4.8 Article

Techno-economic analysis for upgrading the biomass-derived ethanol-to-jet blendstocks

Journal

GREEN CHEMISTRY
Volume 19, Issue 4, Pages 1082-1101

Publisher

ROYAL SOC CHEMISTRY
DOI: 10.1039/c6gc02800d

Keywords

-

Funding

  1. U.S. Department of Energy Bioenergy Technologies Office [DE-AC36-08GO28308]
  2. National Renewable Energy Laboratory

Ask authors/readers for more resources

This study summarizes the detailed techno-economic analysis of the ethanol-to-jet (ETJ) process based on two different feedstocks (corn grain and corn stover) at the plant scale of 2000 dry metric tons per day. Ethanol biologically derived from biomass is upgraded catalytically to jet blendstocks via alcohol dehydration, olefin oligomerization, and hydrotreating. In both pathways, corn-grain-derived ethanol to jet (corn mill ETJ) and corn-stover-derived ethanol to jet (corn stover ETJ), there are portions of gasoline and diesel produced as coproducts. Two cost bases are used in this study: the minimum jet fuel selling prices (MJSP) for jet-range blendstocks and the minimum fuel selling prices (MFSP) for all the hydrocarbons (gasoline, jet, and diesel) produced using a gallon gasoline equivalent (GGE) basis. The nth-plant MJSPs for the two pathways are estimated to be $4.20 per gal for corn mill and $6.14 per gal for corn stover, while MFSPs are $3.91 per GGE for corn mill and $5.37 per GGE for corn stover. If all of the hydrocarbon products (gasoline, jet, and diesel ranges) can be considered as fuel blendstocks using a GGE basis, the total hydrocarbon yield for fuel blendstock is 49.6 GGE per dry ton biomass for corn stover and 71.0 GGE per dry ton biomass for corn grain. The outcome of this study shows that the renewable jet fuel could be cost competitive with fossil derived jet fuel if further improvements could be made to increase process yields (particularly yields of sugars, sugar to ethanol, and ethanol to hydrocarbons), research and development of sustainable feedstocks, and more effective catalytic reaction kinetics. Pioneer plant analysis, which considers the increased capital investment and the decreased plant performance over the nth-plant analysis, is also performed, showing a potential 31%-178% increase in cost compared to the nth-plant assumptions for the dry mill pathway, but with a much wider range of 69%-471% cost increase over the nth-plant assumptions for the corn stover pathway. While there are large differences between the estimated first of a kind plant cost and the targeted nth-plant case, reduction of costs is possible through improvement of the overall process efficiency, yields, reduction in overall capital, co-product revenues and strategically improve performance by process learnings.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.8
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Biotechnology & Applied Microbiology

Using waste CO2 from corn ethanol biorefineries for additional ethanol production: life-cycle analysis

Uisung Lee, Troy R. Hawkins, Eunji Yoo, Michael Wang, Zhe Huang, Ling Tao

Summary: The study evaluates the potential of converting high-purity CO2 from corn ethanol plants into ethanol using gas fermentation and electrochemical reduction technologies. It shows that the sources of electricity and hydrogen significantly impact the greenhouse gas emissions of CO2-based ethanol. Using wind electricity can greatly reduce the carbon intensities of ethanol, providing emissions reduction benefits compared to gasoline.

BIOFUELS BIOPRODUCTS & BIOREFINING-BIOFPR (2021)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Biofuel Options for Marine Applications: Technoeconomic and Life-Cycle Analyses

Eric C. D. Tan, Troy R. Hawkins, Uisung Lee, Ling Tao, Pimphan A. Meyer, Michael Wang, Tom Thompson

Summary: This study evaluates the economic feasibility and emission benefits of various biofuel production pathways compared to conventional marine fuels. The results show that biofuels can effectively reduce greenhouse gas and pollutant emissions from the maritime shipping industry at a lower cost. Cofeeding biomass with natural gas could be a practical approach to transition to biofuels with lower marginal CO2 abatement costs.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY (2021)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Toward net-zero sustainable aviation fuel with wet waste-derived volatile fatty acids

