4.7 Article

Strong negative impacts of whole tree harvesting in pine stands on poor, sandy soils: A long-term nutrient budget modelling approach

Journal

FOREST ECOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT
Volume 356, Issue -, Pages 101-111

Publisher

ELSEVIER SCIENCE BV
DOI: 10.1016/j.foreco.2015.07.028

Keywords

Whole tree harvesting; Stem only harvesting; Woody biomass; Nutrient cycling; Forest management

Categories

Funding

  1. Agency of Nature and Forest in Flanders (ANB)
  2. Research Foundation - Flanders (FWO)
  3. Flemish Institute for Technological Research (VITO)

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Global environmental changes such as climate change, overexploitation and human population growth increase the interest in woody biomass from forests as a resource for green energy, chemistry and materials. Whole Tree Harvesting (WTH) can provide additional woody biomass, mainly for bioenergy, by harvesting parts of the crown not harvested under conventional Stem-Only Harvesting (SOH). However, WFH also increases nutrient export, potentially depleting soil nutrients and threatening future stand productivity. Here we assess the impacts of WTH in Corsican pine stands (Pinus nigra ssp. Laricio var. Corsicana Loud.) with a rotation period of 48 years on poor, sandy soils in Belgium. We performed a detailed nutrient budget assessment before and after thinnings and clear-cuts under scenarios of WTH and modelled the long-term changes in ecosystem nutrients under both WTH and SOH. Our results demonstrate a strong immediate impact of WTH on aboveground nutrient stocks (mainly in clear-cuts). In clear-cuts with WTH, half of the base cations (calcium, potassium, magnesium) in the trees and forest floor were exported. The amount of available cations in the soil is not sufficient to immediately compensate for this export. Only one fourth of the amount exported were available for biota in the top 50 cm of the soil. We also modelled long-term development of ecosystem nutrients (available nutrients in the soil and nutrients in trees and forest floor) and found that the available soil calcium, potassium and phosphorus stocks are insufficiently replenished by deposition and weathering to sustain WFH on the long term. We found no indications of potential depletion of ecosystem cations and phosphorus for the next ten rotation periods under SOH management. Our results thus support a less intensive management in pine stands on poor, sandy soils, for instance, by adopting SOH and/or longer rotation periods. (C) 2015 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Plant Sciences

Intra-individual variation in Galium odoratum is affected by experimental drought and shading

Charlotte Moller, Marti March-Salas, Jonas Kuppler, Pieter De Frenne, J. F. Scheepens

Summary: Climate change leads to earlier leaf-out and shading of the forest floor. Forest understorey herbs respond to these changes by varying traits at different levels of organization. Little is known about how variation at the intra-individual level responds to environmental changes.

ANNALS OF BOTANY (2023)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Effects of shade tree species on soil biogeochemistry and coffee bean quality in plantation coffee

Merkebu Getachew, Kris Verheyen, Kassaye Tolassa, Ayco J. M. Tack, Kristoffer Hylander, Biruk Ayalew, Pascal Boeckx, Dries Landuyt, Pieter De Frenne

Summary: Shade trees are widely used in coffee production systems and can have significant impacts on soil biogeochemistry and coffee bean quality. However, quantitative data on these effects are scarce. This study found that N-fixing shade tree species had a negative impact on soil pH and base cation concentrations, while Albizia gummifera L. enhanced phosphorus availability. The study highlights the importance of careful selection and integration of shade tree species for sustaining soil chemical properties in coffee agroecosystems.

AGRICULTURE ECOSYSTEMS & ENVIRONMENT (2023)

Article Agronomy

Within and among farm variability of coffee quality of smallholders in southwest Ethiopia

Merkebu Getachew, Pascal Boeckx, Kris Verheyen, Kassaye Tolassa, Ayco J. M. Tack, Kristoffer Hylander, Stijn Luca, Beyene Zewdie, Pieter De Frenne

Summary: The present study aimed to quantify the relative importance of biophysical variables affecting coffee bean quality and evaluate a near infrared spectroscopy-based model for coffee quality prediction. The study found large within farm variability, indicating the importance of coffee plant-level conditions for physical attributes and cupping scores of green coffee beans. Elevation appeared to be the key variable driving all measured coffee bean quality attributes at the farm level, while canopy cover was the most important variable at the coffee plant level.

