4.4 Article

PAIRED RADIOCARBON DATING ON HUMAN SAMPLES AND CAMELID FIBERS AND TEXTILES FROM NORTHERN CHILE: THE CASE OF PICA 8 (TARAPACA)

Journal

RADIOCARBON
Volume 59, Issue 4, Pages 1195-1213

Publisher

UNIV ARIZONA DEPT GEOSCIENCES
DOI: 10.1017/RDC.2017.36

Keywords

Atacama Desert; marine reservoir effect; stable carbon and nitrogen isotopes

Funding

  1. NERC Radiocarbon Facility [NR/2015/1/7]
  2. FONDECYT [1130279]
  3. NERC [NRCF010002] Funding Source: UKRI

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Pica 8 is a Late Intermediate Period (AD 900-1450) cemetery located in the Atacama Desert. Burials at the site present unexpectedly high variability in delta C-13 (-8 parts per thousand to -16 parts per thousand) and delta N-15 (10 parts per thousand to 24 parts per thousand) values in their skeletal tissues, implying highly diverse diets. There are two possible explanations for this variability: the first is diachronic change in diet while the second involves synchronic sociocultural distinctions. To distinguish between them a radiocarbon (C-14) dating program (n=23) was initiated. The presumed importance of marine foods adds the complication of a marine reservoir effect. To address this problem, paired C-14 dates were obtained on human bone and camelid textiles from nine graves. The results fall into two groups, one showing an average offset of 117 +/- 9 C-14 yr, and the other no statistically significant offsets. We conclude that the contribution of marine foods to bone collagen at Pica 8 was less than previously supposed. Other factors must be invoked to account for the unusually high human N-15 values at the site. Manuring crops with sea-bird guano emerges as a probable explanation. No relationship with chronology is seen implying the presence of considerable diversity in diets and hence lifeways within the Pica 8 community.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.4
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Instruments & Instrumentation

Physicochemical Changes in Bone Bioapatite During the Late Postmortem Interval Pre- and Post-Burning

Emese I. Vegh, Nicholas Marquez-Grant, Rick J. Schulting

Summary: This study investigates the impact of a one year postmortem interval on the structural and chemical alterations of unburnt and burnt bone. The results show that the concentrations of elements associated with extracellular fluid change with the postmortem interval and survive burning. Calcium, phosphorus, iron, aluminum, silicon, and strontium are not significantly altered with burning, while increased crystallinity and carbonate loss can be detected in unburnt bones.

APPLIED SPECTROSCOPY (2022)

Article Geography, Physical

Reconstruction of diachronic changes in human fishing activity and marine ecosystems from carbon and nitrogen stable isotope ratios of archaeological fish remains

Takumi Tsutaya, Tomonari Takahashi, Takayuki Omori, Kohei Yamazaki, Takao Sato, Minoru Yoneda, Rick J. Schulting, Hirofumi Kato, Andrzej W. Weber

Summary: Stable isotope analysis is an effective method for reconstructing human fishing practices and changes in marine ecosystems. The study found that there were changes in fishing practices and marine ecosystems during the Epi-Jomon and Okhotsk periods, possibly related to the development of fishing gear, changes in fishing strategies, and climate events.

QUATERNARY INTERNATIONAL (2022)

Article Ecology

Radiocarbon dating from Yuzhniy Oleniy Ostrov cemetery reveals complex human responses to socio-ecological stress during the 8.2 ka cooling event

Rick J. Schulting, Kristiina Mannermaa, Pavel E. Tarasov, Thomas Higham, Christopher Bronk Ramsey, Valeri Khartanovich, Vyacheslav Moiseyev, Dmitriy Gerasimov, John O'Shea, Andrzej Weber

Summary: The Mesolithic cemetery of Yuzhniy Oleniy Ostrov in Karelia, northwest Russia, was mainly used for a few centuries during a northern hemisphere climatic downturn event. The cemetery's use coincided with the 8.2 ka cooling event and suggests that human response to climate-driven environmental change might have influenced burial practices. The use of the cemetery during this time led to increased social stress and greater mortuary complexity, but this phenomenon lasted only for the duration of the climate downturn.

