4.5 Article

Role of Third Bodies in Friction and Wear of Cold-Sprayed Ti and Ti-TiC Composite Coatings

Journal

TRIBOLOGY LETTERS
Volume 65, Issue 3, Pages -

Publisher

SPRINGER/PLENUM PUBLISHERS
DOI: 10.1007/s11249-017-0899-4

Keywords

Cold spray; Ti matrix composite; Third bodies; In situ tribometry; Friction; TiC

Funding

  1. Canadian Foundation for Innovation (CFI) Project [8246]
  2. CFI Leader's Opportunity Fund [13029]
  3. Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council (NSERC) Strategic Grants Program

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Titanium (Ti) and Ti-based alloy wear performance is often poor unless coating or lubricants are used. An alternative is to use hard phase reinforcement. Cold spray is a relatively new method to deposit composite coatings, where here we report the deposition of a Ti-TiC coating and its sliding wear behavior. Mixtures of mechanically blended Ti-TiC with various TiC content were injected into a de Laval nozzle and sprayed onto substrates. Two composite coatings and a pure Ti coating are reported here, where the as-sprayed compositions of the composites were 13.8 and 33.4 vol% TiC. Reciprocating dry sliding wear was performed using a custom-built in situ tribometer. All tests were conducted with a sliding speed of 3 mm/s and at a normal load of 0.5 N. Using a transparent sapphire hemisphere of 6.25 mm as counterface, dynamic behavior of third bodies was directly observed. It was found that adhesive transfer of Ti was the primary wear mechanism for the Ti coating, with oxidative and abrasive wear also occurring for longer sliding cycles. The superior wear resistance of the composite coatings compared to Ti was related to dual function of TiC particles, where they reinforced the Ti matrix and facilitated the formation of a stable and protective tribofilms. The tribofilms contained carbonaceous material that provided easier shear and lower friction. The formation of these tribofilms was highly dependent on the TiC particles, which contained excess carbon compared to the equilibrium composition. Higher TiC content was more effective in quickly developing and sustaining the tribofilms.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Mechanical properties and wear resistance of industrial bearing liners in concentrated boundary-lubricated sliding

Alexandre R. C. Nascimento, Richard R. Chromik, Robert Schulz

Summary: This study investigated the friction and wear behavior of three materials commonly used in industrial bearing applications: a Sn-based Babbitt, polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE), and a polyether ether ketone (PEEK) composite. The effects of load and sliding velocities on wear rates were evaluated by regression analysis, with a focus on the relationship between wear and materials mechanical properties. The ranking of wear performance correlated most strongly with the ratio of hardness to reduced modulus, with implications for estimating oil film thickness in lubrication regimes.
Article Engineering, Mechanical

Sliding wear behavior of cold-sprayed Ni-WC composite coatings: Influence OF WC content

Sima A. Alidokht, Richard R. Chromik

Summary: Metal matrix composites reinforced with WC particles and Co or Ni matrices are known for their unique combination of hardness, toughness, and superior wear performance. This study focused on Ni-WCNi composite coatings and found that coatings with higher WC fill ratios displayed better wear resistance due to the uniform distribution of WC particles and shorter mean free path reducing adhesive wear. However, at higher loads, subsurface crack propagation at WC particle interfaces led to a reduction in the protective role of mechanically mixed layers. Scratch tests were used to qualitatively compare coating cohesion strengths and correlate them to wear properties.
Article Engineering, Mechanical

High temperature sliding wear behavior and mechanisms of cold-sprayed Ti and Ti-TiC composite coatings

M. Koricherla, T. B. Torgerson, S. A. Alidokht, V. N. V. Munagala, R. R. Chromik, T. W. Scharf

Summary: Ti and Ti-based alloys are commonly used in aerospace and automotive components, but face challenges in wear resistance at elevated temperatures. The study found that Ti-xTiC composite coatings exhibit improved friction and wear performance compared to baseline Ti coatings, with Ti-35%TiC showing the best overall performance at 575 degrees C. The tribological behavior was attributed to the formation of stable oxide layers on the wear surfaces containing TiO2, WO3, and CoWO4.
Article Materials Science, Coatings & Films

The role of metal powder properties on the tribology of cold sprayed Ti6Al4V-TiC metal matrix composites