Nabila A. Huq, Glenn R. Hafenstine, Xiangchen Huo, Hannah Nguyen, Stephen M. Tifft, Davis R. Conklin, Daniela Stuck, Jim Stunkel, Zhibin Yang, Joshua S. Heyne, Matthew R. Wiatrowski, Yimin Zhang, Ling Tao, Junqing Zhu, Charles S. McEnally, Earl D. Christensen, Cameron Hays, Kurt M. Van Allsburg, Kinga A. Unocic, Harry M. Meyer, Zia Abdullah, Derek R. Vardon

Summary: The paper evaluates the catalytic conversion of food waste-derived VFAs to produce n-paraffin SAF for near-term use as a 10 vol% blend for ASTM Fast Track qualification and produce a highly branched, isoparaffin VFA-SAF to increase the renewable blend limit. VFA ketonization models assessed the carbon chain length distributions suitable for each VFA-SAF conversion pathway, and food waste-derived VFA ketonization was demonstrated for >100 h of time on stream at approximately theoretical yield. Fuel property blending models and experimental testing determined normal paraffin VFA-SAF meets 10 vol% fuel specifications for Fast Track. Synergistic blending with isoparaffin VFA-SAF increased the blend limit to 70 vol% by addressing flashpoint and viscosity constraints, with sooting 34% lower than fossil jet. Techno-economic analysis evaluated the major catalytic process cost-drivers, determining the minimum fuel selling price as a function of VFA production costs. Life cycle analysis determined that if food waste is diverted from landfills to avoid methane emissions, VFA-SAF could enable up to 165% reduction in greenhouse gas emissions relative to fossil jet.

PROCEEDINGS OF THE NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA (2021)

Editorial Material Chemistry, Physical

Biorefinery ethanol upgrading: Opportunities and challenges

Ling Tao, Thomas D. Foust

Summary: Producing drop-in replacements for biofuels is a grand challenge, with lignocellulosic biomass being a promising feedstock for fuel ethanol production. Restrepo-Florez et al. systematically studied upgrading ethanol to advanced fuels with tailored properties, while considering process synthesis.

JOULE (2021)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Life cycle analysis of renewable natural gas and lactic acid production from waste feedstocks

Uisung Lee, Arpit Bhatt, Troy Robert Hawkins, Ling Tao, Pahola Thathiana Benavides, Michael Wang

Summary: Producing fuels and chemicals from waste is economically and environmentally favorable, with renewable natural gas and lactic acid showing significantly lower carbon intensities compared to conventional pathways. Life cycle analysis helps identify greenhouse gas emission hotspots and emission savings sources, supporting decisions for sustainable waste valorization.

JOURNAL OF CLEANER PRODUCTION (2021)

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

Techno-economic Analysis and Life-Cycle Analysis of Renewable Diesel Fuels Produced with Waste Feedstocks

Longwen Ou, Shuyun Li, Ling Tao, Steven Phillips, Troy Hawkins, Avantika Singh, Lesley Snowden-Swan, Hao Cai

Summary: This study explores the economic and environmental implications of using wet waste feedstocks to produce biofuels, focusing on two pathways from yellow grease and swine manure. The swine manure HTL pathway shows negative GHG emissions due to credits of avoided emissions from conventional swine manure management. The commercialized yellow grease HEFA pathway benefits from carbon credits in the California Low Carbon Fuel Standard market.

ACS SUSTAINABLE CHEMISTRY & ENGINEERING (2022)

Article Chemistry, Physical

Developing reactors for electrifying bio-methanation: a perspective from bio-electrochemistry

Buddhinie S. Jayathilake, Swetha Chandrasekaran, Megan C. Freyman, Jorg S. Deutzmann, Frauke Kracke, Alfred M. Spormann, Zhe Huang, Ling Tao, Simon H. Pang, Sarah E. Baker

Summary: The integration of microbial synthesis with renewable electricity offers a promising solution for CO2 utilization and energy storage. Electrifying bioreactors provides benefits such as the use of selective bio-catalysts for CO2 conversion and the use of microbes as robust catalysts for higher efficiency. This Perspective proposes research on electro-bioreactor components and presents a case study on methane production to motivate these developments.

SUSTAINABLE ENERGY & FUELS (2022)

Article Energy & Fuels

Effect of Feedstock Variability, Feedstock Blends, and Pretreatment Conditions on Sugar Yield and Production Costs

Yudong Li, Ling Tao, Nick Nagle, Melvin Tucker, Xiaowen Chen, Erik M. Kuhn

Summary: Mass production of sustainable biofuels can significantly reduce greenhouse gas emissions, but the variability, availability, and affordability of biomass feedstock pose risks. This study found that different feedstock species and harvesting techniques impact sugar yields and production costs. Blending feedstocks of different biomass species is a potential successful strategy for sustainable biofuel production.

