4.8 Article

Predictive Power of Clean Bed Filtration Theory for Fecal Indicator Bacteria Removal in Stormwater Biofilters

Journal

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY
Volume 51, Issue 10, Pages 5703-5712

Publisher

AMER CHEMICAL SOC
DOI: 10.1021/acs.est.7b00752

Keywords

-

Funding

  1. U.S. National Science Foundation Partnerships for International Research and Education [OISE-1243543]
  2. Office Of The Director
  3. Office Of Internatl Science &Engineering [1243543] Funding Source: National Science Foundation

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Green infrastructure (also referred to as low impact development, or LID) has the potential to transform urban stormwater runoff from an environmental threat to a valuable water resource. In this paper we focus on the removal of fecal indicator bacteria (FIB, a pollutant responsible for runoff associated inland and coastal beach closures) in stormwater biofilters (a common type of green infrastructure). Drawing on a combination of previously published and new laboratory studies of FIB removal in biofilters, we find that 66% of the variance in FIB removal rates can be explained by clean bed filtration theory (CBFT, 31%), antecedent dry period (14%), study effect (8%), biofilter age (7%), and the presence or absence of shrubs (6%). Our analysis suggests that, with the exception of shrubs, plants affect FIB removal indirectly by changing the infiltration rate, not directly by changing the FIB removal mechanisms or altering filtration rates in ways not already accounted for by CBFT. The analysis presented here represents a significant step forward in our understanding of how physicochemical theories (such as CBFT) can be melded with hydrology, engineering design, and ecology to improve the water quality benefits of green infrastructure.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.8
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Environmental Sciences

The forgotten ocean: Why COP26 must call for vastly greater ambition and urgency to address ocean change

Dan Laffoley, John M. Baxter, Diva J. Amon, Joachim Claudet, Craig A. Downs, Sylvia A. Earle, Kristina M. Gjerde, Jason M. Hall-Spencer, Heather J. Koldewey, Lisa A. Levin, Chris P. Reid, Callum M. Roberts, Rashid U. Sumaila, Michelle L. Taylor, Torsten Thiele, Lucy C. Woodall

Summary: Climate and biodiversity crises are the top two interconnected threats facing the planet, with the ocean playing a vital role in both. COP26 has the potential to be a turning point, but it requires commitment to united action for the ocean and science-led solutions to address the interconnectivity of ocean, climate, and biodiversity.

AQUATIC CONSERVATION-MARINE AND FRESHWATER ECOSYSTEMS (2022)

Article Limnology

Five state factors control progressive stages of freshwater salinization syndrome

Sujay S. Kaushal, Paul M. Mayer, Gene E. Likens, Jenna E. Reimer, Carly M. Maas, Megan A. Rippy, Stanley B. Grant, Ian Hart, Ryan M. Utz, Ruth R. Shatkay, Barret M. Wessel, Christine E. Maietta, Michael L. Pace, Shuiwang Duan, Walter L. Boger, Alexis M. Yaculak, Joseph G. Galella, Kelsey L. Wood, Carol J. Morel, William Nguyen, Shane Elizabeth C. Querubin, Rebecca A. Sukert, Anna Lowien, Alyssa Wellman Houde, Anais Roussel, Andrew J. Houston, Ari Cacopardo, Cristy Ho, Haley Talbot-Wendlandt, Jacob M. Widmer, Jairus Slagle, James A. Bader, Jeng Hann Chong, Jenna Wollney, Jordan Kim, Lauren Shepherd, Matthew T. Wilfong, Megan Houlihan, Nathan Sedghi, Rebecca Butcher, Sona Chaudhary, William D. Becker

Summary: The severity and recovery chances of freshwater salinization syndrome (FSS) are influenced by various factors, including human activities, geology, flowpaths, climate, and time. These factors drive the spread of FSS across ecosystems in different stages, leading to failures in systems-level functions.

LIMNOLOGY AND OCEANOGRAPHY LETTERS (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Can Common Pool Resource Theory Catalyze Stakeholder-Driven Solutions to the Freshwater Salinization Syndrome?

