4.6 Article

Institutional issues in planning for more uncertain futures

Journal

TRANSPORTATION
Volume 46, Issue 4, Pages 1075-1092

Publisher

SPRINGER
DOI: 10.1007/s11116-017-9805-z

Keywords

Forecasting; Uncertainty; Planning; Futures; Institutions

Funding

  1. DEMAND Centre - Research Councils UK [EP/K011723/1]
  2. US-UK Fulbright Commission
  3. EPSRC [EP/K011723/1] Funding Source: UKRI

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Future travel demand has always been difficult to estimate. Recent trends of a slow down or stagnation in traffic growth combined with substantial demographic, economic, and technological shifts further complicate that task. This poses a significant planning challenge given that decision-making is often based on the benefits of infrastructure investments which accrue over periods as long as 60 years. In contrast to the changing ideas around what mobility in the future will look like and the types of demand it may need to service, the practice of forecasting future travel demand remains largely unchanged as do the decision-making processes which flow from this. Alternative approaches to thinking about futures such as scenario planning exist but have had more limited deployment in the transport sector. This paper explores the institutional issues surrounding the purpose, practice and barriers to changing the approaches of forecasting and decision-making through an exploration of the state of practice in the UK drawing on interviews with 23 practitioners. Drawing on Hall's work on policy change, the research finds that there is a strong policy paradigm built around the relationships between transport investment and traffic growth. This has strengthened since the recession with an increased focus on the relationship between transport and job creation. The forecasting approaches in use today are an important part of a complex decision-making apparatus reflective of specialized policy arenas like transport. Challenges in acknowledging, representing and communicating uncertainty are identified leaving a growing tension between planning visions and planning practice. We conclude by reflecting on events which may stimulate a broader reframing of how we plan for transport futures whilst embracing key uncertainties.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.6
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Engineering, Civil

Opening out and closing down: the treatment of uncertainty in transport planning's forecasting paradigm

Glenn Lyons, Greg Marsden

Summary: This paper examines the incorporation of uncertainty into decision-making through a case study of the Department for Transport in England, highlighting the need for a balance between technical depth and analytical breadth. It suggests a new approach to opening out and closing down uncertainties in transport decision-making, emphasizing the importance of opening up processes for reaching technical advice and negotiating uncertainties.

TRANSPORTATION (2021)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Behind the Targets? The Case for Coherence in a Multi-Scalar Approach to Carbon Action Plans in the Transport Sector

Greg Marsden, Jillian Anable

Summary: This paper emphasizes the need for radical action across all policy sectors as required by the Paris Agreement. Without a clear framework that considers interactions across spatial scales, policy responses will be incoherent and inadequate. Through a case study of the transport sector in the UK, key elements such as budget coherence, accounting coherence, and policy coherence are highlighted for setting out a new framework.

SUSTAINABILITY (2021)

Article Economics

Mega-disruptions and policy change: Lessons from the mobility sector in response to the Covid-19 pandemic in the UK

Greg Marsden, Iain Docherty

Summary: The paper examines the possibility for significant policy changes in the transport sector in England and Scotland due to the Coronavirus pandemic. While some policy commitments have been accelerated, the government's capacity for radical policy adaptation has been limited under the stress of the pandemic. The crisis is seen as a potential disruptor to existing trajectories in terms of business practices, industry structures, ways of working, and public finances.

TRANSPORT POLICY (2021)

Article Social Issues

Public acceptance of the use of drones for logistics: The state of play and moving towards more informed debate

Angela Smith, Janet E. Dickinson, Greg Marsden, Tom Cherrett, Andrew Oakey, Matt Grote

Summary: This paper critically examines the research on public acceptance of drones, finding that the conflation of diverse drone applications has caused ambiguity in concerns and the absence of clear parameters for drone use in local transport environments has limited informed public opinion. Studies that build familiarity and understanding of practical drone use show potential for positive outcomes. The paper calls for further research to build understanding of drones within transport environments to facilitate more informed debates among stakeholders to shape future transport provision.

TECHNOLOGY IN SOCIETY (2022)

Article Energy & Fuels

Energy demand reduction options for meeting national zero-emission targets in the United Kingdom

John Barrett, Steve Pye, Sam Betts-Davies, Oliver Broad, James Price, Nick Eyre, Jillian Anable, Christian Brand, George Bennett, Rachel Carr-Whitworth, Alice Garvey, Jannik Giesekam, Greg Marsden, Jonathan Norman, Tadj Oreszczyn, Paul Ruyssevelt, Kate Scott

Summary: Research suggests that reducing energy demand can reduce reliance on carbon removal technologies, have moderate investment requirements, and increase climate ambition. National policies should prioritize energy demand reduction measures.