FRONTIERS IN ENERGY RESEARCH (2022)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

An economic analysis of the role of materials, system engineering, and performance in electrochemical carbon dioxide conversion to formate

Alex Badgett, Mark Ruth, Allison Crow, Gary Grim, Yingying Chen, Leiming Hu, Ling Tao, Wilson Smith, K. C. Neyerlin, Randy Cortright

Summary: The development of technology to utilize carbon dioxide is crucial in mitigating climate change. It is important to consider the nonlinear relationships between system performance, materials, and costs to optimize the scalability and cost-effectiveness of carbon dioxide reduction systems.

JOURNAL OF CLEANER PRODUCTION (2022)

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

Environmental, Economic, and Scalability Considerations of Selected Bio-Derived Blendstocks for Mixing-Controlled Compression Ignition Engines

Andrew W. Bartling, Pahola Thathiana Benavides, Steven D. Phillips, Troy Hawkins, Avantika Singh, Matthew Wiatrowski, Eric C. D. Tan, Christopher Kinchin, Longwen Ou, Hao Cai, Mary Biddy, Ling Tao, Andrew Young, Kathleen Brown, Shuyun Li, Yunhua Zhu, Lesley J. Snowden-Swan, Chirag R. Mevawala, Daniel J. Gaspar

Summary: Economic and environmental favorability are crucial for the development and deployment of sustainable fuels. This study conducted economic and sustainability analyses of 25 pathways for producing bioblendstocks. The results showed that most of the bioblendstocks had favorable economic metrics, but biochemically-based pathways faced challenges in achieving favorable minimum fuel selling price. Additionally, some pathways showed significant reductions in greenhouse gas emissions and fossil energy use.

ACS SUSTAINABLE CHEMISTRY & ENGINEERING (2022)

Article Thermodynamics

Evaluation of performance variables to accelerate the deployment of sustainable aviation fuels at a regional scale

Arpit H. Bhatt, Yimin Zhang, Anelia Milbrandt, Emily Newes, Kristi Moriarty, Bruno Klein, Ling Tao

Summary: The increasing consumption and emissions of jet fuel worldwide have created the necessity for sustainable aviation fuel (SAF) technologies. One option is to use waste or biomass-based feedstocks, which can significantly reduce greenhouse gas emissions compared to conventional jet fuel. This study evaluates the implications of key variables on the deployment of SAF at Chicago's O'Hare International Airport and finds that woody biomass-based Fischer-Tropsch technology has the lowest production costs and reduces GHG emissions by 86% compared to conventional jet fuel.

ENERGY CONVERSION AND MANAGEMENT (2023)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Life cycle analysis of polylactic acids from different wet waste feedstocks

Taemin Kim, Arpit Bhatt, Ling Tao, Pahola Thathiana Benavides

Summary: Producing valuable chemical products from wet wastes can effectively address the issues of waste accumulation and greenhouse gas emissions. This study evaluated the environmental impacts of waste-derived polylactic acids (PLA) from different waste feedstocks. The results showed that swine manure was the most carbon-intensive pathway, followed by food waste and wastewater sludge. Waste-to-PLA pathways had lower carbon footprints compared to fossil-based resins. The decarbonization potential was higher for food waste and wastewater sludge pathways than for swine manure pathway.

JOURNAL OF CLEANER PRODUCTION (2022)

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

Electrifying the production of sustainable aviation fuel: the risks, economics, and environmental benefits of emerging pathways including CO2

R. Gary Grim, Dwarak Ravikumar, Eric C. D. Tan, Zhe Huang, Jack R. Ferrell, Michael Resch, Zhenglong Li, Chirag Mevawala, Steven D. Phillips, Lesley Snowden-Swan, Ling Tao, Joshua A. Schaidle

Summary: Due to weight and travel distance challenges, liquid hydrocarbon fuels will remain the primary choice for medium to long-haul aviation. However, sustainable aviation fuels (SAF) produced from biogenic carbon sources are gaining attention as an alternative to reduce CO2 emissions. Recent studies propose utilizing CO2 and renewable electricity to convert into SAF, offering competitive costs and carbon intensity, and providing a different option from traditional technologies.

