4.5 Article

On the evaluation of methods for the recovery of plant root systems from X-ray computed tomography images

Journal

FUNCTIONAL PLANT BIOLOGY
Volume 42, Issue 5, Pages 460-470

Publisher

CSIRO PUBLISHING
DOI: 10.1071/FP14071

Keywords

root architecture; root image analysis; segmentation

Categories

Funding

  1. Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC)
  2. Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council Centre for Integrative Systems Biology program funding
  3. European Research Council
  4. BBSRC
  5. Belgian Science Policy Office [IAP7/29]
  6. Royal Society Wolfson Research Merit Award
  7. EU project EURoot: Enhancing Resource Uptake from Roots under Stress in Cereal Crops [FP7-KBBE-2011-5]
  8. BBSRC [BB/L026848/1, BB/G023972/1] Funding Source: UKRI
  9. Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council [BB/L026848/1, BB/G023972/1] Funding Source: researchfish

Ask authors/readers for more resources

X-ray microcomputed tomography (mu CT) allows nondestructive visualisation of plant root systems within their soil environment and thus offers an alternative to the commonly used destructive methodologies for the examination of plant roots and their interaction with the surrounding soil. Various methods for the recovery of root system information from X-ray computed tomography (CT) image data have been presented in the literature. Detailed, ideally quantitative, evaluation is essential, in order to determine the accuracy and limitations of the proposed methods, and to allow potential users to make informed choices among them. This, however, is a complicated task. Three-dimensional ground truth data are expensive to produce and the complexity of X-ray CT data means that manually generated ground truth may not be definitive. Similarly, artificially generated data are not entirely representative of real samples. The aims of this work are to raise awareness of the evaluation problem and to propose experimental approaches that allow the performance of root extraction methods to be assessed, ultimately improving the techniques available. To illustrate the issues, tests are conducted using both artificially generated images and real data samples.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Agronomy

A European perspective on opportunities and demands for field-based crop phenotyping

Merlijn Morisse, Darren M. Wells, Emilie J. Millet, Morten Lillemo, Sven Fahrner, Francesco Cellini, Peter Lootens, Onno Muller, Juan M. Herrera, Alison R. Bentley, Michela Janni

Summary: To address the challenges of future food security, innovative technologies are needed to accelerate crop production. Plant phenotyping methods have advanced significantly, and field-based phenotyping plays a crucial role in capturing plant responses to the environment for breeding and selection requirements.

FIELD CROPS RESEARCH (2022)

Article Plant Sciences

Dual expression and anatomy lines allow simultaneous visualization of gene expression and anatomy

Britta M. C. Kumpers, Jingyi Han, John Vaughan-Hirsch, Nicholas Redman, Alexander Ware, Jonathan A. Atkinson, Nicola Leftley, George Janes, Giuseppe Castiglione, Paul T. Tarr, Kevin Pyke, Ute Voss, Darren M. Wells, Anthony Bishopp

Summary: The study developed dual expression anatomy lines to track gene expression and anatomy changes in plant organs, which can be applied at different growth stages.

PLANT PHYSIOLOGY (2022)

Article Plant Sciences

Root system size and root hair length are key phenes for nitrate acquisition and biomass production across natural variation in Arabidopsis

Jerome De Pessemier, Taraka Ramji Moturu, Philippe Nacry, Rebecca Ebert, Hugues De Gernier, Pascal Tillard, Kamal Swarup, Darren M. Wells, Jim Haseloff, Seth C. Murray, Malcolm J. Bennett, Dirk Inze, Christopher Vincent, Christian Hermans

Summary: A positive correlation was found between root system size and high-affinity nitrate uptake in a core set of Arabidopsis natural accessions, highlighting the beneficial role of exploratory root organ in plant nitrogen acquisition. The study evaluated the role of root phenes in nitrogen acquisition and biomass production in different accessions of Arabidopsis thaliana. The low nitrogen treatment resulted in increased root to shoot biomass ratio and enhanced proliferation of lateral roots and root hairs. Greater biomass production could be achieved through increased root length or specific root hair characteristics.

JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL BOTANY (2022)

Article Biochemistry & Molecular Biology

Systems approaches reveal that ABCB and PIN proteins mediate co-dependent auxin efflux

Nathan L. Mellor, Ute Voss, Alexander Ware, George Janes, Duncan Barrack, Anthony Bishopp, Malcolm J. Bennett, Markus Geisler, Darren M. Wells, Leah R. Band

Summary: Members of the B family of membrane-bound ATP-binding cassette (ABC) transporters play important roles in auxin efflux in plants. This study integrates ABCB localization data into a multicellular model to predict the impact of ABCB-mediated auxin transport on organ-scale distribution. The results suggest that ABCBs enable auxin efflux independently of PINs, but PINs predominantly mediate auxin efflux when co-localized with ABCBs.

