4.7 Review

Effects of landscape structure on avian-mediated insect pest control services: a review

Journal

LANDSCAPE ECOLOGY
Volume 32, Issue 5, Pages 931-944

Publisher

SPRINGER
DOI: 10.1007/s10980-017-0503-1

Keywords

Avian predators; Conservation; Crop fields; Ecosystem services; Insect pests; Pest suppression

Funding

  1. Sao Paulo Research Foundation (FAPESP) [2013/23457-6, 2013/12777-0, 2014/11676-8]
  2. Brazilian Ministry of Education (CAPES-DS)
  3. National Science Foundation Grant [1158817]
  4. National Council for Scientific and Technological Development (CNPQ) [307934/2011-0]
  5. Office Of Internatl Science &Engineering
  6. Office Of The Director [1158817] Funding Source: National Science Foundation

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Context Despite increasing evidence that landscape composition and configuration strongly influence the community structure of potential pest-regulators, landscape structure has seldom been explicitly linked with the rate and magnitude of pest-control services. Objectives and methods We conducted a systematic literature review evaluating 158 relevant studies to: (1) characterize our existing understanding of the empirical relationships between landscape structure and avian-mediated insect pest control services in agricultural systems, (2) identify gaps in our current understanding, and (3) develop a conceptual model of landscape structural influences on avian-mediated pest control. Results and discussion We found on-farm pest suppression by birds was often higher in landscapes with higher native habitat cover, higher compositional heterogeneity, and in agricultural patches in closer proximity to native habitats. We identified more than 200 bird species that provide pest control services across both temperate and tropical regions. While most avian predators are habitat-generalist species, a substantial fraction of pest control services in tropical regions was mediated by habitat-dependent species, suggesting a link between conservation management and maintenance of pest control services. We identified a three-part research agenda for future investigations of the relationships between landscape structure and avian-mediated pest control, focusing on an improved understanding of mechanisms related to: (1) predator-prey interactions and landscape modulation of trophic relationships, (2) bird dispersal ability and landscape connectivity, and (3) cross-habitat spillover of habitat-dependent avian predators. Implications These findings can be applied to efforts to manage and design landscapes capable of supporting both biodiversity and ecosystem services.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Roads and forest edges facilitate yellow fever virus dispersion

Paula Ribeiro Prist, Leandro Reverberi Tambosi, Luis Filipe Mucci, Adriano Pinter, Renato Pereira de Souza, Renata de Lara Muylaert, Jonathan Roger Rhodes, Cesar Henrique Comin, Luciando da Fontoura Costa, Tatiana Lang D'Agostini, Juliana Telles de Deus, Monica Pavao, Marcio Port-Carvalho, Leila Del Castillo Saad, Maria Anice Mureb Sallum, Roberta Maria Fernandes Spinola, Jean Paul Metzger

Summary: Landscape connectivity is crucial for disease spread, with the yellow fever virus mainly dispersing through roads adjacent to forests and along forest edges. The spread speed varies by season, with most dispersals occurring within 1 km per day and within a week after arriving at the source node.

JOURNAL OF APPLIED ECOLOGY (2022)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

The value of biotic pollination and dense forest for fruit set of Arabica coffee: A global assessment

Celine Moreaux, Desiree A. L. Meireles, Jesper Sonne, Ernesto Badano, Alice Classen, Adrian Gonzalez-Chaves, Juliana Hipolito, Alexandra-Maria Klein, Pietro K. Maruyama, Jean Paul Metzger, Stacy M. Philpott, Carsten Rahbek, Fernanda T. Saturni, Tuanjit Sritongchuay, Teja Tscharntke, Shinsuke Uno, Carlos H. Vergara, Blandina F. Viana, Niels Strange, Bo Dalsgaard

Summary: Animal pollinators play a crucial role in enhancing coffee fruit set, increasing it by an average of approximately 18%. Dense forests in close proximity to coffee plantations can positively affect fruit set by providing high-quality habitats for bees, while forest cover and distance to open forest have minimal impact on bee richness and coffee fruit set. Further research is needed to better understand the biodiversity value of dense forest for pollinators and their pollination services.

AGRICULTURE ECOSYSTEMS & ENVIRONMENT (2022)

Article Ecology

The Brazilian intergovernmental fiscal transfer for conservation: A successful but self-limiting incentive program

P. G. C. Ruggiero, A. Pfaff, P. Pereda, E. Nichols, J. P. Metzger

Summary: The ICMS-E policy in Brazil incentivizes the establishment of PAs by municipalities to receive financial rewards, but the impact decreases as more PAs are created. States use ICMS-E to encourage local implementation of conservation preferences, while municipal governments focus on low-cost actions to increase revenue.