NATURE ECOLOGY & EVOLUTION (2022)

Article Geography, Physical

FRUITS of the sea? A cautionary tale regarding Bayesian modelling of palaeodiets using stable isotope data

Rick J. Schulting, Rebecca MacDonald, Michael P. Richards

Summary: A recent paper used Bayesian modelling software to argue that Neolithic individuals from Carding Mill Bay obtained up to ca. 21% dietary protein from marine sources, differing from previous interpretations. Resolving this discrepancy is important for understanding the Mesolithic-Neolithic transition in Atlantic Europe. Caution is needed when interpreting Bayesian palaeodietary modelling due to the uncertainty of parameters. The results reaffirm the terrestrial nature of diet at Carding Mill Bay.

QUATERNARY INTERNATIONAL (2023)

Article Geochemistry & Geophysics

FRESHWATER RESERVOIR EFFECTS IN ARCHAEOLOGICAL CONTEXTS OF SIBERIA AND THE EURASIAN STEPPE

Svetlana Svyatko, Paula J. Reimer, Rick J. Schulting, Irina Shevnina, Andrei Logvin, Dmitriy Voyakin, Astrid Stobbe, Ilya Merts, Vasilii Soenov, Natalia Tsydenova, Victor Varfolomeev

Summary: This paper evaluates the extent of freshwater reservoir effects in the Eurasian Steppe and provides the most up-to-date map of these effects in the region. The data confirm that freshwater reservoir offsets are widespread and variable in both modern and archaeological samples.

RADIOCARBON (2022)

Article Biochemical Research Methods

Micromilling vs hand drilling in stable isotope analyses of incremental carbonates: The potential for δ13C contamination by embedding resin

Tansy Branscombe, Julia Lee-Thorp, Rick Schulting, Melanie Leng

Summary: By comparing the results of hand-drilled and resin-embedded micromilled samples, it was found that hand-drilled samples had no anomalous δ13C values, while embedded samples exhibited spikes. This suggests that resin contamination may be responsible for the occurrence of spikes. Although hand-drilled samples had reduced spatial resolution, it did not significantly impact the observed isotopic range and seasonal patterns in rapidly growing marine shells. Moreover, the occurrence of anomalous δ13C values was eliminated and the failure rates due to insufficient sample size were greatly reduced in the hand-drilled dataset.

RAPID COMMUNICATIONS IN MASS SPECTROMETRY (2022)

Article Archaeology

Freshwater reservoir effects in Cis-Baikal: An overview

Rick J. Schulting, Christopher Bronk Ramsey, Ian Scharlotta, Michael P. Richards, Vladimir I. Bazaliiskii, Andrzej Weber

Summary: This paper provides a summary of research on the freshwater reservoir effects (FRE) in the Baikal region and their impact on radiocarbon dating of human remains. The study reveals varying relationships between human delta 13C and delta 15N values and 14C offsets in paired human-terrestrial mammal radiocarbon dates. It also emphasizes the importance of further research in identifying different isotopic ecologies and evaluating the dietary contributions of freshwater resources using other proxies.

ARCHAEOLOGICAL RESEARCH IN ASIA (2022)

Article Anthropology

The Eneolithic cemetery at Khvalynsk on the Volga River

David W. Anthony, A. A. Khokhlov, S. A. Agapov, D. S. Agapov, R. Schulting, I. Olalde, D. Reich

Summary: Genetically attested migrations of the third millennium BC have raised questions about the origins and nature of the Yamnaya culture across northern Eurasia. However, the key archaeological sites important for understanding the evolution of Yamnaya culture have not been published in western languages.

