4.4 Article Proceedings Paper

Microfluidic platform for optimization of crystallization conditions

Journal

JOURNAL OF CRYSTAL GROWTH
Volume 472, Issue -, Pages 18-28

Publisher

ELSEVIER SCIENCE BV
DOI: 10.1016/j.jcrysgro.2017.01.026

Keywords

Growth from solutions; Single crystal growth; Biological macromolecules; Lysozyme

Funding

  1. Institut de Recherche Servier
  2. ANR BAcMolMot [ANR-14-CE09-0023-03]
  3. Agence Nationale de la Recherche (ANR) [ANR-14-CE09-0023] Funding Source: Agence Nationale de la Recherche (ANR)

Ask authors/readers for more resources

We describe a universal, high-throughput droplet-based microfluidic platform for crystallization. It is suitable for a multitude of applications, due to its flexibility, ease of use, compatibility with all solvents and low cost. The platform offers four modular functions: droplet formation, on-line characterization, incubation and observation. We use it to generate droplet arrays with a concentration gradient in continuous long tubing, without using surfactant. We control droplet properties (size, frequency and spacing) in long tubing by using hydrodynamic empirical relations. We measure droplet chemical composition using both an off-line and a real-time on-line method. Applying this platform to a complicated chemical environment, membrane proteins, we successfully handle crystallization, suggesting that the platform is likely to perform well in other circumstances. We validate the platform for fine-gradient screening and optimization of crystallization conditions. Additional on-line detection methods may well be integrated into this platform in the future, for instance, an on-line diffraction technique. We believe this method could find applications in fields such as fluid interaction engineering, live cell study and enzyme kinetics.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.4
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Chemistry, Physical

The unexpected dominance of secondary over primary nucleation

Johannes Hoffmann, James Flannigan, Andrew Cashmore, Maria L. Briuglia, Rene R. E. Steendam, Charline J. J. Gerard, Mark D. Haw, Jan Sefcik, Joop H. ter Horst

Summary: Controlling particle formation in industrial crystallization processes is still a challenge. Secondary nucleation is identified as the dominant nucleation mechanism, and enantioselective secondary nucleation can be used to control the chirality of the product, making antisolvent crystallization a viable crystallization-enhanced deracemization technique.

FARADAY DISCUSSIONS (2022)

Article Chemistry, Physical

Nucleation in sessile saline microdroplets: induction time measurement via deliquescence-recrystallization cycling

Ruel Cedeno, Romain Grossier, Mehdi Lagaize, David Nerini, Nadine Candoni, Adrian Flood, Stephane Veesler

Summary: This study presents a novel approach for measuring and analyzing induction times in arrays of microdroplets. By controlling relative humidity, interference between microdroplets can be eliminated. Statistical analysis shows that the dimensionless induction times obtained from different datasets obey the same distribution, confirming the effect of confinement. The experimental method and data-treatment procedure presented in this study offer promising routes in the study of nucleation kinetics.

FARADAY DISCUSSIONS (2022)

Article Medicine, Research & Experimental

Melatonin: A short clarification for the use of over-enthusiasts

Jean A. Boutin

M S-MEDECINE SCIENCES (2022)

Article Biochemistry & Molecular Biology

Further assessments of ligase LplA-mediated modifications of proteins in vitro and in cellulo

Alicia Schirer, Anne Rouch, Estelle Marcheteau, Johann Stojko, Sophie Landron, Elodie Jeantet, Benjamin Fould, Gilles Ferry, Jean A. Boutin

Summary: The study provides a detailed method for labeling target proteins in cells using mutant ligase, revealing challenges such as difficulty in evaluating the click chemistry step in living cells and suggesting the preferred use of the Halo-Tag technique for clearer protein imaging in cellular context.

MOLECULAR BIOLOGY REPORTS (2022)

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

Template-Assisted Crystallization Behavior in Stirred Solutions o the Monoclonal Antibody Anti-CD20: Probability Distributions of Induction Times

Charline J. J. Gerard, Maria L. Briuglia, Nazer Rajoub, Teresa F. Mastropietro, Wenqian Chen, Jerry Y. Y. Heng, Gianluca Di Profio, Joop H. ter Horst

Summary: A method to determine protein template crystallization behavior has been presented and validated through experiments. The use of silica particles has been shown to enhance crystallization and nucleation rate, highlighting the importance of template particle characteristics in promoting protein crystallization.

