4.7 Article

Understanding socio-economic and policy constraints to dairy development in Ethiopia: A coupled functional-structural innovation systems analysis

Journal

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS
Volume 141, Issue -, Pages 69-78

Publisher

ELSEVIER SCI LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.agsy.2015.09.007

Keywords

Functions of innovation systems; Institutions; Dairy value chains; Ethiopia

Funding

  1. Dutch Ministry of Economic Affairs
  2. CGIAR Challenge Programme on Water and Food (CPWF) through the International Livestock Research Institute (ILRI)

Ask authors/readers for more resources

This study investigates how the Ethiopian dairy innovation system hat functioned to support the development of the Ethiopian dairy sector and what have been the major technical, economic, and institutional constraints in the process. We used a coupled functional-structural analysis of innovation systems to analyse the influence of socioeconomic and policy constraints on the development of the Ethiopian dairy sector. Results show that problems with structural elements such as the absence of key actors, limited capacity of existing actors, insecure property rights, cumbersome bureaucratic processes, poor interaction among actors and inadequate infrastructure have all limited dairy innovation. Out of the seven innovation system functions studied, our findings show that entrepreneurship, knowledge diffusion, market development and legitimacy creation have been particularly weak. Our evidence thus suggests that problems with certain structural elements coupled with weaknesses in various innovation system functions have been major hindrances to the uptake of technologies and dairy sector development in Ethiopia. The narrow policy focus on biophysical technology generation and dissemination, without considering the underlying problems related to institutional conditions and socio-economic processes, has also contributed to low technology adoption and limited broader development in the dairy sector. We suggest that combinations of institutional and technological interventions are needed to overcome the various system weaknesses that have hindered dairy sector development in Ethiopia. (C) 2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Agriculture, Dairy & Animal Science

Predicting nitrogen use efficiency, nitrogen loss and dry matter intake of individual dairy cows in late lactation by including mid-infrared spectra of milk samples

Rui Shi, Wenqi Lou, Bart Ducro, Aart van der Linden, Han A. Mulder, Simon J. Oosting, Shengli Li, Yachun Wang

Summary: This study aimed to develop and validate the best prediction model of nitrogen use efficiency (NUE), nitrogen loss (NL), and dry matter intake (DMI) for individual dairy cows in China. The results showed that individual NUE can be predicted with moderate accuracy in both within-herd and external validations, while NL and DMI had lower accuracies. Additionally, the study found that information from MIR spectra variables increased the predictive ability of the models.

JOURNAL OF ANIMAL SCIENCE AND BIOTECHNOLOGY (2023)

Article Agronomy

Supporting participatory livestock feed improvement using the Feed Assessment Tool (FEAST)

Alan J. Duncan, Ben Lukuyu, Gilbert Mutoni, Zelalem Lema, Simon Fraval

Summary: Livestock production is crucial for smallholder farmers in low- and middle-income countries, but inadequate feed limits their potential to reduce poverty. The Feed Assessment Tool (FEAST) was developed to involve farmers in decision-making on feed improvement. It uses discussions and interviews to gather information. FEAST has been used in many countries and its data can inform feed strategies and be used by researchers to understand livestock feed issues.

AGRONOMY FOR SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT (2023)

Article Agriculture, Dairy & Animal Science

Evaluation of LiGAPS-Beef to assess extensive pasture-based beef production in three agro-ecological regions in South Africa

Christopher Magona, Abubeker Hassen, Eyob Tesfamariam, Carina Visser, Simon Oosting, A. van der Linden

Summary: This study evaluated the ability of the mechanistic LiGAPS-Beef model to quantify beef production of selected cattle breed types in diverse agro-ecological regions in South Africa. The model simulated average daily gain (ADG) with a mean absolute percentage error (MAPE) of 23% after calibration, and the simulated and measured values were positively correlated (r = 0.88) and largely in agreement (index of agreement=0.92).