Stanley B. Grant, Megan A. Rippy, Thomas A. Birkland, Todd Schenk, Kristin Rowles, Shalini Misra, Payam Aminpour, Sujay Kaushal, Peter Vikesland, Emily Berglund, Jesus D. Gomez-Velez, Erin R. Hotchkiss, Gabriel Perez, Harry X. Zhang, Kingston Armstrong, Shantanu V. Bhide, Lauren Krauss, Carly Maas, Kent Mendoza, Caitlin Shipman, Yadong Zhang, Yinman Zhong

Summary: Freshwater salinization is a growing issue globally, affecting ecosystems and human water supplies. This article proposes using a social-ecological systems framework to understand and manage this issue, using rising sodium concentrations in the Occoquan Reservoir in Northern Virginia as a case study to explore impacts, causes, solutions, and research needs.

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY (2022)

Article Environmental Sciences

Consequences of Mouth Closure and Hypoxia-Induced State Changes in Low-Inflow Estuaries: Benthic Community and Trait-Based Response

Lisa A. Levin, Guillermo F. Mendoza, Carlos Neira, Sarah N. Giddings, Jeffrey A. Crooks

Summary: This study evaluated the effects of mouth closure and hypoxia on macrobenthic communities in two estuaries along the southern California coastline. The results showed that mouth closure increased macrofaunal density and diversity, especially at the mouth, and suppressed seasonality. Hypoxia, on the other hand, led to changes in taxonomic composition but had no effect on taxon richness or diversity. The differences in community composition and traits between the two estuaries disappeared in the middle and upper reaches.

ESTUARIES AND COASTS (2023)

Article Engineering, Environmental

Stormwater biofilter response to high nitrogen loading under transient flow conditions: Ammonium and nitrate fates, and nitrous oxide emissions

Marina Feraud, Sean P. Ahearn, Emily A. Parker, Sumant Avasarala, Megyn B. Rugh, Wei-Cheng Hung, Dong Li, Laurie C. Van De Werfhorst, Timnit Kefela, Azadeh Hemati, Andrew S. Mehring, Yiping Cao, Jennifer A. Jay, Haizhou Liu, Stanley B. Grant, Patricia A. Holden

Summary: This study found that nitrogen in urban runoff can be treated with biofilters during simulated storms, but the nitrogen transformation within the biofilters is insufficient, mainly undergoing ammonification and nitrification, without much denitrification. Therefore, it is necessary to redesign biofilters to promote plant assimilation and/or denitrification of nitrogen in order to reduce the nitrogen generation and export caused by nitrification.

WATER RESEARCH (2023)

Article Limnology

Oxygen and irradiance constraints on visual habitat in a changing ocean: The luminoxyscape

Lillian R. McCormick, Shailja Gangrade, Jessica C. Garwood, Nicholas W. Oesch, Lisa A. Levin

LIMNOLOGY AND OCEANOGRAPHY LETTERS (2023)

Article Ecology

Nutrient and stoichiometric time series measurements of decomposing coarse detritus in freshwaters

Caleb J. Robbins, Beth C. Norman, Halvor M. Halvorson, David W. P. Manning, Elliot Bastias, Cristiane Biasi, Allyn K. Dodd, Rebecca A. Eckert, Alice Gossiaux, Jeremy Jabiol, Andrew S. Mehring, Ada Pastor

Summary: The decomposition of coarse detritus in freshwater ecosystems has been well studied in terms of mass loss, but less is known about the temporal changes in the elemental composition of these materials during decomposition. This dataset synthesizes published measurements of detrital nutrients and stoichiometry to provide a basis for understanding the temporality of elemental content in freshwater detritus.

ECOLOGY (2023)

Article Ecology

Nutrient and stoichiometry dynamics of decomposing litter in stream ecosystems: A global synthesis

Caleb J. J. Robbins, David W. P. Manning, Halvor M. M. Halvorson, Beth C. C. Norman, Rebecca A. A. Eckert, Ada Pastor, Allyn K. K. Dodd, Jeremy Jabiol, Elliot Bastias, Alice Gossiaux, Andrew S. S. Mehring

