4.7 Article

The post-breakage response of laminated heat-treated glass under in plane and out of plane loading

Journal

COMPOSITES PART B-ENGINEERING
Volume 147, Issue -, Pages 227-239

Publisher

ELSEVIER SCI LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.compositesb.2018.04.005

Keywords

Laminated glass; Post-glass-breakage response; Bending; Reinforced concrete; Polyeric interlayer; Tension stiffening

Funding

  1. Italian Dipartimento della Protezione Civile under project ReLUIS-DPC
  2. Italian Ministero dell'Istruzione, dell'Universitei e della Ricerca under grant MIUR-PRIN voce COAN [5.50.16.01, 2015JW9NJT]

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Any reliable use of glass for structural purposes cannot neglect that its breakage may be provoked by imponderable events, like impacts at critical spots or thermal shocks. Laminated glass, composed by glass plies sandwiching polymeric interlayer sheets, is used in architectural application thanks to its safe post-glass breakage response. When glass breaks, the interlayer retains the glass shards, and the cracked element maintain a certain residual load-bearing capacity, strongly influenced by the tension stiffening of the polymer due to the adhesion with the glass shards, which depends upon the size of the shards and of the debonded zones. Here, we review the most recent experimental results on the post-glass breakage response of laminated heat-treated glass elements, providing charts for the evaluation of such a stiffening effect. Based on this, simple formulas to analyze and interpret the experimental findings under both in-plane and out-of plane bending are proposed, providing analogies with the bending of bimodulus materials and the load-bearing mechanism of reinforced concrete, respectively.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Correction Construction & Building Technology

Cantilevered laminated glass balustrades: the Conjugate Beam Effective Thickness method-part II: comparison and application (vol 7, pg 23, 2022)

Adam J. Nizich, Laura Galuppi

GLASS STRUCTURES & ENGINEERING (2023)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Theoretical mechanical properties of strands and cables made of wound carbon nanotube fibers

Giovanni Migliaccio, Reginald Des Roches, Gianni Royer-Carfagni

Summary: Carbon-NanoTube Fibers (CNTFs) have great potential for challenging structural applications due to their high strength-to-weight ratio. This paper presents a theoretical model to describe the mechanical response of stretched and twisted strands/cables made of CNTFs. The model can provide a foundation for future experimental studies.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF MECHANICAL SCIENCES (2022)

Article Materials Science, Multidisciplinary

Geometry of sliding lamellae dictates the constitutive properties of nacre-like hierarchical materials

Roberto Ballarini, Claudio Boni, Gianni Royer Carfagni

Summary: The mechanical properties of nacre, which are superior to its constituent materials, are derived from a micro-architecture formed by the arrangement of aragonite tiles with surface asperities bonded by organic interlayers. A mechanical model is developed to study the effects of contact profile on the constitutive response of hierarchical metamaterials. The model not only agrees well with experimental results, but also describes complex stress-strain curves, demonstrating its potential as a design tool for innovative metamaterials.

JOURNAL OF THE MECHANICS AND PHYSICS OF SOLIDS (2022)

Article Engineering, Civil

Transparent hybrid glass-steel bracing to improve the seismic capacity of historic buildings with colonnades

Claudio Boni, Gianni Royer-Carfagni

Summary: Any seismic retrofitting plan on historical monuments must adhere to the principles of minimal intervention, recognizability, and reversibility. A feasibility study proposes a new type of glass-based bracing suitable for strengthening soft storeys with colonnades. The bracing, a laminated glass pane confined by a thin steel frame, offers stiffness, slimness, and transparency while being recognizable and reversible. The study also addresses important aspects such as stress concentration, correct placement, and connection to the existing structure, showing that a well-designed and positioned bracing system can enhance seismic capacity with minimal visual impact.

ENGINEERING STRUCTURES (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Flextegrity simple cubic lattices

Claudio Boni, Gianni Royer-Carfagni

Summary: Flextegrity lattices are spatial grids composed of stiff segments kept in contact by compliant pre-tensioned tendons. They are sensitive to the orientation of the segments and the shape of the pitch surfaces of the contact joints. The theoretical predictions are compared with experimental results on 3D-printed physical models. Extensions are discussed for lattices with different arrangements and multi-stable contact joints.