LIVESTOCK SCIENCE (2023)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

The role of forest extraction in the livelihood strategies of Indonesian smallholder cattle farmers

Eko Nugroho, Rico Ihle, Simon J. Oosting, Wim Heijman

Summary: The understanding of the role of forest resource utilization in the livelihood strategies of smallholder farmers is limited. This study conducted a survey of 600 Indonesian cattle farmers to investigate the impact of extracting forest resources on livelihood strategies and household income. The results indicate that forest extraction is a core livelihood strategy for farmers relying on forests, and it increases with income diversification. The promotion of sustainable forest resource usage schemes, such as agroforestry or silvopastoral systems, would contribute to the sustainable future use of forest resources.

OUTLOOK ON AGRICULTURE (2023)

Article Agriculture, Dairy & Animal Science

Feed gap analysis of dual-purpose chicken production in Tanzania: feed quantity and quality limited production

Wilson C. Wilson, Maja Slingerland, Frederick P. Baijukya, Ken E. Giller, Simon Oosting

Summary: The demand for chicken meat and eggs in Tanzania exceeds production capacity due to low productivity of the sector. This study examines the yield gap in chicken production in Tanzania and explores the potential for increased production by addressing feed deficiencies. The findings highlight inadequate feed quantity and quality, lack of awareness about aflatoxin contamination, and the need for improved feeding strategies to ensure suitable and safe feed formulations.

POULTRY SCIENCE (2023)

Review Fisheries

Feed-food competition in global aquaculture: Current trends and prospects

Anne-Jo van Riel, Marit A. J. Nederlof, Killian Chary, Geert F. Wiegertjes, Imke J. M. de Boer

Summary: This study analyzed the feed-food competition in aquaculture using natural trophic levels (TLs) and species-specific human-edible protein conversion ratios (HePCRs). The results showed that under current feed use, carp, tilapia, and shrimp are net contributors of protein, requiring 0.6 kg of human edible protein to produce 1 kg of fillet/meat protein. However, the use of food-competing ingredients like soya bean meal and fishmeal increases the HePCR to 2, making these species become net consumers of protein. To prevent this, the use of high-quality food-competing ingredients should be minimized in aquaculture feed.

REVIEWS IN AQUACULTURE (2023)

Review Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

When and where are livestock climate-smart? A spatial-temporal framework for comparing the climate change and food security synergies and tradeoffs of Sub-Saharan African livestock systems

Leah A. Germer, Corina E. van Middelaar, Simon J. Oosting, Pierre J. Gerber

Summary: This paper proposes a practical framework for assessing and comparing the synergies and tradeoffs among different livestock systems in achieving food security and climate change objectives. The framework aims to support stakeholders in policy and development to identify the livestock systems that contribute most to food security and climate change objectives over time and space.

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS (2023)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Easier said than defined? Conceptualising justice in food system transitions

Annemarieke de Bruin, Imke J. M. de Boer, Niels R. Faber, Gjalt de Jong, Katrien J. A. M. Termeer, Evelien M. de Olde

Summary: The transition towards sustainable and just food systems is being actively pursued through various initiatives aiming to address unsustainable practices and social injustices. This paper investigates the conceptualizations of justice and the principles used by authors when discussing food system initiatives, offering insights into how justice is understood in the context of these transitions. The identified conceptualizations and principles provide a framework for reflection and clarity in conceptualizing justice, guiding efforts towards a just transition for sustainable and equitable food systems.

AGRICULTURE AND HUMAN VALUES (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Determining the transformative potential of circular agriculture initiatives

Jelle Silvius, Anne G. Hoogstra, Jeroen J. L. Candel, Evelien M. de Olde, Imke J. M. de Boer, Catrien J. A. M. Termeer

Summary: Policymakers and scientists recognize the importance of emerging circular initiatives in driving transformations towards sustainable food systems, but it is challenging to determine their transformative potential. To address this gap, we develop a heuristic of five characteristics for potentially transformative circular agriculture initiatives and provide examples to illustrate these characteristics.

