4.4 Article

Is it time to abandon care planning in mental health services? A qualitative study exploring the views of professionals, service users and carers

Journal

HEALTH EXPECTATIONS
Volume 21, Issue 3, Pages 597-605

Publisher

WILEY
DOI: 10.1111/hex.12650

Keywords

care planning; experiences of care; mental health; qualitative; user; carer involvement

Funding

  1. Programme Grants for Applied Research [RP-PG-1210-12007]
  2. Manchester Mental Health and Social Care Trust (MMHSCT)
  3. National Institute for Health Research [NF-SI-0513-10103, NF-SI-0509-10195, RP-PG-1210-12007] Funding Source: researchfish
  4. National Institutes of Health Research (NIHR) [RP-PG-1210-12007] Funding Source: National Institutes of Health Research (NIHR)

Ask authors/readers for more resources

BackgroundIt has been established that mental health-care planning does not adequately respond to the needs of those accessing services. Understanding the reasons for this and identifying whose needs care plans serve requires an exploration of the perspectives of service users, carers and professionals within the wider organizational context. ObjectiveTo explore the current operationalization of care planning and perceptions of its function within mental health services from the perspectives of multiple stakeholders. Settings and participantsParticipants included 21 mental health professionals, 29 service users and 4 carers from seven Mental Health Trusts in England. All participants had experience of care planning processes within secondary mental health-care services. MethodsFifty-four semi-structured interviews were conducted with participants and analysed utilizing a qualitative framework approach. FindingsCare plans and care planning were characterized by a failure to meet the complexity of mental health needs, and care planning processes were seen to prioritize organizational agendas and risk prevention which distanced care planning from the everyday lives of service users. Discussion and conclusionsCare planning is recognized, embedded and well established in the practices of mental health professionals and service users. However, it is considered too superficial and mainly irrelevant to users for managing mental health in their everyday lives. Those responsible for the planning and delivery of mental health services should consider ways to increase the relevance of care planning to the everyday lives of service users including separating risk from holistic needs assessment, using support aids and utilizing a peer workforce in this regard.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.4
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Psychology, Developmental

One session treatment (OST) is equivalent to multi-session cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) in children with specific phobias (ASPECT): results from a national non-inferiority randomized controlled trial

Barry Wright, Lucy Tindall, Alexander J. Scott, Ellen Lee, Cindy Cooper, Katie Biggs, Penny Bee, Han- Wang, Lina Gega, Emily Hayward, Kiera Solaiman, M. Dawn Teare, Thompson Davis, Jon Wilson, Karina Lovell, Dean McMillan, Amy Barr, Hannah Edwards, Jennifer Lomas, Chris Turtle, Steve Parrott, Catarina Teige, Tim Chater, Rebecca Hargate, Shezhad Ali, Sarah Parkinson, Simon Gilbody, David Marshall

Summary: This study compared the effectiveness of One Session Treatment (OST) with Cognitive Behaviour Therapy (CBT) for treating specific phobias in children and young people. The results showed that OST is non-inferior to CBT in terms of clinical effectiveness. OST may be a cost-saving alternative for treating specific phobias in children and young people.

JOURNAL OF CHILD PSYCHOLOGY AND PSYCHIATRY (2023)

Article Nursing

Women's experiences of care and support following perinatal death in high burden countries: A metasynthesis

Omotewa Kuforiji, Tracey A. Mills, Karina Lovell

Summary: The experiences of women in low and middle-income countries following perinatal death remains difficult and challenging, thereby increasing their susceptibility to negative psychological impact particularly with insufficient bereavement care and support.