PROCEEDINGS OF THE ROYAL SOCIETY A-MATHEMATICAL PHYSICAL AND ENGINEERING SCIENCES (2023)

Review Construction & Building Technology

Architectural Glass under Climatic Actions and Fire: Review of State of the Art, Open Problems and Future Perspectives

Laura Galuppi, Annalisa Franco, Chiara Bedon

Summary: The evaluation of thermally induced stresses and strains is a critical issue in the design of structural glass elements in buildings. Thermal stresses are one of the main causes of premature failure in glass due to its sensitivity to temperature gradients. Existing standards prescribe different methods for calculating temperature fields and the resulting stress, often based on simplifying assumptions, and lack uniformly defined procedures.

BUILDINGS (2023)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Thermal analysis of architectural glazing in uneven conditions based on Biot's variational principle: part I-description of the finite element modelling

Laura Galuppi, Gianni Royer-Carfagni

Summary: Breakages in architectural glazing are often caused by thermal stress resulting from uneven heating of the glass pane. A 3D approach is necessary to calculate the stress, although thermal analyses assume temperature homogeneity in the plane. In this study, a semi-analytical formulation based on Biot's variational principle for heat transfer is presented to accurately assess the temperature field in non-uniformly irradiated glazing.

GLASS STRUCTURES & ENGINEERING (2023)

Review Construction & Building Technology

The new CEN/TS 19100: Design of glass structures

Markus Feldmann, Maximilian Laurs, Jan Belis, Nebosja Buljan, Annie Criaud, Eric Dupont, Martina Eliasova, Laura Galuppi, Paavo Hassinen, Ruth Kasper, Christian Louter, Giampiero Manara, Anne Minne, Tim Morgan, Gabriele Pisano, Mauro Overend, Gianni Royer-Carfagni, Jens Schneider, Gregor Schwind, Christian Schuler, Geralt Siebert, Anna Sikynova

Summary: Since the beginning of 2021, CEN/TS 19100 Design of Glass Structures has been released in its first three parts, with the fourth part expected soon. This Technical Specification serves as a pre-standard for the future Eurocode and is the first comprehensive design code for structural glass engineering in the European market. It is compatible with EN 1990 Basis of Design and addresses glass-specific design matters. The standard allows European countries to adapt the design results to their own safety level through National Determined Parameters.

GLASS STRUCTURES & ENGINEERING (2023)

Article Mechanics

Piecewise power law approximation of the interlayer relaxation curve for the long term viscoelastic fractional modeling of laminated glass

Luca Viviani, Mario Di Paola, Gianni Royer-Carfagni

Summary: This paper proposes an approximation of the polymer relaxation curve using continuously-connected power law branches and extends the Grunwald-Letnikov integration scheme for fractional differential equations. Numerical results show excellent correspondence with experiments under long duration loads. Compared to the classic Prony series approach, this method simplifies the calibration of material parameters and is computationally more efficient and stable.

COMPOSITE STRUCTURES (2023)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

A refined model for the effective tensile stiffness of Carbon NanoTube fibers

Laura Galuppi, Vincenzo Andrea Muratore

Summary: The paper presents a solid-mechanics based method for determining the macroscopic tensile properties of fibers composed of monodispersed Carbon NanoTubes (CNTs). The model takes into account the offset arrangement of CNTs in a cross-sectional square lattice, their deformable elastic behavior, and the coupling occurring on their lateral surfaces. By solving a delayed-advanced differential equation using finite difference technique, the effective tensile stiffness of the fiber can be evaluated based on the length of the constituent CNTs, their offset, and their axial compliance. The proposed approach is validated through comparisons with literature data.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF MECHANICAL SCIENCES (2023)

Article Mechanics

Thermal and elastic modeling of architectural glass unevenly heated by the environment. Formal symmetry from Biot's variational principle