AMBIO (2023)

Article Agriculture, Dairy & Animal Science

Characterising sustainability certification standards in dairy production

K. McGarr-O'Brien, J. Herron, L. Shalloo, I. J. M. De Boer, E. M. De Olde

Summary: This study characterized the sustainability certification standards used in dairy production and identified 19 standards that qualify as sustainability certification based on selection criteria. The standards vary in terms of organization type, number of indicators, sustainability themes covered, and the balance of credibility, accessibility, and continuous improvement. The environmental pillar is most frequently addressed, while the economic pillar is least addressed. The analysis shows that credibility and accessibility are often described and assured, but continuous improvement is less focused on. The variability in standards allows farmers to choose a standard that aligns with their beliefs or stage of development, but it may also create mistrust in standards.

ANIMAL (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Recoupling livestock and feed production in the Netherlands to reduce environmental impacts

Benjamin van Selm, Renske Hijbeek, Martin K. van Ittersum, Ollie van Hal, Corina E. van Middelaar, Imke J. M. de Boer

Summary: Livestock and feed production are often separated and this disrupts nutrient cycles and leads to environmental degradation. Reconnecting livestock and feed production at a local level can enhance circularity and decrease emissions. This study shows that recoupling livestock and feed production has the potential to improve sustainability and reduce environmental impact.

SCIENCE OF THE TOTAL ENVIRONMENT (2023)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

The role of fisheries and fish farming in a circular food system in the European Union

Ollie van Hal, Hannah H. E. van Zanten, Friederike Ziegler, Johan W. Schrama, Kiki Kuiper, Imke J. M. de Boer

Summary: Studies have shown that aquatic animals also contribute to food supply, especially as a source of valuable omega-3 fatty acids. Proper balance of different fish and livestock systems is required to provide valuable human food, with priority given to edible fish for human consumption.

SUSTAINABLE PRODUCTION AND CONSUMPTION (2023)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

The role of power relationships, trust and social networks in shaping milk quality in Kenya

Ndungu S. Nyokabi, Imke J. M. de Boer, Jos Bijman, Bockline Bebe, Norman Aguilar-Gallegos, Lisette Phelan, Johanna Lindahl, Bernard Bett, Simon J. Oosting

Summary: The study aimed to examine social networks in dairy value chains in Kenya and understand how power relationships and trust among actors influence milk quality behavior. The researchers conducted stakeholder analysis using the Net-Map tool and analyzed social networks using VisuaLyzer software. They found that formal value chains had more actors and dense social networks with power asymmetries and limited trust, while informal value chains had fewer actors and less dense social networks with higher trust due to personal relationships. They also discovered that milk quality was perceived to be higher in the formal value chain. The study highlights the importance of addressing power asymmetries and enhancing trust to improve compliance with milk quality standards.

NJAS-IMPACT IN AGRICULTURAL AND LIFE SCIENCES (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

The impact of intensive farming systems on groundwater availability in dryland environments: A watershed level study from Telangana, India

Bhavana Rao Kuchimanchi, Raimon Ripoll-Bosch, Fokje A. Steenstra, Renie Thomas, Simon J. Oosting

Summary: The intensification of agriculture in India has improved food self-sufficiency but has also led to negative environmental impacts, particularly on groundwater resources. This study aims to understand the impact of intensified agriculture on water availability in a dryland watershed in Telangana, India. The findings reveal that the crop-dairy system consumes the highest amount of water, followed by the crop with small ruminants system and the crop without livestock system. The overall water balance of the watershed shows a deficit, indicating the over-utilization of water resources and groundwater depletion.