Summary: Decomposing organic matter is a vital resource for aquatic ecosystems, providing fuel for their biogeochemical function and secondary production. However, the dynamics of detrital nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) in aquatic ecosystems have been less explored compared to terrestrial ecosystems, despite their fundamental connection with microbial processes and ecosystem function. This study synthesized published time series data from stream ecosystems to analyze the nutrient dynamics of decomposing litter. The results showed that detritus contributed as a net source of N to the environment, regardless of the initial N content. On the other hand, the sink/source dynamics of P were more influenced by the initial P content, shifting from P sinks to net P mineralization after a certain level of mass loss. However, variations in N and P predictions indicated the importance of nonmicrobial factors such as invertebrate fragmentation. Overall, this analysis helps to bridge the gap between organic matter decomposition in aquatic and terrestrial ecosystems and provides insights for future research on detrital nutrient dynamics.

ECOLOGY (2023)

Review Environmental Sciences

Integrating Non-Targeted Ecosystem Services into Assessment of Natural Stormwater Treatment Systems

Jennifer T. Le, Jennifer P. Gonzalez, Richard T. Carson, Richard F. Ambrose, Lisa A. Levin

Summary: Natural stormwater treatment systems (NTS) are designed ecosystems that capture and treat stormwater runoff using natural processes. The biological communities associated with NTS can provide additional ecosystem services, such as biodiversity and climate regulation, as well as recreational and aesthetic value. The review highlights the need for indicators, measurements, and monitoring of ecosystem services and co-benefits from NTS. Three models are presented to evaluate NTS performance, providing important information for NTS design, spatial placement, and decision-making.

WATER (2023)

Article Ecology

Ecological restoration using intertidal foundation species: Considerations and potential for rockweed restoration

Stephen G. Whitaker, Richard F. Ambrose, Laura M. Anderson, Robin J. Fales, Jayson R. Smith, Sierra Sutton, Robert J. Miller

Summary: Foundation species like trees, corals, grasses, oysters, and rockweeds play a crucial role in modifying the physical environment and increasing biodiversity. However, many of these important species are declining due to various factors. This comprehensive review focuses on rockweeds, their ecological importance, and the need for restoration efforts to conserve and enhance their population for the benefit of ecosystems.

ECOSPHERE (2023)

Article Environmental Sciences

Longitudinal stream synoptic monitoring tracks chemicals along watershed continuums: a typology of trends

Sujay S. S. Kaushal, Carly M. M. Maas, Paul M. M. Mayer, Tammy A. A. Newcomer-Johnson, Stanley B. B. Grant, Megan A. A. Rippy, Ruth R. R. Shatkay, Jonathan Leathers, Arthur J. J. Gold, Cassandra Smith, Evan C. C. McMullen, Shahan Haq, Rose Smith, Shuiwang Duan, Joseph Malin, Alexis Yaculak, Jenna E. E. Reimer, Katie Delaney Newcomb, Ashley Sides Raley, Daniel C. C. Collison, Joseph G. G. Galella, Melissa Grese, Gwendolyn Sivirichi, Thomas R. R. Doody, Peter Vikesland, Shantanu V. V. Bhide, Lauren Krauss, Madeline Daugherty, Christina Stavrou, MaKayla Etheredge, Jillian Ziegler, Andrew Kirschnick, William England, Kenneth T. T. Belt

Summary: There are challenges in monitoring and managing water quality due to spatial and temporal heterogeneity in contaminant sources, transport, and transformations. We demonstrate the importance of longitudinal stream synoptic (LSS) monitoring, which can track combinations of water quality parameters along flowpaths across space and time.

FRONTIERS IN ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE (2023)

Article Biodiversity Conservation

Perceived services and disservices of natural treatment systems for urban stormwater: Insight from the next generation of designers

Megan A. Rippy, Gregory Pierce, David Feldman, Brandon Winfrey, Andrew S. Mehring, Patricia A. Holden, Richard Ambrose, Lisa A. Levin

Summary: Natural treatment systems (NTS) have the potential to provide various ecosystem services for stormwater management. However, there are significant differences in the perception of NTS among different groups, and engineering students generally lack familiarity with the appearance of NTS and its placement in the broader landscape context. Collaboration with expertise from urban planning and ecology can help bridge the knowledge gaps and enhance the capacity of engineers in designing NTS.

PEOPLE AND NATURE (2022)

No Data Available