Venkata Naga Vamsi Munagala, Richard R. Chromik

Summary: Ti6Al4V-TiC metal matrix composite (MMC) coatings were cold sprayed using spherical and irregular Ti6Al4V powders with plasma gas atomization and the Armstrong process, respectively. Composite coatings deposited using irregular powders exhibit higher ceramic retentions and lower porosity compared to those made with spherical powder. In wear tests, irregular powder composites showed resistance to abrasive wear mechanisms with lower coefficients of friction and wear rates due to the presence of islands of tribolayers, while increasing ceramic content led to even lower wear rates and continuous tribolayer formation at higher loads. The formation of tribolayers resulted in coarser-grain microstructures in the worn subsurface, indicating less stress transfer and lower wear rates.

SURFACE & COATINGS TECHNOLOGY (2021)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Effect of Al and Cd sacrificial coatings on the wear of steel substrates

Priyadarshi Behera, Richard R. Chromik, Stephen Yue

Summary: The study showed that changes in relative humidity and coating type have a 10-fold difference in wear rate of the steel substrate. The Cd coating decreases substrate wear, while the Al coating increases it. Residual third bodies, which were oxides and hydroxides of the coating, affect the wear process of the steel substrate after coating wear-through.
Article Engineering, Mechanical

Short-time exposure oxidation studies on multi-component coatings and their influence on tribological behavior

B. C. N. M. de Castilho, N. Sharifi, S. A. Alidokht, K. Harrington, P. Stoyanov, C. Moreau, R. R. Chromik

Summary: NiCr-Cr2O3-Ag-BaF2/CaF2 (PS304) and NiMoAl-Cr2O3-Ag-BaF2/CaF2 (PS400) coatings exhibit low wear and friction at temperatures ranging from 25 to 700 degrees C. However, the formation of small precipitates in high temperatures due to expansion of NiCr matrix component can pose challenges for coating integrity in gas turbine applications. Experimental evidence suggests that the precipitates are formed by fluorine diffusing from fluorides to NiCr, driven by oxidation of the fluorides to form BaCrO4 and CaCrO4. PS400 coatings show superior thermal stability and wear resistance compared to PS304 coatings under tested conditions.
Review Materials Science, Coatings & Films

Factors Affecting Adhesion in Metal/Ceramic Interfaces Created by Cold Spray

Sara I. Imbriglio, Richard R. Chromik

Summary: Research on metal/ceramic interfaces created by cold spray is expanding due to their interesting applications, where adhesion of particles is achieved by high-speed impact while remaining in the solid state. The combination of mechanical interlocking and physicochemical interactions is considered crucial for adhesion, with the formation and contribution of physicochemical interactions remaining of interest.

JOURNAL OF THERMAL SPRAY TECHNOLOGY (2021)

Article Chemistry, Physical

Effect of metal powder properties on the deposition characteristics of cold-sprayed Ti6Al4V-TiC coatings: An experimental and finite element study

Venkata Naga Vamsi Munagala, Rohan Chakrabarty, Jun Song, Richard R. Chromik

Summary: By adjusting the properties of metal powders, such as surface morphology and porosity, MMCs with higher ceramic retentions can be deposited using the cold spray process, affecting the quality of the coatings.

SURFACES AND INTERFACES (2021)

Article Materials Science, Coatings & Films

Wear resistant solid lubricating coatings via compression molding and thermal spraying technologies

Samantha Michelle Gateman, Sima Ahmad Alidokht, Emmanuel Mena-Morcillo, Robert Schulz, Richard R. Chromik, Anne-Marie Kietzig, Ivan P. Parkin, Janine Mauzeroll

Summary: This work combines thermal spray and compression molding methods to create wear-resistant and solid-lubricating composite coatings suitable for high load applications. The coatings fabricated on SS444 substrates consist of a mixture of PTFE and PI, with the addition of graphite to lower material costs and increase load capacity. The coatings show low wear rates and coefficient of frictions, with the influence of graphite on wear properties found to be minimal.

SURFACE & COATINGS TECHNOLOGY (2021)

Article Materials Science, Coatings & Films

Microstructural and Tribological Behavior of Thermal Spray CrMnFeCoNi High Entropy Alloy Coatings

Payank Patel, Sima A. Alidokht, Navid Sharifi, Amit Roy, Kelly Harrington, Pantcho Stoyanov, Richard R. Chromik, Christian Moreau

Summary: High entropy alloys (HEAs), characterized by containing five or more principal elements, are considered as potential candidates for high-temperature applications due to their superior mechanical and thermal properties. In this study, the microstructure and wear behavior of CrMnFeCoNi HEA coatings were evaluated, revealing equivalent behavior of as sprayed and annealed coatings on polished surfaces and higher wear rates on rough surfaces.

