4.2 Review

Bridging the gap: large animal models in neurodegenerative research

Journal

MAMMALIAN GENOME
Volume 28, Issue 7-8, Pages 324-337

Publisher

SPRINGER
DOI: 10.1007/s00335-017-9687-6

Keywords

-

Funding

  1. BBSRC [BB/J004332/1]
  2. MRC [MR/M010341/1 - TMW]
  3. BBSRC [BBS/E/D/20251969, BBS/E/D/10002071] Funding Source: UKRI
  4. MRC [MR/M010341/1] Funding Source: UKRI
  5. Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council [BBS/E/D/20251969, BBS/E/D/10002071] Funding Source: researchfish
  6. Medical Research Council [MR/M010341/1] Funding Source: researchfish

Ask authors/readers for more resources

The world health organisation has declared neurological disorders as one of the greatest public health risks in the world today. Yet, despite this growing concern, the mechanisms underpinning many of these conditions are still poorly understood. This may in part be due to the seemingly diverse nature of the initiating insults ranging from genetic (such as the Ataxia's and Lysosomal storage disorders) through to protein misfolding and aggregation (i.e. Prions), and those of a predominantly unknown aetiology (i.e. Alzheimer's and Parkinson's disease). However, efforts to elucidate mechanistic regulation are also likely to be hampered because of the complexity of the human nervous system, the apparent selective regional vulnerability and differential degenerative progression. The key to elucidating these aetiologies is determining the regional molecular cascades, which are occurring from the early through to terminal stages of disease progression. Whilst much molecular data have been captured at the end stage of disease from post-mortem analysis in humans, the very early stages of disease are often conspicuously asymptomatic, and even if they were not, repeated sampling from multiple brain regions of affected patients and controls is neither ethical nor possible. Model systems therefore become fundamental for elucidating the mechanisms governing these complex neurodegenerative conditions. However, finding a model that precisely mimics the human condition can be challenging and expensive. Whilst cellular and invertebrate models are frequently used in neurodegenerative research and have undoubtedly yielded much useful data, the comparatively simplistic nature of these systems makes insights gained from such a stand alone model limited when it comes to translation. Given the recent advances in gene editing technology, the options for novel model generation in higher order species have opened up new and exciting possibilities for the field. In this review, we therefore explain some of the reasons why larger animal models often appear to give a more robust recapitulation of human neurological disorders and why they may be a critical stepping stone for effective therapeutic translation.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.2
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Biochemistry & Molecular Biology

Pre-natal manifestation of systemic developmental abnormalities in spinal muscular atrophy

Anna A. L. Motyl, Kiterie M. E. Faller, Ewout J. N. Groen, Rachel A. Kline, Samantha L. Eaton, Leire M. Ledahawsky, Helena Chaytow, Douglas J. Lamont, Thomas M. Wishart, Yu-Ting Huang, Thomas H. Gillingwater

HUMAN MOLECULAR GENETICS (2020)

Article Anatomy & Morphology

Comparative anatomy of the mammalian neuromuscular junction

Ines Boehm, Abrar Alhindi, Ana S. Leite, Chandra Logie, Alyssa Gibbs, Olivia Murray, Rizwan Farrukh, Robert Pirie, Christopher Proudfoot, Richard Clutton, Thomas M. Wishart, Ross A. Jones, Thomas H. Gillingwater

JOURNAL OF ANATOMY (2020)

Article Gastroenterology & Hepatology

SMN Depleted Mice Offer a Robust and Rapid Onset Model of Nonalcoholic Fatty Liver Disease

Marc-Olivier Deguise, Chantal Pileggi, Yves De Repentigny, Ariane Beauvais, Alexandra Tierney, Lucia Chehade, Jean Michaud, Maica Llavero-Hurtado, Douglas Lamont, Abdelmadjid Atrih, Thomas M. Wishart, Thomas H. Gillingwater, Bernard L. Schneider, Mary-Ellen Harper, Simon H. Parson, Rashmi Kothary

Summary: The Smn(2B/-) mouse model rapidly develops microvesicular steatohepatitis, providing an opportunity to study the pathogenesis of NAFLD. While not a typical NAFLD/NASH model, it offers a reliable, low-cost, and early-onset model for both adult and pediatric populations.

CELLULAR AND MOLECULAR GASTROENTEROLOGY AND HEPATOLOGY (2021)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Application across species of a one health approach to liquid sample handling for respiratory based -omics analysis

Anna E. Karagianni, Samantha L. Eaton, Dominic Kurian, Eugenio Cillan-Garcia, Jonathan Twynam-Perkins, Anna Raper, Thomas M. Wishart, R. Scott Pirie

Summary: Airway inflammation is common in horses, with cytological analysis being the main method to assess lower airway inflammation. Bronchoalveolar lavage fluid (BALF) cytology is more diagnostically advantageous for equine asthma, but the invasiveness of sample acquisition makes it unsuitable for routine screening. Technological advances have enabled a wider range of analyses to be applied to tracheal wash (TW) samples.

