4.4 Article

Competition policy for health care provision in Norway

Journal

HEALTH POLICY
Volume 121, Issue 2, Pages 134-140

Publisher

ELSEVIER IRELAND LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.healthpol.2016.11.013

Keywords

Health care; Competition policy; Norway

Funding

  1. Health Foundation

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Competition policy has played a very limited role for health care provision in Norway. The main reason is that Norway has a National Health Service (NHS) with extensive public provision and a wide set of sector-specific regulations that limit the scope for competition. However, the last two decades, several reforms have deregulated health care provision and opened up for provider competition along some dimensions. For specialised care, the government has introduced patient choice and (partly) activity (DRG) based funding, but also corporatised public hospitals and allowed for more private provision. For primary care, a reform changed the payment scheme to capitation and (a higher share of) fee-for-service, inducing almost all GPs on fixed salary contracts to become self-employed. While these reforms have the potential for generating competition in the Norwegian NHS, the empirical evidence is quite limited and the findings are mixed. We identify a set of possible caveats that may weaken the incentives for provider competition - such as the partial implementation of DRG pricing, the dual purchaser-provider role of regional health authorities, and the extensive consolidation of public hospitals - and argue that there is great scope for competition policy measures that could stimulate provider competition within the Norwegian NHS. (c) 2016 Elsevier Ireland Ltd. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.4
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Economics

Competition and equity in health care markets

Luigi Siciliani, Odd Rune Straume

JOURNAL OF HEALTH ECONOMICS (2019)

Article Economics

Competition and physician behaviour: Does the competitive environment affect the propensity to issue sickness certificates?

Kurt R. Brekke, Tor Helge Holmas, Karin Monstad, Odd Rune Straume

JOURNAL OF HEALTH ECONOMICS (2019)

Article Economics

Dynamic hospital competition under rationing by waiting times

Luis Sa, Luigi Siciliani, Odd Rune Straume

JOURNAL OF HEALTH ECONOMICS (2019)

Article Economics

Hospital competition in a national health service: Evidence from a patient choice reform

Kurt R. Brekke, Chiara Canta, Luigi Siciliani, Odd Rune Straume

Summary: The study shows that hospitals in more competitive areas have a significant reduction in AMI mortality and a positive impact on all-cause mortality, but may increase readmissions. Additionally, it suggests that competition environment could lead to shorter hospital stays and reduced waiting times.

JOURNAL OF HEALTH ECONOMICS (2021)

Article Economics

International outsourcing and trade union (de-)centralisation *

Kjell Erik Lommerud, Frode Meland, Odd Rune Straume

Summary: The research shows that decentralized wage setting allows trade unions to capture a larger share of rents generated by international outsourcing, leading to lower outsourcing levels. In some cases, both firms and unions prefer decentralized wage setting, which is potentially driven by international outsourcing opportunities.

JOURNAL OF ECONOMIC BEHAVIOR & ORGANIZATION (2021)

Article Economics

When does remote electronic access (not) boost productivity? Longitudinal evidence from Portugal *

Natalia P. Monteiro, Odd Rune Straume, Marieta Valente

Summary: The theoretical ambiguity regarding whether remote work increases firm labour productivity is empirically examined using a sample of Portuguese firms from 2011 to 2016. The study finds a significantly negative association, on average, between remote access and productivity, but this relationship varies across different categories of firms. Remote access is found to be significantly positive for firms engaging in R&D activities, while it may be detrimental for non-exporting, small firms without R&D activities and a below-average skill level workforce.

INFORMATION ECONOMICS AND POLICY (2021)

Article Economics

Investment and quality competition in healthcare markets

Ziad Ghandour, Luigi Siciliani, Odd Rune Straume

Summary: This study examines the strategic relationship between hospital investment and service quality provision. It shows that the inability of providers to commit to quality under a fixed pricing system leads to under or overinvestment relative to the optimal solution. The study also analyzes the welfare effects of different policy options.

JOURNAL OF HEALTH ECONOMICS (2022)

Article Economics

Quality provision in hospital markets with demand inertia: The role of patient expectations

Luis Sa, Odd Rune Straume

Summary: The study found that different types of patient expectations about hospital quality can affect the level of quality provided by hospitals. Patients with naive expectations may lead to higher quality provision, while patients with rational expectations may result in the highest or lowest quality levels. Additionally, policies to reduce switching costs may lower the quality provided by hospitals.

JOURNAL OF HEALTH ECONOMICS (2021)

Article Economics

Paying for pharmaceuticals: uniform pricing versus two-part tariffs

Kurt R. Brekke, Dag Morten Dalen, OddRune Straum

Summary: The study suggests that implementing two-part pricing, similar to the Netflix model, for pharmaceuticals can lead to higher patient utility and lower drug costs for the health plan. However, the effectiveness of this pricing model depends on the presence of competition and exclusive contracts. Additionally, the choice of payment scheme can influence the incentives for resources to be allocated towards drastic innovations versus incremental innovations.

JOURNAL OF HEALTH ECONOMICS (2022)

Article Economics

Optimal funding coverage in a mixed oligopoly with quality competition and price regulation

Ziad Ghandour, Odd Rune Straume

Summary: This study investigates the optimal design of a public funding scheme in a mixed oligopoly setting, focusing on healthcare and education. The findings suggest that including at least one private provider in the public funding scheme is necessary to achieve the best outcome. However, the inclusion of a single private provider is sufficient to induce the desired result. Such inclusion helps eliminate the negative competition externality between private providers, which leads to underprovision of quality.

JOURNAL OF ECONOMICS (2022)

Article Economics

National pricing with local quality competition

Tommy Staahl Gabrielsen, Bjorn Olav Johansen, Odd Rune Straume

Summary: This article examines the incentives of national retail chains to implement national pricing in local markets with varying size and competition intensity. The study finds that, in the presence of quality competition, at least one chain may adopt national pricing as a strategy. Interestingly, the impact of national pricing on consumers can be both beneficial and harmful, regardless of whether it leads to higher or lower prices.

JOURNAL OF ECONOMICS & MANAGEMENT STRATEGY (2023)

Article Economics

Therapeutic reference pricing and drug innovation incentives?

Odd Rune Straume

Summary: Therapeutic reference pricing (TRP) is believed to reduce incentives for 'me-too' innovations in pharmaceuticals, but this paper shows that it also reduces incentives for therapeutic differentiation and leads to less differentiated drugs entering the market. However, TRP can have pro-competitive effects when it comes to innovation incentives. Overall, TRP may lead to lower health benefits unless there are strong incentives for therapeutic differentiation.

ECONOMICS LETTERS (2023)

Article Economics

Optimal dynamic volume-based price regulation

Michele Bisceglia, Roberto Cellini, Luigi Siciliani, Odd Rune Straume

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF INDUSTRIAL ORGANIZATION (2020)

Article Economics

How Does The Type of Remuneration Affect Physician Behavior? Fixed Salary versus Fee-for-Service

Kurt R. Brekke, Tor Helge Holmas, Karin Monstad, Odd Rune Straume

AMERICAN JOURNAL OF HEALTH ECONOMICS (2020)

Article Economics

Hospital competition under pay-for-performance: Quality, mortality, and readmissions

Domenico Lisi, Luigi Siciliani, Odd Rune Straume

JOURNAL OF ECONOMICS & MANAGEMENT STRATEGY (2020)

No Data Available