4.7 Article

The cost of equity: Assessing transit accessibility and social disparity using total travel cost

Journal

Publisher

PERGAMON-ELSEVIER SCIENCE LTD
DOI: 10.1016/j.tra.2016.07.003

Keywords

Equity; Job accessibility; Transit fare; Travel time; Cost

Funding

  1. Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada (NSERC) program

Ask authors/readers for more resources

Social equity is increasingly incorporated as a long-term objective into urban transportation plans. Researchers use accessibility measures to assess equity issues, such as determining the amount of jobs reachable by marginalized groups within a defined travel time threshold and compare these measures across socioeconomic categories. However, allocating public transit resources in an equitable manner is not only related to travel time, but also related to the out-of-pocket cost of transit, which can represent a major barrier to accessibility for many disadvantaged groups. Therefore, this research proposes a set of new accessibility measures that incorporates both travel time and transit fares. It then applies those measures to determine whether people residing in socially disadvantaged neighborhoods in Montreal, Canada experience the same levels of transit accessibility as those living in other neighborhoods. Results are presented in terms of regional accessibility and trends by social indicator decile. Travel time accessibility measures estimate a higher number of jobs that can be reached compared to combined travel time and cost measures. However, the degree and impact of these measures varies across the social deciles. Compared to other groups in the region, residents of socially disadvantaged areas have more equitable accessibility to jobs using transit; this is reflected in smaller decreases in accessibility when fare costs are included. Generating new measures of accessibility combining travel time and transit fares provides more accurate measures that can be easily communicated by transportation planners and engineers to policy makers and the public since it translates accessibility measures to a dollar value. (C) 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.7
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Environmental Studies

Exploring temporal variability in travel patterns on public transit using big smart card data

Xia Zhao, Mengying Cui, David Levinson

Summary: This study investigates the temporal variability in travel patterns of over 3.3 million passengers in public transit in Beijing over 120 days. The results show that commuters and non-commuters exhibit different patterns in terms of travel distance and coverage, and commuters are less affected by the day of the week. Moreover, travel distance and frequency increase faster and more linearly than space-coverage features.

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING B-URBAN ANALYTICS AND CITY SCIENCE (2023)

Article Engineering, Civil

Equilibrium or imbalance? Rail Transit and Land Use Mix in Station Areas

Yuning Wang, Duanfang Lu, David Levinson

Summary: This article provides a quantitative analysis of land use mix changes around the rail transit system in Tianjin, China. The study shows that rail transit increases land use mix in previously low-mixed areas, while the change is not significant in already diverse areas. It also reveals that station areas with higher land use dominance experience more balanced development, while areas with lower land use dominance intensify their leading functions. The findings contribute to understanding how rail transit planning can address differentiated development in cities.

TRANSPORTATION (2023)

Review Regional & Urban Planning

Toward Evidence-Based Urban Planning Integrating Quality Assessments in Literature Reviews

Lea Ravensbergen, Ahmed El-Geneidy

Summary: This article introduces the use of Risk of Bias Assessment (RoB) and Evaluation of Certainty of Evidence (ECE) tools in enhancing the quality of literature reviews in urban planning and informing practitioners on policy development.

JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN PLANNING ASSOCIATION (2023)

Review Transportation

Associations between Light Rail Transit and physical activity: a systematic review

Lea Ravensbergen, Rania Wasfi, Mathilde Van Liefferinge, Isidor Ehrlich, Stephanie A. Prince, Gregory Butler, Yan Kestens, Ahmed El-Geneidy

Summary: This study provides a systematic review on the associations between Light Rail Transit (LRT) and physical activity. The findings indicate a moderate certainty of evidence for the relationship between LRT and walking behaviour, with LRT leading to an increase in walking in most studies. The study also identifies a positive relationship between LRT and moderate-to-vigorous intensity physical activity (MVPA) and cycling, although the evidence for MVPA and cycling is not as strong.

TRANSPORT REVIEWS (2023)

Article Geography

The Spatiotemporal Evolution of Sydney's Tram Network Using Network Econometrics

Yingshuo Wang, Bahman Lahoorpoor, David M. Levinson

Summary: This study examines the evolution of the Sydney tram network using network econometrics approaches. The results show that complementary and competitive links have distinct roles in shaping the network structure.

GEOGRAPHICAL ANALYSIS (2023)

Article Transportation

Joint modelling of longitudinal and lateral dynamics in lane-changing maneuvers

Ang Ji, Mohsen Ramezani, David Levinson

Summary: This study presents a model for lane-changing events, consisting of two interconnected phases: 'stay' and 'execution'. The model incorporates stochastic duration of the 'stay' phase based on external traffic conditions, and models the 'execution' phase using longitudinal speed profiles. Bayesian survival analysis is used to predict the probability of the stay duration before a new execution phase, addressing the censoring issue. Using real-world vehicle trajectory data, the study identifies factors influencing driver behavior in lane-keeping and lane-changing execution, such as surrounding conditions, lane-changing purpose, directions, and departure lanes. The findings highlight the impact of urgency and patience on lane-changing decisions, as well as the influence of distances and relative speeds with surrounding vehicles on acceleration behavior during the execution phase.