WOMEN AND BIRTH (2023)

Article Psychiatry

Heightened COVID-19 Mortality in People With Severe Mental Illness Persists After Vaccination: A Cohort Study of Greater Manchester Residents

Lamiece Hassan, Chelsea Sawyer, Niels Peek, Karina Lovell, Andre F. Carvalho, Marco Solmi, George Tilston, Matthew Sperrin, Joseph Firth

Summary: Previous studies have shown that people with severe mental illness (SMI) are at higher risk of COVID-19 mortality. This study investigated COVID-19 mortality among people with schizophrenia and other SMIs before, during, and after the UK vaccine roll-out. The results showed that people with SMI, particularly those with schizophrenia and bipolar disorder (BD), were at greater risk of COVID-19 mortality compared to matched controls. Disparities in COVID-19 mortality for people with SMI still exist despite vaccination efforts.

SCHIZOPHRENIA BULLETIN (2023)

Review Ophthalmology

Impact of Charles Bonnet Syndrome on visually impaired older adults' ability to engage in physical activity: A scoping review

Katharine Fisher, Caroline Sanders, Emma Stanmore

Summary: This scoping review aimed to explore the impact of Charles Bonnet syndrome (CBS) on older adults' engagement in physical activities. The findings suggested that CBS may interfere with older adults' ability to move and jeopardize their safety while walking. Further empirical research is needed to comprehensively understand the impact of CBS on older adults' participation in physical activities, considering the limited evidence available.

BRITISH JOURNAL OF VISUAL IMPAIRMENT (2023)

Article Behavioral Sciences

A brief transdiagnostic group (the take control course) compared to individual low-intensity CBT for depression and anxiety: a randomized non-inferiority trial

Lydia Morris, Karina Lovell, Phil McEvoy, Richard Emsley, Lesley-Anne Carter, Dawn Edge, Rachel Bates, Tanya Wallwork, Warren Mansell

Summary: Few studies have examined the effectiveness of brief transdiagnostic groups. We developed the Take Control Course (TCC) for patients with mild to moderate common mental health problems and conducted a single-blind individually randomised parallel non-inferiority trial to compare the effectiveness of TCC and individual low-intensity CBT. The results showed that TCC is not less effective than individual CBT, providing preliminary support for its use within Improving Access to Psychological Therapies (IAPT) services.

COGNITIVE BEHAVIOUR THERAPY (2023)

Article Psychiatry

Enhancing the quality of psychological interventions delivered by telephone in mental health services: increasing the likelihood of successful implementation using a theory of change

Cintia L. L. Faija, Janice Connell, Judith Gellatly, Kelly Rushton, Karina Lovell, Helen Brooks, Christopher Armitage, Peter Bower, Penny Bee

Summary: This study explores the use of a Theory of Change (ToC) for intervention design and evaluation in mental health settings. The intervention, targeting telephone-delivered psychological therapies, was evaluated and modified based on the findings. Four key recommendations were identified to optimize the implementation of complex interventions.

BMC PSYCHIATRY (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Establishing evidence to inform culturally competent mental health services: A mixed methods study protocol

Ge Yu, Maria Panagioti, Eugene Y. H. Tang, Damian Robinson, Nusrat Husain, Reena Lasrado, Karina Lovell, Eileen Kaner, Yu Fu

Summary: COVID-19 has worsened mental health inequalities for ethnic minorities, who faced difficulties in accessing support and ended up in crisis care. This study aims to identify beneficial changes to mental health services during the pandemic and inform culturally competent service provision.

PLOS ONE (2023)

Article Rheumatology

Cost-effectiveness of cognitive behavioural and personalized exercise interventions for reducing fatigue in inflammatory rheumatic diseases

Huey Yi Chong, Paul McNamee, Eva-Maria Bachmair, Kathryn Martin, Lorna Aucott, Neeraj Dhaun, Emma Dures, Richard Emsley, Stuart. R. Gray, Elizabeth Kidd, Vinod Kumar, Karina Lovell, Graeme MacLennan, John Norrie, Lorna Paul, Jonathan Packham, Stuart. H. Ralston, Stefan Siebert, Alison Wearden, Gary Macfarlane, Neil Basu

Summary: This study estimated the cost-effectiveness of combining cognitive behavioural approach (CBA) or personalized exercise programme (PEP) with usual care (UC) for patients with inflammatory rheumatic diseases and chronic, moderate to severe fatigue. The results showed that PEP was more expensive but significantly more effective than UC, while CBA was more expensive but not significantly more effective. Therefore, combining PEP with UC is likely to be a cost-effective use of healthcare resources.

