4.4 Article

Economics of size-structured forestry with carbon storage

Journal

CANADIAN JOURNAL OF FOREST RESEARCH
Volume 48, Issue 1, Pages 11-22

Publisher

CANADIAN SCIENCE PUBLISHING
DOI: 10.1139/cjfr-2017-0261

Keywords

carbon sequestration; carbon subsidy; continuous cover forestry; management regimes; optimal rotation; uneven-aged forestry

Categories

Funding

  1. Finnish Academy of Sciences

Ask authors/readers for more resources

We study the economics of carbon storage using a model that includes forest size structure and determines the choice between rotation forestry and continuous cover forestry. Optimal harvests may rely solely on thinning, implying infinite rotation and continuous cover forestry, or both thinning and clearcuts, implying finite rotation periods. Given several carbon prices and interest rates, we optimize the timing and intensity of thinnings along with the choice of management regime. In addition to the carbon storage in living trees, we include the carbon dynamics of dead trees and timber products. Forest growth is specified by an empirically validated transition matrix model for Norway spruce (Picea abies (L.) Karst.). The optimization problem is solved in its general dynamic form by applying bilevel optimization with gradient-based interior point methods and a genetic algorithm. Carbon pricing postpones thinnings, increases stand density by directing harvests to larger trees, and typically yields a regime shift from rotation forestry to continuous cover forestry. In continuous cover solutions, the steady-state harvesting interval and the diameter distribution of standing and harvested trees are sensitive to carbon price, implying that carbon pricing increases the sawlog ratio of timber yields. Additionally, we obtain relatively inexpensive stand-level marginal costs of carbon storage.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.4
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Forestry

Optimality of continuous cover vs. clear-cut regimes in managing forest resources

Olli Tahvonen, Janne Ramo

CANADIAN JOURNAL OF FOREST RESEARCH (2016)

Article Management

Optimal management of naturally regenerating uneven-aged forests

Ankur Sinha, Janne Ramo, Pekka Malo, Markku Kallio, Olli Tahvonen

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF OPERATIONAL RESEARCH (2017)

Article Economics

Optimal carbon storage in even- and uneven-aged forestry

Aino Assmuth, Olli Tahvonen

FOREST POLICY AND ECONOMICS (2018)

Article Economics

Economics of boreal conifer species in continuous cover and rotation forestry

Vesa-Pekka Parkatti, Aino Assmuth, Janne Ramo, Olli Tahvonen

FOREST POLICY AND ECONOMICS (2019)

Article Forestry

Economics of mixed-species forestry with ecosystem services

Olli Tahvonen, Janne Ramo, Mikko Monkkonen

CANADIAN JOURNAL OF FOREST RESEARCH (2019)

Article Forestry

Optimal Continuous Cover Forest Management with a Lower Bound Constraint on Dead Wood

Janne Ramo, Aino Assmuth, Olli Tahvonen

FOREST SCIENCE (2020)

Article Forestry

Profitability of continuous-cover forestry in Norway spruce dominated peatland forest and the role of water table

Artti Juutinen, Vladimir Shanin, Anssi Ahtikoski, Janne Ramo, Raisa Makipaa, Raija Laiho, Sakari Sarkkola, Ari Lauren, Timo Penttila, Hannu Hokka, Markku Saarinen

Summary: CCF is more profitable than RF in peatland forestry, especially with a 15-year harvest interval, although the overall profitability of CCF depends on the interest rate. There are many relatively profitable CCF harvesting alternatives in boreal spruce-dominated peatland forests.

CANADIAN JOURNAL OF FOREST RESEARCH (2021)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Development towards low carbon and sustainable agriculture in Finland is possible with moderate changes in land use and diets

Heikki Lehtonen, Janne Ramo

Summary: Food security, sustainability, and climate targets present challenges for agriculture and food sectors in many countries. Finland aims to achieve climate neutrality by 2035 and reducing agricultural greenhouse gas emissions is crucial. This paper explores how Finland can significantly decrease emissions while addressing other sustainability concerns. Results suggest that moderate changes in diets and land use can reduce emissions by over 40% by 2050 with support from productivity growth and policy changes.

SUSTAINABILITY SCIENCE (2023)

Article Environmental Studies

Towards climate targets with cropland afforestation - effect of subsidies on profitability

Janne Ramo, Boris Tupek, Heikki Lehtonen, Raisa Makipaa

Summary: Through the study of economic and ecological models based on Finnish conditions, we found that afforestation can be more profitable than low-income agriculture even without subsidies. On high-income farms, forestry is more profitable than agriculture if carbon is moderately subsidized and afforestation costs are low. Additional afforestation subsidies are needed for forestry to compete with agriculture when afforestation costs are high. In the case of very high agricultural income, forestry remains less profitable unless carbon subsidies or additional afforestation subsidies are very high.

LAND USE POLICY (2023)

Article Economics

Optimal Carbon Storage in Mixed-Species Size-Structured Forests

Aino Assmuth, Janne Ramo, Olli Tahvonen

Summary: This study extends the research on economically optimal carbon storage to mixed-species size-structured stands, using an ecological model and optimization methods to analyze carbon storage and timber revenues. The results show that carbon pricing can increase stand volume, promote tree species diversity, and lower the marginal cost of carbon storage with a higher number of tree species in a stand.

ENVIRONMENTAL & RESOURCE ECONOMICS (2021)

Article Economics

Optimizing the Harvest Timing in Continuous Cover Forestry

Janne Ramo, Olli Tahvonen

ENVIRONMENTAL & RESOURCE ECONOMICS (2017)

No Data Available