PRAEHISTORISCHE ZEITSCHRIFT (2022)

Article Anthropology

In a nutshell: Using structural and chemical changes to establish the charring conditions of archaeological hazelnut shells

A. Holguin, M. Charles, S. Mithen, R. Schulting

Summary: This paper investigates the conditions under which hazelnut shells can become charred. The study finds that temperature, duration, and oxygen availability are key factors in the charring process. The results of the study can guide future analytical work on hazelnut shells and similar archaeobotanical materials.

JOURNAL OF ARCHAEOLOGICAL SCIENCE (2022)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Automated SEM Mineralogy and Archaeological Ceramics: Applications in Formative Period Pottery From the Atacama Desert

Camila Riera-Soto, Carolina Agueero, Osvaldo Gonzalez-Maurel, Mauricio Uribe, Andrew Menzies

Summary: This study examines archaeological ceramics from the San Pedro de Atacama oases in the Atacama Desert, using automated SEM mineralogy to fully characterise the ceramics. The results show that the ceramics are more complex than previously thought, with varying components and mineral abundance. The mineralogical information allows for the discussion of possible raw material sources.

FRONTIERS IN EARTH SCIENCE (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Palaeogenomics of Upper Palaeolithic to Neolithic European hunter-gatherers

Cosimo Posth, He Yu, Ayshin Ghalichi, Helene Rougier, Isabelle Crevecoeur, Yilei Huang, Harald Ringbauer, Adam B. Rohrlach, Kathrin Nagele, Vanessa Villalba-Mouco, Rita Radzeviciute, Tiago Ferraz, Alexander Stoessel, Rezeda Tukhbatova, Dorothee G. Drucker, Martina Lari, Alessandra Modi, Stefania Vai, Tina Saupe, Christiana L. Scheib, Giulio Catalano, Luca Pagani, Sahra Talamo, Helen Fewlass, Laurent Klaric, Andre Morala, Mathieu Rue, Stephane Madelaine, Laurent Crepin, Jean-Baptiste Caverne, Emmy Bocaege, Stefano Ricci, Francesco Boschin, Priscilla Bayle, Bruno Maureille, Foni Le Brun-Ricalens, Jean-Guillaume Bordes, Gregorio Oxilia, Eugenio Bortolini, Olivier Bignon-Lau, Gregory Debout, Michel Orliac, Antoine Zazzo, Vitale Sparacello, Elisabetta Starnini, Luca Sineo, Johannes van der Plicht, Laure Pecqueur, Gildas Merceron, Geraldine Garcia, Jean-Michel Leuvrey, Coralie Bay Garcia, Asier Gomez-Olivencia, Marta Poltowicz-Bobak, Dariusz Bobak, Mona Le Luyer, Paul Storm, Claudia Hoffmann, Jacek Kabacinski, Tatiana Filimonova, Svetlana Shnaider, Natalia Berezina, Borja Gonzalez-Rabanal, Manuel Gonzalez R. Morales, Ana B. Marin-Arroyo, Belen Lopez, Carmen Alonso-Llamazares, Annamaria Ronchitelli, Caroline Polet, Ivan Jadin, Nicolas Cauwe, Joaquim Soler, Neus Coromina, Isaac Rufi, Richard Cottiaux, Geoffrey Clark, Lawrence G. Straus, Marie-Anne Julien, Silvia Renhart, Dorothea Talaa, Stefano Benazzi, Matteo Romandini, Luc Amkreutz, Herve Bocherens, Christoph Wissing, Sebastien Villotte, Javier Fernandez-Lopez de Pablo, Magdalena Gomez-Puche, Marco Aurelio Esquembre-Bebia, Pierre Bodu, Liesbeth Smits, Benedicte Souffi, Rimantas Jankauskas, Justina Kozakaite, Christophe Cupillard, Hartmut Benthien, Kurt Wehrberger, Ralf W. Schmitz, Susanne C. Feine, Tim Schueler, Corinne Thevenet, Dan Grigorescu, Friedrich Lueth, Andreas Kotula, Henny Piezonka, Franz Schopper, Jiri Svoboda, Sandra Sazelova, Andrey Chizhevsky, Aleksandr Khokhlov, Nicholas J. Conard, Frederique Valentin, Katerina Harvati, Patrick Semal, Bettina Jungklaus, Alexander Suvorov, Rick Schulting, Vyacheslav Moiseyev, Kristiina Mannermaa, Alexandra Buzhilova, Thomas Terberger, David Caramelli, Eveline Altena, Wolfgang Haak, Johannes Krause

