4.5 Article

Wind Integration into Energy Systems with a High Share of Nuclear Power-What Are the Compromises?

Journal

ENERGIES
Volume 8, Issue 4, Pages 2493-2527

Publisher

MDPI
DOI: 10.3390/en8042493

Keywords

-

Categories

Funding

  1. STEEM project (Sustainable Transition of European Energy Markets)
  2. Aalto Energy Efficiency Research Program
  3. Aalto University

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Towards low-carbon energy systems, there are countries with ongoing plans for expanding their nuclear power capacity, and simultaneously advancing the role of variable renewable energy sources (RES), namely wind and solar energy. This crossroads of capital-intensive, baseload power production and uncontrollable, intermittent RES may entail new challenges in the optimal and economic operation of power systems. This study examines this case by hourly analysis of a national-level energy system with the EnergyPLAN modeling tool, coupled with wind integration simulations (including uncertainty) implemented using MATLAB. We evaluate the maximum feasible wind integration under different scenarios for nuclear power plants, energy demand, and the flexibility of energy infrastructure for a real case study (Finland). We propose wind-nuclear compromise charts to envision the impact of any mix of these two technologies on four parameters: total costs, power exchange, carbon emissions, and renewable energy integration. The results suggest that nuclear power constrains the room for maximum uptake of wind energy by a descending parabolic relationship. If nuclear power production exceeds 50% of the total power demand, wind will be unlikely to penetrate in shares over 15% of the respective demand. Moreover, we investigate the role of four flexibility options: demand side management, electrical energy storage, smart electric heating, and large-scale heat pumps (backed with thermal energy storage). Heat pumps (which are in connection with combined heat and power (CHP) and district heating systems) offer the highest efficiency in balancing excess power from variable RES. However, power-to-heat options offer a limited capability for absorbing excess power, as oversupply arises mainly in the periods with relatively low demand for heat. This calls for longer-term energy storage and/or other flexibility options to achieve the planned targets in wind-nuclear scenarios.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Energy & Fuels

Contributing factors for electricity storage in a carbon-free power system

Tero Koivunen, Sanna Syri, Noora Veijalainen

Summary: The study investigates the behavior of electrical storages in a carbon-free national power system model set in Finland in 2050. It found that nuclear energy and electricity trading capacities are key factors affecting the need for electricity storage. Historical data also play a significant role in determining the required electricity storage capacities, particularly due to interannual variations in renewable production.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ENERGY RESEARCH (2022)

Article Thermodynamics

Electric Truck Hydropower, a flexible solution to hydropower in mountainous regions

Julian David Hunt, Jakub Jurasz, Behnam Zakeri, Andreas Nascimento, Samuel Cross, Carla Schwengber ten Caten, Diego Augusto de Jesus Pacheco, Pharima Pongpairoj, Walter Leal Filho, Fernanda Munari Caputo Tome, Rodrigo Senne, Bas van Ruijven

Summary: This paper proposes an innovative solution that converts water into electricity using the regenerative braking systems of electric trucks and stores it in the truck's battery. This electric truck hydropower technology has the advantages of low cost, low environmental impact, and can be combined with solar and wind resources to provide energy storage services to the grid.

ENERGY (2022)

Article Thermodynamics

Seawater air-conditioning and ammonia district cooling: A solution for warm coastal regions

Julian David Hunt, Andreas Nascimento, Behnam Zakeri, Paulo Sergio Franco Barbosa, Leandro Costalonga

Summary: This paper discusses a sustainable solution for cooling needs in coastal areas using seawater air-conditioning, and proposes the use of ammonia for distributing cooling services as an effective method.

