4.7 Review

Sediment source fingerprinting as an aid to catchment management: A review of the current state of knowledge and a methodological decision-tree for end-users

Journal

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT
Volume 194, Issue -, Pages 86-108

Publisher

ACADEMIC PRESS LTD- ELSEVIER SCIENCE LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.jenvman.2016.09.075

Keywords

Suspended sediment sources; Source fingerprinting; Source tracing; Mixing model; Uncertainty

Ask authors/readers for more resources

The growing awareness of the environmental significance of fine-grained sediment fluxes through catchment systems continues to underscore the need for reliable information on the principal sources of this material. Source estimates are difficult to obtain using traditional monitoring techniques, but sediment source fingerprinting or tracing procedures, have emerged as a potentially valuable alternative. Despite the rapidly increasing numbers of studies reporting the use of sediment source fingerprinting, several key challenges and uncertainties continue to hamper consensus among the international scientific community on key components of the existing methodological procedures. Accordingly, this contribution reviews and presents recent developments for several key aspects of fingerprinting, namely: sediment source classification, catchment source and target sediment sampling, tracer selection, grain size issues, tracer conservatism, source apportionment modelling, and assessment of source predictions using artificial mixtures. Finally, a decision-tree representing the current state of knowledge is presented, to guide end-users in applying the fingerprinting approach. (C) 2016 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Education & Educational Research

(Un)willingness to contribute financially towards advice surrounding diffuse water pollution: the perspectives o farmers and advisors

Charlotte-Anne Chivers, Adrian L. Collins

Summary: This study explores the willingness of English farmers to pay for advice on diffuse water pollution from agriculture (DWPA). The findings indicate that the majority of participants are unwilling to pay, citing reasons such as unwillingness to contribute, financial constraints, availability of alternative advice sources, farmers' accountability, and exclusion risk. Only a small proportion express a willingness to pay, particularly if the advice is of high quality and relevant to the farm or compliance is required.

JOURNAL OF AGRICULTURAL EDUCATION & EXTENSION (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Sediment source apportionment using geochemical composite signatures in a large and polluted river system with a semiarid-coastal interface, Brazil

Rennan Cabral Nascimento, Angelo Jamil Maia, Ygor Jacques Agra Bezerra da Silva, Fabio Farias Amorim, Clistenes Williams Araujo do Nascimento, Tales Tiecher, Olivier Evrard, Adrian L. Collins, Caroline Miranda Biondi, Yuri Jacques Agra Bezerra da Silva

Summary: The source contributions to suspended and bed sediments in the polluted Ipojuca River system were quantified using geochemical tracers. The study identified the lower catchment, Oxisols, and sugarcane croplands as the dominant sediment sources. These findings are crucial for managing excessive sediment loads and sediment-associated contaminants in estuarine and coastal environments.

CATENA (2023)

Editorial Material Engineering, Environmental

Protein quality as a complementary functional unit in life cycle assessment (LCA)

G. A. McAuliffe, T. Takahashi, T. Beal, T. Huppertz, F. Leroy, J. Buttriss, A. L. Collins, A. Drewnowski, S. J. McLaren, F. Ortenzi, J. C. van der Pols, S. van Vliet, M. R. F. Lee

Summary: A number of recent life cycle assessment (LCA) studies have highlighted the environmental impacts of animal-sourced foods and suggested restrictions or avoidance of these foods in human diets. However, it is important to consider nutrient bioavailability and protein quality before making such recommendations, especially considering their contribution to nutrient adequacy in vulnerable populations. This paper discusses the usefulness of nutritional LCA (nLCA) and proposes the consideration of protein quality in nLCA studies.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF LIFE CYCLE ASSESSMENT (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Optimisation of Cereal Farm Strategies for Mitigating Externalities Associated with Intensive Production

Yusheng Zhang, Adrian L. Collins

Summary: The intensive cereal farming in the UK leads to unintended consequences, such as water pollution. The current adoption of best management measures has limited benefits, and alternative management scenarios need to be explored. This study used the Farmscoper tool to examine two management scenarios for intensive cereal farms in eastern England. The mechanistic scenario, based on a better understanding of on-farm pollutant sources, resulted in greater reductions in pollutant emissions compared to the current advice scenario, but with mixed impacts on costs. Neither scenario had a significant impact on unintended consequences, highlighting the need for structural changes in land cover.

