4.3 Review

Reporting quality of randomized controlled trials in prehabilitation: a scoping review

Journal

PERIOPERATIVE MEDICINE
Volume 12, Issue 1, Pages -

Publisher

BMC
DOI: 10.1186/s13741-023-00338-8

Keywords

Prehab; Pre-rehab; Perioperative medicine; ERAS (enhanced recovery after surgery)

Ask authors/readers for more resources

This study aimed to assess the reporting quality of prehabilitation trials and found that current reports only cover about half of the methodological and intervention guidelines. It is necessary to develop a specific reporting checklist for prehabilitation interventions to improve reporting quality.
BackgroundInadequate study reporting precludes interpretation of findings, pooling of results in meta-analyses, and delays knowledge translation. While prehabilitation interventions aim to enhance candidacy for surgery, to our knowledge, a review of the quality of reporting in prehabilitation has yet to be conducted. Our objective was to determine the extent to which randomized controlled trials (RCTs) of prehabilitation are reported according to methodological and intervention reporting checklists.MethodsEligibility criteria: RCTs of unimodal or multimodal prehabilitation interventions. Sources of evidence: search was conducted in March 2022 using MEDLINE, Embase, PsychINFO, Web of Science, CINAHL, and Cochrane. Charting methods: identified studies were compared to CONSORT, CERT & Modified CERT, TIDieR, PRESENT, and CONSORT-SPI. An agreement ratio (AR) was defined to evaluate if applicable guideline items were correctly reported. Data were analyzed as frequency (n, %) and mean with standard deviation (SD).ResultsWe identified 935 unique articles and included 70 trials published from 1994 to 2022. Most prehabilitation programs comprised exercise-only interventions (n = 40, 57%) and were applied before oncologic surgery (n = 32, 46%). The overall mean AR was 57% (SD: 20.9%). The specific mean ARs were as follows: CONSORT: 71% (SD: 16.3%); TIDieR: 62% (SD:17.7%); CERT: 54% (SD: 16.6%); Modified-CERT: 40% (SD:17.8%); PRESENT: 78% (SD: 8.9); and CONSORT-SPI: 47% (SD: 22.1).ConclusionAltogether, existing prehabilitation trials report approximately half of the checklist items recommended by methodological and intervention reporting guidelines. Reporting practices may improve with the development of a reporting checklist specific to prehabilitation interventions.

Authors

I am an author on this paper
Click your name to claim this paper and add it to your profile.

Reviews

Primary Rating

4.3
Not enough ratings

Secondary Ratings

Novelty
-
Significance
-
Scientific rigor
-
Rate this paper

Recommended

Article Anesthesiology

Age, minimum alveolar concentration and choice of depth of sedation monitor: examining the paradox of age when using the Narcotrend monitor A secondary analysis of an observational study

Darren Hight, Cornelia Schanderhazi, Markus Huber, Frank Stuber, Heiko A. Kaiser

Summary: With an aging global population, it is important to customize the dosing of anesthetics according to age and their effects on the brain. A recent study observed that the concentration of volatile anesthetics during general surgery decreases by around 3% per age-decade, which is less than the expected decrease of 6% based on age-adjusted values. Paradoxically, despite the excessive dosing, the Bispectral index (BIS) values also increased. The aim of this study was to investigate this paradox of age using the Narcotrend depth of anesthesia monitor.

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ANAESTHESIOLOGY (2022)

Article Anesthesiology

Outcome in patients with open abdomen treatment for peritonitis: a multidomain approach outperforms single domain predictions

Sven Petersen, Markus Huber, Federico Storni, Gero Puhl, Alice Deder, Axel Prause, Joerg C. Schefold, Dietrich Doll, Patrick Schober, Markus M. Luedi

Summary: This study aimed to predict survival outcomes in peritonitis patients treated with open abdomen surgery using a multidomain prediction model. The results indicated that the surgical predictor skin closure, along with the physiological predictors SAPS-II and MPI, were key factors in predicting survival. The integrative prediction model outperformed individual predictors in predicting survival outcomes.

