4.5 Article

An Unbiased Method for Probabilistic Fire Safety Engineering, Requiring a Limited Number of Model Evaluations

Journal

FIRE TECHNOLOGY
Volume 53, Issue 5, Pages 1705-1744

Publisher

SPRINGER
DOI: 10.1007/s10694-017-0660-4

Keywords

Fire; Probability; Monte Carlo; Maximum entropy; ME-MDRM; Concrete; Structural fire safety

Ask authors/readers for more resources

The rise of Performance Based Design methodologies for fire safety engineering has increased the interest of the fire safety community in the concepts of risk and reliability. Practical applications have however been severely hampered by the lack of an efficient unbiased calculation methodology. This is because on the one hand, the distribution types of model output variables in fire safety engineering are not known and traditional distribution types as for example the normal and lognormal distribution may result in unsafe approximations. Therefore unbiased methods must be applied which make no (implicit) assumptions on the PDF type. Traditionally these unbiased methods are based on Monte Carlo simulations. On the other hand, Monte Carlo simulations require a large number of model evaluations and are therefore too computationally expensive when large and nonlinear calculation models are applied, as is common in fire safety engineering. The methodology presented in this paper avoids this deadlock by making an unbiased estimate of the PDF based on only a very limited number of model evaluations. The methodology is known as the Maximum Entropy Multiplicative Dimensional Reduction Method (ME-MDRM) and results in a mathematical formula for the probability density function (PDF) describing the uncertain output variable. The method can be applied with existing models and calculation tools and allows for a parallelization of model evaluations. The example applications given in the paper stem from the field of structural fire safety and illustrate the excellent performance of the method for probabilistic structural fire safety engineering. The ME-MDRM can however be considered applicable to other types of engineering models as well.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

HALK: A hybrid active-learning Kriging approach and its applications for structural reliability analysis

Xufang Zhang, Mahesh D. Pandey, Ruyu Yu, Zhenguang Wu

Summary: The paper introduces a hybrid active-learning approach using adaptive Kriging surrogate models for structural reliability analysis. It combines the quasi first-order reliability method and a U-function based criterion to optimize training sample efficiency, resulting in the HALK algorithm for developing adaptive surrogate models. Numerical examples demonstrate the effectiveness of the HALK algorithm in handling structural reliability problems.

ENGINEERING WITH COMPUTERS (2022)

Article Engineering, Civil

Direct Method for Generating Floor Response Spectra considering Soil-Structure Interaction

Wei Jiang, Yang Zhou, Wei-Chau Xie, Mahesh D. Pandey

Summary: A methodology is developed for generating floor response spectra (FRS) considering the effect of dynamic soil-structure interaction (SSI) using the substructure technique and a direct spectra-to-spectra method. The method is accurate and efficient in modeling FRS with different Non-Exceedance Probability (NEP) levels and highlights the advantages of considering SSI in the analysis.

JOURNAL OF EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING (2022)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Nondestructive Assessment of Elastomeric Bridge Bearings Using 3D Digital Image Correlation

Saleh Ahmadi Soleimani, Dimitrios Konstantinidis, Georgios P. Balomenos

Summary: This paper presents an alternative vision-based assessment methodology for nondestructive identification of the internal structure of elastomeric bridge bearings. The methodology utilizes the unique deformation pattern on the vertical surfaces of a bearing to deduce the thicknesses of rubber layers and covers, providing a rapid and cost-effective qualification of manufacturing defects.

JOURNAL OF STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING (2022)

Article Engineering, Civil

Restoration curves for infrastructure: preliminary case study on a bridge in Quebec, Canada

Behfar Godazgar, Georgios Balomenos, Susan Tighe

Summary: As critical infrastructures, bridges play a crucial role in the resilience and functionality of the transportation system. This paper presents a study on the Chemin des Dalles Bridge (CDB) in Quebec, Canada, providing a probabilistic resilience curve to assess its functionality. The results show that the bridge has a resilient performance in code-level earthquakes, but improvements should be made to enhance its resiliency in stronger events.

PROCEEDINGS OF THE INSTITUTION OF CIVIL ENGINEERS-BRIDGE ENGINEERING (2022)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Effect of Manufacturing Imperfections on the Service-Level Performance of Elastomeric Bridge Bearings

Saleh Ahmadi Soleimani, Dimitrios Konstantinidis, Georgios P. Balomenos

Summary: During the vulcanization process of steel-laminated elastomeric bridge bearings, the flow of elastomer and manufacturing imperfections such as misaligned or distorted steel laminates can affect the quality and performance of the bearings. This paper presents a finite element investigation on the effects of manufacturing imperfections on the performance of elastomeric bridge bearings and observes that such imperfections have a negligible effect on the maximum shear strain induced in the elastomer and the vertical deflection of the bearings. However, they can increase the tensile stresses in the steel laminates causing plastic damage, which may affect the long-term performance of the bearings.

JOURNAL OF STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING (2022)

Review Construction & Building Technology

State-of-the-art review of the reliability evaluation of concrete beams exposed to fire

Tulio Coelho, Sofia Diniz, Francisco Rodrigues, Ruben Van Coile

Summary: This paper investigates the reliability evaluation of reinforced concrete beams in a fire situation. The review of the state of the art reveals gaps in the literature and suggests future research direction.

JOURNAL OF STRUCTURAL FIRE ENGINEERING (2023)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Experimental investigation into the effect of elevated temperatures on the fracture strength of soda-lime-silica glass

Evelien Symoens, Ruben Van Coile, Jan Belis

Summary: This study investigates the fracture behavior and strength of soda-lime-silica glass at elevated temperatures, and finds that a slight increase in fracture strength is observed as the temperature increases.