WATER (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Investigating the effect of seismicity on spatial sediment sources and loads using the fingerprinting approach

Nafiseh Ashtari, Kazem Nosrati, Salma Ommi, Adrian L. Collins

Summary: Elevated soil erosion and suspended sediment loss are severe environmental problems in river catchments of Iran. This study investigated the sediment sources and loads in the Talar Drainage Basin in Iran, in relation to earthquake frequency and magnitude. The results showed that seismic activity and ground acceleration have a significant impact on sediment loss and can elevate erosivity and erodibility factors. The study supports environmental planners in targeting management strategies to reduce suspended sediment loads and protect fluvial habitats.

CATENA (2023)

Article Geosciences, Multidisciplinary

Post-farming land restoration schemes exhibit higher soil aggregate stability and organic carbon: Evidence in the Three Gorges Reservoir Area, China

Chen Han, Minxin Song, Qiang Tang, Jie Wei, Xiubin He, Adrian L. Collins

Summary: The impact of restorative land management schemes on soil systems in the Three Gorges Reservoir Area remains poorly understood. This study found that reforestation and cropland abandonment can increase soil aggregate stability and organic carbon stocks. Additionally, abandoned croplands even exhibited higher soil aggregate stability and organic carbon stocks than reforestation woodlands. However, citrus woodlands had lower soil aggregate stability and organic carbon content compared to present-day croplands.

CATENA (2023)

Article Ecology

What do macroinvertebrate indices measure? Stressor-specific stream macroinvertebrate indices can be confounded by other stressors

J. Iwan Jones, Charlotte E. M. Lloyd, John F. F. Murphy, Amanda Arnold, Chas P. P. Duerdoth, Adrianna Hawczak, James L. L. Pretty, Penny J. J. Johnes, Jim E. E. Freer, Moragh W. W. Stirling, Carla Richmond, Adrian L. L. Collins

Summary: Monitoring programmes worldwide use biota to assess water body health. Numerical stressor-specific biotic indices based on biota response have been developed, but it is unclear how variation in pressures within sites influences different biotic groups. Understanding this would help in setting achievable targets and implementing effective mitigation strategies.

FRESHWATER BIOLOGY (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Using the colour of recent overbank sediment deposits in two large catchments to determine sediment sources for targeting mitigation of catchment-specific management issues

S. Pulley, A. L. Collins

Summary: The effective management of sediment losses in large river systems is crucial for preserving their water sources and ecosystem services. However, due to budgetary and logistical constraints, the understanding of catchment sediment dynamics needed for targeted management is often lacking. This study investigates the use of office document scanners to collect recently deposited overbank sediment and measure its color, providing a rapid and cost-effective method to identify the evolution of sediment sources in two UK river catchments. The results demonstrate the potential of using sediment color as an informative tool for improving catchment management measures.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Use of a submersible spectrophotometer probe to fingerprint spatial suspended sediment sources at catchment scale

Niels F. Lake, Nuria Martinez-Carreras, Jean Francois Iffly, Peter J. Shaw, Adrian L. Collins

Summary: Sediment fingerprinting is a method used to identify the sources of sediment in a catchment. Traditional approaches require extensive resources for sampling and laboratory analysis. This study proposes the use of UV-VIS absorbance spectra, measured by submersible spectrophotometers, as a rapid and non-destructive method for sediment fingerprinting. Results showed a relatively low deviation between the spatial source contributions using absorbance and sediment budgeting, indicating the potential of this method for sediment tracing in natural environments.