SCIENTIFIC REPORTS (2021)

Article Biochemistry & Molecular Biology

The mitochondrial protein Sideroflexin 3 (SFXN3) influences neurodegeneration pathways in vivo

Leire M. Ledahawsky, Maria Eirini Terzenidou, Ruairidh Edwards, Rachel A. Kline, Laura C. Graham, Samantha L. Eaton, Dinja Hoorn, Helena Chaytow, Yu-Ting Huang, Ewout J. N. Groen, Anna A. L. Motyl, Douglas J. Lamont, Kostas Tokatlidis, Thomas M. Wishart, Thomas H. Gillingwater

Summary: Synapses are a primary pathological target in neurodegenerative diseases, and SFXN3 has been found to have an impact on neurodegeneration and cell death, potentially playing a significant role in regulating neurodegeneration pathways.

FEBS JOURNAL (2022)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Training associated alterations in equine respiratory immunity using a multiomics comparative approach

Anna E. Karagianni, Dominic Kurian, Eugenio Cillan-Garcia, Samantha L. Eaton, Thomas M. Wishart, R. Scott Pirie

Summary: This study aims to characterize the effect of training on the local pulmonary immune system in racehorses by analyzing the gene and protein expression of tracheal wash samples. The results showed differentially expressed genes and proteins related to acute phase response, oxidative stress, haemopoietic processes, immune response, and inflammation. The study highlighted the potential mechanisms underlying training-associated airway inflammation.

SCIENTIFIC REPORTS (2022)

Article Cell Biology

Temporal Profiling of the Cortical Synaptic Mitochondrial Proteome Identifies Ageing Associated Regulators of Stability

Laura C. Graham, Rachel A. Kline, Douglas J. Lamont, Thomas H. Gillingwater, Neil A. Mabbott, Paul A. Skehel, Thomas M. Wishart

Summary: Proteomic analysis of synaptic and non-synaptic mitochondria in mice revealed unique protein expression profiles in aged synaptic mitochondria. Recapitulation of aged synaptic mitochondrial protein expression in the Drosophila neuromuscular junction disrupted synaptic architecture, indicating that temporal regulation of the mitochondrial proteome may directly modulate synaptic stability.

CELLS (2021)

Article Biochemistry & Molecular Biology

Confocal Endomicroscopy of Neuromuscular Junctions Stained with Physiologically Inert Protein Fragments of Tetanus Toxin

Cornelia Roesl, Elizabeth R. Evans, Kosala N. Dissanayake, Veronika Boczonadi, Ross A. Jones, Graeme R. Jordan, Leire Ledahawsky, Guy C. C. Allen, Molly Scott, Alanna Thomson, Thomas M. Wishart, David Hughes, Richard J. Mead, Clifford C. Shone, Clarke R. Slater, Thomas H. Gillingwater, Paul A. Skehel, Richard R. Ribchester

Summary: The construction of truncated TetC derivatives enabled high-contrast staining of motor nerve terminals without impairing NMJ function. These derivatives not only allowed easy visualization of nerve terminals in situ or in isolated preparations, but also facilitated the observation of regenerated NMJs and degenerating NMJs in diseased muscle.

BIOMOLECULES (2021)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Effects of chronic cannabidiol in a mouse model of naturally occurring neuroinflammation, neurodegeneration, and spontaneous seizures

Joshua T. Dearborn, Hemanth R. Nelvagal, Nicholas R. Rensing, Keigo Takahashi, Stephanie M. Hughes, Thomas M. Wishart, Jonathan D. Cooper, Michael Wong, Mark S. Sands

Summary: In a mouse model of CLN1 disease, chronic CBD administration reduced neuroinflammation but had no apparent effect on seizures and neuron survival. Higher doses of CBD may be needed to reduce neurodegeneration and seizure frequency.

SCIENTIFIC REPORTS (2022)

Article Neurosciences

Synaptic proteomics reveal distinct molecular signatures of cognitive change and C9ORF72 repeat expansion in the human ALS cortex

Zsofia Laszlo, Nicole Hindley, Anna Sanchez Avila, Rachel A. Kline, Samantha L. Eaton, Douglas J. Lamont, Colin Smith, Tara L. Spires-Jones, Thomas M. Wishart, Christopher M. Henstridge

Summary: Increasing evidence suggests that synaptic dysfunction is a central and possibly triggering factor in Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis (ALS). This study aimed to assess the molecular profile of ALS synapses using an unbiased synaptic proteomics experiment. The researchers identified ALS-associated proteins and alterations in synaptic protein expression levels, as well as the influence of cognitive decline and a specific genetic mutation on synaptic composition. This study provides novel insights into the role of synaptic dysfunction in ALS pathophysiology.

