4.0 Article

Sexual dimorphism and regional variation in human frontal bone inclination measured via digital 3D models

Journal

LEGAL MEDICINE
Volume 29, Issue -, Pages 53-61

Publisher

ELSEVIER IRELAND LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.legalmed.2017.10.001

Keywords

Forensic anthropology; Digital morphometrics; Population data; Sex estimation; Cranial morphology; Craniometrics

Funding

  1. Ax:son Johnson foundation

Ask authors/readers for more resources

The frontal bone is one of the most sexually dimorphic elements of the human skull, due to features such as the glabella, frontal eminences, and frontal inclination. While glabella is frequently evaluated in procedures to estimate sex in unknown human skeletal remains, frontal inclination has received less attention. In this study we present a straightforward, quick, and reproducible method for measuring frontal inclination angles from glabella and supraglabella. Using a sample of 413 human crania from four different populations (U.S. Whites, U.S. Blacks, Portuguese, and Chinese), we test the usefulness of the inclination angles for sex estimation and compare their performance to traditional methods of frontal inclination assessment. Accuracy rates in the range 75-81% were achieved for the U.S. White, U.S. Black, and Portuguese groups. For Chinese the overall accuracy was lower, i.e. 66%. Although some regional variation was observed, a cut-off value of 78.2 for glabellar inclination angles separates female and male crania from all studied populations with good accuracy. As inclination angles measured from glabella captures two sexually dimorphic features (i.e. glabellar prominence and frontal inclination) in a single measure, the observed clear male/female difference is not unexpected. Being continuous variables, inclination angles are suitable for use in statistical methods for sex estimations.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.0
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Dentistry, Oral Surgery & Medicine

Accuracy of intraoral scans: An in vivo study of different scanning devices

Florian Kernen, Stefan Schlager, Veronica Seidel Alvarez, Juergen Mehrhof, Kirstin Vach, Ralf Kohal, Katja Nelson, Tabea Fluegge

Summary: The accuracy of intraoral scanners is crucial for computer-aided design and computer-aided manufacturing (CAD-CAM) dentistry. This clinical study compared the accuracy of intraoral scanning with different devices to extraoral scanning. The results showed that extraoral scans had higher precision and trueness compared to intraoral scans, except for complete-arch scans with one specific intraoral scanner. Short-span scans had higher precision and trueness compared to complete-arch scans.

JOURNAL OF PROSTHETIC DENTISTRY (2022)

Article Anatomy & Morphology

Virtual reconstruction of orbital floor defects using a statistical shape model

Mathieu Gass, Marc Anton Fuessinger, Marc Christian Metzger, Steffen Schwarz, Johannes Daniel Baehr, Leonard Brandenburg, Julia Weingart, Stefan Schlager

Summary: Utilizing a statistical shape model (SSM) for orbital floor reconstruction results in higher accuracy compared to the conventional mirroring method. The SSM-based approach can better accommodate the natural asymmetry of the skull, achieving higher precision in reconstructing injured orbits.

JOURNAL OF ANATOMY (2022)

Article Medicine, Legal

Applying posterior probability informed thresholds to traditional cranial trait sex estimation methods

Patricia R. Avent, Cris E. Hughes, Heather M. Garvin

Summary: This study evaluated the impact of posterior probability-informed thresholds (PPITs) on sex estimation accuracy and found that using PPITs of at least 0.85 increased accuracy rates to over 92% while remaining inclusive of the sample. PPITs < 0.75 were not significantly higher than chance and should be reported as indeterminate. The 0.75-0.84 PPIT interval had an accuracy rate of 76% with lower confidence in the results.

JOURNAL OF FORENSIC SCIENCES (2022)

Article Biology

Forensic Tools for Species Identification of Skeletal Remains: Metrics, Statistics, and OsteoID

Heather M. Garvin, Rachel Dunn, Sabrina B. Sholts, M. Schuyler Litten, Merna Mohamed, Nathan Kuttickat, Noah Skantz

Summary: This study aimed to assess the utility of quantitative methods in distinguishing human from nonhuman remains and present additional resources for species identification. Through data analysis and the development of a web tool, the study achieved accurate differentiation between human and nonhuman species, providing important statistical support and resources for forensic anthropologists and other disciplines.

BIOLOGY-BASEL (2022)

Article Biology

The Effects of Cranial Orientation on Forensic Frontal Sinus Identification as Assessed by Outline Analyses

Lauren N. Butaric, Allison Richman, Heather M. Garvin

Summary: This study investigates how slight deviations in radiographic orientations affect frontal sinus size and outline shape, potentially impacting identification. The study found that horizontal deviations had minimal impact on sinus breadth, while vertical deviations significantly affected sinus height. Smaller and/or discontinuous sinuses were more prone to alterations, highlighting the need for careful matching of radiographic orientation in frontal sinus identification.

BIOLOGY-BASEL (2022)

Article Anatomy & Morphology

Ontogenetic patterns in human frontal sinus shape: A longitudinal study using elliptical Fourier analysis

Lauren N. Butaric, Jessica L. Campbell, Kristine M. Fischer, Heather M. Garvin

Summary: Frontal sinus morphology varies greatly between individuals and becomes more complex with age. The final shape of the frontal sinus is typically achieved by the age of 20, with females reaching this shape earlier than males. This study has significant implications for understanding the development of frontal sinuses, clinical applications, and forensic work.