AGROFORESTRY SYSTEMS (2023)

Article Ecology

Forest edge effects on moss growth are amplified by drought

Irena Adia Koelemeijer, Johan Ehrlen, Pieter De Frenne, Mari Joensson, Peter Berg, Kristoffer Hylander

Summary: Forest fragmentation increases the number of edges in the landscape. Differences in wind, radiation, and vegetation structure create edge-to-interior gradients in forest microclimate. The effects of climate extremes on edge influences are amplified by drought, suggesting that fragmentation effects are aggravated when droughts become more frequent and severe. Dense edges and buffer zones with high canopy cover can mitigate negative drought impacts in forest edges.

ECOLOGICAL APPLICATIONS (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

ForestClim-Bioclimatic variables for microclimate temperatures of European forests

Stef Haesen, Jonas J. Lembrechts, Pieter De Frenne, Jonathan Lenoir, Juha Aalto, Michael B. Ashcroft, Martin Kopecky, Miska Luoto, Ilya Maclean, Ivan Nijs, Pekka Niittynen, Johan van den Hoogen, Nicola Arriga, Josef Bruna, Nina Buchmann, Marek Ciliak, Alessio Collalti, Emiel De Lombaerde, Patrice Descombes, Mana Gharun, Ignacio Goded, Sanne Govaert, Caroline Greiser, Achim Grelle, Carsten Gruening, Lucia Hederova, Kristoffer Hylander, Juergen Kreyling, Bart Kruijt, Martin Macek, Frantisek Malis, Matej Man, Giovanni Manca, Radim Matula, Camille Meeussen, Sonia Merinero, Stefano Minerbi, Leonardo Montagnani, Lena Muffler, Roma Ogaya, Josep Penuelas, Roman Plichta, Miguel Portillo-Estrada, Jonas Schmeddes, Ankit Shekhar, Fabien Spicher, Mariana Ujhazyova, Pieter Vangansbeke, Robert Weigel, Jan Wild, Florian Zellweger, Koenraad Van Meerbeek

Summary: Microclimate research has gained renewed interest in the past decade, and its importance for ecological processes is increasingly recognized. To improve ecological models, there is a growing need for high-resolution microclimatic temperature grids across broad spatial extents. In this study, we present a new set of open-access bioclimatic variables for microclimate temperatures of European forests at a resolution of 25 x 25 m(2).

GLOBAL CHANGE BIOLOGY (2023)

Article Plant Sciences

More warm-adapted species in soil seed banks than in herb layer plant communities across Europe

Alistair G. Auffret, Pieter Vangansbeke, Pieter De Frenne, Inger Auestad, Sofia Basto, Ulf Grandin, Hans Jacquemyn, Anna Jakobsson, Rein Kalamees, Marcus A. Koch, Rob Marrs, Bryndis Marteinsdottir, Markus Wagner, Renee M. Bekker, Hans Henrik Bruun, Guillaume Decocq, Martin Hermy, Malgorzata Jankowska-Blaszczuk, Per Milberg, Inger E. Maren, Robin J. Pakeman, Gareth K. Phoenix, Ken Thompson, Hans Van Calster, Vigdis Vandvik, Jan Plue

Summary: Responses to climate change often lag behind warming rates. Soil seed banks can buffer unsuitable conditions, containing species with warm and wide climatic ranges. Seed banks may play a role in climate-driven community shifts and the spread of generalist species.