ECOLOGICAL ECONOMICS (2022)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Positive forest cover effects on coffee yields are consistent across regions

Adrian Gonzalez-Chaves, Luisa G. Carvalheiro, Lucas A. Garibaldi, Jean Paul Metzger

Summary: Enhancing biodiversity-based ecosystem services can lead to win-win opportunities for conservation and agricultural production. Forest cover is a crucial factor affecting coffee yields, and coffee cover is the most relevant management practice associated with coffee yield prediction.

JOURNAL OF APPLIED ECOLOGY (2022)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Landscape composition regulates the spillover of beneficial insects between forest remnants and adjacent coffee plantations

Hugo Reis Medeiros, Felipe Martello, Jean Paul Metzger, Karen Amanda Harper, Ximo Mengual, Ciro Abbud Righi, Milton Cezar Ribeiro

Summary: Cross-habitat movements are vital for the survival of beneficial insects in agricultural landscapes. This study examined how landscape structure influences the spillover of beneficial insects between crop and non-crop habitats. The findings suggest that predatory wasps forage in coffee plantations but rely on forest remnants for nesting sites and a consistent supply of resources. Forest conservation and restoration should be incorporated into agro-environmental schemes to enhance the spillover of beneficial insects and ecosystem services in coffee farmlands.

PERSPECTIVES IN ECOLOGY AND CONSERVATION (2022)

Article Ecology

AMAZONIA CAMTRAP: A data set of mammal, bird, and reptile species recorded with camera traps in the Amazon forest

Ana Carolina Antunes, Anelise Montanarin, Diogo Maia Grabin, Erison Carlos dos Santos Monteiro, Fernando Ferreira de Pinho, Guilherme Costa Alvarenga, Jorge Ahumada, Robert B. Wallace, Emiliano Esterci Ramalho, Adrian Paul Ashton Barnett, Alex Bager, Alexandre Martins Costa Lopes, Alexine Keuroghlian, Aline Giroux, Ana Maria Herrera, Ana Paula de Almeida Correa, Ana Yoko Meiga, Anah Tereza de Almeida Jacomo, Ananda de Barros Barban, Andre Antunes, Andre Giovanni de Almeida Coelho, Andre Restel Camilo, Andre Valle Nunes, Andrea Cristina dos Santos Maroclo Gomes, Antonio Carlos da Silva Zanzini, Arlison Bezerra Castro, Arnaud Leonard Jean Desbiez, Axa Figueiredo, Benoit de Thoisy, Benoit Gauzens, Brunno Tolentino Oliveira, Camilla Angelica de Lima, Carlos Augusto Peres, Carlos Cesar Durigan, Carlos Rodrigo Brocardo, Clarissa Alves da Rosa, Claudia Zarate-Castaneda, Claudio M. Monteza-Moreno, Cleide Carnicer, Cristiano Trape Trinca, Daiana Jeronimo Polli, Daniel da Silva Ferraz, Daniel F. Lane, Daniel Gomes da Rocha, Daniele Cristina Barcelos, David Auz, Dian Carlos Pinheiro Rosa, Diego Afonso Silva, Divino Vicente Silverio, Donald P. Eaton, Eduardo Nakano-Oliveira, Eduardo Venticinque, Elildo Carvalho Junior, Eloisa Neves Mendonca, Emerson Monteiro Vieira, Emiliana Isasi-Catala, Erich Fischer, Erika Paula Castro, Erison Gomes Oliveira, Fabiano Rodrigues de Melo, Fabio de Lima Muniz, Fabio Rohe, Fabricio Beggiato Baccaro, Fernanda Michalski, Fernanda Pozzan Paim, Fernanda Santos, Fernando Anaguano, Francesca Belem Lopes Palmeira, Francielly da Silva Reis, Francisca Helena Aguiar-Silva, Gabriel de Avila Batista, Galo Zapata-Rios, German Forero-Medina, Gilson De Souza Ferreira Neto, Giselle Bastos Alves, Guido Ayala, Gustavo Henrique Prado Pedersoli, Hani R. El Bizri, Helena Alves do Prado, Hugo Borghezan Mozerle, Hugo C. M. Costa, Ivan Junqueira Lima, Jaime Palacios, Jasmine de Resende Assis, Jean P. Boubli, Jean Paul Metzger, Jessica Vieira Teixeira, Joao Marcelo Deliberador Miranda, John Polisar, Julia Salvador, Karen Borges-Almeida, Karl Didier, Karla Dayane de Lima Pereira, Kelly Torralvo, Krisna Gajapersad, Leandro Silveira, Leandro Uceli Maioli, Leonardo Maracahipes-Santos, Leonor Valenzuela, Leticia Benavalli, Lydia Fletcher, Lucas Navarro Paolucci, Lucas Pereira Zanzini, Luciana Zago da Silva, Luiz Claudio Ribeiro Rodrigues, Maira Benchimol, Marcela Alvares Oliveira, Marcela Lima, Marcelia Basto da Silva, Marcelo Augusto dos Santos Junior, Maria Viscarra, Mario Cohn-Haft, Mark Ilan Abrahams, Maximiliano Auguto Benedetti, Miriam Marmontel, Myriam R. Hirt, Natalia Mundim Torres, Orlando Ferreira Cruz Junior, Patricia Alvarez-Loayza, Patrick Jansen, Paula Ribeiro Prist, Paulo Monteiro Brando, Phamela Bernardes Peronico, Rafael do Nascimento Leite, Rafael Magalhaes Rabelo, Rahel Sollmann, Raone Beltrao-Mendes, Raphael Augusto Foscarini Ferreira, Raphaella Coutinho, Regison da Costa Oliveira, Renata Ilha, Renato Richard Hilario, Ricardo Araujo Prudente Pires, Ricardo Sampaio, Roberto da Silva Moreira, Robinson Botero-Arias, Rodolfo Vasquez Martinez, Rodrigo Affonso de Albuquerque Nobrega, Rodrigo Ferreira Fadini, Ronaldo G. Morato, Ronaldo Leal Carneiro, Rony Peterson Santos Almeida, Rossano Marchetti Ramos, Roxana Schaub, Rubem Dornas, Ruben Cueva, Samir Rolim, Samuli Laurindo, Santiago Espinosa, Tais Nogueira Fernandes, Tania Margarete Sanaiotti, Thiago Henrique Gomide Alvim, Tiago Teixeira Dornas, Tony Enrique Noriega Pina, Victor Lery Caetano Andrade, Wagner Tadeu Vieira Santiago, William E. Magnusson, Zilca Campos, Milton Cezar Ribeiro