JOURNAL OF THERMAL SPRAY TECHNOLOGY (2022)

Review Chemistry, Physical

Tribological Performance of High-Entropy Coatings (HECs): A Review

Payank Patel, Amit Roy, Navid Sharifi, Pantcho Stoyanov, Richard R. Chromik, Christian Moreau

Summary: This review article discusses the synthesis methods, microstructural characteristics, and tribological performance of high-entropy coatings (HECs). HECs exhibit favorable mechanical and tribological properties at high temperatures.

MATERIALS (2022)

Article Materials Science, Multidisciplinary

Mechanical Properties and Residual Stress Measurement of TiN/Ti Duplex Coating Using HiPIMS TiN on Cold Spray Ti

Nhat Minh Dang, Wen-Yen Lin, Zhao-Ying Wang, Sima Ahmad Alidokht, Richard R. Chromik, Terry Yuan-Fang Chen, Ming-Tzer Lin

Summary: This study investigated the mechanical properties and residual stress of high-power impulse magnetron sputtering (HiPIMS) titanium nitride (TiN) thin film capping on a cold spray titanium (Ti) coating. The results showed that the TiN/Ti duplex coating exhibited excellent mechanical properties, and the residual stresses did not significantly change with different Ti cold spray substrates, indicating the feasibility of coating technology in the aerospace industry.

COATINGS (2022)

Article Materials Science, Multidisciplinary

Microstructure and mechanical properties of Tribaloy coatings deposited by high-velocity oxygen fuel

S. A. Alidokht, Y. Gao, B. C. N. M. de Castilho, N. Sharifi, M. Harfouche, P. Stoyanov, M. Makowiec, C. Moreau, R. R. Chromik

Summary: In this study, two Co-based Tribaloy powders were coated on mild steel substrate using high-velocity oxygen fuel (HVOF) spraying. The microstructure and distribution of Laves phases in the coatings were investigated. It was found that Co3Mo2Si and Co3Mo were the main constituents of the intermetallic Laves phases in the sprayed coatings. The volume fraction of Laves phases in the coatings was significantly lower compared to similar alloys due to high cooling rate and solidification in HVOF. The Laves-free solid solution exhibited a nano-crystalline microstructure with similar local hardness to the Laves phases.

JOURNAL OF MATERIALS SCIENCE (2022)

Article Materials Science, Coatings & Films

Friction and wear behavior of suspension plasma sprayed tantalum oxide coatings at elevated temperatures

Amit Roy, Venkata Naga Vamsi Munagala, Payank Patel, Navid Sharifi, Sima A. Alidokht, Mary Makowiec, Richard R. Chromik, Christian Moreau, Pantcho Stoyanov

Summary: Tantalum oxide-based coatings have been developed by suspension plasma spraying and their tribological behavior at high temperatures has been evaluated. The coatings exhibit uniform and dense nanostructure with no phase transformation. The friction coefficient of the coatings decreases slightly from 0.9 at 25 degrees C to 0.8 at 300 degrees C, while the wear rate decreases by more than 50%. The decrease in friction and wear at elevated temperatures is attributed to the formation of a smooth continuous layer and a stable transfer film.

SURFACE & COATINGS TECHNOLOGY (2023)

Article Engineering, Mechanical

Room and elevated temperature sliding wear of high velocity oxy-fuel sprayed Diamalloy3001 coatings

Venkata Naga Vamsi Munagala, Sima A. Alidokht, Navid Sharifi, Mary E. Makowiec, Pantcho Stoyanov, Christian Moreau, Richard R. Chromik

Summary: CoMoCrSi alloys with intermetallic Laves phases exhibit high hardness and excellent wear resistance. Diamalloy3001 coatings deposited using HVOF spraying process showed low wear rates at room temperature due to the formation of tribolayers composed of Co, Cr, and Mo oxides. However, at elevated temperatures, detachment of tribolayers and formation of cavities increased the wear rates.

TRIBOLOGY INTERNATIONAL (2023)

No Data Available