JOURNAL OF ECOLOGY (2023)

Article Ecology

Forest edge structure from terrestrial laser scanning to explain bird biophony characteristics from acoustic indices

Tom E. E. Verhelst, Pieter Vangansbeke, Pieter De Frenne, Barbara D'hont, Quentin Ponette, Luc Willems, Hans Verbeeck, Kim Calders

Summary: Forest edges are important for biodiversity, but their potential is dependent on forest structure. However, current methods lack accuracy in characterizing forest edge abruptness. In this study, we used three-dimensional forest structural data and biodiversity monitoring to assess the influence of forest edge structure on habitat suitability. Our results demonstrate clear differences in the structural metrics and recorded soundscapes, but no correlation was found between acoustic indices and bird species richness.

REMOTE SENSING IN ECOLOGY AND CONSERVATION (2023)

Article Agronomy

From broadleaves to conifers: The effect of tree composition and density on understory microclimate across latitudes

Joan Diaz-Calafat, Jaime Uria-Diez, Jorg Brunet, Pieter De Frenne, Pieter Vangansbeke, Adam Felton, Erik Ockinger, Sara A. O. Cousins, Juergen Bauhus, Quentin Ponette, Per-Ola Hedwall

Summary: Forest canopies play a crucial role in buffering the macroclimate and mitigating climate-warming impacts on forest ecosystems. However, our knowledge about the effects of forest structure, composition, and their interactions with macroclimate is limited. This study found that forest density is the key determinant of understory temperatures, and the proportion of broadleaves and forest density have varying importance on different response variables. Climate factors outside forests also influence understory temperature buffering.

AGRICULTURAL AND FOREST METEOROLOGY (2023)

Article Plant Sciences

Trait variation in juvenile plants from the soil seed bank of temperate forests in relation to macro-and microclimate

Cristina Gasperini, Elisa Carrari, Sanne Govaert, Camille Meeussen, Karen De Pauw, Jan Plue, Pieter Sanczuk, Thomas Vanneste, Pieter Vangansbeke, Giovanni Iacopetti, Pieter De Frenne, Federico Selvi

Summary: This study investigates the effects of macro- and microclimatic gradients on the juvenile plant communities from the realized seed bank of temperate forests in Italy and Belgium. The results show that taller communities develop at the forest edge due to higher light availability and warmer temperatures. However, the shadier and cooler microclimate of the forest core reduces the mean leaf area, dry weight, height, and leaf number in the communities realized from the edge soil. Global warming may result in a functional shift of the understorey due to early filtering effects and adaptive trait adjustments to temperature increase.

APPLIED VEGETATION SCIENCE (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Effects of tree pollen on throughfall element fluxes in European forests

Arne Verstraeten, Nicolas Bruffaerts, Fabiana Cristofolini, Elena Vanguelova, Johan Neirynck, Gerrit Genouw, Bruno De Vos, Peter Waldner, Anne Thimonier, Anita Nussbaumer, Mathias Neumann, Sue Benham, Pasi Rautio, Liisa Ukonmaanaho, Paeivi Merilae, Antti-Jussi Lindroos, Annika Saarto, Jukka Reiniharju, Nicholas Clarke, Volkmar Timmermann, Manuel Nicolas, Maria Schmitt, Katrin Meusburger, Anna Kowalska, Idalia Kasprzyk, Katarzyna Kluska, Lukasz Grewling, Malgorzata Malkiewicz, Lars Vesterdal, Morten Ingerslev, Miklos Manninger, Donat Magyar, Hugues Titeux, Gunilla Pihl Karlsson, Regula Gehrig, Sandy Adriaenssens, Agneta Ekebom, Asloeg Dahl, Marco Ferretti, Elena Gottardini

Summary: The effects of tree pollen on precipitation chemistry are not fully understood, which may lead to misinterpretations of element deposition in European forests. The study found that tree pollen has an impact on the element fluxes in forest throughfall, but the extent of the impact varies among different tree species.

