4.4 Article

What the novel ecosystem concept provides: a reply to Kattan et al

Journal

RESTORATION ECOLOGY
Volume 25, Issue 4, Pages 488-490

Publisher

WILEY
DOI: 10.1111/rec.12530

Keywords

decision trees; ecological restoration; historical conditions; proof of concept; restoration terminology

Categories

Funding

  1. Division Of Environmental Biology
  2. Direct For Biological Sciences [1235828] Funding Source: National Science Foundation

Ask authors/readers for more resources

The novel ecosystem concept expands the restoration palette by focusing our attention on what is possible when recovery to an historical pre-disturbance condition is not. Although some elements of the concept have long been accepted in restoration circles, the novel ecosystem framework brings these elements to the fore. There is a growing frustration with restoration prescriptions that above all else emphasize native species and historical trajectories, and there is a clear need for alternatives that recognize real limitations to achieving these goals in at least some instances. Though not perfect, the novel ecosystem framework represents such an alternative.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.4
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Ecology

Generalized and Specific State-and-Transition Models to Guide Management and Restoration of Caldenal Forests

H. Raul Peinetti, Brandon T. Bestelmeyer, Claudia C. Chirino, Alicia G. Kin, Maria E. Frank Buss

RANGELAND ECOLOGY & MANAGEMENT (2019)

Article Environmental Sciences

Prioritizing land for investments based on short- and long-term land potential and degradation risk: A strategic approach

Jeffrey E. Herrick, Jason Neff, Amy Quandt, Shawn Salley, Jon Maynard, Amy Ganguli, Brandon Bestelmeyer

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY (2019)

Article Ecology

The effect of small mammal exclusion on grassland recovery from disturbance in the Chihuahuan Desert

Lauren N. Svejcar, Brandon T. Bestelmeyer, Darren K. James, Debra P. C. Peters

JOURNAL OF ARID ENVIRONMENTS (2019)

Article Ecology

Does habitat disturbance promote geographical parthenogenesis in whiptail lizards?

Bradley J. Cosentino, Robert L. Schooley, Brandon T. Bestelmeyer, Herman Campos, Laura M. Burkett

EVOLUTIONARY ECOLOGY (2019)

Article Biology

Traversing the Wasteland: A Framework for Assessing Ecological Threats to Drylands

David L. Hoover, Brandon Bestelmeyer, Nancy B. Grimm, Travis E. Huxman, Sasha C. Reed, Osvaldo Sala, Timothy R. Seastedt, Hailey Wilmer, Scott Ferrenberg

BIOSCIENCE (2020)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Indicators and benchmarks for wind erosion monitoring, assessment and management

Nicholas P. Webb, Emily Kachergis, Scott W. Miller, Sarah E. McCord, Brandon T. Bestelmeyer, Joel R. Brown, Adrian Chappell, Brandon L. Edwards, Jeffrey E. Herrick, Jason W. Karl, John F. Leys, Loretta J. Metz, Stephen Smarik, John Tatarko, Justin W. Van Zee, Greg Zwicke

ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS (2020)

Article Computer Science, Information Systems

Scaling Up Agricultural Research With Artificial Intelligence

Brandon T. Bestelmeyer, Guillermo Marcillo, Sarah E. McCord, Steven Mirsky, Glenn Moglen, Lisa G. Neven, Debra Peters, Clement Sohoulande, Tewodros Wakie

IT PROFESSIONAL (2020)

Article Ecology

Exotic oryx interact with shrub encroachment in the Chihuahuan Desert

Kieran J. Andreoni, Casey J. Wagnon, Brandon T. Bestelmeyer, Robert L. Schooley

Summary: The introduced African oryx in the Chihuahuan Desert of southern New Mexico has been found to prefer unencroached grasslands, especially during drier years, and exhibit peak activity during crepuscular periods. This behavior may contribute to shrub encroachment and potentially impact livestock production and ecosystem services.

JOURNAL OF ARID ENVIRONMENTS (2021)

Review Ecology

Rangeland degradation in Mongolia: A systematic review of the evidence

Sumjidmaa Sainnemekh, Isabel C. Barrio, Bulgamaa Densambuu, Brandon Bestelmeyer, Asa L. Aradottir

Summary: Rangeland degradation in Mongolia remains controversial, with studies highlighting changes in vegetation and land cover as key indicators. Grazing and climate are identified as primary drivers, but their impacts vary across ecological zones. Most studies focus on central Mongolia's steppe, forest steppe, and desert steppe zones.