PLANT CELL (2022)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Identification of QTL and underlying genes for root system architecture associated with nitrate nutrition in hexaploid wheat

Marcus Griffiths, Jonathan A. Atkinson, Laura-Jayne Gardiner, Ranjan Swarup, Michael P. Pound, Michael H. Wilson, Malcolm J. Bennett, Darren M. Wells

Summary: The genetic basis of root system architecture and resource adaptive responses in wheat was studied using a high-throughput germination paper-based plant phenotyping system and quantitative trait locus (QTL) analysis. Significant genotypic and nitrate-N treatment variation was found for seedling traits, and a total of 59 seedling trait QTLs were identified. Transcriptomic analysis revealed gene enrichment in N-related biological processes and differentially expressed genes related to root angle response. These findings provide genetic insight into root system architecture and plant adaptive responses, and offer targets for improving nitrogen capture in wheat.

JOURNAL OF INTEGRATIVE AGRICULTURE (2022)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Working with UK farmers to investigate anecic earthworm middens and soil biophysical properties

Jacqueline L. Stroud, Iain Dummett, Simon J. Kemp, Craig J. Sturrock

Summary: The conversion from conventional tillage to no-tillage soil management practices improves aggregate stability and earthworm populations. UK farmers found that middened soil, which accounts for up to 42% of the soil surface, has significantly more earthworms than general soil. In a recent experimental field trial, middened areas covering 13% of the trial showed improved aggregate stability and porosity compared to general soil. These findings emphasize the importance of considering middens in assessing soil quality and health in arable systems.

ANNALS OF APPLIED BIOLOGY (2023)

Article Soil Science

Activity and burrowing behaviour of wireworms (Agriotes spp.) in the presence or absence of roots

Samuel W. Booth, Benedikt Kurtz, Martine I. de Heer, Sacha J. Mooney, Craig J. Sturrock

Summary: In this study, X-ray CT was used to visualize and quantify wireworms, their burrow networks, and the root architecture of maize, barley, and bare soil. The study found that the presence of root structures caused behavioral differences in wireworms, leading to variations in the volume and structure of burrow networks.

APPLIED SOIL ECOLOGY (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Ethylene inhibits rice root elongation in compacted soil via ABA- and auxin-mediated mechanisms

Guoqiang Huang, Azad Kilic, Michal Karady, Jiao Zhang, Poonam Mehra, Xiaoyun Song, Craig J. Sturrock, Wanwan Zhu, Hua Qin, Sjon Hartman, Hannah M. Schneider, Rahul Bhosale, Ian C. Dodd, Robert E. Sharp, Rongfeng Huang, Sacha J. Mooney, Wanqi Liang, Malcolm J. Bennett, Dabing Zhang, Bipin K. Pandey

Summary: Soil compaction poses a significant challenge to agriculture, inhibiting root elongation and affecting crop productivity. This study reveals that ethylene regulates the synthesis of auxin and abscisic acid, as well as cortical cell radial expansion, thereby impacting the ability of rice roots to penetrate compacted soil.

PROCEEDINGS OF THE NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Root angle is controlled by EGT1 in cereal crops employing an antigravitropic mechanism

Riccardo Fusi, Serena Rosignoli, Haoyu Lou, Giuseppe Sangiorgi, Riccardo Bovina, Jacob K. Pattem, Aditi N. Borkar, Marco Lombardi, Cristian Forestan, Sara G. Milner, Jayne L. Davis, Aneesh Lale, Gwendolyn K. Kirschner, Ranjan Swarup, Alberto Tassinari, Bipin K. Pandey, Larry M. York, Brian S. Atkinson, Craig J. Sturrock, Sacha J. Mooney, Frank Hochholdinger, Matthew R. Tucker, Axel Himmelbach, Nils Stein, Martin Mascher, Kerstin A. Nagel, Laura De Gara, James Simmonds, Cristobal Uauy, Roberto Tuberosa, Jonathan P. Lynch, Gleb E. Yakubov, Malcolm J. Bennet, Rahul Bhosale, Silvio Salvi

Summary: Root angle in crops is an important trait for efficient utilization of soil resources. This study identifies a regulatory gene called EGT1 that controls root angle by affecting cell wall stiffness in elongating root cortical tissue. Mutations in the EGT1 gene result in a striking root phenotype with steeper growth angles in barley and wheat. These findings suggest that EGT1 plays a crucial role in exerting an antigravitropic mechanism to control root angle in cereal crops.