ENERGY (2022)

Article Thermodynamics

Lift Energy Storage Technology: A solution for decentralized urban energy storage

Julian David Hunt, Andreas Nascimento, Behnam Zakeri, Jakub Jurasz, Pawel B. Dabek, Paulo Sergio Franco Barbosa, Roberto Branda, Nivalde Jose de Castro, Walter Leal Filho, Keywan Riahi

Summary: This paper proposes Lift Energy Storage Technology (LEST) that utilizes lifts and empty apartments in tall buildings for energy storage. It suggests using gravity to lift high-density containers filled with materials like wet sand and transporting them with autonomous trailer devices. LEST is particularly suitable for decentralized ancillary and energy storage services and has the potential for large-scale application at a lower cost.

ENERGY (2022)

Article Energy & Fuels

Implications of intercontinental renewable electricity trade for energy systems and emissions

Fei Guo, Bas J. van Ruijven, Behnam Zakeri, Shining Zhang, Xing Chen, Changyi Liu, Fang Yang, Volker Krey, Keywan Riahi, Han Huang, Yuanbing Zhou

Summary: The study investigates the impact of direct-current ultra-high-voltage transmission lines on energy transition and climate change by using integrated assessment models. The results indicate that renewable electricity trade through these transmission lines can boost renewable energy development, reduce CO2 emissions, and significantly decrease air pollutant emissions in importing regions.

NATURE ENERGY (2022)

Article Energy & Fuels

Transition towards university campus carbon neutrality by connecting to city district heating network

Pauli Hiltunen, Anna Volkova, Eduard Latosov, Kertu Lepiksaar, Sanna Syri

Summary: This paper analyzes the possibilities of replacing the natural gas boiler with district heating in Tallinn University of Technology. The results show that connecting to an existing high-temperature district heating network or using a low-temperature energy cascade can reduce carbon dioxide emissions and achieve primary energy savings.

ENERGY REPORTS (2022)

Article Energy & Fuels

Feasibility study of energy storage options for photovoltaic electricity generation in detached houses in Nordic climates

Johannes Hyvonen, Annukka Santasalo-Aarnio, Sanna Syri, Matti Lehtonen

Summary: This study evaluates the cost-effectiveness of utilizing energy storage systems to enhance residential photovoltaic electricity generation, finding that solar PV systems without selling surplus electricity to the grid are profitable under certain renewable fractions and market prices. Among the examined energy storage technologies, lithium-ion battery storage was found to be the most financially feasible option.

JOURNAL OF ENERGY STORAGE (2022)

Article Energy & Fuels

Underground Gravity Energy Storage: A Solution for Long-Term Energy Storage

Julian David Hunt, Behnam Zakeri, Jakub Jurasz, Wenxuan Tong, Pawel B. Dabek, Roberto Brandao, Epari Ritesh Patro, Bojan Durin, Walter Leal Filho, Yoshihide Wada, Bas van Ruijven, Keywan Riahi

Summary: Low-carbon energy transitions worldwide are driven by integrating renewable energy sources like wind and solar power, requiring energy storage options. This article proposes using decommissioned underground mines as storage reservoirs and a gravitational-based energy storage method called Underground Gravity Energy Storage (UGES). UGES can discharge electricity by lowering sand into the mine and store electricity by elevating sand from the mine. Unlike battery storage, UGES has zero self-discharge rate and uses sand as the storage medium, reducing the risk of contaminating underground water resources. It offers weekly to pluriannual energy storage cycles with investment costs of 1 to 10 USD/kWh and a global energy storage potential of 7 to 70 TWh, supporting sustainable development through seasonal energy storage services.

ENERGIES (2023)

Article Economics

Coupling energy system models with multi-regional input-output models based on the make and use framework - insights from MESSAGEix and EXIOBASE

Maik Budzinski, Richard Wood, Behnam Zakeri, Volker Krey, Anders Hammer Stromman

Summary: Technology-rich integrated assessment models (IAMs) provide high resolution of the energy-related climate impacts but usually ignore industrial linkages and other environmental pressures. This manuscript presents a method for coupling energy system models (ESMs) with multiregional input-output models (MRIOs) based on the Make and Use framework, which improves both models simultaneously. An exemplary case study is carried out to illustrate the usefulness and challenges of this approach, and further steps are identified for systematic prospective analyzes.