BIOGEOCHEMISTRY (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Microclimate and forest density drive plant population dynamics under climate change

Pieter Sanczuk, Karen De Pauw, Emiel De Lombaerde, Miska Luoto, Camille Meeussen, Sanne Govaert, Thomas Vanneste, Leen Depauw, Jorg Brunet, Sara A. O. Cousins, Cristina Gasperini, Per-Ola Hedwall, Giovanni Iacopetti, Jonathan Lenoir, Jan Plue, Federico Selvi, Fabien Spicher, Jaime Uria-Diez, Kris Verheyen, Pieter Vangansbeke, Pieter De Frenne

Summary: Macroclimatic changes have global impacts on ecosystems. Forest floors under dense tree canopies buffer the impacts of macroclimate change on forest biodiversity, while canopy opening exacerbates these impacts. A cross-continental transplant experiment was conducted to understand the role of forest microclimates in shaping future plant distributions.

NATURE CLIMATE CHANGE (2023)

Article Plant Sciences

Soil legacies of tree species richness in a young plantation do not modulate tree seedling response to watering regime

E. Dhiedt, L. Baeten, P. De Smedt, K. Verheyen

Summary: Trees have a strong influence on soil properties, even after they are removed. This study investigated the effects of soil legacies of tree species richness on tree seedling growth and how these legacies interact with irrigation frequency. The results showed that species richness did not have a significant effect on plant performance or response to irrigation frequency. However, the effect of irrigation frequency varied depending on the species identity of the seedlings. These patterns can be attributed to the young age of the forest and the previous agricultural land use, which have a greater impact on soil characteristics and plant response to drought than species diversity.

PLANT BIOLOGY (2023)

Article Plant Sciences

Forest understorey flowering phenology responses to experimental warming and illumination

Eline Lorer, Kris Verheyen, Haben Blondeel, Karen De Pauw, Pieter Sanczuk, Pieter De Frenne, Dries Landuyt

Summary: Species are adjusting their phenology in response to warming temperatures. This study focuses on understory plants in forests, which experience different light and temperature conditions compared to open environments due to tree canopy shading. The researchers recorded the flowering patterns of 10 temperate forest understory plant species in mesocosm experiments to understand how phenology is influenced by sub-canopy warming and illumination. They found that flowering onset is advanced by an average of 7.1 days per 1 degree Celsius warming, with warm-adapted species showing greater advances. The study suggests that considering sub-canopy temperature and light availability is crucial for understanding future phenological responses of understory plants.

NEW PHYTOLOGIST (2023)

Article Forestry

Recovery of aboveground biomass, soil carbon stocks and species diversity in tropical montane secondary forests of East Africa

Sadadi Ojoatre, Jos Barlow, Suzanne R. Jacobs, Mariana C. Rufino

Summary: This study evaluates the changes in a forest complex in Kenya and finds that within 20 years of disturbance, there is rapid recovery of aboveground biomass and carbon accumulation, and the species diversity remains high in these previously disturbed fragments.

FOREST ECOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Forestry

Self-thinning of Scots pine across Europe changes with solar radiation, precipitation and temperature but does not show trends in time

Astor Torano Caicoya, Peter Biber, Miren del Rio, Ricardo Ruiz-Peinado, Catia Arcangeli, Robert Matthews, Hans Pretzsch

Summary: This study analyzed the effects of site and climate on the self-thinning line in Scots pine forests in Europe. The results showed that species tolerance, temperature, and precipitation influenced the slope of the self-thinning line. In terms of the intercept, latitude and radiation had compensating effects. Time did not show significant trends in the self-thinning line. The study highlights the need to adapt management strategies and models based on self-thinning to different latitudes. Climate change has not yet significantly impacted the self-thinning trajectory, but a continuous rise in temperature and high precipitation may accelerate the self-thinning process and result in increased biomass accumulation.