PROCEEDINGS OF THE NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA (2022)

Review Anatomy & Morphology

Anatomy, histology, development and functions of Ossa cordis: A review

Adam Best, Monika Egerbacher, Sophia Swaine, William Perez, Aziza Alibhai, Paul Rutland, Valentina Kubale, Samir A. A. El-Gendy, Mohamed A. M. Alsafy, Kerstin Baiker, Craig J. Sturrock, Catrin Sian Rutland

Summary: This systematic review compares the prevalence, histology, and anatomical location of Ossa cordis in different veterinary species and humans. It also discusses the associated factors, such as aging and cardiovascular disease, and the potential functions and formation mechanisms of Ossa cordis.

ANATOMIA HISTOLOGIA EMBRYOLOGIA (2022)

Article Agronomy

Root architecture and leaf photosynthesis traits and associations with nitrogen-use efficiency in landrace-derived lines in wheat

Shadia H. S. Kareem, Malcolm J. Hawkesford, Jayalath DeSilva, Minuka Weerasinghe, Darren M. Wells, Michael P. Pound, Jonathan A. Atkinson, M. John Foulkes

Summary: The study demonstrates genetic variation in seedling RSA traits in landrace-derived wheat lines above the elite parental cultivar Paragon, which could potentially be used to enhance nitrogen use efficiency in breeding programs.

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF AGRONOMY (2022)

Review Soil Science

Zero tillage has important consequences for soil pore architecture and hydraulic transport: A review

D. Luke R. Wardak, Faheem N. Padia, Martine I. de Heer, Craig J. Sturrock, Sacha J. Mooney

Summary: This paper reviews 34 studies that demonstrate the influence of zero-tillage (ZT) on porosity, depending on soil texture, pore size class, and depth. ZT can also affect important transport mechanisms that impact the fate of agrochemicals in soils, although the effects on hydraulic transport are less clear.

GEODERMA (2022)

Article Plant Sciences

Defining the scope for altering rice leaf anatomy to improve photosynthesis: a modelling approach

Yi Xiao, Jen Sloan, Chris Hepworth, Marc Fradera-Soler, Andrew Mathers, Rachel Thorley, Alice Baillie, Hannah Jones, Tiangen Chang, Xingyuan Chen, Nazmin Yaapar, Colin P. Osborne, Craig Sturrock, Sacha. J. J. Mooney, Andrew. J. J. Fleming, Xin-Guang Zhu

Summary: Leaf structure plays a crucial role in photosynthesis, but the relationship between a single structural parameter and the overall photosynthetic performance is still debated. In this study, a mechanistic model called eLeaf was developed to capture the photosynthetic performance of rice leaves under various environmental conditions. The model successfully quantified the importance of different elements by analyzing imaging data and biochemical measurements. The results showed that photosynthetic metabolism was the major driver of increased carbon assimilation under elevated CO2 levels, and various structural elements made positive and negative contributions. The findings provide theoretical support for experimental data and highlight the significance of leaf structural plasticity in improving crop photosynthesis.

NEW PHYTOLOGIST (2023)

Article Plant Sciences

Chlorophyll fluorescence-based high-throughput phenotyping facilitates the genetic dissection of photosynthetic heat tolerance in African (Oryza glaberrima) and Asian (Oryza sativa) rice

Jordan K. Robson, John N. Ferguson, Lorna McAusland, Jonathan A. Atkinson, Christine Tranchant-Dubreuil, Phillipe Cubry, Francois Sabot, Darren M. Wells, Adam H. Price, Zoe A. Wilson, Erik H. Murchie

Summary: Rising temperatures and extreme heat events threaten rice production. Developing heat-tolerant rice is essential for food security. Researchers have developed a high-throughput chlorophyll fluorescence-based screen for photosynthetic heat tolerance, which has identified candidate genes for improving rice's heat tolerance.

JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL BOTANY (2023)

Article Plant Sciences

Mechanistic insight into the role of AUXIN RESISTANCE4 in trafficking of AUXIN1 and LIKE AUX1-2

Alison Tidy, Norliza Abu Bakar, David Carrier, Ian D. Kerr, Charlie Hodgman, Malcolm J. Bennett, Ranjan Swarup

Summary: AXR4 is an endoplasmic reticulum accessory protein that regulates the trafficking of auxin influx carriers AUXIN1 and LIKE-AUX2.

PLANT PHYSIOLOGY (2023)

No Data Available