CURRENT RESEARCH IN ENVIRONMENTAL SUSTAINABILITY (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Interventions to increase circularity and reduce environmental impacts in food systems

Benjamin van Selm, Hannah H. E. van Zanten, Renske Hijbeek, Corina E. van Middelaar, Marijke Schop, Martin K. van Ittersum, Imke J. M. de Boer

Summary: Applying circularity interventions to the food system can reduce land use and greenhouse gas emissions. Changes in human diets, imports, exports, and waste utilisation can have significant environmental benefits.

AMBIO (2023)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

A methodology based on territorial metabolism analysis to assess the multi-criteria sustainability of African village terroirs with contrasted crop-livestock systems

Elise Audouin, Mariana Odru, Dominique Masse, Gualbert Seraphin Dorego, Valerie Delaunay, Philippe Lecomte, Jonathan Vayssieres

Summary: Agricultural intensification is important for food security and limiting rural exodus in sub-Saharan Africa. Livestock farming has the potential to improve the sustainability of farming systems, but landscape-level studies are rare. By considering the interactions between animals, crops, and trees, the landscape level is the only level where the impacts of livestock farming can be fully understood. This study developed a methodology to compare different livestock systems based on territorial metabolism and sustainability indicators.

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS (2024)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Collective action, replanting and resilience; Key lessons from 40 years of smallholder oil palm cultivation in the Ophir plantation, Indonesia

Idsert Jelsma, Turinah, Frederic Gay, Jean Ollivier, Bruno Rapidel

Summary: Our study aims to analyze the resilience of farmer organizations in the Ophir plantation during replanting. By examining a 40-year period in five farmer cooperatives, we provide unique insights on the dynamics that influence the resilience of farmer organizations, shed light on smallholder oil palm replanting strategies, and draw several key lessons from this case.

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS (2024)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

What determines the acceptance of Climate Smart Technologies? The influence of farmers' behavioral drivers in connection with the policy environment

Maria Rodriguez-Barillas, Laurens Klerkx, P. Marijn Poortvliet

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS (2024)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Effects of fertilization practices and understory on soil health and oil palm performances in smallholdings: An Indonesian case study

Alexis Thoumazeau, Romane Mettauer, Turinah, Heri Junedi, Victor Baron, Cecile Cheron-Bessou, Jean Ollivier

Summary: This study investigates the effects of fertilization and understory vegetation management on soil health and oil palm performances. It aimed to isolate and decipher the specific effects of some key practices on the overall plantation performances.

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS (2024)

Review Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Assessing the role of agriculture-forestry-livestock nexus in improving farmers' food security in South Asia: A systematic literature review

Pritha Datta, Bhagirath Behera, Dil Bahadur Rahut

Summary: This study aims to evaluate the potential of South Asian agroforestry systems as a viable agroecological approach for ensuring farmers' food security. A systematic literature review found that out of 95 reviewed studies, only nine focused on food security and none of them examined all four dimensions of food security simultaneously. Moreover, the majority of studies were skewed towards the Himalayan belt and lacked quantitative measurement, making it challenging to determine the significance of this field.

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS (2024)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Modeling the effect of multiple pests on ecosystem services provided by fruit crops: Application to apple

Octave Lacroix, Francoise Lescourret, Michel Genard, Mohamed-Mahmoud Memah, Gilles Vercambre, Pierre Valsesia, Daniele Bevacqua, Isabelle Grechi

Summary: In this study, a pest-crop model was developed to examine the impact of multiple pests on fruit tree functioning and ecosystem services provided by orchards. Through simulations and analysis, it was found that pests significantly affected indicators such as fruit sugar content, marketable yield, carbon sequestration, and water drainage.

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS (2024)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

How to find alternative crops for climate-resilient regional food production

Malve Heinz, Valeria Galetti, Annelie Holzka

Summary: This paper presents an innovative approach for identifying climate-adapted alternative food crops that can help diversify existing cropping systems, increase their climate resilience, and contribute to nutritious plant-based regional diets with reduced emissions.

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS (2024)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Technical efficiency drivers of farmer-led restoration strategies, and how substantial is the unrealised potential for farm output?