NATURE ENERGY (2022)

Article Transportation

Sharing airspace with Uncrewed Aerial Vehicles (UAVs): Views of the General Aviation (GA) community

Matt Grote, Aliaksei Pilko, James Scanlan, Tom Cherrett, Janet Dickinson, Angela Smith, Andrew Oakey, Greg Marsden

Summary: This study analyzed concerns and issues regarding the shared airspace concept by conducting an interactive online workshop with participants from the General Aviation (GA) community in the UK. The findings highlighted the need for aircraft to be equipped with Detect-And-Avoid (DAA) systems and the importance of developing equitable regulatory and technology environments for managing shared airspace.

JOURNAL OF AIR TRANSPORT MANAGEMENT (2022)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Road safety in Nigeria: unravelling the challenges, measures, and strategies for improvement

Chinebuli Uzondu, Samantha Jamson, Greg Marsden

Summary: The study highlights the challenges facing road safety improvement in Nigeria, including poor road design, organization and enforcement of legislation, road user behavior, and inadequate research. Stakeholders generally view public education and information campaigns as highly effective and easy to implement measures.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF INJURY CONTROL AND SAFETY PROMOTION (2022)

Article Urban Studies

The case for 'public' transport in the age of automated mobility

Iain Docherty, John Stone, Carey Curtis, Claus Hedegaard Sorensen, Alexander Paulsson, Crystal Legacy, Greg Marsden

Summary: This paper discusses the profound impact of Connected and Autonomous Vehicles (CAVs) on the 'publicness' of urban transportation and mobility systems, and presents key challenges that policy makers need to address when introducing CAVs.

CITIES (2022)

Article Geography

Analysing multilevel governance dynamics in India: exercising hierarchy through the Smart Cities Mission

Louise Reardon, Gregory Marsden, Morgan Campbell, Sanjay Gupta, Ashish Verma

Summary: This paper empirically analyzes the impact of Narendra Modi's claim of 'more governance, less government' in practice in India through a qualitative case study of the Smart Cities Mission implemented in four cities. The study applies multilevel governance theorizing and reveals centralizing dynamics through the use of 'special purpose vehicles' that bypass local-level institutions. It argues that institutional design can shape multilevel governance dynamics and raises concerns about the long-term risks for democratic development.

TERRITORY POLITICS GOVERNANCE (2022)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Steering Smart Mobility Services: Lessons from Seattle, Greater Manchester and Stockholm

Ioanna Moscholidou, Greg Marsden, Kate Pangbourne

Summary: This paper examines the governance of smart mobility services in the early stages of their introduction in three cities: Seattle, Greater Manchester, and Stockholm. Despite limited steering capacity, cities assume that smart mobility will bring social, environmental, and economic benefits. Although the full potential of smart mobility is yet to be realized, these new services are changing mobility patterns in cities. Clear accountability arrangements between the public and private sectors are necessary for a collaborative governance approach, where shared goals can be identified and maximized.

SUSTAINABILITY (2023)

Article Business

Lessons from highway management reforms in a less developed province in China

Siyi Lin, Greg Marsden, Kate Pangbourne, Qiyang Liu

Summary: This article examines the conflict between national imaginaries of market reforms for fast-growing Chinese regions and embedded governance practices in less developed provinces. It also explores the role of institutional change and persistence using path dependence and junctures as an organizing lens. The study finds that political and administrative factors are more influential than economic and technical factors in transport management and institutional processes in China's less developed provinces.

RESEARCH IN TRANSPORTATION BUSINESS AND MANAGEMENT (2023)

Article Remote Sensing

Pathways to Unsegregated Sharing of Airspace: Views of the Uncrewed Aerial Vehicle (UAV) Industry

Matt Grote, Aliaksei Pilko, James Scanlan, Tom Cherrett, Janet Dickinson, Angela Smith, Andy Oakey, Greg Marsden

Summary: The UAV industry is expanding rapidly, leading to challenges in sharing airspace with existing crewed aircraft activities. Stakeholder engagement is crucial for the co-development of a shared airspace solution that is widely acceptable. Key issues include the need for a reliable detect-and-avoid system and support from the wider aviation community.

DRONES (2021)

Article Economics

Studying disruptive events: Innovations in behaviour, opportunities for lower carbon transport policy?

Greg Marsden, Jillian Anable, Tim Chatterton, Iain Docherty, James Faulconbridge, Lesley Murray, Helen Roby, Jeremy Shires

TRANSPORT POLICY (2020)

Article Ergonomics

Work, ICT and travel in multinational corporations: the synthetic work mobility situation

James Faulconbridge, Ian Jones, Greg Marsden, Jillian Anable

NEW TECHNOLOGY WORK AND EMPLOYMENT (2020)

Article Political Science

Exploring the role of the state in the depoliticisation of UK transport policy

Louise Reardon, Greg Marsden

POLICY AND POLITICS (2020)

No Data Available