CRYSTAL GROWTH & DESIGN (2022)

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

Evaporation Dynamics of Sessile Saline Microdroplets in Oil

Ruel Cedeno, Romain Grossier, Victoria Tishkova, Nadine Candoni, Adrian E. Flood, Stephane Veesler

Summary: The presence of concentration and temperature gradients in saline microdroplets evaporating in air makes them unsuitable for nucleation studies. However, immersing the droplet in oil and reducing the volume can address this issue. In this study, a model for evaporation dynamics of microdroplets in a thin layer of oil was presented. The model takes into account the diffusion distance, solute concentration, and diffusive interaction between neighboring droplets. Experimental data showed that neglecting diffusive interactions can lead to inaccurate droplet concentration measurement in nucleation experiments.

LANGMUIR (2022)

Article Biochemistry & Molecular Biology

Caloxin-derived peptides for the inhibition of plasma membrane calcium ATPases

Jean A. Boutin, Stephane Bedut, Magali Jullian, Mathieu Galibert, Lukasz Frankiewicz, Philippe Gloanec, Gilles Ferry, Karine Puget, Jerome Leprince

Summary: PMCAs are a family of transmembrane proteins responsible for calcium homeostasis and possibly linked to certain diseases. Through studying the functionality of PMCAs, a series of new peptide inhibitors with IC50 in the low mu M range have been discovered.

PEPTIDES (2022)

Article Biochemistry & Molecular Biology

Approach to the specificity and selectivity between D2 and D3 receptors by mutagenesis and binding experiments part I: Expression and characterization of D2 and D3 receptor mutants

Celine Legros, Anne Rojas, Clemence Dupre, Chantal Brasseur, Isabelle Riest-Fery, Olivier Muller, Jean-Claude Ortuno, Olivier Nosjean, Sophie-Penelope Guenin, Gilles Ferry, Jean A. Boutin

Summary: D3/D2 sub-specificity is a complex problem to solve due to the lack of easy structural biology of G-protein coupled receptors. This study used directed mutagenesis and basic binding experiments to explore a rational approach for the discovery of highly specific D3 ligands over D2 ligands. Stable expression of receptors in HEK cells was used to construct mutants and chimeras of D2 and D3 receptors, and their binding characteristics were analyzed using standard binding conditions. The study demonstrated the feasibility and potential of the approach.

PROTEIN SCIENCE (2022)

Article Biotechnology & Applied Microbiology

Perfusion process for CHO cell producing monoclonal antibody: Comparison of methods to determine optimum cell specific perfusion rate

Sophie Maria, Laurent Bonneau, Benjamin Fould, Gilles Ferry, Jean Albert Boutin, Charlotte Cabanne, Xavier Santarelli, Gilles Joucla

Summary: In this study, three culture methods were compared to determine the perfusion process parameters for a CHO cell line producing a monoclonal antibody. The push-to-low (PTL) and perfusion-without-bleeding (PWB) methods resulted in lower CSPRmin estimations, suggesting a three-step approach to determine the perfusion parameters.

BIOCHEMICAL ENGINEERING JOURNAL (2023)

Article Chemistry, Physical

CNT effective interfacial energy and pre-exponential kinetic factor from measured NaCl crystal nucleation time distributions in contracting microdroplets

Ruel Cedeno, Romain Grossier, Nadine Candoni, Nicolas Levernier, Adrian Flood, Stephane Veesler

Summary: In this study, we present the first stochastic treatment of NaCl-water nucleation kinetics using a recently developed microfluidic system and evaporation model. Our experimental results show an excellent agreement between the measured interfacial energies, extracted from a modified Poisson distribution of nucleation time, and theoretical predictions. Additionally, our analysis of nucleation parameters in microdroplets of different sizes reveals an interesting interplay between kinetic confinement and shifting of nucleation mechanisms. Overall, our findings emphasize the importance of treating nucleation stochastically rather than deterministically to bridge the gap between theory and experiment.

JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL PHYSICS (2023)

Review Biochemistry & Molecular Biology

Melatonin: Facts, Extrapolations and Clinical Trials

J. A. Boutin, D. J. Kennaway, R. Jockers

Summary: Since its discovery in 1958, melatonin has been a topic of great interest for scientists. Recently, the focus has shifted from studying its natural role in regulating biological time to exploring its potential roles in various clinical conditions. While there is extensive literature supporting the positive effects of high doses of melatonin, there are also limitations and flaws in the experimental evidence. This review aims to provide a critical analysis of the existing literature and encourage further reflection and research on the true capabilities of melatonin.