Laura Galuppi, Gianni Royer-Carfagni

Summary: This paper proposes a dedicated thermo-elastic model for the stress state resulting from non-uniform temperature distribution in architectural glass panes. The model overcomes the limitations of standardized prescriptions, simplified practical rules, and general-purpose thermal softwares not interfaced with a structural analysis. It is based on Biot's variational principle for heat transfer and implemented using a finite element framework.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SOLIDS AND STRUCTURES (2023)

Article Mechanics

A constrained solid-shell model for the geometric nonlinear finite-element analysis of laminates with alternating stiff/soft layers. Applications to laminated glass

Domenico Magisano, Leonardo Leonetti, Giovanni Garcea, Gianni Royer-Carfagni

Summary: Solid-shell models are developed for the nonlinear analysis of multi-layered composite structures. The proposed approach is based on a geometrically exact solid-shell finite element model with one element per layer. An alternative solid-shell model with fewer parameters is derived by imposing equal finite rotation of the stiff layers and enforcing the plane stress condition. Extensive numerical examples for laminated glass plates and curved shells are provided to validate the proposed models.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SOLIDS AND STRUCTURES (2023)

Article Engineering, Civil

Analytical solutions for plates connected by edge beams, under various loading conditions: An application for insulating glass units

Laura Galuppi, Enrico Zacchei

Summary: This study analytically solves the problem of insulating glass units under loading conditions and proposes an engineering approach for their design. Comparisons with finite element analysis confirm the accuracy of the proposed method.

THIN-WALLED STRUCTURES (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Shear and flexural deformations in flextegrity segmental beams inspired by Leonardo's triangular masonry construction

Claudio Boni, Gianni Royer-Carfagni

Summary: In this article, Leonardo da Vinci's ingenious masonry structure presented in Codex Atlanticus is introduced. The structure consists of segments in the shape of inverted triangles, assembled by contact in a chain. By connecting the segments through elastic tendons, a new type of flextegrity beam is formed. The system involves both rotational and sliding types of deformation, which is theoretically analyzed and experimentally confirmed.

PROCEEDINGS OF THE ROYAL SOCIETY A-MATHEMATICAL PHYSICAL AND ENGINEERING SCIENCES (2023)

Article Engineering, Multidisciplinary

The relationship between the impact position interference and CAI strength of composite sandwich structures under double impacts

Keyu Zhu, Xitao Zheng, Jing Peng, Jiaming Sun, Ruilin Huang, Leilei Yan

Summary: This paper discusses the influence of multiple impacts on the compression strength of honeycomb sandwich structures with composite face sheets. It is found that the size of the impactor affects the turning point of the compression strength. Additionally, high impact energy leads to damage in the bottom face sheet and reduces the overall compression strength.

COMPOSITES PART B-ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Multidisciplinary

Effect of carbonation on the corrosion behavior of steel rebar embedded in magnesium phosphate cement

Danqian Wang, Yanfei Yue, Jueshi Qian

Summary: Magnesium Potassium Phosphate Cement (MKPC) as a binder for steel rebars shows improved corrosion resistance when subjected to carbonation, due to the increase in pH and the formation of a more protective oxide film.

COMPOSITES PART B-ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Multidisciplinary

Mechanical properties and failure mechanisms of all-CFRP corrugated sandwich truncated cone

Zhibin Li, Wenyu Wang, Pengcheng Xue, Xingyu Wei, Jian Xiong

Summary: This work proposes a design approach and manufacturing method for carbon fiber reinforced plastic (CFRP) corrugated sandwich truncated cones (CSTC) to improve their anti-debonding ability and ensure reliability. The study establishes theoretical models for CSTCs' stiffness and failure modes, which are verified through experiments and finite element analysis (FEA). The research reveals the effect of geometric parameters on failure modes and performs an optimal design for CSTC structures. The findings have significant implications for the design and application of lightweight CSTCs in constructions, such as launch vehicle adapters.