SCIENCE OF THE TOTAL ENVIRONMENT (2023)

Article Soil Science

The soil organic carbon: Clay ratio in North Devon, UK: Implications for marketing soil carbon as an asset class

S. Pulley, H. Taylor, J. M. Prout, S. M. Haefele, A. L. Collins

Summary: Building up stocks of soil organic carbon (SOC) can improve soil conditions and mitigate climate change. The ratio of SOC to clay provides a better indicator of soil condition and could serve as a benchmark for ecosystem service payments. The study found that all arable soils and most ley grassland soils in the North Devon UNESCO World Biosphere Reserve exceeded the desired SOC:clay ratio, indicating potential for building up SOC stocks. However, land use had a significant impact on SOC:clay ratios, with permanent pasture fields having the highest ratios. The study suggests that preserving existing SOC stocks would be a more suitable basis for ecosystem service payments in the region.

SOIL USE AND MANAGEMENT (2023)

Editorial Material Agronomy

A commentary on key methodological developments related to nutritional life cycle assessment (nLCA) generated throughout a 6-year strategic scientific programme

G. A. McAuliffe, T. Takahashi, M. R. F. Lee, A. Jebari, L. Cardenas, A. Kumar, F. Pereyra-Goday, H. Scalabrino, A. L. Collins

Summary: Rothamsted Research is the world's oldest agricultural research centre, which has successfully integrated human nutrition into environmental footprint assessment through life cycle assessment methodology, providing valuable insights for sustainable agriculture.

FOOD AND ENERGY SECURITY (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Hydro-chemical responses at different scales in a rural catchment, UK, and implications for managing the unintended consequences of agriculture

S. J. Granger, H. R. Upadhayay, A. L. Collins

Summary: Diffuse pollutant transfers from agricultural land are major contributors to annual loads in catchments, with storm events dominating these fluxes. The mechanisms of pollutants' movement through catchments at different scales are not well understood, which hinders the matching of on-farm management strategies with environmental quality assessment. This study aimed to investigate how the mechanisms of pollutant export change at different scales and the implications for on-farm management strategies.

ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Grazing livestock move by Levy walks: Implications for soil health and environment

Alejandro Romero-Ruiz, M. Jordana Rivero, Alice Milne, Sarah Morgan, Paulo De Meo-Filho, Simon Pulley, Carmen Segura, Paul Harris, Michael RF. Lee, Kevin Coleman, Laura Cardenas, Andrew P. Whitmore

Summary: Grazing livestock is crucial for food security, agricultural sustainability, and climate change. Understanding how livestock move and interact with their environment can provide insights into the impact of grazing practices on soil and ecosystem functions. GPS data was used to characterize daily and seasonal grazing patterns and a new model was developed to predict changes in soil properties.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Bioenergy crop production and carbon sequestration potential under changing climate and land use: A case study in the upper River Taw catchment in southwest England

Prakash N. Dixit, Goetz M. Richter, Kevin Coleman, Adrian L. Collins

Summary: Reducing CO2 emissions is crucial for the UK to achieve its net zero policy objective. By leveraging climate change and land use change, suitable bioenergy crops can be strategically deployed to enhance energy production and carbon sequestration. This study evaluates the potential of bioenergy crops and their response to changing climate in the upper River Taw observatory catchment in southwest England. The results indicate that a warming climate positively impacts the production of all crops considered, with colder areas benefiting more in terms of biomass. Additionally, converting permanent grassland to perennial bioenergy crops can increase production and carbon sequestration potential.