ACTA NEUROPATHOLOGICA COMMUNICATIONS (2022)

Review Cell Biology

An Optimized Comparative Proteomic Approach as a Tool in Neurodegenerative Disease Research

Rachel A. Kline, Lena Loesslein, Dominic Kurian, Judit Aguilar Marti, Samantha L. Eaton, Felipe A. Court, Thomas H. Gillingwater, Thomas M. Wishart

Summary: Recent advances in proteomic technologies have enabled unprecedented assessment of molecular composition in various sample types. However, careful consideration is required when applying these technologies, including methodological selection and analysis workflow. The effectiveness of most proteomics screens is hindered by inadequate analyses, rather than technical limitations. Furthermore, studying progressive neurodegenerative conditions presents inherent difficulties that should be addressed.

CELLS (2022)

Article Cell Biology

The Proteome Signatures of Fibroblasts from Patients with Severe, Intermediate and Mild Spinal Muscular Atrophy Show Limited Overlap

Sharon J. Brown, Rachel A. Kline, Silvia A. Synowsky, Sally L. Shirran, Ian Holt, Kelly A. Sillence, Peter Claus, Brunhilde Wirth, Thomas M. Wishart, Heidi R. Fuller

Summary: This study conducted proteomic profiling of skin fibroblasts from different severities of spinal muscular atrophy (SMA) patients. The results showed limited overlap in differentially expressed proteomic profiles among different types of SMA, and the greatest variability was observed within SMA II fibroblasts. Despite limited proteomic overlap, common enriched canonical pathways were identified in two of the three SMA severities. The study also identified protein profiles that may be associated with SMA severity.

CELLS (2022)

Review Cell Biology

Modelling Neurological Diseases in Large Animals: Criteria for Model Selection and Clinical Assessment

Samantha L. Eaton, Fraser Murdoch, Nina M. Rzechorzek, Gerard Thompson, Claudia Hartley, Benjamin Thomas Blacklock, Chris Proudfoot, Simon G. Lillico, Peter Tennant, Adrian Ritchie, James Nixon, Paul M. Brennan, Stefano Guido, Nadia L. Mitchell, David N. Palmer, C. Bruce A. Whitelaw, Jonathan D. Cooper, Thomas M. Wishart

Summary: The impact of neurological disorders is globally recognized, and the translation from rodent-derived therapeutics to human neurological interventions is challenging. In order to improve translation, higher order mammals with complex neuroanatomy, such as livestock, are being used. We provide comprehensive neurological assessment protocols for large animal species to standardize the characterization of these models and recommend their use in neurological clinical scoring.

CELLS (2022)

Article Medicine, Research & Experimental

Cross-species efficacy of enzyme replacement therapy for CLN1 disease in mice and sheep

Hemanth R. Nelvagal, Samantha L. Eaton, Sophie H. Wang, Elizabeth M. Eultgen, Keigo Takahashi, Steven Q. Le, Rachel Nesbitt, Joshua T. Dearborn, Nicholas Siano, Ana C. Puhl, Patricia Dickson, Gerard Thompson, Fraser Murdoch, Paul M. Brennan, Mark Gray, Stephen N. Greenhalgh, Peter Tennant, Rachael Gregson, Eddie Clutton, James Nixon, Chris Proudfoot, Stefano Guido, Simon G. Lillico, C. Bruce A. Whitelaw, Jui-Yun Lu, Sandra L. Hofmann, Sean Ekins, Mark S. Sands, Thomas M. Wishart, Jonathan D. Cooper

Summary: CLN1 disease, a fatal neurodegenerative lysosomal storage disorder, has proven challenging to treat. This study tested the efficacy of enzyme replacement therapy (ERT) and found that intracerebrovascular administration of recombinant PPT1 showed therapeutic benefits in mouse and sheep models. The findings highlight the feasibility and therapeutic efficacy of ERT and emphasize the importance of cross-species research in developing successful treatment strategies.

JOURNAL OF CLINICAL INVESTIGATION (2022)

Article Clinical Neurology

Microarray profiling emphasizes transcriptomic differences between hippocampal in vivo tissue and in vitro cultures

Declan King, Paul A. Skehel, Owen Dando, Katie Emelianova, Rona Barron, Thomas M. Wishart

Summary: Primary hippocampal cell cultures are commonly used as a model platform for studying the hippocampus and brain tissue, containing multiple cell types for easy analysis. Comparing the transcriptomic profiles of these cultures with intact hippocampal tissue raises questions about the extent to which the in vivo environment is replicated. Additionally, gene conservation appears to be largely retained across genetically altered lines based on comparisons with wild type and PrP 101LL transgenic model profiles.

BRAIN COMMUNICATIONS (2021)

No Data Available