COMPOSITES PART B-ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Multidisciplinary

Asymmetric wettability fibrous membranes: Preparation and biologic applications

Mingyu Zhang, Lei Chu, Jiahua Chen, Fuxun Qi, Xiaoyan Li, Xinliang Chen, Deng-Guang Yu

Summary: This review summarizes the different structures and construction methods of fibrous membranes with asymmetric wettability. It also reviews the biological applications of these membranes and suggests future challenges.

COMPOSITES PART B-ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Multidisciplinary

Effect of fibre concentration on the mechanical properties of welded reinforced polypropylene

E. Mofakhami, L. Gervat, B. Fayolle, G. Miquelard-Garnier, C. Ovalle, L. Laiarinandrasana

Summary: This study investigates the effects of fibre concentration on the mechanical response of welded glass-fibre-reinforced polypropylene (GF-PP). Experimental observations reveal a significant reduction in weld ratio, up to 60%, indicating a decreased strength compared to the bulk material. Increasing fibre content in the welded material results in a decrease in stress at break and strain at the maximum stress. The use of DIC technique and X-ray microtomography further confirms the localized strain amplification in the welded zone due to the significant increase in fibre density.

COMPOSITES PART B-ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Multidisciplinary

Interlaminar shear strength of Carbon/PEEK thermoplastic composite laminate: Effects of in-situ consolidation by automated fiber placement and autoclave re-consolidation

Emad Pourahmadi, Farjad Shadmehri, Rajamohan Ganesan

Summary: This research compares the mechanical properties of laminates manufactured using automated fiber placement and conventional autoclave curing methods. The results show that laminates manufactured using automated fiber placement have a lower interlaminar shear strength compared to laminates reconsolidated using autoclave curing. A finite element simulation method is proposed to quantitatively analyze these differences.

COMPOSITES PART B-ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Multidisciplinary

Bolted joint method for composite materials using a novel fiber/metal patch as hole reinforcement-Improving both static and fatigue properties

Johnny Jakobsen, Benny Endelt, Fahimeh Shakibapour

Summary: This study proposes a new bolted/pinned joining method for composite applications, which improves load transfer by introducing a patch-type reinforcement. Experimental results demonstrate significant improvements in both static and fatigue load conditions compared to existing methods. Finite element simulations highlight the advantage of this method, as it creates a more efficient load-transferring mechanism through different stress distributions.

COMPOSITES PART B-ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Multidisciplinary

Novel multi-crack damage approach for pultruded fiber-polymer web-flange junctions

Gisele G. Cintra, Janine D. Vieira, Daniel C. T. Cardoso, Thomas Keller

Summary: This paper proposes a novel approach to assess multi-crack behavior in layered fiber-polymer composites. The generated Compliance and R-curves provide useful insights into understanding the multiple delamination process and allow for separate evaluation of strain energy release rate (SERR) for each crack. The developed cohesive zone model successfully simulates the failure process zone of three parallel cracks, showing good agreement between the numerical model and experimental results.

COMPOSITES PART B-ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Multidisciplinary

Uncovering the hidden structure: A study on the feasibility of induction thermography for fiber orientation analysis in CFRP composites using 2D-FFT

Renil Thomas Kidangan, Sreedhar Unnikrishnakurup, C. Krishnamurthy, Krishnan Balasubramaniam

Summary: The induction heating process can accurately identify fiber orientation and stacking order, making it a valuable tool for large-area inspection and quality control in manufacturing fiber-reinforced composites.

COMPOSITES PART B-ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Multidisciplinary

Morphological characteristics of spray dried cellulose nanofibers produced using various wood pulp feedstocks and their effects on polypropylene composite properties

Sungjun Hwang, Yousoo Han, Douglas J. Gardner

Summary: Bleached Kraft pulp, unbleached Kraft pulp, and old corrugated cardboard pulp are suitable for producing cellulose nanofibril suspensions. Spray drying is a fast, simple, cost-effective, and scalable drying method. Spray-dried cellulose nanofibrils can be used as reinforcing materials in polypropylene matrices. The particle size of cellulose nanofibrils affects the material properties.