FOREST ECOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Forestry

Positive interactions in shaping neighborhood diversity during secondary forests recovery: Revisiting the classical paradigm

Haonan Zhang, Jianing Xu, Weiqi Meng, Zhonglin Li, Yanyan Ni, Weijie Li, Hao Chen, Xingshuo Zhang, Huanhuan Yuan, Zhi Wang

Summary: Secondary forests play a crucial role in ecosystem dynamics and biodiversity recovery. This study investigated the mechanisms underlying secondary succession in a restored secondary forest and found that deciduous tree species transition from diversity accumulators to repellents as they progress through different life history stages, while evergreen tree species can act as accumulators or remain neutral. The study also revealed the effects of density dependence on the mortality and regeneration of different tree species, and highlighted the importance of early-arriving tree species in facilitating the establishment and diversity of late-arriving counterparts.

FOREST ECOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Forestry

Comparison of resistance to pest infestation between native and exotic mangrove species

Yierxiati Abulaiti, Zijian Huang, Guojiao Xie, Xiaojuan Zou, Qin Luo, Minhuang Wang, Qiong Yang, Ping Hu, Shixiao Yu

Summary: In this study, the resistance to pest infestation of native and exotic mangrove species was compared based on their traits and spectral reflectance. The results showed that exotic species exhibited higher resistance to pest infestation compared to native species.

FOREST ECOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Forestry

Are western European oak forests man-made constructs? The pedoanthracological perspective

Thomas Feiss, Vincent Robin, Delphine Aran, Joseph Levillain, Thierry Paul, Jean-Luc Dupouey

Summary: Fagus sylvatica L. is a competitive tree in European temperate deciduous forests, but often sporadic or absent in present-day stands where Quercus spp. are dominant. Through soil charcoal analysis in the Lorraine Plateau in France, the presence of Fagus and Quercus in mature Quercus stands was confirmed. Radiocarbon dating results indicated that historical forest management caused the replacement of Fagus by Quercus, starting from the Bronze Age.

FOREST ECOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Forestry

PHENTHAUproc - An early warning and decision support system for hazard assessment and control of oak processionary moth (Thaumetopoea processionea)

Paula Halbig, Anne-Sophie Stelzer, Peter Baier, Josef Pennerstorfer, Horst Delb, Axel Schopf

Summary: The incidence of oak processionary moth in Central Europe has been increasing, posing severe threats to oak trees, humans, and animals. To address this issue, researchers have developed an online early warning system that provides phenological forecasts and decision support for the protection of oak trees and human health.

FOREST ECOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Forestry

Using high-resolution images to analyze the importance of crown size and competition for the growth of tropical trees

Jean-Baptiste Ndamiyehe Ncutirakiza, Sylvie Gourlet-Fleury, Philippe Lejeune, Xavier Bry, Catherine Trottier, Frederic Mortier, Adeline Fayolle, Francois Muhashy Habiyaremye, Leopold Ndjele Mianda-Bungi, Gauthier Ligot

Summary: This study examines the influence of canopy structure on tropical tree growth using data collected through unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) and field measurements. The results show that combining UAV and field data can improve the prediction of tree diameter increment. Diameter at breast height and crown area are complementary predictors, and crown-based competition indices significantly enhance prediction models. The calibrated model at one site can accurately predict growth at another site.

FOREST ECOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Forestry

Shading and species diversity act as safety nets for seedling survival and vitality of native trees in dryland forests: Implications for restoration

Abebe Damtew, Emiru Birhane, Christian Messier, Alain Paquette, Bart Muys

Summary: Restoring degraded dryland requires a diverse mixture of trees and shrubs. Shading and species diversity can improve seedling survival and vitality. Shaded conditions led to higher seedling survival, vitality, and chlorophyll content, while increasing species richness improved seedling vitality in non-shaded conditions.