Summary: By analyzing ancient hunter-gatherer genomes from western and central Eurasia, this study uncovers genetic changes and migrations during the human colonization of Europe. The Last Glacial Maximum led to population replacements in southern Europe and gene flow between western and eastern European hunter-gatherers.

NATURE (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Provenancing antiquarian museum collections using multi-isotope analysis

Samantha Neil, Jane Evans, Janet Montgomery, Rick Schulting, Chris Scarre

Summary: Many important archaeological sites in Europe were excavated by antiquarians over 100 years ago. This study uses multi-isotope analysis and C-14 dating to evaluate the origin of human remains in a collection believed to be from one of Britain's most significant archaeological sites. The Coldrum site in Kent, excavated in 1910, is a megalithic burial monument that may be associated with the transition to farming in Britain. Isotope analysis confirms the presence of Neolithic remains, but also reveals remains dating to the 5th-7th centuries AD. This study provides new information about subsistence and mobility patterns of early Neolithic populations and emphasizes the value of isotope analysis in determining provenance of museum collections.

ROYAL SOCIETY OPEN SCIENCE (2023)

Article Anthropology

?For there is no rock?: Lucayan stone celts from The Bahamas and Turks and Caicos Islands

Joanna Ostapkowicz, Rick J. Schulting, Gareth R. Davies

Summary: This paper presents the first systematic study of pre-Columbian imported stone celts recovered from the limestone islands of the Lucayan archipelago. The study found that the Lucayan archipelago had a sufficient supply of stone celts and there was no clear evidence of size diminution with distance from sources. The majority of stone celts were jade, supplemented with other materials.

JOURNAL OF ANTHROPOLOGICAL ARCHAEOLOGY (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Yersinia pestis genomes reveal plague in Britain 4000 years ago

Pooja Swali, Rick Schulting, Alexandre Gilardet, Monica Kelly, Kyriaki Anastasiadou, Isabelle Glocke, Jesse McCabe, Mia Williams, Tony Audsley, Louise Loe, Teresa Fernandez-Crespo, Javier Ordono, David Walker, Tom Clare, Geoff Cook, Ian Hodkinson, Mark Simpson, Stephen Read, Tom Davy, Marina Silva, Mateja Hajdinjak, Anders Bergstrom, Thomas Booth, Pontus Skoglund

Summary: This study sequenced three Yersinia pestis genomes from Britain and found the earliest evidence of LNBA plague in the country. The genomes belong to a sublineage observed in Bronze Age individuals from Central Europe and later found in Eastern Asia. The results suggest that the LNBA plague had substantial transmissibility.

NATURE COMMUNICATIONS (2023)

Article Anthropology

Determining the Postmortem Timing of Sharp Force Damage and the Pre-burning Condition of Burnt Bone

Emese I. I. Vegh, Nicholas Marquez-Grant, Rick J. J. Schulting

Summary: This study found that the characteristics of cutmarks on burnt bones can be used to determine the time interval between pre-burning and post-burning. By conducting experiments on burnt pig tibiae, it was discovered that significant alterations in cutmark characteristics occurred after 6 months of exposure to fire, which can provide information on the pre-burning time interval.

JOURNAL OF ARCHAEOLOGICAL METHOD AND THEORY (2023)

No Data Available