4.5 Article

Large uncertainty in soil carbon modelling related to method of calculation of plant carbon input in agricultural systems

Journal

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF SOIL SCIENCE
Volume 68, Issue 6, Pages 953-963

Publisher

WILEY
DOI: 10.1111/ejss.12454

Keywords

-

Categories

Funding

  1. Danish Ministry of Environment and Food as part of the SINKS2 project

Ask authors/readers for more resources

The application of dynamic models to report changes in soil organic carbon (SOC) stocks, for example as part of greenhouse gas inventories, is becoming increasingly important. Most of these models rely on input data from harvest residues or decaying plant parts and also organic fertilizer, together referred to as soil carbon inputs (C). The soil C inputs from plants are derived from measured agricultural yields using allometric equations. Here we compared the results of five previously published equations. Our goal was to test whether the choice of method is critical for modelling soil C and if so, which of these equations is most suitable for Swiss conditions. For this purpose we used the five equations to calculate soil C inputs based on yield data from a Swiss long-term cropping experiment. Estimated annual soil C inputs from various crops were averaged from 28 years and four fertilizer treatments; the average was 3.6 Mg C ha(-1) and covered a surprisingly large range from 2.1 to 5.3 Mg C ha(-1) year(-1) among the five equations. For single crop species, differences reached 6.6 Mg C ha(-1) year(-1). The variation between estimated soil C inputs depended on crop type and increased with yield. Simulations with the model C-TOOL showed that calculated SOC stocks were affected strongly by the choice of the allometric equation. With four equations, a decrease in SOC stocks was simulated, whereas with one equation there was no change. This considerable uncertainty in modelled soil C is attributable solely to the allometric equation used to estimate the soil C input. We identify the evaluation and selection of allometric equations and associated coefficients as critical steps when setting up a model-based soil C inventory for agricultural systems. Highlights Uncertainty analyses in soil C modelling have focused mainly on model parameters and structures. The uncertainty related to estimation of soil C inputs from crop residues was calculated. Simulated soil C stocks and stock changes depend strongly on the method of estimating C input. The method to derive soil C inputs is critical for model-based soil C inventories.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.5
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Environmental Sciences

Effects of exogenous organic/inorganic nitrogen addition on carbon pool distribution and transformation in grassland soil

Menghan Wang, Fucui Li, Lili Dong, Xiang Wang, Liebao Han, Jurgen E. Olesen

Summary: Increases in nitrogen deposition have the potential to impact the organic carbon cycle in soil. The effects of nitrogen addition on soil organic carbon pools are inconsistent, highlighting the need for quantifying the response of organic carbon pool distribution to nitrogen addition. Furthermore, the influence of adding a mixture of organic and inorganic nitrogen on organic carbon pool distribution and stabilization in grassland soil remains unclear.

SCIENCE OF THE TOTAL ENVIRONMENT (2023)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Organic carbon contents of mineral grassland soils in Switzerland over the last 30 years

Janine Moll-Mielewczik, Sonja G. Keel, Andreas Gubler

Summary: Long-term monitoring of soil organic carbon (SOC) content and stocks is crucial for climate change and carbon sequestration. Field data and models are used to report changes in SOC stocks and validate models. This study presents SOC measurements from 1985 to 2014 in Swiss grassland sites and compares them with predictions from the RothC model. While there was no general trend in measured data, the model showed a good fit in two-thirds of the cases.

AGRICULTURE ECOSYSTEMS & ENVIRONMENT (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Challenges in upscaling laboratory studies to ecosystems in soil microbiology research

Ji Chen, Yong Zhang, Yakov Kuzyakov, Dong Wang, Jorgen Eivind Olesen

Summary: Soil microbiology has entered the era of big data, but faces challenges in integrating laboratory, field, and model-based studies. The limitations of laboratory experiments ignore the interactions of various environmental drivers, leading to discrepancies between laboratory and field studies. The upscaling of soil microbiology research from laboratory to ecosystems is a grand challenge with the potential to inform climate-smart and resource-efficient ecosystems. Understanding the gaps between laboratory and field studies and the issues in bridging observations and model predictions is crucial for interdisciplinary collaboration and knowledge advancement.

GLOBAL CHANGE BIOLOGY (2023)

Article Agronomy

Evaluation of MSWX gridded data for modeling of wheat performance across Iran

Alireza Araghi, Christopher J. Martinez, Jorgen E. Olesen

Summary: This study assessed the accuracy of a gridded weather dataset called MSWX in modeling wheat performance in Iran. The results showed that MSWX temperature had higher accuracy than AgERA5, while MSWX solar radiation had weaker performance. It was found that MSWX temperature data could be the best replacement for measured temperature data in the study area.