Summary: The Amazon forest is home to the highest biodiversity on Earth. However, information on the diversity of vertebrates in the Amazonian region is still lacking. In this study, camera traps were used to collect data on mammals, birds, and reptiles in different regions of the Amazon. The resulting dataset is the most comprehensive inventory of species ever compiled for the area, providing opportunities for ecological studies and evaluation of environmental impacts.

ECOLOGY (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Turnover rates of regenerated forests challenge restoration efforts in the Brazilian Atlantic forest

Pedro Ribeiro Piffer, Marcos Reis Rosa, Leandro Reverberi Tambosi, Jean Paul Metzger, Maria Uriarte

Summary: Natural forest regeneration is crucial for global ecosystem restoration. This study focuses on the Brazilian Atlantic Forest and reveals that regenerated forests have higher persistence and longevity in areas with steep slopes, close to rivers and existing forests, near permanent agriculture, and in regions with higher economic development and agricultural yield. However, regenerated forests are less likely to persist in areas with higher rural-urban population ratios. The findings emphasize the importance of favorable conditions and policies to promote second-growth forest persistence in tropical regions.

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2022)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Agricultural certification as a complementary tool for environmental law compliance

Francisco d'Albertas, Patricia Ruggiero, Luis Fernando Guedes Pinto, Gerd Sparovek, Jean Paul Metzger

Summary: Agricultural sustainability standards play an important role in reducing the negative impact of commodity expansion on biodiversity. However, the actual conservation benefits derived from certification are not clear. In a study conducted in southern Brazil, it was found that certification had no significant effects on vegetation regeneration, deforestation rates, and vegetation cover deficit in certified farms.

BIOLOGICAL CONSERVATION (2023)

Article Biology

Habitat split as a driver of disease in amphibians

C. Guilherme Becker, Sasha E. E. Greenspan, Renato A. A. Martins, Mariana L. L. Lyra, Paula Prist, Jean Paul Metzger, Vinicius Sao Sao Pedro, Celio F. B. Haddad, Emily H. H. Le Sage, Douglas C. C. Woodhams, Anna E. E. Savage

Summary: Anthropogenic habitat disturbance is altering disease transmission and immunity patterns in vertebrate species. While previous studies have focused on habitat loss and fragmentation, equally important is the process of habitat split, which can lead to population declines and enhanced disease risk. This study links habitat split to disease risk in amphibians by exploring the forces shaping immunity and conducting a field study on tropical frogs. The study proposes a framework to investigate the mechanisms by which habitat split influences disease risk, highlighting the importance of symbiotic microbial communities, immunogenetic variation, and stress hormone levels. The findings suggest that habitat restoration strategies can enhance the vertebrate immune system and reduce disease through connecting multiple natural habitats.