COMPOSITES PART B-ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Multidisciplinary

Four-dimensional printing of continuous glass fiber-reinforced thermoplastics

Mehdi Mahdavi, Abbas Zolfaghari

Summary: This study aims to improve the recovery forces of shape memory polymers (SMPs) through material extrusion additive manufacturing. By using glass fiber (GF) as reinforcement and manufacturing multi-layer composite specimens, it was found that PLA with 6.62% GF exhibited the best recovery force, which was further optimized through annealing heat treatment.

COMPOSITES PART B-ENGINEERING (2024)

Review Engineering, Multidisciplinary

Flame retardancy and fire mechanical properties for natural fiber/polymer composite: A review

Xiang Ao, Antonio Vazquez-Lopez, Davide Mocerino, Carlos Gonzalez, De-Yi Wang

Summary: The vulnerability of natural fibers to heat and fire poses a significant challenge for their substitution of traditional fiber reinforcements in composite materials. Natural fiber/polymer composites (NFCs) are regarded as potential candidates for engineering applications due to their environmental friendliness and low-impact sourcing. Thus, appropriate approaches need to be implemented to enhance the fire safety of NFCs. This review summarizes and discusses the latest understanding of flammability and thermal properties of natural fibers, with a special focus on their interaction with polymer matrix in fire behavior. Additionally, the latest developments in flame-retardant approaches for NFCs are reviewed, covering both flame retardancy and fire structural integrity. Finally, future prospects and perspectives on fire safety of NFCs are proposed, providing insights into further advancements of NFCs.

COMPOSITES PART B-ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Multidisciplinary

Construction of an epoxidized, phosphorus-based poly(styrene butadiene styrene) and its application in high-performance epoxy resin

Cheng Wang, Siqi Huo, Guofeng Ye, Bingtao Wang, Zhenghong Guo, Qi Zhang, Pingan Song, Hao Wang, Zhitian Liu

Summary: The demand for multifunctional, transparent epoxy resin with superior dielectric, mechanical, and fire-safety performances is increasing in modern industries. Researchers have developed an epoxidized, phosphaphenanthrene-containing poly(styrene butadiene styrene) (ESD) for advanced fire-safe epoxy resin, which maintains high transparency and improves UV-blocking property. The addition of 10 wt% ESD results in improved mechanical properties, decreased dielectric constant and loss, and outperformance compared to other fire-safe epoxy resins. This research provides an effective method for developing multifunctional flame-retardant epoxy resin.

COMPOSITES PART B-ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Multidisciplinary

Inner superhydrophobic materials based on waste fly ash: Microstructural morphology of microetching effects

Bo Pang, Heping Zheng, Zuquan Jin, Dongshuai Hou, Yunsheng Zhang, Xiaoyun Song, Yanan Sun, Zhiyong Liu, Wei She, Lin Yang, Mengyuan Li

Summary: This study develops an internal superhydrophobic material (ISM) using waste denitrification fly ash, which maintains stable hydrophobicity under harsh conditions of use and does not rely on expensive fluor-based surface modifications. The synthesized ISM has excellent matrix strength, strong waterproof properties, and retains superhydrophobicity even at damaged or friction interfaces.

COMPOSITES PART B-ENGINEERING (2024)

Article Engineering, Multidisciplinary

Directional eddy current probe configuration for in-line detection of out-of-plane wrinkles

Meirbek Mussatayev, Qiuji Yi, Mark Fitzgerald, Vincent K. Maes, Paul Wilcox, Robert Hughes

Summary: Real-time monitoring of carbon fibre composites during Automated Fibre Placement (AFP) manufacturing remains a challenge for non-destructive evaluation (NDE) techniques. This study designed a directional eddy-current (EC) probe to evaluate the detectability of out-of-plane wrinkles. Experimental evaluations and finite element modeling were conducted to better understand the relationship between eddy-current density and defect detection. The findings suggest that the probe configuration with an asymmetric driver coil and differential pickup coils shows the best capability for wrinkle detection.

COMPOSITES PART B-ENGINEERING (2024)