RHEUMATOLOGY (2023)

Article Psychology, Clinical

Exploring access and engagement with Improving Access to Psychological Therapies (IAPT) services, before, during, and after the COVID-19 lockdown: A service evaluation in the Northwest of England

Irini L. Verbist, Hannah Fabian, Dale Huey, Helen Brooks, Karina Lovell, Amy Blakemore

Summary: The study compared the prevalence of clients and explored the characteristics predicting access and engagement with IAPT treatment before, during, and after lockdown. A retrospective observational service evaluation was conducted using IAPT data from 13,019 clients. The study found that the number of people accessing and engaging with IAPT treatment significantly increased after lockdown, and unemployed clients were less likely to access treatment during and after lockdown. However, perinatal clients and people from a black ethnic background were more likely to access treatment during lockdown.

PSYCHOTHERAPY RESEARCH (2023)

Article Medicine, Research & Experimental

Culturally adapted family intervention for people with schizophrenia in Indonesia (FUSION): a development and feasibility study protocol

Laoise Renwick, Herni Susanti, Helen Brooks, Budi-anna Keliat, Tim Bradshaw, Penny Bee, Karina Lovell

Summary: This study aims to test the feasibility and acceptability of delivering family interventions for relatives and caregivers of people with schizophrenia through task shifting in primary care settings in Indonesia, providing valuable information for further intervention and trial process improvement.

PILOT AND FEASIBILITY STUDIES (2023)

Review Psychiatry

Exploring the use of social network interventions for adults with mental health difficulties: a systematic review and narrative synthesis

Helen Brooks, Angela Devereux-Fitzgerald, Laura Richmond, Neil Caton, Mary Gemma Cherry, Penny Bee, Karina Lovell, James Downs, Bethan Mair Edwards, Ivaylo Vassilev, Laura Bush, Anne Rogers

Summary: This narrative synthesis reviewed 54 studies on social network interventions for people with mental health difficulties and found that these interventions were generally beneficial. However, the heterogeneity in intervention type, implementation, and evaluation made it difficult to draw definitive conclusions. Personalized interventions outside formal health services that provided opportunities for authentic valued activities were found to be most effective.

BMC PSYCHIATRY (2023)

Article Pediatrics

Evaluating a prototype digital mental health literacy intervention for children and young people aged 11-15 in Java, Indonesia: a mixed methods, multi-site case study evaluation

Helen Brooks, Irmansyah Irmansyah, Armaji Kamaludi Syarif, Rebecca Pedley, Laoise Renwick, Atik Puji Rahayu, Christa Manik, Benny Prawira, Mark Hann, Helen Brierley, Karina Lovell, Penny Bee

Summary: The IMPeTUs intervention is a digital intervention designed to improve mental health literacy among young people in Indonesia. The study evaluated the usability and feasibility of the intervention and found it to be highly acceptable and feasible. The qualitative data also revealed unexpected positive effects of the intervention.

CHILD AND ADOLESCENT PSYCHIATRY AND MENTAL HEALTH (2023)

Article Health Care Sciences & Services

Experiences and perceptions of continuous deep sedation: An interview study among Dutch patients and relatives

Louise Annemoon Jonker, Madelon T. Heijltjes, Judith A. C. Rietjens, Agnes van der Heide, Geeske Hendriksen, Johannes J. M. van Delden, Ghislaine J. M. W. van Thiel

Summary: This study explores the perceptions and experiences of patients and relatives regarding Continuous Deep Sedation (CDS). The findings suggest that patients and relatives consider CDS as a regular palliative care option and prioritize avoiding suffering at the end of life. They also claim a substantial say in the decision-making process.

HEALTH EXPECTATIONS (2024)