4.5 Review

Emerging investigators series: a critical review of decision support systems for water treatment: making the case for incorporating climate change and climate extremes

Journal

Publisher

ROYAL SOC CHEMISTRY
DOI: 10.1039/c6ew00121a

Keywords

-

Funding

  1. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency [R835865]
  2. EPA [R835865, 909756] Funding Source: Federal RePORTER

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Water treatment plants (WTPs) are tasked with providing safe potable water to consumers. However, WTPs face numerous potential obstacles, including changes in source water quality and quantity, financial burdens related to operations and upgrades, and stringent water quality regulations. Moreover, these challenges may be exacerbated by climate change in the form of long-term climatic perturbations and the increasing frequency and intensity of extreme weather events. To help WTPs overcome these issues, decision support systems (DSSs), which are used to aid and enhance the quality and consistency of decision-making, have been developed. This paper reviews the scientific literature on the development and application of DSSs for water treatment, including physically-based models, statistical models, and artificial intelligence techniques, and suggests future directions in the field. We first set the context of how water quality is impacted by climate change and extreme weather events. We then provide a comprehensive review of DSSs and conclude by offering a series of recommendations for future DSS efforts for WTPs, suggesting that these tools should (1) more accurately reflect the practical needs of WTPs, (2) represent the tradeoffs between the multiple competing objectives inherent to water treatment, (3) explicitly handle uncertainty to better inform decision makers, (4) incorporate nonstationarity, especially with regard to extreme weather events and climate change for long-term planning, and (5) use standardized terminology to accelerate the dissemination of knowledge in the field.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Engineering, Environmental

Decision Science Can Help Address the Challenges of Long-Term Planning in the Colorado River Basin

Rebecca Smith, Edith Zagona, Joseph Kasprzyk, Nathan Bonham, Elliot Alexander, Alan Butler, James Prairie, Carly Jerla

Summary: Deep uncertainty refers to planning contexts where likelihood of future conditions cannot be determined, conflicting objectives and unpredictable outcomes exist. Evidence of its relevance in the Colorado River Basin is seen in severe and unexpected drought, diverse stakeholders and viewpoints. Decision Making under Deep Uncertainty (DMDU) aims to address these challenges. Reclamation has explored DMDU since 2012, using adaptation, vulnerability and robustness concepts to design strategies for supply-demand imbalance. This article presents the basis for continued exploration of DMDU techniques and how ongoing studies can contribute to future planning efforts in the Colorado River Basin.

JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN WATER RESOURCES ASSOCIATION (2022)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

post-MORDM: Mapping policies to synthesize optimization and robustness results for decision-maker compromise

Nathan Bonham, Joseph Kasprzyk, Edith Zagona

Summary: This paper introduces a decision-support framework called post-MORDM, which addresses the challenges of generating a large number of policies and disagreements among decision-makers in Many Objective Robust Decision Making (MORDM). It uses the Self-Organizing Map (SOM) technology to cluster policies, discover salient characteristics, and assess cause-effect relationships, aiming to create a structured platform that encourages negotiation and compromise.

ENVIRONMENTAL MODELLING & SOFTWARE (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Satellites reveal widespread decline in global lake water storage

Fangfang Yao, Ben Livneh, Balaji Rajagopalan, Jida Wang, Jean-Francois Cretaux, Yoshihide Wada, Muriel Berge-Nguyen

Summary: This study finds that over the past few decades, approximately 53% of the largest 1,972 global lakes have experienced significant declines in water volume. The volume loss in natural lakes is primarily attributed to climate warming, increasing evaporative demand, and human water consumption, while sedimentation dominates storage losses in reservoirs. It is estimated that around one-quarter of the world's population resides in a basin of a drying lake, emphasizing the importance of incorporating climate change and sedimentation impacts into sustainable water resources management.

SCIENCE (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Can Remotely Sensed Snow Disappearance Explain Seasonal Water Supply?

Kaitlyn Bishay, Nels R. R. Bjarke, Parthkumar Modi, Justin M. M. Pflug, Ben Livneh

Summary: Understanding the relationship between remotely sensed snow disappearance and seasonal water supply is important for supplementing limited ground based measurements in a changing climate. A study investigated this relationship for 15 snow dominated basins across the western U.S. using satellite-derived Day of Snow Disappearance (DSD) and April-July total streamflow volume. The study found a significant relationship between DSD and water supply, with satellite-based models showing better prediction skill than in-situ-based models.

WATER (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Recent decreases in snow water storage in western North America

Katherine E. Hale, Keith S. Jennings, Keith N. Musselman, Ben Livneh, Noah P. Molotch

Summary: Mountain snowpacks serve as natural water storage, but the Snow Storage Index (SSI) has shown a decrease in western North America since 1950 due to earlier snowmelt, spring rains, and reduced winter precipitation. The SSI measures the delay in water input from the timing of a melting snowpack, offering insights into hydrologic sensitivity to climate change and its implications for water resources and ecosystems.