TRANSPORTMETRICA B-TRANSPORT DYNAMICS (2023)

Article Green & Sustainable Science & Technology

Evaluating the need for secured bicycle parking across cyclist typologies

Juliette Fournier, Mathilde Van Liefferinge, Lea Ravensbergen, James DeWeese, Ahmed El-Geneidy

Summary: This study investigates the secured bicycle parking needs of different cyclist typologies in Montreal. Dedicated cyclists have the highest demand for secured bicycle parking, while occasional cyclists have the lowest. Leisure cyclists are willing to pay and walk longer distances for secured parking. The top three important characteristics of secured bicycle parking are being free or low cost, having secured access, and being close to destinations.

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SUSTAINABLE TRANSPORTATION (2023)

Article Engineering, Civil

Who Does Light Rail Serve? Examining Gendered Mobilities and Light-Rail Transit in Montreal, Canada

Julian Villafuerte-Diaz, Rodrigo Victoriano-Habit, Aryana Soliz, Ahmed El-Geneidy

Summary: Investment in light-rail transit (LRT) has been a key strategy to address environmental, economic, and social issues in major cities. A study in Montreal, Canada, investigated the gender differences in intention to use the new LRT system. The findings show that women are less likely than men to have the intention to use LRT, and there are significant variations in the effect of sociodemographic and travel behavior characteristics across gender identities.

TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH RECORD (2023)

Article Engineering, Civil

Who is Buying SUVs and Light Trucks in Montreal? A Factor and Cluster Analysis

Stephen Hickson, Madhav G. Badami, Kevin Manaugh, James DeWeese, Ahmed El-Geneidy

Summary: The steady growth of light truck use and ownership in Canada has raised concerns due to its negative externalities such as higher fatalities, increased congestion, environmental impacts, and infrastructure wear and tear. Understanding drivers' motivation for using these vehicles is crucial for policymakers aiming to reduce their usage. This study, based on data from 2,203 vehicle owners in the Montreal metropolitan area, identifies five distinct groups of drivers through factor-cluster analysis: auto-dependent families, pragmatic drivers, established drivers, physically active workers, and urban drivers. Identifying these unique groups can assist policymakers in reducing light truck ownership by influencing changes in vehicle choice, mode shifts, and land use. The findings of this study provide valuable insights for transport policymakers in comprehending the nuanced factors influencing the preference for light trucks on Montreal's roads.

TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH RECORD (2023)

Article Public, Environmental & Occupational Health

Impacts of commute mode on body mass index: A longitudinal analysis before and during the COVID-19 pandemic

Grace Commers, Rodrigo Victoriano-Habit, Lancelot Rodrigue, Yan Kestens, Ahmed El-Geneidy

Summary: COVID-19 has impacted commuters' travel patterns and BMI. This study examines the relationship between commute mode and BMI among employed individuals in Montreal during the pandemic. The findings show that for women, BMI increased significantly during the pandemic, but telecommuting, especially as a replacement for driving, led to a statistically significant decrease in BMI. For men, higher residential local accessibility was associated with decreased BMI, while telecommuting did not have a significant effect on BMI.

JOURNAL OF TRANSPORT & HEALTH (2023)

Article Engineering, Civil

Route Choice Set Generation on High-Resolution Networks

Haotian Wang, Emily Moylan, David Levinson

Summary: This study aims to find a strategy to capture the most observed trajectories using a minimum number of algorithms. GPS information from 4,538 real trips in Minneapolis-St. Paul in 2008 was collected and analyzed. The study combines labeling and link penalty approaches to generate alternatives based on observed or free-flow speed.

TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH RECORD (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Creating a dataset of historic roads in Sydney from scanned maps

Hamish Turner, Bahman Lahoorpoor, David M. Levinson

Summary: This study uses map digitization technology to create a historic dataset of road opening dates in Sydney. By georeferencing and analyzing historic maps, spatial data is extracted and placed in a collective vector layer. The study finds that about half of the road links in a significant area of Sydney were already open by the start of the twentieth century, and another half opened within a thirty-year period. The project establishes the foundation for a historic road dataset for Sydney and provides methods and procedures to further develop the dataset.

SCIENTIFIC DATA (2023)

Article Transportation

Does the squeaky wheel get the complaint? Linking bus performance, sociodemographic characteristics, and customer comments

Leila Hawa, James DeWeese, Ehab Diab, Miles Crumley, Ahmed El-Geneidy

Summary: Public transit agencies rely on performance measures to guide service improvement efforts and collect customer feedback on performance. This study links performance measures obtained from AVL and APC with customer complaints to understand the relationship between service performance and complaints. The research also investigates the impact of area's affluence on service complaints. Findings reveal the relationship between service complaints, bus operations, and socioeconomic characteristics, providing insights for transport planners and researchers.