BIOMOLECULES (2023)

Article Crystallography

Modular microfluidic platform for solubility measurement, nucleation statistics and polymorph screening of active pharmaceutical ingredients: Irbesartan, Rimonabant, Aripiprazole and Sulfathiazole

Mathilde Lambert, Romain Grossier, Mehdi Lagaize, Thirou Bactivelane, Vasile Heresanu, Benoit Robert, Nadine Candoni, Stephane Veesler

Summary: This paper presents a newly developed modular microfluidic platform for crystallisation studies without use of surfactants. By dissolving a powder, the set-up generates saturated solutions that can be used for solubility measurements or distributed in microdroplets. The cooling rate influences both nucleation and polymorphism results, reflecting the competition between thermodynamics and kinetics.

JOURNAL OF CRYSTAL GROWTH (2023)

Article Clinical Neurology

The specific NQO2 inhibitor, S29434, only marginally improves the survival of dopamine neurons in MPTP-intoxicated mice

Maeva Vallucci, Jean A. Boutin, Elzbieta Janda, Florence Blandel, Ruth Musgrove, Donato Di Monte, Gilles Ferry, Patrick P. Michel, Etienne C. Hirsch

Summary: Evidence suggests that NQO2 is expressed in dopaminergic neurons and its inhibitor, S29434, has a role in reducing toxicity induced by MPTP, but does not show robust protective activity in a mouse model of MPTP-induced neurodegeneration.

JOURNAL OF NEURAL TRANSMISSION (2023)

Article Biochemical Research Methods

A workflow for the development of template-assisted membrane crystallization downstream processing for monoclonal antibody purification

Nazer Rajoub, Charline J. J. Gerard, Elvira Pantuso, Enrica Fontananova, Rocco Caliandro, Benny D. Belviso, Efrem Curcio, Fiore P. Nicoletta, James Pullen, Wenqian Chen, Jerry Y. Y. Heng, Sean Ruane, John Liddell, Natalie Alvey, Joop H. ter Horst, Gianluca Di Profio

Summary: This study investigates the use of template-assisted membrane crystallization for purifying monoclonal antibodies, replacing the protein A affinity stage in traditional chromatography-based purification. By using crystallization with templates attached to a membrane, protein purification can be achieved in a more cost-effective and environmentally sustainable manner.

NATURE PROTOCOLS (2023)

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

Microdroplet Approach for Measuring Aqueous Solubility and Nucleation Kinetics of a Metastable Polymorph: The Case of KDP Phase IV

Ruel Cedeno, Romain Grossier, Nadine Candoni, Stephane Veesler

Summary: This study presents a rapid microfluidic technique for measuring the aqueous solubility of metastable phases. By analyzing the dissolution behavior of crystals in contact with supersaturated microdroplets, and with the help of nucleation time measurement technique and calculation of interfacial energies, the interfacial energies of both the metastable and stable phases were accessed. Classical Nucleation Theory was used to model the competition of polymorphs, and the results were in good agreement with observations and experimental reports.

CRYSTAL GROWTH & DESIGN (2023)

Article Crystallography

Study of AlN growth using AMEC Prismo HiT3 MOCVD reactor

Jianzheng Hu, Long Yan, Ning Zhou, Yao Chen, Xiaoni Yang, Lianqiao Yang, Shiping Guo

Summary: The effect and mechanism of carrier gas velocity, V/III ratio, and carrier gas velocity match on the growth rate of AlN were investigated in this study. The results showed that the growth rate of AlN initially increased with hydrogen flow rate, reached saturation, and then decreased monotonically. The turning point value depended on the equipment and process. By increasing the MO VM, the growth rate of AlN could be improved, but the uniformity deteriorated due to turbulence and loss of uniform boundary layer. High quality AlN films were successfully grown on nano-patterned sapphire substrates with improved crystalline quality and atomic smooth surfaces.