JOURNAL OF CLINICAL MONITORING AND COMPUTING (2022)

Article Anesthesiology

Carbon Dioxide Changes during High-flow Nasal Oxygenation in Apneic Patients: A Single-center Randomized Controlled Noninferiority Trial

Thomas Riva, Robert Greif, Heiko Kaiser, Thomas Riedel, Markus Huber, Lorenz Theiler, Sabine Nabecker

Summary: This study investigated the effects of different flow rates of humidified 100% oxygen on the increase of arterial partial pressure of carbon dioxide. The results showed that different flow rates resulted in comparable increases in arterial partial pressure of carbon dioxide, suggesting no additional ventilatory effect of high-flow nasal oxygenation.

ANESTHESIOLOGY (2022)

Article Pediatrics

Direct versus video laryngoscopy with standard blades for neonatal and infant tracheal intubation with supplemental oxygen: a multicentre, non-inferiority, randomised controlled trial

Thomas Riva, Thomas Engelhardt, Reto Basciani, Rachele Bonfiglio, Evelien Cools, Alexander Fuchs, Annery G. Garcia-Marcinkiewicz, Robert Greif, Walid Habre, Markus Huber, Maria -Alexandra Petre, Britta S. von Ungern-Sternberg, David Sommerfield, Lorenz Theiler, Nicola Disma, OPTIMISE Collaboration

Summary: Direct laryngoscopy and video laryngoscopy with supplemental oxygen were compared in neonates and infants undergoing tracheal intubation. The study found that video laryngoscopy with standard blades and supplemental oxygen increased the success rate of first-attempt tracheal intubation compared to direct laryngoscopy. The incidence of adverse events was similar between the two groups.

LANCET CHILD & ADOLESCENT HEALTH (2023)

Article Anesthesiology

A Pilot Investigation Evaluating Relative Changes in Fronto-Occipital Alpha and Beta Spectral Power as Measurement of Anesthesia Hypnotic Depth

Eloy S. Fehrlin, Darren Hight, Heiko A. Kaiser, Markus M. Luedi, Markus Huber, Frederic Zubler, Friedrich Lersch

Summary: A new index called FO-RPAB was proposed to monitor the ratio of alpha and beta activity between the frontal and occipital regions during general anesthesia. FO-RPAB was found to serve as a marker of unconsciousness and was not affected by additional administration of ketamine for analgesia.

ANESTHESIA AND ANALGESIA (2023)

Article Medical Informatics

Decision curve analysis confirms higher clinical utility of multi-domain versus single-domain prediction models in patients with open abdomen treatment for peritonitis

Markus Huber, Patrick Schober, Sven Petersen, Markus M. M. Luedi

Summary: Prediction models have become increasingly important in perioperative systems approaches, particularly in complex patients with open abdomen treatment for peritonitis. Combining predictors from multiple medical domains enhances the prediction capabilities compared to single-domain models. However, the clinical utility of these prediction models needs further investigation.

BMC MEDICAL INFORMATICS AND DECISION MAKING (2023)

Letter Anesthesiology

Authors' reply to the comment by Shan et al.

Christian M. Beilstein, Markus Huber, Dominique Engel, Patrick Y. Wuethrich

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF PAIN (2023)

Article Emergency Medicine

Factors influencing on-scene time in a physician-staffed helicopter emergency medical service (HEMS): a retrospective observational study

Alexander Fuchs, Markus Huber, Thomas Riva, Stefan Becker, Roland Albrecht, Robert Greif, Urs Pietsch

Summary: For helicopter emergency service systems, factors such as helicopter hoist operations, resuscitation, airway management, critical interventions, remote location, night-time, and paediatric patients are associated with longer on-scene times. Compared to adult patients, paediatric patients had longer on-scene times. Improving individual interventions or performing them in parallel may reduce on-scene time.

SCANDINAVIAN JOURNAL OF TRAUMA RESUSCITATION & EMERGENCY MEDICINE (2023)

Article Medicine, General & Internal

Characteristics and neurological survival following intraoperative cardiac arrest in a Swiss University Hospital: a 7-year retrospective observational cohort study

Alexander Fuchs, Lea Franzmeier, Marie Cheseaux-Carrupt, Martina Kaempfer, Nicola Disma, Urs Pietsch, Markus Huber, Thomas Riva, Robert Greif

Summary: This retrospective observational study evaluated anesthesia procedures from 2015 to 2021 and found that intraoperative cardiac arrest is rare but more common in older patients, those with ASA physical status ≥IV, cardiac and vascular surgery, and emergency procedures. Most patients had pulseless electrical activity as the initial rhythm. With immediate treatment, most patients can achieve return of spontaneous circulation and survive after 30 days, with favorable neurological outcomes for the majority.