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF AGRONOMY (2023)

Article Soil Science

Limitations of farm management data in analyses of decadal changes in SOC stocks in the Danish soil-monitoring network

Laura Sofie Harbo, Jorgen E. Olesen, Camilla Lemming, Bent T. Christensen, Lars Elsgaard

Summary: Changes in soil organic carbon (SOC) storage in agricultural land are important for national greenhouse gas emission inventories and climate mitigation strategies. We analyzed the effects of management practices on SOC stocks in Danish agricultural mineral soils using data from two surveys. The overall SOC stock remained stable, but deeper soil layers should be included in soil-monitoring networks. The use of farm management data to explain changes in SOC stocks appears limited.

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF SOIL SCIENCE (2023)

Article Agronomy

Faba bean productivity, yield stability and N2-fixation in long-term organic and conventional crop rotations

Chiara De Notaris, Ea Elisabeth Enggrob, Jorgen E. Olesen, Peter Sorensen, Jim Rasmussen

Summary: Increasing grain legume production in Europe has multiple benefits, including protein self-sufficiency and environmental advantages such as biological nitrogen fixation. Faba bean is the main grain legume grown in Europe, with growing interest from the organic sector. However, the inclusion of grain legumes in cropping systems faces agronomic and economic challenges that can be overcome by considering ecosystem services.

FIELD CROPS RESEARCH (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Replacing chemical fertilizer with manure reduces N2O emissions in winter wheat-summer maize cropping system under limited irrigation

Xiquan Wang, Shang Wang, Huadong Zang, Jiangwen Nie, Jie Zhao, Peixin Wang, Leanne Peixoto, Yadong Yang, Jorgen Eivind Olesen, Zhaohai Zeng

Summary: Nitrous oxide (N2O) emissions from agroecosystems are a major contributor to global warming and ozone depletion. This study investigated the effects of manure application and irrigation on N2O emissions in a wheat-maize cropping system. The results showed that manure application reduced N2O emissions by 25-51% compared to chemical fertilizer, particularly during the two weeks after fertilization combined with irrigation. Furthermore, manure application maintained grain nitrogen yield, while increasing N2O emissions.

JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT (2023)

Article Agriculture, Multidisciplinary

Methane and nitrous oxide emissions from rice grown on organic soils in the temperate zone

Chloe Wust-Galley, Sandra Heller, Christof Ammann, Sonja Paul, Sebastian Doetterl, Jens Leifeld

Summary: Wet rice cultivation in organic soils contributes to methane and nitrous oxide emissions, but the use of a mineral cover layer can significantly reduce these greenhouse gas emissions.

AGRICULTURE ECOSYSTEMS & ENVIRONMENT (2023)

Article Soil Science

The importance of biochar quality and pyrolysis yield for soil carbon sequestration in practice

Leonor Rodrigues, Alice Budai, Lars Elsgaard, Brieuc Hardy, Sonja G. Keel, Claudio Mondini, Cesar Plaza, Jens Leifeld

Summary: Biochar is a carbon-rich material produced from biomass through pyrolysis. It has been suggested as an effective long-term option to sequester CO2 for climate change mitigation. However, there is no universally applicable approach to measure its carbon sequestration efficiency. Guidelines on biochar quality have been developed to ensure its safe environmental use in agriculture. The hydrogen-to-organic C ratio is an important quality criterion widely used as a proxy for biochar stability.

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF SOIL SCIENCE (2023)

Article Agronomy

Excessive N applications reduces yield and biological N fixation of summer-peanut in the North China Plain

Wenhai Huang, Yuhao Yang, Haoyu Zheng, Jorgen Eivind Olesen, Robert M. Rees, Jun Zou, Li Zhang, Suya Hu, Bowen Qiao, Xiaohui Wang, Shuaijie Shen, Biaoding Yang, Zhiyuan Bai, Axiang Zheng, Wenjie Li, Zhenwei Song, Xinya Wen, Fu Chen, Xiaogang Yin

Summary: This study evaluated the effects of different fertilizer nitrogen inputs on the yield and biological nitrogen fixation (BNF) of summer peanut in the North China Plain (NCP). The results showed that the optimal nitrogen application rate for achieving high nitrogen use efficiency (NUE) and low nitrogen losses without sacrificing yield was 150 kg N ha-1, which resulted in a yield of 3915 kg ha-1 and NUEoi of 73.0% in the summer-peanut production. These findings have important implications for the sustainable development of summer-peanut systems.