GLASS STRUCTURES & ENGINEERING (2022)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Compliance-based topology optimization of structural components subjected to thermo-mechanical loading

Ticho Ooms, Gieljan Vantyghem, Thomas Thienpont, Ruben Van Coile, Wouter De Corte

Summary: In the construction industry, thermal gradient can subject structural components to internally restrained thermal expansion, which can alter the mechanical response in structural topology optimization. In this paper, a density-based topology optimization procedure is developed for compliance minimization of structural components under thermo-mechanical loads. The proposed procedure takes into account the influence of design-dependent temperature field and thermal properties, and its effectiveness is demonstrated on the MBB problem with thermal loading.

STRUCTURAL AND MULTIDISCIPLINARY OPTIMIZATION (2023)

Article Chemistry, Physical

Probability Density Function Models for Float Glass under Mechanical Loading with Varying Parameters

Evelien Symoens, Ruben Van Coile, Balsa Jovanovic, Jan Belis

Summary: Glass as a construction material is crucial in the building industry, but predicting the strength of structural glass in different configurations remains a challenge. The failure of glass elements is mainly caused by pre-existing microscopic surface flaws, which vary in properties. The strength of glass is described by a probability function, depending on panel size, loading conditions, and flaw size distribution. This study extends an existing strength prediction model and identifies the most appropriate probability density function using the Akaike information criterion. The results show that the appropriate model depends on the number of flaws subjected to maximum tensile stresses.

MATERIALS (2023)

Article Construction & Building Technology

Capacity and failure modes of restrained hollow core slabs taking into account compressive membrane action

Thomas Thienpont, Ruben Van Coile, Wouter De Corte, Robby Caspeele

Summary: The study investigates the compressive membrane action in restrained precast concrete hollow core slabs and its impact on load bearing capacity and failure mode during excessive loading. An experimental campaign is conducted to quantify this phenomenon, and the outcomes are analyzed using a finite element model. The results indicate that the ultimate capacity and failure mode of restrained hollow core slabs are influenced by restraint conditions and span-to-depth ratio. Additionally, inherent uncertainties in material properties and geometry significantly affect the membrane action in precast hollow core slabs.

STRUCTURAL CONCRETE (2023)

Article Engineering, Civil

Effects of steel shim geometric characteristics and imperfections on the behavior of unbonded elastomeric bridge bearings subjected to large lateral displacements

Saleh Ahmadi Soleimani, Dimitrios Konstantinidis, Georgios P. Balomenos

Summary: Unbonded laminated elastomeric bridge bearings are designed for service-level deformations but can experience significantly larger deformations during earthquakes. The effects of steel shim characteristics and imperfections on the seismic behavior of these bearings have been understudied. This study investigates how manufacturing imperfections and shim thickness affect the behavior of these bearings under large lateral displacement.

ENGINEERING STRUCTURES (2023)

Article Computer Science, Interdisciplinary Applications

Thermoelastic topology optimization of structural components at elevated temperatures considering transient heat conduction

Ticho Ooms, Gieljan Vantyghem, Thomas Thienpont, Ruben Van Coile, Wouter De Corte

Summary: This paper presents a compact and efficient MATLAB code for thermoelastic topology optimization considering transient heat conduction. The code utilizes finite-element modeling and an implicit finite difference scheme for time discretization. A density-based topology optimization procedure is developed and applied, and sensitivity analysis is performed using the adjoint variable method. Detailed explanation of the methodology and implementation in MATLAB is provided, along with numerical examples to demonstrate the influence of various parameters on thermo-mechanical loading and transient heat conduction analysis.

ENGINEERING WITH COMPUTERS (2023)

Article Engineering, Geological

Fragility framework for corroded steel moment-resisting frame buildings subjected to mainshock-aftershock sequences

Ghazal Saed, Georgios P. Balomenos

Summary: This study proposes a framework for assessing the seismic fragility of steel moment-resisting frames under different corrosion rates and subjected to real mainshock-aftershock sequences. Uncertainties in structural characteristics can significantly impact structural performance. By considering both demand and capacity parameters, the framework incorporates randomness using Latin hypercube sampling. Application of the framework on three modeled frames exposed to nine recorded mainshock-aftershock sequences illustrates its usefulness. The results highlight the significant impact of corrosion and aftershocks on seismic fragility, particularly for extreme limit states.

SOIL DYNAMICS AND EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING (2023)

Proceedings Paper Construction & Building Technology

Influence of Self-healing via Embedded Macrocapsules Filled with Polyurethane on Carbonation of High-Volume Fly Ash Mortar

Tim Van Mullem, Arne Sintobin, Philip Van den Heede, Laurence De Meyst, Robby Caspeele, Nele De Belie

Summary: During carbonation, concrete consumes calcium hydroxide, leading to a pH drop and potential steel corrosion. Cracks in cementitious materials allow for faster carbon dioxide ingress. Self-healing cementitious materials can close cracks without manual repair but the influence of carbonation is seldom studied. In this study, High-Volume Fly Ash mortar samples with glass macrocapsules filled with polyurethane were tested. Non-pressurized capsules showed sealing efficiency of over 80%, while pressurized capsules only had a 25% efficiency. Carbonation depth was shallower at cracked locations compared to reference samples. Non-pressurized capsules performed well with carbonation depth half that of reference samples.

PROCEEDINGS OF THE 75TH RILEM ANNUAL WEEK 2021 (2023)

No Data Available