JOURNAL OF CRYSTAL GROWTH (2024)

Article Crystallography

Molecular dynamics simulation of homogeneous nucleation of melting in superheated sodium crystal

Tingting Ma, Yang Li, Kangning Sun, Qinglin Cheng, Sen Li

Summary: This study investigates the melting process and nucleation behavior of sodium crystals using molecular dynamics simulation. The results show good agreement between simulated and experimental values for the melting temperature, density, and radial distribution function of sodium. The diffusion coefficient of liquid sodium increases linearly with temperature, and the homogeneous nucleation rate of melting in superheated sodium crystal exponentially increases with temperature. The findings provide theoretical support for applications involving heat and mass transfer in sodium-related systems.

JOURNAL OF CRYSTAL GROWTH (2024)

Article Crystallography

Fabrication of epitaxial V2O3 thin films on Al2O3 substrates via mist chemical vapor deposition

Hisato Nishii, Shintarou Iida, Akira Yamasaki, Takumi Ikenoue, Masao Miyake, Toshiya Doi, Tetsuji Hirato

Summary: Epitaxial V2O3 films were fabricated on sapphire substrates using mist chemical vapor deposition (mist CVD) method, eliminating the need for high vacuum conditions. The films can be grown on sapphire substrates even under atmospheric pressure, with the optimal growth temperature at 823 K. The films grown at 823 K exhibit a metal-insulator transition at approximately 155 K. The film on C-plane sapphire exhibits a lower transition temperature compared to those on R- and A-plane sapphire substrates.

JOURNAL OF CRYSTAL GROWTH (2024)

Article Crystallography

Controlling morphology of NiSb needles in InSb through low temperature gradient horizontal gradient freeze

Jani Jesenovec, Kevin Zawilski, Peter Alison, Stephan J. Meschter, Sambit K. Saha, Andrew J. Sepelak, Peter G. Schunemann

Summary: In this study, NiSb needles were successfully formed in InSb by manipulating the growth rate and adding NiSb. These needle structures in InSb can be used to tune the magnetoresistance of devices. Additionally, undoped InSb crystals demonstrated good infrared transmission at low growth rates.

JOURNAL OF CRYSTAL GROWTH (2024)

Article Crystallography

Synthesis, crystal growth, and its characterization of 2-amino-4-methylpyridinium oxalate

D. Joseph Daniel, P. Karuppasamy, H. J. Kim

Summary: The 2-amino 4-methyl pyridinium oxalate (2A4MPO) compound was synthesized and its crystal structure, functional groups, thermal stability, electrical properties, and third-order nonlinear optical properties were studied. The results demonstrate that the synthesized crystal has good structural integrity, thermal stability, and potential for third-order nonlinear optical applications.

JOURNAL OF CRYSTAL GROWTH (2024)

Article Crystallography

Twenty years crystal growth of solar silicon: My serendipity journey

C. W. Lan

Summary: The past two decades have witnessed a significant transformation in solar silicon crystal growth, especially in the competition between multi-crystalline silicon (Multi-Si) and mono-crystalline silicon (Mono-Si). The demand for this crucial material has exponentially surged, with silicon solar panels capturing over 95% of the global PV market share. The advancements in crystal growth technology during this period have set historical benchmarks, with the market share shifting from high-performance multi-crystalline silicon (HPM-Si) to CZ silicon.

JOURNAL OF CRYSTAL GROWTH (2024)

Article Crystallography

Design and numerical analysis of a novel argon gas tube to reduce impurities in large size casting crystalline silicon furnace

Peiyao Hao, Lili Zheng, Hui Zhang

Summary: A novel design of argon gas tube for removing impurities during silicon ingot growth was developed, and numerical simulations showed that it can effectively extract SiO.

JOURNAL OF CRYSTAL GROWTH (2024)

Article Crystallography

Dependence of reaction time in hydrothermal synthesis of MoS2 quantum dots: An investigation using optical tools and fractal analysis

Geetika Sahu, Chanchal Chakraborty, Subhadeep Roy, Souri Banerjee

Summary: This article discusses the novel fractal nature of hydrothermally synthesized MoS2 QDs. By adjusting the reaction time, the study found that the average size of QDs increases and then decreases with longer reaction times. STEM images indicate that shorter reaction times lead to sheet formation, while extended reaction times cause sheets to fragment into QDs.