SCIENCE OF THE TOTAL ENVIRONMENT (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Treatment of cow manure from exercise pens: A laboratory-scale study of the effect of air injection on conventional and alternative biofilters

Elizabeth Alvarez-Chavez, Stephane Godbout, Mylene Genereux, Caroline Cote, Alain N. Rousseau, Sebastien Fournel

Summary: This study evaluated the effect of alternative filtering materials and bed aeration on the retention of nutrients and fecal bacteria in woodchip bedded stand-off pads for cows. The results showed that the alternative biofilters were more efficient in removing COD, SS, TN, and NO3-N, while conventional biofilters were more efficient for PO4-P removal. Aeration did not have a significant effect under the tested temperature conditions.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Research on oxygen enrichment for municipal solid waste fly ash melting: A pilot-scale study on natural gas and coal as the melting fuel

Yike Zhang, Zengyi Ma, Zhuoting Fang, Yuandong Qian, Zhiping Huang, Yilong Ye, Jianhua Yan

Summary: This study investigates the application of oxygen enrichment melting technology in the melting of municipal solid waste incineration fly ash. The results demonstrate that oxygen enrichment technology can reduce energy consumption and operating costs, as well as decrease pollution emissions.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Temporal and vertical dynamics of carbon accumulation potential under grazing-excluded grasslands in China: The role of soil bulk density

Liangang Xiao, Mingkai Leng, Philip Greenwood, Rongqin Zhao, Zhixiang Xie, Zengtao You, Junguo Liu

Summary: This study investigates the effects of grazing exclusion on soil organic carbon (SOC) accumulation and vegetation recovery. It finds that grazing exclusion can increase the potential for SOC accumulation, and higher annual precipitation is positively correlated with SOC accumulation.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Adsorption on activated carbon combined with ozonation for the removal of contaminants of emerging concern in drinking water

Beatrice Cantoni, Jessica Ianes, Beatrice Bertolo, Selena Ziccardi, Francesco Maffini, Manuela Antonelli

Summary: This study evaluates the performance of ozonation and adsorption as in-series processes compared to standalone processes for the removal of Contaminants of Emerging Concern (CECs) in drinking water. The combination of both processes proves to be more effective than adsorption and ozonation alone. Ozonation improves the adsorption performance of poorly-oxidizable CECs but worsens that of well-oxidizable compounds. This research highlights the importance of considering both processes in the removal of CECs in drinking water treatment plants.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

The characteristic of compound drought and saltwater intrusion events in the several major river estuaries worldwide

Dan Li, Bingjun Liu, Yang Lu, Jianyu Fu

Summary: A new Standardized compound Drought and Saltwater intrusion Index (SDSI) was developed to detect changes in the severity of CDSEs in six estuaries. The study found that saltwater intrusion plays a dominant role in influencing SDSI severity, and CDSEs vary in frequency, duration and severity among different estuaries.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Inactivation of pathogenic microorganisms in water by electron beam excitation multi-wavelength ultraviolet irradiation: Efficiency, influence factors and mechanism

Yong-Qiang Li, Rui Sun, Chong-Miao Zhang, Zi-Xuan Liu, Rui-tao Chen, Jian Zhao, Hua-dong Gu, Huan-Cai Yin

Summary: In this study, an electron beam excitation multi-wavelength ultraviolet (EBE-MW-UV) system was established and found to have significantly higher microbial inactivation effects compared to single-wavelength UV-LEDs in water. Mechanism analysis revealed that EBE-MW-UV damaged microbial DNA and proteins, and generated additional reactive oxygen species, leading to microbial inactivation.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Improved anaerobic sludge fermentation mediated by a tryptophan-degrading consortium: Effectiveness assessment and mechanism deciphering

Kaili Ma, Xinxin Han, Qiujuan Li, Yu Kong, Qiaoli Liu, Xu Yan, Yahong Luo, Xiaopin Li, Huiyang Wen, Zhiguo Cao

Summary: This study reveals that the use of a tryptophan-degrading microbial consortium (TDC) can enhance the hydrolysis efficiency of waste activated sludge (WAS), increasing the yield and quality of short chain fatty acids (SCFAs) and improving the solubilization and release of organic substances from WAS.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Assessing and decoupling ecosystem services evolution in karst areas: A multi-model approach to support land management decision-making

Ling Xiong, Rui Li

Summary: Incorporating Ecosystem Service Value (ESV) into land use planning can provide informed land management decisions. This study evaluates the ESV of Guizhou Province in China's karst region. The results show an increase in total ESV over the past two decades due to ecological restoration projects.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Secure water quality prediction system using machine learning and blockchain technologies