FRONTIERS IN MEDICINE (2023)

Article Multidisciplinary Sciences

Convalescent plasma and all-cause mortality of COVID-19 patients: systematic review and meta-analysis

Nora Mihalek, Dragana Radovanovic, Otto Barak, Petar Colovic, Markus Huber, Gabor Erdoes

Summary: This study aimed to investigate the survival benefit of convalescent plasma therapy in COVID-19 patients. The results showed no statistical evidence of the benefit of convalescent plasma therapy on all-cause mortality. Further studies are needed to determine in which patients this therapy may lead to a reduction in mortality.

SCIENTIFIC REPORTS (2023)

Article Medicine, General & Internal

Impact of Intraoperative Fluid Balance and Norepinephrine on Postoperative Acute Kidney Injury after Cystectomy and Urinary Diversion over Two Decades: A Retrospective Observational Cohort Study

Markus Huber, Marc A. Furrer, Francois Jardot, Dominique Engel, Christian M. Beilstein, Fiona C. Burkhard, Patrick Y. Wuethrich

Summary: The use of norepinephrine and intraoperative fluid administration have been found to increase the risk of acute kidney injury (AKI) after cystectomy. A study on 1488 patients showed that the overall incidence of AKI was 21.6%, and it increased by 0.6% per year since 2000. Decreased intraoperative fluid balance combined with increased norepinephrine administration were associated with an increased risk of AKI, though other factors may also contribute to the observed increase in AKI incidence.

JOURNAL OF CLINICAL MEDICINE (2023)

Article Cell Biology

Gas6 in chronic liver disease-a novel blood-based biomarker for liver fibrosis

Katharina Staufer, Heidemarie Huber, Jasmin Zessner-Spitzenberg, Rudolf Stauber, Armin Finkenstedt, Heike Bantel, Thomas S. Weiss, Markus Huber, Rudolf Markus, Patrick Starlinger, Thomas Gruenberger, Thomas Reiberger, Susanne Sebens, Gail McIntyre, Ray Tabibiazar, Amato Giaccia, Heinz Zoller, Michael Trauner, Wolfgang Mikulits

Summary: The expression of Axl and sAxl is increased in liver fibrosis, cirrhosis, and HCC. Gas6/alb ratio shows high diagnostic accuracy for the detection of fibrosis and cirrhosis, and predicts severity of liver disease including CSPH. However, it fails to discriminate between HCC in cirrhosis versus cirrhosis only.

CELL DEATH DISCOVERY (2023)

Article Cardiac & Cardiovascular Systems

Determination of selective antegrade perfusion flow rate in aortic arch surgery to restore baseline cerebral near-infrared spectroscopy values: a single-centre observational study

Jan-Oliver Friess, Maurus Beeler, Murat Yildiz, Dominik P. Guensch, Anja Levis, Daniel Gerber, Jakob Wollborn, Hansjoerg Jenni, Markus Huber, Florian Schoenhoff, Gabor Erdoes

Summary: The aim of this study was to determine the cerebral perfusion flow rate required to achieve the preoperative awake baseline cerebral oxygen saturation. The results showed that a flow rate of 8 ml/kg/min during selective antegrade cerebral perfusion is more likely to achieve the baseline cerebral saturation value.

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF CARDIO-THORACIC SURGERY (2023)

Article Anesthesiology

Emergency front-of-neck access in infants: A pragmatic crossover randomized control trial comparing two approaches on a simulated rabbit model

Thomas Riva, Simon Goerge, Alexander Fuchs, Robert Greif, Markus Huber, Andrea C. Lusardi, Thomas Riedel, Francis F. Ulmer, Nicola Disma

Summary: This study aims to investigate the equivalence between rapid-sequence tracheotomy and scalpel-bougie tracheotomy in establishing tracheal access using rabbit cadavers. The primary outcome is the duration until successful tracheal tube placement. Secondary outcomes include success rate, structural injuries, and participant self-evaluation.

PEDIATRIC ANESTHESIA (2023)

No Data Available