ENERGY & ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE (2022)

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

Towards cost-competitive middle distillate fuels from ethanol within a market-flexible biorefinery concept

Junyan Zhang, Eunji Yoo, Brian H. Davison, Dongxia Liu, Joshua A. Schaidle, Ling Tao, Zhenglong Li

Summary: Ethanol to middle distillates is a promising pathway for sustainable liquid fuel production, leveraging abundant biomass and CO2 utilization, with potential for reducing greenhouse gas emissions. Leveraging existing ethanol infrastructure and catalysis innovation can drive cost-effective production of middle distillate fuels.

GREEN CHEMISTRY (2021)

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

The economic outlook for converting CO2 and electrons to molecules

Zhe Huang, R. Gary Grim, Joshua A. Schaidle, Ling Tao

Summary: The research explores the possibility of using renewable energy to drive CO2 reduction reactions to transform the linear consumption economic model. Through economic evaluation of five major technologies, it is found that production costs of 8 out of 11 potential carbonaceous products have the potential to reach parity with or even lower than current market prices.

ENERGY & ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE (2021)

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

The synergy of in situ-generated Ni0 and Ni2P to enhance CO adsorption and protonation for selective CH4 production from photocatalytic CO2 reduction

Xuemei Liu, Chaonan Cui, Shuoshuo Wei, Jinyu Han, Xinli Zhu, Qingfeng Ge, Hua Wang

Summary: This study presents a new strategy for designing efficient photocatalysts that can convert CO2 into hydrocarbons by utilizing synergistic catalytic sites. The findings provide a solution for the selective photocatalytic reduction of CO2 to CH4.

GREEN CHEMISTRY (2024)

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

Cu-Catalyzed, electron-relayed three-component synthesis of 2-alkenylbenzothiazoles with cathodic ammonia evolution

Chengxian Hu, Dan Wang, Lu Wang, Ying Fu, Zhengyin Du

Summary: A novel one-pot, three-component reaction conducted under electrochemical conditions was studied. The reaction involved 2-aminothiophenols, aldehydes, and malononitrile, using TBABF4 as an electrolyte and CuI as a catalyst. The proposed reaction mechanism suggested that CuI served as an electron relay. This method offers simplified operation, high atom economy, and mild reaction conditions.

GREEN CHEMISTRY (2024)

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

Iridium-catalyzed asymmetric, complete hydrogenation of pyrimidinium salts under batch and flow

Zhi Yang, Yu Chen, Linxi Wan, Yuxiao Li, Dan Chen, Jianlin Tao, Pei Tang, Fen-Er Chen

Summary: A highly enantioselective method for the complete hydrogenation of pyrimidinium salts using Ir/(S,S)-f-Binaphane complex as the catalyst was developed. This method provides easy access to fully saturated chiral hexahydropyrimidines, which are prevalent in many bioactive molecules. The reactions exhibit high yields and enantioselectivities under mild reaction conditions without additives. Successful application of this methodology in a continuous flow fashion further extends its practical utility.

GREEN CHEMISTRY (2024)

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

Spatiotemporal dynamics of cellulose during enzymatic hydrolysis studied by infrared spectromicroscopy

Tina Jeoh, Jennifer Danger Nill, Wujun Zhao, Sankar Raju Narayanasamy, Liang Chen, Hoi-Ying N. Holman

Summary: In this study, the enzymatic hydrolysis of cellulose was investigated using real-time infrared spectromicroscopy. The spatial heterogeneity of cellulose was found to impact the hydrolysis kinetics. Hydration affected cellulose ordering, and Cel7A preferentially removed less extensively hydrogen bonded cellulose.

GREEN CHEMISTRY (2024)

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

Efficient nickel-catalysed telomerisation on glycerol carbonate: a new linker route for lignin functionalisation

Tiphaine Richard, Walid Abdallah, Xavier Trivelli, Mathieu Sauthier, Clement Dumont

Summary: An effective method of grafting functionalities onto lignin based on glycerol carbonate has been developed using an efficient nickel-catalysed telomerisation reaction. This method allows lignin to have new reactive functions and reduces the glass transition temperatures of modified lignins, thereby expanding the application range of lignin-based resins.

