4.5 Article

A critical analysis of the improved Clarke and Wright savings algorithm

Journal

Publisher

WILEY
DOI: 10.1111/itor.12443

Keywords

optimization; combinatorial optimization; heuristics

Ask authors/readers for more resources

In their paper An improved Clarke and Wright savings algorithm for the capacitated vehicle routing problem, published in ScienceAsia (38, 3, 307-318, 2012), Pichpibul and Kawtummachai developed a simple stochastic extension of the well-known Clarke and Wright savings heuristic for the capacitated vehicle routing problem. Notwithstanding the simplicity of the heuristic, which they call the improved Clarke and Wright savings algorithm (ICW), the reported results are among the best heuristics ever developed for this problem. Through a careful reimplementation, we demonstrate that the results published in the paper could not have been produced by the ICW heuristic. Studying the reasons how this paper could have passed the peer review process to be published in an ISI-ranked journal, we have to conclude that the necessary conditions for a thorough examination of a typical paper in the field of optimization are generally lacking. We investigate how this can be improved and come to the conclusion that disclosing source code to reviewers should become a prerequisite for publication.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Management

Integrating partner objectives in horizontal logistics optimisation models

Christof Defryn, Kenneth Sorensen, Wout Dullaert

OMEGA-INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT SCIENCE (2019)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

What makes a VRP solution good? The generation of problem-specific knowledge for heuristics

Florian Arnold, Kenneth Sorensen

COMPUTERS & OPERATIONS RESEARCH (2019)

Article Management

Pushing frontiers in auction-based transport collaborations

Margaretha Gansterer, Richard F. Hartl, Kenneth Sorensen

OMEGA-INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT SCIENCE (2020)

Article Management

A multilevel evaluation method for heuristics with an application to the VRPTW

J. Corstjens, B. Depaire, A. Caris, K. Sorensen

INTERNATIONAL TRANSACTIONS IN OPERATIONAL RESEARCH (2020)

Article Management

Large neighborhood search for the bike request scheduling problem

Nicholas Vergeylen, Kenneth Sorensen, Pieter Vansteenwegen

INTERNATIONAL TRANSACTIONS IN OPERATIONAL RESEARCH (2020)

Editorial Material Operations Research & Management Science

Comments on: Shared resources in collaborative vehicle routing

Kenneth Sorensen

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

A progressive filtering heuristic for the location-routing problem and variants

Florian Arnold, Kenneth Soerensen

Summary: This study introduces an efficient and effective heuristic for the LRP, which reduces the solution space by estimating an upper bound for the number of open depots and iteratively applying routing heuristic to each remaining depot configuration. The progressive filtering framework quickly detects unpromising configurations, and a good design combining coarse and fine filters outperforms existing heuristics on various instances.

COMPUTERS & OPERATIONS RESEARCH (2021)

Article Computer Science, Artificial Intelligence

A matheuristic for the stochastic facility location problem

Renata Turkes, Kenneth Sorensen, Daniel Palhazi Cuervo

Summary: The paper presents a matheuristic approach to solve the stochastic facility location problem, optimizing the storage facility configuration to minimize unmet demand and response time. Numerical experiments show the effectiveness and efficiency of the method, particularly for tackling larger instances.

JOURNAL OF HEURISTICS (2021)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

The joint order batching and picker routing problem: Modelled and solved as a clustered vehicle routing problem

Babiche Aerts, Trijntje Cornelissens, Kenneth Soerensen

Summary: The research focuses on the joint order batching and picker routing problem (JOBPRP) in a warehouse environment, using a two-level variable neighborhood search (2level-VNS) metaheuristic algorithm. Comparing different batching criteria, it is concluded that the minimum aisles criterion is more suitable for JOBPRP in warehouse contexts.

COMPUTERS & OPERATIONS RESEARCH (2021)

Article Management

Meta-analysis of metaheuristics: Quantifying the effect of adaptiveness in adaptive large neighborhood search

Renata Turkes, Kenneth Sorensen, Lars Magnus Hvattum

Summary: This paper promotes meta-analysis as a more suitable way to gain problem- and implementation-independent insights on metaheuristics. The research shows that adding an adaptive layer in adaptive large neighborhood search algorithms can improve objective function value slightly, but it also adds complexity and should therefore be recommended in specific situations only.

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF OPERATIONAL RESEARCH (2021)

Article Transportation Science & Technology

A large neighborhood search algorithm to optimize a demand-responsive feeder service

Bryan David Galarza Montenegro, Kenneth Sorensen, Pieter Vansteenwegen

Summary: Feeder services are discussed in two forms: on-demand service and traditional service. Experimental results show that demand-responsive feeder service demonstrates higher service quality compared to traditional service.

TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH PART C-EMERGING TECHNOLOGIES (2021)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Data for a meta-analysis of the adaptive layer in adaptive large neighborhood search

Renata Turkes, Kenneth Sorensen, Lars Magnus Hvattum, Eva Barrena, Hayet Chentli, Leandro C. Coelho, Iman Dayarian, Axel Grimault, Anders N. Gullhav, Cagatay Iris, Merve Keskin, Alexander Kiefer, Richard Martin Lusby, Geraldo Regis Mauri, Marcela Monroy-Licht, Sophie N. Parragh, Juan-Pablo Riquelme-Rodriguez, Alberto Santini, Vinicius Gandra Martins Santos, Charles Thomas

DATA IN BRIEF (2020)

Article Operations Research & Management Science

Pre-positioning of emergency supplies: does putting a price on human life help to save lives?

Renata Turkes, Daniel Palhazi Cuervo, Kenneth Sorensen

ANNALS OF OPERATIONS RESEARCH (2019)

Article Management

Instances for the problem of pre-positioning emergency supplies

Renata Turkes, Kenneth Sorensen

JOURNAL OF HUMANITARIAN LOGISTICS AND SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT (2019)

Article Management

Comparison of four mechanisms for request exchange in collaborative transportation

Daniel Nicola

Summary: This paper presents frameworks for auction-based and posted price mechanisms for exchanging requests between carriers operating in the same geographical areas. Results show that individual auction-based mechanisms provide similar results to centralized auction-based mechanisms, both outperforming posted price mechanisms.

INTERNATIONAL TRANSACTIONS IN OPERATIONAL RESEARCH (2024)