauma sensitivity in research policies, frameworks, and leadership. Awareness and sensitivity to trauma are essential for maintaining ongoing awareness and ensuring psychological safety.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF MENTAL HEALTH NURSING (2021)

Review Nursing

Vicarious trauma and nursing: An integrative review

Sophie Isobel, Margaret Thomas

Summary: This integrative review explores the concept of vicarious trauma and its implications for nursing, highlighting the significant impact it can have on nurses personally and professionally. Recommended approaches at individual, team, organizational, and social levels include awareness, prevention, self-care, education, screening, and access to clinical supervision and peer support. Recognizing vicarious trauma as a likely 'cost' of delivering compassionate care to trauma survivors is essential in today's healthcare environment.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF MENTAL HEALTH NURSING (2022)

Book Review Psychology, Clinical

Complex trauma: the Tavistock model. A review

Sophie Isobel

JOURNAL OF MENTAL HEALTH (2022)

Review Psychiatry

Trauma-informed training and education for professionals in Australia: a scoping review

Kimie Maree McNaughton, Sophie Isobel, Liam Phelan, Emma Quilty

Summary: Trauma-informed care and practice (TICP) has been gaining international attention since the mid-1990s, but its recent adoption in Australia faces barriers such as a lack of training and education opportunities. Studies in Australia have shown that TICP training is mainly focused on the healthcare sector for nursing professionals, improving knowledge, confidence, and approaches to care. Training is commonly delivered through one-day workshops and brief web-based approaches, signaling a need for consensus on TICP content and ongoing commitment from stakeholders and funding bodies.

JOURNAL OF MENTAL HEALTH TRAINING EDUCATION AND PRACTICE (2022)

Article Social Work

Considering the moral implications of psychiatric diagnosis for children

Sophie Isobel

Summary: An increasing number of children are being diagnosed with psychiatric disorders, which have both short-term and long-term impacts on their lives and self-understanding. This paper critically examines the moral implications of psychiatric diagnoses for children, including the uncertainties surrounding accuracy, treatment efficacy, and long-term effects. It also explores the challenges in identifying, diagnosing, and treating childhood mental illness, and emphasizes the importance of child agency, rights, and the need for alternative ways of addressing child distress. The author argues for questioning and critiquing systems of psychiatric diagnosis for children and promoting social and political responsibilities to prevent childhood adversity.

CHILDREN & SOCIETY (2023)

Review Nursing

Trauma and the perinatal period: A review of the theory and practice of trauma-sensitive interactions for nurses and midwives

Sophie Isobel

Summary: This paper explores the relationship between trauma and the perinatal period, presents elements of trauma-sensitive practice in the perinatal period, and emphasizes the importance of nurses and midwives understanding the dynamics of trauma in relation to pregnancy, birth, early parenting, and distress for effective care delivery.

NURSING OPEN (2023)

Article Social Sciences, Interdisciplinary

Raising the Bar: A Qualitative Study of a Co-Produced Model for Promoting research Partnerships in Mental Health

Jo River, Brett Bellingham, Sophie Isobel, Katherine Gill, Katherine Boydell, Liam Conlon, Mark Goodhew, Natalie Cutler, Holly Kemp

Summary: Internationally, there is increasing emphasis on the need for high-level research participation in mental health. However, evidence suggests that people with lived experience are often recruited as subjects rather than active agents in research, or are tokenistically consulted. Participatory research has the potential to rectify these disparities, but few studies have addressed the transition from exclusion and tokenism to high-level research participation. This paper presents a qualitative co-evaluation of a co-produced model of research partnership, Raising the Bar, which established and facilitated six participatory research teams, comprising lived experience and traditional mental health researchers. The findings indicate that the model set high standards and enabled research teams to address inconsistencies in knowledge about participation. It also equipped researchers with the skills and resources for participatory research and challenged traditional research outputs to make research accessible to affected communities. However, systemic barriers to participatory research remain and must be acknowledged and addressed to promote a culture of high-level research participation.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF QUALITATIVE METHODS (2023)

Article Psychiatry

'I feel like I have a voice': promoting mental health among Australian high school students through public speaking

Sophie Isobel, Danielle Pretty, Felicity Meehan, Nicole Smith

Summary: This study explored the experience of student and teacher participants in a mental health public speaking challenge, finding that it benefits students by reducing stigma and boosting confidence in supporting peers. Teachers highlighted the commitment and preparation required for the challenge, but also its benefits for individuals and schools in embedding mental health literacy into education.

ADVANCES IN MENTAL HEALTH (2021)

No Data Available