JOURNAL OF ANATOMY (2022)

Article Medicine, General & Internal

A Novel Method for Digital Reconstruction of the Mucogingival Borderline in Optical Scans of Dental Plaster Casts

Leonard Simon Brandenburg, Stefan Schlager, Lara Sophie Harzig, David Steybe, Rene Marcel Rothweiler, Felix Burkhardt, Benedikt Christopher Spies, Joachim Georgii, Marc Christian Metzger

Summary: Adequate soft-tissue dimensions are crucial for the success of dental implants. This study uses statistical shape models to calculate the mucogingival borderline and accurately reconstructs it using intra-oral scanner data and principal component analysis.

JOURNAL OF CLINICAL MEDICINE (2022)

Article Mathematics

Geodesics in the TPS Space

Valerio Varano, Stefano Gabriele, Franco Milicchio, Stefan Shlager, Ian Dryden, Paolo Piras

Summary: In shape analysis, the interpolation of shapes' trajectories is often done through geodesics in a chosen Riemannian Shape Space. A new Riemannian shape space called TPS Space based on the Thin Plate Spline interpolant is introduced, and its geodesic properties are characterized. Several applications demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed formulation in conserving important physical properties of deformation.

MATHEMATICS (2022)

Article Medicine, Legal

Investigating error in saw mark minimum kerf width measurements

Alexis L. VanBaarle, Heather M. Garvin

Summary: This study investigated the measurement precision of minimum kerf width (MKW), which provides information about the tool used in cases of skeletal sharp force trauma. The results showed that measurements taken with internal calipers and a stereo microscope had the lowest error, while measurements taken with external calipers performed the worst.

JOURNAL OF FORENSIC SCIENCES (2023)

Article Dentistry, Oral Surgery & Medicine

Creating an anatomical wax-up in partially edentulous patients by means of a statistical shape model

Leonard Simon Brandenburg, Steffen Jochen Schwarz, Benedikt Christopher Spies, Julia Vera Weingart, Joachim Georgii, Britta A. Jung, Felix Burkhardt, Stefan Schlager, Marc Christian Metzger

Summary: This study presents a new method for automatically reconstructing missing teeth using a virtual wax-up. The accuracy of the method was evaluated and compared with the final prosthodontic work. The results showed that the reconstruction accuracy was close to the original in artificially generated tooth gaps. However, the method did not consider prosthodontic aspects and further improvements are needed for clinical use.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF COMPUTERIZED DENTISTRY (2022)

Article Engineering, Biomedical

Reconstruction of dental roots for implant planning purposes: a feasibility study

Leonard Simon Brandenburg, Lukas Berger, Steffen Jochen Schwarz, Hans Meine, Julia Vera Weingart, David Steybe, Benedikt Christopher Spies, Felix Burkhardt, Stefan Schlager, Marc Christian Metzger

Summary: This study examines the use of a statistical shape model (SSM) to compute the course of dental roots based on a surface scan. The SSM is generated using open-source software and allows for the estimation of tooth axes. The results show that the SSM can accurately predict the approximate course of dental roots and can be used as a reference for implant positioning.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF COMPUTER ASSISTED RADIOLOGY AND SURGERY (2022)

Meeting Abstract Anthropology

Frontal sinus morphology as a forensic identification method: a comparison of intra-observer scores between scout radiographs and 3D skull images

Patricia R. Avent, Jessica L. Campbell, Heather M. Garvin, Lauren N. Butaric

AMERICAN JOURNAL OF BIOLOGICAL ANTHROPOLOGY (2022)

Meeting Abstract Anthropology

A test of subadult stature estimation equations on modern samples

Heather M. Garvin, Tanner Pulsipher

AMERICAN JOURNAL OF BIOLOGICAL ANTHROPOLOGY (2022)

Meeting Abstract Anthropology

Dmanisi, Malapa, and the Evolution of Broca's Language Area

Shawn D. Hurst, Ralph L. Holloway, Alannah Pearson, Grace Bocko, Heather M. Garvin, Lee R. Berger, John Hawks

AMERICAN JOURNAL OF BIOLOGICAL ANTHROPOLOGY (2022)

Article Medicine, Legal

Detection of diatoms in a case of mud aspiration at a coastal area

Shigeki Tsuneya, Makoto Nakajima, Maiko Yoshida, Yumi Hoshioka, Fumiko Chiba, Go Inokuchi, Suguru Torimitsu, Hirotaro Iwase

Summary: This case report highlights the detection of diatoms in a non-drowned human who had aspirated mud. Careful analysis of diatoms in various samples can help differentiate true drowning from false-positives in non-drowning cases.

LEGAL MEDICINE (2024)

Article Medicine, Legal

Drug-facilitated sexual assault followed by femicidal chloroform poisoning and suffocation: A case-report of criminal responsibility

Jessika Camatti, Ivan Galliani, Antonello Cirnelli, Rossana Cecchi

Summary: This article presents a case study on the evaluation of criminal responsibility of a murderer. The multidisciplinary approach was used to investigate and analyze the case, and through psychological tests and interviews, experts concluded that the accused cannot be exempted from criminal responsibility for the homicide.

LEGAL MEDICINE (2024)