Vianny Ahimbisibwe, Eliza Zhunusova, Habtemariam Kassa, Sven Guenter

Summary: This study examines the technical efficiency levels of home gardens and woodlot systems in Ethiopia and investigates the factors that contribute to technical efficiency.

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS (2024)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Farm typologies for understanding farm systems and improving agricultural policy

Robert Huber, Bartosz Bartkowski, Calum Brown, Nadja El Benni, Jan-Henning Feil, Pascal Grohmann, Ineke Joormann, Heidi Leonhardt, Hermine Mitter, Birgit Mueller

Summary: Farm typologies help identify patterns in farm systems and support agricultural policy design, but they are often developed without much connection to previous studies and policy making.

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS (2024)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Opportunities to close wheat yield gaps in Nepal's Terai: Insights from field surveys, on-farm experiments, and simulation modeling

Mina Devkota, Krishna Prasad Devkota, Gokul Prasad Paudel, Timothy J. Krupnik, Andrew James McDonald

Summary: Wheat production in the Terai region of Nepal has not met the increasing demand, with low average productivity and high spatial and temporal variability. This study identifies strategies for closing yield gaps through field surveys, on-farm experiments, and simulation models. The results suggest that improving agronomic practices, such as fertilization and irrigation management, can significantly increase wheat productivity.

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS (2024)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Importance of (semi)natural vegetation on farms for achieving multiple objectives: A conceptual model based on temperate southern Australia

Angie Haslem, Andrew F. Bennett, James Q. Radford

Summary: This study integrates knowledge on the benefits and disbenefits of (semi)natural vegetation on farms for achieving six objectives, and develops a conceptual model of the relationships between these objectives and different types of vegetation. The results show that (semi)natural vegetation provides more benefits than disbenefits, with greater support for the benefits of native vegetation. Farm-level restoration contributes towards reversing vegetation loss, but the process takes time. Management practices play a role in enhancing the benefits of (semi)natural vegetation.

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS (2024)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Trade-offs between higher productivity and lower environmental impacts for biodiversity-friendly and conventional cattle-oriented systems

Aymeric Mondiere, Michael S. Corson, Julie Auberger, Daphne Durant, Sylvain Foray, Jean-Francois Glinec, Penny Green, Sandra Novak, Frederic Signoret, Hayo M. G. van der Werf

Summary: This study assessed the productivity and environmental impacts of different livestock production systems and found that biodiversity-friendly systems perform better in terms of environmental impact. The results emphasize the importance of considering the multiple functions and overall environmental performance of these systems.

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS (2024)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Introducing sheep for agroecological weed management on banana plantations in Guadeloupe: A co-design process with farmers

Nadine Andrieu, Elodie Dorey, Steewy Lakhia, Paul Meynard, Esther Hatil, Loic Normand, Jean-Luc Gourdine, Jean-Christophe Bambou

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS (2024)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Evaluation of nitrogen balances and nitrogen use efficiencies on farm level of the German agricultural sector

Philipp Loew, Bernhard Osterburg

Summary: This study evaluated the nitrogen performance of the German agricultural sector and identified the potential for nitrogen utilization in different farm types. The study also revealed the relationships between nitrogen performance and independent variables such as soil fertility, crop selection and diversity, production type, operating profit, and consulting services received.

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS (2024)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Farmer Options and Risks in Complex Ecological-Social systems: The FORCES game designed for agroforestry management of upper watersheds

Rika Ratna Sari, Lisa Tanika, Erika N. Speelman, Danny Dwi Saputra, Arief Lukman Hakim, Danae M. A. Rozendaal, Kurniatun Hairiah, Meine van Noordwijk

Summary: This study aims to clarify the design principles of the FORCES game and apply it to diverse watershed contexts. The game design balances generic and site-specific information, and the performance and impact of the game are evaluated through testing and assessment.

AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS (2024)