COMMUNICATIONS EARTH & ENVIRONMENT (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Estimating Reservoir Sedimentation Rates and Storage Capacity Losses Using High-Resolution Sentinel-2 Satellite and Water Level Data

Fangfang Yao, J. Toby Minear, Balaji Rajagopalan, Chao Wang, Kehan Yang, Ben Livneh

Summary: In nearly all reservoirs, storage capacity is lost due to sediment accumulation, and the sedimentation rates are poorly understood. In this study, a novel approach is proposed to estimate reservoir sedimentation rates and storage capacity losses using satellite images and water level data. The approach is validated on eight reservoirs in the United States and shows good accuracy in estimating the bathymetry and sedimentation rates.

GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2023)

Editorial Material Engineering, Civil

Guiding Questions for Water Resources Systems Analysis Research

Joseph Kasprzyk, Margaret Garcia

JOURNAL OF WATER RESOURCES PLANNING AND MANAGEMENT (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Effects of Snow Water Storage on Hydrologic Partitioning Across the Mountainous, Western United States

K. E. Hale, K. N. Musselman, A. J. Newman, B. Livneh, N. P. Molotch

Summary: In the mountainous western United States, a warming climate is causing a decrease in the fraction of precipitation falling as snow and a shift in the timing of snowmelt, leading to uncertain impacts on the distribution of water between evapotranspiration and streamflow. By using a Snow Storage Index (SSI) and a Budyko-based framework, this study found that greater snow water storage was associated with greater hydrologic partitioning to streamflow in several mountainous areas. The retention and release of stored snow water during the summer months plays a significant role in water distribution. If SSI decreases with future warming, it will have substantial implications for ecosystems and water supplies in the western U.S.

WATER RESOURCES RESEARCH (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Ensemble of CMIP6 derived reference and potential evapotranspiration with radiative and advective components

Nels Bjarke, Joseph Barsugli, Ben Livneh

Summary: Assessing changes in future aridity requires an understanding of variations in the atmospheric demand for water. Here we describe the development and validation of a dataset of global monthly estimates of ET0, ETP, and vapor pressure deficit from CMIP6 projections. Overall, evaporative demand is projected to increase across all emissions scenarios, with the largest increases over polar regions and a larger contribution from advection in regions with higher baseline ET0.

SCIENTIFIC DATA (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Interactions between thresholds and spatial discretizations of snow: insights from estimates of wolverine denning habitat in the Colorado Rocky Mountains

Justin M. Pflug, Yiwen Fang, Steven A. Margulis, Ben Livneh

Summary: Thresholds can be useful for interpreting environmental data, but they may vary when applied to different datasets or time periods. This study examines the impact of different spatial discretizations of snow on estimates of wolverine denning opportunities. The results show that snow thresholds are important but may not capture the full variability in snow-adapted wildlife denning opportunities.

HYDROLOGY AND EARTH SYSTEM SCIENCES (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

A data-driven evaluation of post-fire landslide susceptibility

Elsa S. Culler, Ben Livneh, Balaji Rajagopalan, Kristy F. Tiampo

Summary: Wildfires change hydrologic and geomorphic response, leading to additional hazards and challenges. This study evaluates the trigger characteristics of post-wildfire mass movement by comparing precipitation before events in burned and unburned locations. The results show that mass movements in burned sites are preceded by less precipitation, supporting the hypothesis that fire increases rainfall-driven mass movement hazards. Additionally, there are differences in the seasonality of mass movements between burned and unburned locations.

NATURAL HAZARDS AND EARTH SYSTEM SCIENCES (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Performance of Regression and Artificial Neural Network Models, Informed with an In Situ Sensor Network, in Forecasting Groundwater Abstraction in the Central Valley, California

Melanie Holland, Ben Livneh, Evan Thomas

Summary: This study develops a groundwater abstraction forecast model using in situ groundwater abstraction data, hydrologic, and climatic data. Artificial neural network models outperform other model algorithms and can reliably predict groundwater abstraction. The model performs best on a monthly time step and forecasts are reliable within a two-month lead time. Regional heterogeneity may introduce error into the model.

ACS ES&T WATER (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Evaluation of a new observationally based channel parameterization for the National Water Model

Aaron Heldmyer, Ben Livneh, James McCreight, Laura Read, Joseph Kasprzyk, Toby Minear

Summary: Accurate representation of channel properties is crucial for forecasting in hydrologic models. However, there is considerable uncertainty in the parameterization of channel geometry and hydraulic roughness in the NOAA National Water Model due to data scarcity. This study aims to improve channel representativeness by updating channel geometry and roughness parameters using a large, previously unpublished hydraulic geometry dataset.

HYDROLOGY AND EARTH SYSTEM SCIENCES (2022)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Incorporating thermoelectric power plant water use into multi-objective optimal power flow

Jacob Kravits, Joseph R. Kasprzyk, Kyri Baker, Ashlynn S. Stillwell

Summary: This paper presents a novel formulation of the optimal power flow problem, aiming to minimize cost, water withdrawal, and water consumption. The formulation is applied in a realistic case study using global mapping and ranking sensitivity analyses, providing insights into vulnerabilities and potential issues in power systems.

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH: INFRASTRUCTURE AND SUSTAINABILITY (2022)

No Data Available