BIOLOGICAL REVIEWS (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Evidence of time-lag in the provision of ecosystem services by tropical regenerating forests to coffee yields

Adrian David Gonzalez-Chaves, Luisa Gigante Carvalheiro, Pedro Ribero Piffer, Francisco d'Albertas, Tereza Cristina Giannini, Blandina Felipe Viana, Jean Paul Metzger

Summary: Restoring native tropical forests is important for protecting biodiversity and ecosystem functions, but the contribution of early stages of forest regeneration to crop productivity is not well understood. A study in Brazil found that young regenerating forests have a positive association with coffee yield when there is a sufficient amount of preserved forest nearby. These findings highlight the importance of both regenerating and mature forests in supporting pollination and pest control services that affect coffee yields. It emphasizes the need for public policies to promote ecosystem restoration and ensure the long-term permanence of these new forests.

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH LETTERS (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Exploring the role of boundary work in a social-ecological synthesis initiative

Barbara Schroeter, Claudia Sattler, Jean Paul Metzger, Jonathan R. Rhodes, Marie-Josee Fortin, Camila Hohlenwerger, L. Roman Carrasco, Oerjan Bodin

Summary: Inter- and transdisciplinary collaboration in environmental studies face the challenge of effectively communicating across disciplines to address pressing environmental challenges. This research brief evaluates the use of a boundary work approach in a synthesis group on socio-ecological systems, and discusses how it can integrate the knowledge of natural and social scientists. The results show that strategic selection of members, inclusion of boundary spanners, and prior identification of boundary concepts and objects can enhance collaboration and problem-solving in multidisciplinary teams.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL STUDIES AND SCIENCES (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

When forest loss leads to biodiversity gain: Insights from the Brazilian Atlantic Forest

Julia Rodrigues Barreto, Renata Pardini, Jean Paul Metzger, Fernando Augusto Barbosa Silva, Elizabeth S. Nichols

Summary: Decades of research have shown that habitat loss does not always lead to biodiversity loss, as exemplified by the study on dung beetle responses to Atlantic Forest loss. While generalist species increased in abundance and distribution, specialist species did not change in overall abundance but exhibited dissimilar distribution. This suggests that habitat loss can lead to biodiversity gain and differentiation, influenced by regional dynamics and the resilience of forest biota. The study emphasizes the importance of sampling across multiple spatial scales to understand the effects of habitat loss on biodiversity.

BIOLOGICAL CONSERVATION (2023)

Review Environmental Sciences

A Review of Condition Metrics Used in Biodiversity Offsetting

Clarice Borges-Matos, Martine Maron, Jean Paul Metzger

Summary: Biodiversity offsets are often questioned in terms of their effectiveness. The review of existing condition metrics used in the offsetting context revealed differences in how ecological attributes from biodiversity, landscape, and ecosystem services were included. It is suggested that condition metrics should include the three dimensions of equivalence in a disaggregated way, and the use of modeling, expert opinion, and GIS could facilitate this.

ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2023)

Article Ecology

Linking landscape structure and ecosystem service flow

Julia C. Assis, Camila Hohlenwerger, Jean Paul Metzger, Jonathan R. Rhodes, Gabriela T. Duarte, Rafaela A. da Silva, Andrea Larissa Boesing, Paula R. Prist, Milton Cezar Ribeiro

Summary: Despite progress in understanding the effects of landscape structure on ecosystem services, there are challenges in integrating landscape effects on different components of the service provision chain. This study proposes a theoretical framework to explore how the spatial flow of ecosystem services can vary based on landscape structure, emphasizing the role of supply, demand, and neutral areas, as well as individual characteristics of services. The model links landscape metrics with ratios of supply and demand areas to potential effects on spatial flows of ecosystem services.

ECOSYSTEM SERVICES (2023)

Review Biodiversity Conservation

Science and environmental policy establishment: the case of the Forest Act in the State of Sao Paulo, Brazil

Kaline de Mello, Alice Brites, Clarice Borges-Matos, Paulo Andre Tavares, Jean Paul Metzger, Ricardo Ribeiro Rodrigues, Zenilda Ledo dos Santos, Carlos Alfredo Joly, Gerd Sparovek

Summary: Natural ecosystems worldwide are facing severe threats, and environmental policies are crucial in protecting biodiversity, ecosystem services, and addressing climate change. The New Forest Act in Brazil is a key policy for conserving native vegetation on private lands, which account for 54% of the remaining Brazilian native vegetation. However, conflicts between environmental and agricultural concerns hinder the implementation of the Act, highlighting the need for balanced solutions based on scientific evidence.

BIOTA NEOTROPICA (2022)

No Data Available