JOURNAL OF ARID ENVIRONMENTS (2022)

Article Plant Sciences

Degradation influences equilibrium and non-equilibrium dynamics in rangelands: implications in resilience and stability

Dardo Ruben Lopez, Laura Cavallero, Priscila Willems, Brandon Thomas Bestelmeyer, Miguel Angel Brizuela

Summary: The study investigates the response of two states (a reference state and a degraded state) in the grassy-subshrub steppes of northern Patagonia, Argentina, to rainfall variability. The results show that the degraded state is more sensitive to rainfall changes, while the reference state has higher resilience and stability. Therefore, management plans should anticipate climatically favorable and unfavorable periods to prevent rangeland degradation.

APPLIED VEGETATION SCIENCE (2022)

Article Plant Sciences

The consequences of climate change for dryland biogeochemistry

Brooke B. Osborne, Brandon T. Bestelmeyer, Courtney M. Currier, Peter M. Homyak, Heather L. Throop, Kristina Young, Sasha C. Reed

Summary: Drylands cover more than 40% of Earth's terrestrial surface and are key drivers of global biogeochemical cycling and climate change. Understanding the effects of climate change and land-use change on dryland ecosystems is crucial for predicting ecosystem changes and addressing challenges in these vast ecosystems.

NEW PHYTOLOGIST (2022)

Article Ecology

Abrupt transitions in a southwest USA desert grassland related to the Pacific Decadal Oscillation

Erica M. M. Christensen, Darren K. K. James, Robb M. M. Randall, Brandon T. T. Bestelmeyer

Summary: Prediction of abrupt ecosystem transitions resulting from climatic change is crucial for adaptation strategies. In the arid southwest USA, grass cover dynamics during the 20th century were found to be closely correlated with the Pacific decadal oscillation (PDO) index. However, this relationship broke down after 1995, suggesting that warming or land degradation had overwhelmed the ability of grass species to recover.

ECOLOGY (2023)

Article Ecology

Implementing a resilience-based management system in Mongolia's rangelands

Burmaa Dashbal, Brandon T. Bestelmeyer, Bulgamaa Densambuu, Budbaatar Ulambayar, Sumjidmaa Sainnemekh, Justin Van Zee, Jeb Williamson, Ankhtsetseg Battur, Enkh-Amgalan Tseelei

Summary: A resilience-based management system has been implemented in the rangelands of Mongolia, combining vegetation state-and-transition models, standardized monitoring systems, rangeland use agreements, and a product traceability system. Collaborative efforts between national agencies, international donors, scientists, and herders have been essential to the success of this system. Long-term support and monitoring are needed to evaluate the social and ecological outcomes of resilience-based management.

ECOSPHERE (2023)

Article Food Science & Technology

Beef Production in the Southwestern United States: Strategies Toward Sustainability

Sheri Spiegal, Andres F. Cibils, Brandon T. Bestelmeyer, Jean L. Steiner, Richard E. Estell, David W. Archer, Brent W. Auvermann, Stephanie Bestelmeyer, Laura E. Boucheron, Huiping Cao, Andrew R. Cox, Daniel Devlin, Glenn C. Duff, Kristy K. Ehlers, Emile H. Elias, Craig A. Gifford, Alfredo L. Gonzalez, John P. Holland, Jenny S. Jennings, Ann M. Marshall, David McCracken, Matthew M. McIntosh, Rhonda Miller, Mark Musumba, Robert Paulin, Sara E. Place, Matthew Redd, C. Alan Rotz, Cindy Tolle, Anthony Waterhouse

FRONTIERS IN SUSTAINABLE FOOD SYSTEMS (2020)

Article Soil Science

Digital Mapping of Ecological Land Units using a Nationally Scalable Modeling Framework

Jonathan J. Maynard, Travis W. Nauman, Shawn W. Salley, Brandon T. Bestelmeyer, Michael C. Duniway, Curtis J. Talbot, Joel R. Brown

SOIL SCIENCE SOCIETY OF AMERICA JOURNAL (2019)

No Data Available