GREEN CHEMISTRY (2024)

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

Sustainable electrocatalytic oxidation of N-alkylamides to acyclic imides using H2O

Jing Qi, Xiyan Wang, Gan Wang, Srinivas Reddy Dubbaka, Patrick ONeill, Hwee Ting Ang, Jie Wu

Summary: This study presents a green and environmentally friendly approach for the synthesis of imides using electrocatalytic oxidation with H2O as the oxygen source. The method eliminates the need for toxic or expensive oxidants and achieves high yields under mild reaction conditions. It shows broad substrate compatibility and potential for industrial applications.

GREEN CHEMISTRY (2024)

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

Visible light-driven highly atom-economical divergent synthesis of substituted fluorenols and cyclopropylcarbaldehydes

Babasaheb Sopan Gore, Lin-Wei Pan, Jun-Hao Lin, Yi-Chi Luo, Jeh-Jeng Wang

Summary: Here, we report a visible light-promoted intramolecular radical cascade reaction for the construction of fluorenol and naphthalene-fused cyclopropyl carbaldehyde derivatives. This method offers mild reaction conditions, a broad substrate scope, excellent step efficiency, and scalability, without the need for external chemical oxidants. The novelty of this protocol was demonstrated by synthesizing chrysene analogs and performing late-stage functionalizations.

GREEN CHEMISTRY (2024)

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

Supramolecular interaction-driven delignification of lignocellulose

Juho Antti Sirvio, Idamaria Romakkaniemi, Juha Ahola, Svitlana Filonenko, Juha P. Heiskanen, Ari Ammala

Summary: This article discusses the method of using supramolecular interaction between an aromatic hydrogen bond donor and lignin to achieve rapid delignification of softwood at low temperatures.

GREEN CHEMISTRY (2024)

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

Photocatalytic synthesis of 2,3-diamines from anilines and DIPEA via C-N bond cleavage and C-C bond formation

Yunyan Meng, Chunxiang Pan, Na Liu, Hongjiang Li, Zixiu Liu, Yao Deng, Zixiang Wei, Jianbin Xu, Baomin Fan

Summary: A novel visible light-driven synthesis method for 2,3-diamines has been developed, which has mild conditions, avoids the use of metal reagents, and can synthesize diamines and diols in one pot.

GREEN CHEMISTRY (2024)

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

Direct air-induced arylphosphinoyl radicals for the synthesis of benzo[b]phosphole oxides

Mingqing Huang, Haiyang Huang, Mengyao You, Xinxin Zhang, Longgen Sun, Chao Chen, Zhichao Mei, Ruchun Yang, Qiang Xiao

Summary: A direct air-oxidized strategy for the synthesis of benzo[b]phosphole oxides was developed in this study. Arylphosphine oxides were transformed into phosphinoyl radicals, which were further combined with various alkynes to achieve the desired products. DFT calculations revealed the mechanism of phosphinoyl radical formation.

GREEN CHEMISTRY (2024)

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

A simple and convenient strategy for the oxidation of C(sp3)-H bonds based on γ-valerolactone

Anwei Wang, Jiayin Huang, Chunsheng Zhao, Yu Fan, Junfeng Qian, Qun Chen, Mingyang He, Weiyou Zhou

Summary: This study demonstrates an innovative strategy for the aerobic oxidation of C(sp(3))-H bonds using gamma-valerolactone. By optimizing the reaction conditions and utilizing specific catalysts, efficient oxidation of C(sp(3))-H bonds is achieved with good chemoselectivity in certain cases.

GREEN CHEMISTRY (2024)

Article Chemistry, Multidisciplinary

A novel high-entropy sulfide (ZnCoMnFeAlMg)9S8 as a low potential and long life electrocatalyst for overall water splitting in experiments and DFT analysis

Shun Li, Likai Tong, Zhijian Peng, Bo Zhang, Xiuli Fu

Summary: Sulfide compounds show promise as electrocatalysts for water splitting, but their performance is limited by factors such as limited active sites and hindered substance transport. This study successfully prepared a high-entropy sulfide (ZnCoMnFeAlMg)(9)S-8, which reduced grain size and increased specific surface area, enabling the realization of a dual-functional catalyst with multiple catalytic sites. High entropy also modulated the electronic properties of sulfides, reducing the potential energy barrier for hydrolysis. This research introduces a new approach for functionalizing high entropy nanomaterials and improves the performance of water splitting catalysts.

GREEN CHEMISTRY (2024)