FIELD CROPS RESEARCH (2023)

Review Agronomy

Biochar from animal manure: A critical assessment on technical feasibility, economic viability, and ecological impact

Dilani Rathnayake, Hans-Peter Schmidt, Jens Leifeld, Jochen Mayer, Carole Alice Epper, Thomas D. Bucheli, Nikolas Hagemann

Summary: Animal manure has been widely used in agriculture to improve soil fertility, but its increasing surplus due to intensive livestock farming has raised concerns about its impact on human, animal, and environmental health. Conventional manure management methods have limitations in reducing contamination risks and greenhouse gas emissions. Pyrolysis, a thermochemical conversion technique, shows potential as an alternative treatment for manure by reducing toxic elements, eliminating pathogens and micropollutants, and decreasing GHG emissions. However, further research is needed to evaluate the effects of manure pyrolysis on crop yield and fertilization efficiencies.

GLOBAL CHANGE BIOLOGY BIOENERGY (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Challenges of accounting nitrous oxide emissions from agricultural crop residues

Jorgen E. Olesen, Robert M. Rees, Sylvie Recous, Marina A. Bleken, Diego Abalos, Ishita Ahuja, Klaus Butterbach-Bahl, Marco Carozzi, Chiara De Notaris, Maria Ernfors, Edwin Haas, Sissel Hansen, Baldur Janz, Gwenaelle Lashermes, Raia S. Massad, Soren O. Petersen, Tatiana F. Rittl, Clemens Scheer, Kate E. Smith, Pascal Thiebeau, Arezoo Taghizadeh-Toosi, Rachel E. Thorman, Cairistiona F. E. Topp

Summary: Crop residues play a crucial role in carbon and nitrogen input to soils, affecting nitrous oxide emissions. The current inventory methodology only considers nitrogen inputs by crop residues, ignoring other factors and processes. Different biochemical and physical characteristics of residues contribute to variations in emissions, with immature residues having higher concentrations of mineralizable nitrogen and decomposable carbon. Accurately estimating the short-term and long-term effects of crop residues on N2O emissions requires distinguishing between mature and immature residues and considering local conditions. Better mitigation efforts and emission accounting methods are urgently needed.

GLOBAL CHANGE BIOLOGY (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Shifts in soil ammonia-oxidizing community maintain the nitrogen stimulation of nitrification across climatic conditions

Yong Zhang, Xiaoli Cheng, Kees Jan van Groenigen, Pablo Garcia-Palacios, Junji Cao, Xunhua Zheng, Yiqi Luo, Bruce A. Hungate, Cesar Terrer, Klaus Butterbach-Bahl, Jorgen Eivind Olesen, Ji Chen

Summary: Anthropogenic nitrogen loading affects the abundance of soil ammonia-oxidizing archaea and bacteria, leading to changes in soil nitrification. Climate is the most important factor determining the response of the ammonia-oxidizing community to nitrogen loading, and it affects nitrification indirectly through its influence on the ammonia-oxidizing community.

GLOBAL CHANGE BIOLOGY (2023)

Article Agronomy

Weather modifies the spatial extent of carbohydrate transfers from CO2-supplied broad-leaved trees to ectomycorrhizal fungi

Erik A. Hobbie, Rolf Siegwolf, Christian Koerner, Katharina Steinmann, Markus Wilhelm, Matthias Saurer, Sonja G. Keel

Summary: In a Swiss forest, the spatial and temporal dynamics of carbon transfer from tree hosts to ectomycorrhizal fungi were studied. The results showed that fungal morphology did not affect carbon transfer, and carbohydrates were the primary form of carbon transferred to sporocarps across different zones. Environmental factors such as solar radiation and drought influenced carbon transfer.

PLANT AND SOIL (2023)

Editorial Material Food Science & Technology

Models can enhance science-policy-society alignments for climate change mitigation

Davide Cammarano, Jorgen Eivind Olesen, Katharina Helming, Christine Helen Foyer, Martin Schoenhart, Gianluca Brunori, Keerthi Kiran Bandru, Marco Bindi, Gloria Padovan, Bo Jellesmark Thorsen, Florian Freund, Diego Abalos

Summary: The lack of strong interconnection between research, policy, and societal action inhibits climate change mitigation in agri-food systems. Modelling tools, international superordinate bodies, and stakeholder-inclusive assessment frameworks can facilitate better alignment between these three pillars of human progress.

NATURE FOOD (2023)

No Data Available