TRAVEL BEHAVIOUR AND SOCIETY (2023)

Review Geography

Understanding the determinants of x-minute city policies: A review of the North American and Australian cities' planning documents

Michael Lu, Ehab Diab

Summary: The concept of a x-minute city, aiming at providing accessible facilities and destinations within walking or biking distance for better quality of life and community cohesion, has gained global recognition among policymakers. However, there is limited understanding of its determinants and policy directions seem to be dispersed. This study conducted a detailed analysis of x-minute city policies in 15 cities across North America and Australia, revealing different approaches and variations in implementation.

JOURNAL OF URBAN MOBILITY (2023)

Article Transportation

Lane changing and congestion are mutually reinforcing?

Yang Gao, David Levinson

Summary: This study presents a comprehensive analysis of the relationship between congestion and lane changing. The results show that lane changing does not bring significant speed benefits in most cases, and the relationship between lane change rate and speed depends on the purpose of the lane changes. The study also demonstrates a mutual causality relationship between lane changing and congestion, especially in general areas during peak periods.

COMMUNICATIONS IN TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH (2023)

Article Economics

Flight ticket taxes in Europe: Environmental and economic impact

Valeria Bernardo, Xavier Fageda, Jordi Teixido

Summary: The study finds that flight ticket taxes have a significant impact on low-cost airlines' supply and carbon emissions, resulting in a decrease of 12% in the number of flights and a 14% reduction in carbon emissions. Additionally, the burden of the taxes is higher for passengers paying low fares, affecting avoidable flights more significantly.

TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH PART A-POLICY AND PRACTICE (2024)

Article Economics

Is multimodality advantageous? Assessing the relationship between multimodality and perceived transport adequacy and accessibility in different travel contexts

Xingxing Fu, Dea van Lierop, Dick Ettema

Summary: This study investigates the relationship between multimodality and perceived transport adequacy and accessibility. The results show that multimodality is burdensome, especially for car-dependent individuals, and leads to lower perceived achievement or accessibility for those with limited access to a car.

TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH PART A-POLICY AND PRACTICE (2024)

Article Economics

A framework of routine transitions in daily travel

Henrik Johansson Rehn, Lars E. Olsson, Margareta Friman

Summary: This paper presents the Framework of RoUtIne Transitions in daily travel (FRUIT), which analyzes the impact of life events on travel behavior changes and identifies the critical phases in this process. By integrating theories and concepts, the framework provides a theoretical basis for interventions aimed at improving sustainable travel. The applicability of FRUIT is illustrated through an empirical case, and the implications for future research and policy are discussed.

TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH PART A-POLICY AND PRACTICE (2024)

Article Economics

Modeling the resilience of interdependent networks: The role of function dependency in metro and bus systems

Peng-Cheng Xu, Qing-Chang Lu, Chi Xie, Taesu Cheong

Summary: This study investigates the resilience evaluation of interdependent networks. A model is developed to quantify the impacts of network interdependency on the resilience of interdependent transit networks, considering interdependency relations, network topology, flow characteristics, and demand distribution. The model is applied to the metro and bus networks of Xi'an, China. Results show that node degree heterogeneity in topology, bidirectional function dependency among networks, and flow matching between networks are important factors influencing network resilience.

TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH PART A-POLICY AND PRACTICE (2024)

Article Economics

Cost sharing in passenger transport models: specification, implementation, and impacts

Jeppe Rich, James Fox

Summary: Many transport models allocate all costs to the car driver without considering the cost sharing among passengers. This paper questions this premise and argues that cost sharing can occur in various forms, which should be properly accounted for in transport models. The empirical evidence from Denmark suggests that not accounting for cost sharing may result in biased cost elasticities and occupancy rates.

TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH PART A-POLICY AND PRACTICE (2024)

Article Economics

Service design and frequency setting for the European high-speed rail network

Jorik Grolle, Barth Donners, Jan Anne Annema, Mark Duinkerken, Oded Cats

Summary: High-speed rail is considered a promising alternative for long-distance travel, but the current state of the European HSR network is poorly connected. This study presents a customized version of network design and frequency setting problem for HSR, and analyzes the performance under various policies and design variables. The results show that considering externalities leads to more extensive networks and mode shifts, but requires high public investments. The importance of network integration and cross-border cooperation is highlighted. The findings aim to contribute to the design of an attractive and competitive European HSR network.

TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH PART A-POLICY AND PRACTICE (2024)

Article Economics

Effect of the measurement period and spatial dependence on the accuracy of urban freight trip generation models

Mounisai Siddartha Middela, Gitakrishnan Ramadurai

Summary: This study addresses the research gaps in understanding the effect of regression models, measurement period, and spatial dependence on Freight Trip Generation (FTG) modeling and freight-related policies. The results show that the spatial Zero-Inflated Negative Binomial (ZINB) model is the best for daily and weekly Freight Trip Production (FTP), while the non-spatial Negative Binomial (NB) model is the best for daily and weekly Freight Trip Attraction (FTA). The study also highlights the importance of considering spatial dependence and using count models with a week as the measurement period.

TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH PART A-POLICY AND PRACTICE (2024)