ECONOMIC SYSTEMS RESEARCH (2023)

Article Thermodynamics

Operation of district heat network in electricity and balancing markets with the power-to-heat sector coupling

Nima Javanshir, Sanna Syri, Seela Tervo, Argo Rosin

Summary: The stochastic nature of renewable energy resources poses a challenge in balancing supply and demand in the power grid, and district heating networks equipped with power-to-heat technologies and thermal storage can provide balancing services. However, the participation of district heating networks in multiple energy markets and optimizing revenue has not been thoroughly studied.

ENERGY (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Fairness and feasibility in deep mitigation pathways with novel carbon dioxide removal considering institutional capacity to mitigate

Matthew J. Gidden, Elina Brutschin, Gaurav Ganti, Gamze Unlu, Behnam Zakeri, Oliver Fricko, Benjamin Mitterrutzner, Francesco Lovat, Keywan Riahi

Summary: To comprehensively analyze and achieve climate mitigation goals, factors of justice and fairness as well as new carbon dioxide removal technologies should be considered. Introducing novel carbon dioxide removal technologies, including direct air capture of CO2 and institutional capacity, can enhance the feasibility and fairness of mitigation scenarios. However, relying solely on carbon removal measures in developed countries is not sufficient to achieve the 1.5℃ target of the Paris Agreement, and further technical and financial transfers are needed for equitable achievement.

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2023)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Possible bottlenecks in clean energy transitions: Overview and modelled effects-Case Finland

Johannes Hyvonen, Tero Koivunen, Sanna Syri

Summary: This study evaluates the feasibility of achieving carbon neutrality in Finland by 2035, considering potential bottlenecks and resource shortages. It finds that the current climate strategy is outdated and insufficient to reach carbon neutrality by 2035. Alternative measures to improve sustainability and reduce emissions are also presented in the paper.

JOURNAL OF CLEANER PRODUCTION (2023)

Article Energy & Fuels

The role of natural gas in setting electricity prices in Europe

Behnam Zakeri, Iain Staffell, Paul E. Dodds, Michael Grubb, Paul Ekins, Jaakko Jaaskelainen, Samuel Cross, Kristo Helin, Giorgio Castagneto Gissey

Summary: The EU energy and climate policy focuses on enhancing energy security and affordability, while reducing the environmental impacts of energy use. This study finds that fossil fuel-based power plants, particularly natural gas, play a significant role in setting electricity prices in Europe.

ENERGY REPORTS (2023)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Benefits through Space Heating and Thermal Storage with Demand Response Control for a District-Heated Office Building

Yuchen Ju, Pauli Hiltunen, Juha Jokisalo, Risto Kosonen, Sanna Syri

Summary: This study explores the application of demand response techniques in reducing heating costs for building owners. By modeling a district heating network in Espoo, Finland, dynamic district heat prices are defined. The results show that demand response control of space heating and a thermal energy storage tank can achieve energy cost savings of 9.6% and 3.4% respectively, and when both approaches are employed simultaneously, energy cost savings of 12.8% can be attained.

BUILDINGS (2023)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Sustainable heating alternatives for 1960's and 1970's renovated apartment buildings

Iraj Moradpoor, Sanna Syri, Janne Hirvonen

Summary: The Finnish Government's target of carbon neutrality by 2035 poses a challenge for the district heat systems of Finnish cities, which still heavily rely on fossil fuels and peat. To address rising heat prices and prevent energy poverty, affordable low-carbon district heat solutions need to be developed. This study investigates the feasibility of various low-carbon scenarios utilizing biomass combustion and waste heat recovery technologies in different energy renovation levels. Economic and sensitivity analyses were conducted from utility and end-user perspectives, highlighting biomass HOB and waste heat-heat pump + electric boiler as cost-effective options.

CLEANER ENVIRONMENTAL SYSTEMS (2022)

No Data Available