FOREST ECOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Forestry

Natural seeding as an alternative to planting in black spruce-lichen woodlands

Francois Hebert, Isabelle Delisle, Marc Tremblay, Pascal Tremblay, Jean- Francois Boucher, Yan Boucher, Daniel Lord

Summary: Regeneration failures in the closed-crown boreal forest, resulting in the creation of open lichen woodlands, can be restored through clear-cutting, scarification, and natural seeding. Clear-cutting combined with scarification promotes seedling establishment, and scarification creates suitable microsites for germination. Seedling growth in lichen woodlands is higher when logging and scarification are combined, but lower compared to feather moss stands. Afforestation through natural seeding following scarification could be a cost-effective option for restoring lichen woodlands.

FOREST ECOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Forestry

Vegetation density and altitude determine the supply of dry Afromontane forest ecosystem services: Evidence from Ethiopia

Bianca Wulansari Kassun, A. Maarit I. Kallio, Erik Tr Omborg, Meley Mekonen Rannestad

Summary: Mapping and analyzing forest ecosystem services in dry and mountain forests can provide valuable knowledge for sustainable forest management strategies.

FOREST ECOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Forestry

Whoa on the wobble! Stem sinuosity in juvenile Douglas-fir across levels of genetic gain, silvicultural treatments, site conditions, and climatic variables in the Pacific Northwest

Michael Premer, Eric Turnblom, Aaron Weiskittel

Summary: Managed forests serve as a natural climate change solution by sequestering carbon and storing it in harvested wood products, while also providing ecosystem services and wildlife habitat. This study focused on the stem sinuosity of juvenile coastal Douglas-fir and found that genetic improvement, silviculture practices, and local growing conditions can impact stem sinuosity. Factors such as tree spacing, vegetation control, and climate variables also affect the severity of stem sinuosity.

FOREST ECOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Forestry

Effects of forest management on the key fungal decomposer Fomes fomentarius in European beech forests - Lessons from a large-scale experiment

Bronwyn Lira Dyson, Rhea Herpel, Peter Karasch, Jorg Mueller, Dominik Thom, Claus Baessler

Summary: The study aimed to assess the effects of different forest management strategies, dead wood types, and microclimates on Fomes fomentarius. The results showed that the occupancy of Fomes fomentarius was lower in control stands, while the percent cover occupied on snags under a closed canopy was higher. Increasing the number of snags and maintaining dense forest canopies could enhance the presence of Fomes fomentarius as well as provide important microhabitats for various arthropods.

FOREST ECOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Forestry

Exploring the role of canopy triangular units in analysing canopy effects on saplings

Di Liu, Chaofan Zhou, Xiao He, Xiangdong Lei, Huiru Zhang, Xianzhao Liu

Summary: Canopy structure plays a significant role in the distribution and growth of saplings. Traditional canopy metrics are inadequate in irregular stands. The innovative framework of canopy triangular units provides a comprehensive understanding of the canopy's three-dimensional attributes. Through this framework, we can analyze the differences in various triangular unit types and the spatial dispersion of saplings.

FOREST ECOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Forestry

The influence of seed functional traits and anthropogenic disturbances on persistence and size of the soil seed bank from dry subtropical forest species

Amalia Valeria Ibanez Moro, Fabian Borghetti, Leonardo Galetto, Juan M. Cellini, Sandra J. Bravo

Summary: This study evaluated the size and persistence of soil seed banks (SSB) of six native woody species in dry subtropical forests of the western Argentine Chaco region. The results showed that SSB size was influenced by different sites and sampling years, and forest disturbances had varying effects on SSB.

FOREST ECOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Forestry

Harvest block aggregation as a driver of intensive moose browsing pressure on hardwood regeneration in a temperate forest

Stephanie Landry, Marc-Andre Villard, Gaetan Pelletier, Martin-Hugues St-Laurent

Summary: In many regions of the world, excessive browsing by ungulates has reached unsustainable levels, threatening biodiversity and forest regeneration. Moose, as ecological engineers, have severe impacts on forest structure and composition through overbrowsing. The distribution of forage and cover patches affects moose browsing pressure, and this relationship has been explored in conifer-dominated stands but not in hardwood-dominated landscapes.

FOREST ECOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT (2024)