JOURNAL OF CRYSTAL GROWTH (2024)

Article Crystallography

High-throughput thermodynamic study of SiC high-temperature chemical vapor deposition from TMS-H2

Pengjian Lu, Wei Huang, Junjun Wang, Haitao Yang, Shiyue Guo, Bin Li, Ting Wang, Chitengfei Zhang, Rong Tu, Song Zhang

Summary: A systematic study on the tetramethylsilane-hydorgen (TMS-H-2) system for the deposition of pure single-crystal SiC by high-temperature chemical vapor deposition (HTCVD) method is conducted. The study investigates the effect of temperature, pressure, and H-2:TMS ratio on the deposition conditions and provides a theoretical basis and guidance for improving the quality and cost of industrial production of single-crystal SiC.

JOURNAL OF CRYSTAL GROWTH (2024)

Article Crystallography

Molten salt synthesis of A-site disordered niobate microcrystals with tetragonal tungsten bronze structure

Xinyu Jiang, Liangliang Liu, Yanqing Liu, Yan Wang, Zhaoping Hou

Summary: Investigation on the preparation of anisometric templated textured high entropy or multi-element doped ferroelectric ceramics was conducted using A-site disordered niobate microcrystals. The effects of process parameters on the morphology and chemical composition were studied, and the photocatalytic properties of the microcrystals were evaluated.

JOURNAL OF CRYSTAL GROWTH (2024)

Article Crystallography

Synthesis and crystallinity integration of copper nanoparticles by reaction medium

Mobashsara Tabassum, Md. Ashraful Alam, Sabrina Mostofa, Raton Kumar Bishwas, Debasish Sarkar, Shirin Akter Jahan

Summary: In this study, high crystallinity copper nanoparticles were synthesized by altering the reaction medium at low temperatures. The results show that changing the reaction medium can reduce the surface energy of precursors and promote the formation of highly crystalline copper nanoparticles.

JOURNAL OF CRYSTAL GROWTH (2024)

Article Crystallography

Cu2ZnGeSe4 single crystals: Growth, structure and temperature dependence of band gap

Ivan Bodnar, Vitaly V. Khoroshko, Veronika A. Yashchuk, Valery F. Gremenok, Mohsin Kazi, Mayeen U. Khandaker, Tatiana I. Zubar, Daria I. Tishkevich, Alex Trukhanov, Sergei Trukhanov

Summary: This work presents the production of single crystals of Cu2ZnGeSe4, a semiconducting quaternary compound, using a gas chemical method with iodine as a transporter. The phase state, crystal structure, and lattice constants of the synthesized samples were refined and determined. The band gap of Cu2ZnGeSe4 was calculated using transmission spectrum and it was found that the band gap increases by 12% with decreasing temperature in the range of 20-300 K.

JOURNAL OF CRYSTAL GROWTH (2024)

Article Crystallography

Effect of growth temperature of NH3-MBE grown GaN-on-Si layers on donor concentration and leakage currents

Timur Malin, Igor Osinnykh, Vladimir Mansurov, Dmitriy Protasov, Sergey Ponomarev, Denis Milakhin, Konstantin Zhuravlev

Summary: The effect of growth temperature on the buffer leakage currents of GaN-on-Si layers was investigated. It was found that higher growth temperature results in lower leakage currents. The defects in GaN layers grown at different temperatures were studied using photoluminescence technique, and a correlation between leakage currents, structural perfection, and donor concentration in GaN-on-Si layers was established. It was also observed that reduced growth temperature leads to the formation of inversion domains.

JOURNAL OF CRYSTAL GROWTH (2024)

Article Crystallography

Numerical study of continuous Czochralski (CCz) silicon single crystal growth in a double-side heater

Thi-Hoai-Thu Nguyen, Jyh-Chen Chen

Summary: The effect of heater power control on heat, flow, and oxygen transport for CCz crystal growth was studied. Shorter upper side heater design could improve crystal quality and growth, but with higher power consumption.

JOURNAL OF CRYSTAL GROWTH (2024)

Article Crystallography

Contributions to the development of crystal growth technologies

Peter Rudolph

Summary: This article presents an overview of selected contributions to the development of crystal growth technology by the Laudise Prize awardee 2023. It discusses various aspects such as shaped crystal growth, the correlation between melt structure and crystal quality, control of intrinsic defects and inclusions, prevention of dislocation cell patterns, and melt growth experiments under a travelling magnetic field.

JOURNAL OF CRYSTAL GROWTH (2024)