M. Geetha Jenifel

Summary: This article discusses the importance of water and the pollution of freshwater resources, and introduces the use of machine learning models and blockchain technology to predict and protect water quality.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Effect of acid-modified biochar coupled with alternate wetting and drying on P leaching, soil P retention and plant P uptake in paddy fields

Stanslaus Terengia Materu, Taotao Chen, Chang Liu, Daocai Chi, Meng Jun

Summary: The study showed that H2SO4-modified biochar can reduce P leaching, increase soil available P, and enhance plant P uptake in alternate wetting and drying irrigation systems. Biochar additions B20A and IAWDB20A-M were effective in improving yield, reducing P leaching, and increasing APB.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Enhancing nitrogen removal from wastewater in a low C/N ratio using an air-lift bio-electrochemical reactor (ALBER)

Amir Nouri, Ali Akbar Zinatizadeh, Sirus Zinadini, Mark Van Loosdrecht

Summary: This study focuses on the development of an air-lift bio-electrochemical reactor (ALBER) with a continuous feeding regime to enhance nitrogen removal from synthetic wastewater. The effect of temperature, hydraulic retention time (HRT), N -NH+4 /TN ratio, and current density on the reactor performance was investigated, and the ALBER achieved a maximum TN removal of 73%. The results suggest that the ALBER has potential for treating industrial wastewater at low temperatures.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Agricultural practices and ditch size drive microbial community assembly and mediate N- and P-transformation in multistage drainage networks of paddy fields: Insights from a large-scale irrigation district in eastern China

Peifang Wang, Guoxiang You, Yang Gao, Juan Chen, Xun Wang, Chao Wang

Summary: This study investigated the ecological processes of microbial communities and N- and P-transformation processes in multistage agricultural drainage ditches. The results showed that the microbial communities were co-shaped by agricultural practices and ditch size, which further governed the N and P removal performance.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

The combination of multiple environmental stressors strongly alters microbial community assembly in aquatic ecosystems

Xiaofeng Niu, Huan Wang, Tao Wang, Peiyu Zhang, Huan Zhang, Hongxia Wang, Xianghong Kong, Songguang Xie, Jun Xu

Summary: Microorganisms play a critical role in maintaining ecosystem balance, and environmental stressors can affect the assembly processes of microbial communities. The study found that different stressors have opposite effects on microbial community assembly in water and sediment, and warming has different influences compared to herbicides and nutrients.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Hydrological reduction and control effect evaluation of sponge city construction based on one-way coupling model of SWMM-FVCOM: A case in university campus

Yuqing Tan, Qiming Cheng, Fengwei Lyu, Fei Liu, Linhao Liu, Yihong Su, Shaochun Yuan, Wenyu Xiao, Zhen Liu, Yao Chen

Summary: The exacerbation of global warming, extreme weather events, and rapid urbanization have led to increased flooding in urban areas. China has adopted sponge city as an efficient means of preventing and controlling urban floods. Using a SWMM-FVCOM model, the hydrological reduction and control effect of sponge city construction (SPCC) within a university campus were evaluated. The study found that implementing SPCC effectively mitigates surface runoff and reduces the severity of urban flooding. However, the efficacy of runoff control decreases with longer rainfall return periods.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)

Article Environmental Sciences

Development of a two-dimensional model to assess carbon dynamics and anthropogenic effects on CO2 emissions in the Tan river, southern China

Zhonghan Chen, Qiuyan Li, Shibo Yan, Juan Xu, Qiaoyun Lin, Zhuangming Zhao, Ziying He

Summary: Tidal rivers are important biochemical reaction channels, receiving carbon from wastewater and agricultural drains, affecting CO2 emissions. Through modeling and data analysis, researchers explored carbon distribution, emissions, and greenhouse effects, emphasizing the potential of river management to change global CO2 emissions under climate change.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2024)